中美农学领域科研论文比较分析
2020-12-21尼鲁帕尔·迪力夏提郭静利
尼鲁帕尔·迪力夏提 郭静利



摘要 通過论文产出分析科研表现动态,考察中国与国际科研强国的差距,有助于发挥科研能动性。基于Incites数据库2000—2019年数据,对比分析20年中美农学SCI论文表现,为中国农学科研评价体系改革提供数据支持。聚焦中国农学科研论文产量与质量,结合绝对量化、相对量化、归一化3类科研评价指标,分析了中国及主要科研产出国的农学科研产出表现。当前中国SCI论文在国际上占据数量优势,但从论文质量来看,相较美国并不存在明显的“高量低质”性,且SCI论文质量正在稳步提升,具备向好趋势;高影响力、高被引论文欠缺,在农学领域缺乏核心话语权。具体来看在论文总产上不及美国,位居世界第二,与中国在其他领域论文产出相比无明显优势;在论文年产趋势上保持世界最高年增长率,仍处于高速增长阶段且于2019年成为世界农学论文年产第一国;论文总被引频次位居世界第四,学科规范化引文影响力排名世界第六,低于全球平均影响力论文占比77%,在高于全球平均影响力论文中,80%以上的论文处于较低水平,高水平论文数量不及美国1/4。建议今后从科研评价导向、提升成果转化、加强国内期刊建设3方面着力提升农学SCI论文的高质量发展。
关键词 SCI论文;Incites 数据库;学科活跃性指数;影响力全貌;科研评价
中图分类号 S-058文献标识码 A
文章编号 0517-6611(2020)22-0229-04
doi:10.3969/j.issn.0517-6611.2020.22.060
A Comparative Analysis of Sino-US Agronomy Scientific Publication
Nilufar Dlxat,GUO Jing-li (Institute of Agricultural Economics and Development,Chinese Academy of Agricultural Sciences,Beijing 100089)
Abstract It is helpful to give full play to the initiative of scientific research by analyzing the dynamic of scientific research performance through the output of papers and investigating the gap between China and other powerful countries in scientific research.Based on the data of incites database from 2000 to 2019,this paper compared and analyzed the performance of agricultural SCI papers between China and the United States in recent 20 years,so as to provide data support for the reform of agricultural scientific research evaluation system in China.Focusing on the output and quality of agricultural research papers in China,this paper analyzed the performance of agricultural scientific research output in China and major research producing countries by combining three kinds of scientific research evaluation indexes:absolute quantification,relative quantification and normalization.At present,China's SCI papers occupy a quantitative advantage in the world,but from the perspective of paper quality,compared with the United States,“high quantity and low quality”is not obvious,and the quality of SCI papers is steadily improving,with a good trend; high impact,highly cited papers are lack,and lack of core voice in the field of agriculture.To be specific,it ranks the second place in the world compared with the United States in the total output of papers,and has no obvious advantage compared with China in other fields.It maintains the highest annual growth rate in the world on the trend of paper production,is still in the stage of rapid growth,and will become the world's first country in agricultural paper production in 2019.The total citation frequency of the papers ranked fourth in the world,and the standardized citation influence of the discipline ranked sixth in the world,accounting for 77% of the papers below the global average influence.Among the papers above the global average influence,more than 80% of the papers were at a low level,and the number of high-level papers was less than 1/4 of the United States.It is suggested that the high quality development of agricultural SCI papers should be promoted from three aspects:scientific research evaluation orientation,improvement of achievement transformation and strengthening of domestic periodical construction.
Key words SCI papers;Incites database;Subject activity index;The whole picture of influence;Scientific research evaluation
作者简介 尼鲁帕尔·迪力夏提(1995—),女,维吾尔族,新疆伊犁人,硕士研究生,研究方向:农业经济管理。……
