基于随机演化博弈的重大调水工程生态补偿:以南水北调工程为例
2022-03-13高鑫宋瑞震曾赛星沈菊琴
高鑫 宋瑞震 曾赛星 沈菊琴








摘 要:南水北调工程供水区与受水区间因发展和补偿的非协调而导致矛盾越发凸显,亟待建立生态补偿予以化解。鉴于现有研究较少在不确定因素影响下对补偿主客体的决策行为以及纵向补偿与横向补偿的配比关系进行探索,本文结合演化博弈论与随机过程,构建了中央政府、供水区政府与受水区政府的随机演化博弈模型,分析了建立生态补偿的最优策略、约束条件及因素影响。研究发现:受水区政府是建立南水北调生态补偿的关键,其决策易受到初始概率、水环境保护成本、监管成本与随机扰动等因素的影响;惩罚是有效推动受水区政府参与生态补偿的环境规制方式;生态补偿标准及其配比会在方向与程度上影响各政府的决策。
关键词:生态补偿;南水北调工程;演化博弈;随机过程;仿真
中图分类号:F224.32 文献标识码:A 文章编号:2097-0145(2022)01-0026-09 doi:10.11847/fj.41.1.26
Abstract:The contradiction between the water-supply area and the water-receiving area of the South-to-North Water Transfer Project is becoming more prominent due to the non-coordination of development and compensation, which needs to be resolved by establishing ecological compensation. There are few studies on the decision-making behavior of compensation subject and object, and the ratio of vertical compensation and horizontal compensation under the uncertain factors. Therefore, combined with evolutionary game theory and stochastic process, this paper constructs the stochastic evolutionary game model of central government, water-supply area governments and water-receiving area governments, and analyzes the optimal strategy, constraints and influencing factors of establishing ecological compensation. It is found that the water receiving area governments are the key to establish the ecological compensation of South-to-North Water Transfer Project, and their decision-making is easily affected by factors such as initial probability, water environment protection costs, supervision costs and random disturbance; Punishment is an effective way of environmental regulation to promote the governments of water receiving area to participate in ecological compensation; Ecological compensation standard and its distribution affect the decision-making of different governments in direction and degree.
Key words:ecological compensation; south-to-north water transfer project; evolutionary game; stochastic process; simulation
1 引言
南水北調工程是调整我国水资源空间分布不均[1]、缓解我国北方地区水资源短缺的重大水利基础设施工程[2]。工程通过建设东线、中线与西线三条调水线路,使长江、黄河、淮河、海河四大流域相互连通,形成了“四横三纵、南北调配、东西互济”的水资源配置格局。目前,东线、中线一期工程已于2013年与2014年通水,累计调水400多亿m3,直接受益人数高达1.2亿,对我国社会经济发展与生态环境保护具有巨大促进作用[3]。
南水北调工程有效缓解了受水区的用水,却限制了供水区的发展,导致供水区与受水区间的发展矛盾。……