APP下载

3D printed titanium scaffolds with ordered TiO2 nanotubular surface and mesoporous bioactive glass for bone repair

2020-07-29PengyuZhaoYaqinLiuTianLiYanlingZhouSanderLeeflangLeiChenChengtieWuJieZhouZhiguangHuan

Pengyu Zhao ,Yaqin Liu ,Tian Li ,Yanling Zhou ,Sander Leeflang ,Lei Chen ,Chengtie Wu,Jie Zhou,∗,Zhiguang Huan,∗∗

a State Key Laboratory of High Performance Ceramics and Superfine Microstructure,Shanghai Institute of Ceramics,Chinese Academy of Sciences,Shanghai,200050,China

b Center of Materials Science and Optoelectronics Engineering,University of Chinese Academy of Sciences,Beijing,100049,China

c Department of Biomechanical Engineering,Delft University of Technology,Mekelweg 2,2628,CD Delft,the Netherlands

Keywords:Titanium Scaffold Mesoporous bioactive glass Nanotube Anodization

ABSTRACT Titanium alloy scaffolds have recently gained substantial interest for the treatment of critical-size bone defect,particularly along with the maturity of the 3D printing technology that is capable of turning scaffold design ideas into real implants.As titanium alloys lack surface osteogenic activity,for improved biological performance of such scaffolds,surface modification is necessary.Various coating materials and coating methods have been explored.In this study,we developed a unique surface modification method to provide the surface of 3D printed titanium scaffolds with nano-sized structure and bioactive agent.Uniform,ordered TiO2 nanotube arrays were formed by applying two-step anodization,and then mesoporous bioactive glass (MBG) was loaded into nanotubes.The results of in vitro immersion testing showed that bioactive ions,i.e.,Si and Ca ions,could be steadily and continuously released from MBG into basal medium.The assessment of the responses of hBMSCs confirmed that the surface-modified scaffolds supported the adhesion and proliferation of hBMSCs,indicating good surface cytocompatibility.The developed method of combining surface nanostructure and bioactive agent could be used as a new strategy to improve the osteogenic activity of 3D printed titanium alloy scaffolds.

1.Introduction

In bone repair,fusion of implants and tissues,i.e.,osseointegration,is of great importance [1].Since the 1960s,in the field of orthopedics,titanium and its alloys have been selected [2] as the preferred implant materials for hard tissue repair,owing to their outstanding corrosion resistance,high strength-to-weight ratio and superior biocompatibility.With the emergence of the 3D printing technology,desired pore size,pore inter-connectivity,porosity and permeability of titanium alloy scaffolds can be achieved to facilitate osseointegration.In addition,the flexibility in architecture design of 3D printed scaffolds allows for the adjustments of mechanical properties over a wide range[3].Compared with solid titanium with an elastic modulus value of 110 GPa,3D printed scaffolds can be designed to possess an elastic modulus value similar to the elastic modulus of natural cortical bone that is in the range of 7–60 GPa.The reduction in elastic modulus can effectively prevent bone absorption from occurring by avoiding stress shielding[4].By virtue of the porous structure,3D printed titanium alloy scaffolds can maintain cell morphology,promote the adhesion and proliferation of osteoblasts,thereby leading to enhanced bone penetration and long-term stability [5].Although 3D printed titanium alloy scaffolds can indeed possess desired pore characteristics and mechanical properties,the surface of the implants lacks osteogenic activity,due to the bio-inert nature of titanium.Therefore,surface biofunctionalization is strongly needed.

To endow titanium alloy scaffolds with surface bioactivity,various methods have been explored to modify the surface structure,chemical composition and phase constitution,for example,the plasma spraying method [6],sol-gel method [7],chemical treatment method [8],pulse laser method[9],anodization method[10],electrochemical deposition method [11] and micro-arc oxidation method [12].Compared to these methods,anodizing is a simple electrochemical technique that can effectively change the surface features of titanium and its alloys [13].During anodization,titanium alloy serves as the anode,while the counter electrode is an inert material,such as graphite or platinum(Pt)[14].Anodization enables the formation of an ordered nanotubular titanium dioxide structure on the surface of titanium alloy scaffolds[15,16].Multiple studies have shown that cells cultured on the surface of TiO2nanotubes have improved adhesion,proliferation,and ALP activity,when compared to those cultured on the surface of bare titanium alloys,and such surface has enhanced bone matrix deposition capacity [17–21].Scaffolds with TiO2nanotubes can positively affect bone formation and bone development as well by enhancing the function of osteoblasts in vivo.The expression of type I collagen is significantly higher for the nanostructured implants than that for the smooth control surface [22].In addition,open-ended TiO2nanotubes can be used as reservoirs to load drugs or bioactive agents to achieve a sustained release profile [23–25].

Forming a bioactive glass coating layer on the surface of titanium alloy scaffolds is another strategy to improve surface osteogenic activity.It has been applied onto titanium alloy substrates by using the thermal spraying method and others,enabling titanium alloy scaffolds to have enhanced biological activity [26].Mesoporous bioactive glass(MBG) is one of the most extensively studied silicate biomaterials,due to its unique structure and composition[27,28].Bioactive ions,such as Si ions,released from MBG,can promote osteogenic differentiation of osteoblasts and human bone marrow mesenchymal stem cells(hBMSCs)through activated specific signaling pathways [29–32].In our previous study,we observed that the formation of MBG coating on the surface of titanium alloy scaffolds could indeed improve the osteogenic differentiation activity of hBMSCs,thereby improving the osteogenic performance[33].However,the MBG coating was quickly consumed in the Tris-HCl buffer solution,resulting in a short time of releasing bioactive ions and thus a lack of long-term promotion of osteogenesis.

Previous studies have shown that the presence of surface nanostructure and bioactive agent may have a synergetic effect on promoting bone regeneration[34–37].In this work,we aimed to develop a surface modification method to improve the osseointegration performance of 3D printed titanium alloy scaffolds further.Anodization was performed to form TiO2nanotubes on the surface of 3D printed titanium alloy scaffolds.The nanotubes were then used as reservoirs to load MBG in order to achieve the combined presence of surface nanostructure and bioactive agent at 3D printed titanium alloy scaffold surface,as illustrated in Fig.1.Bare scaffolds,anodized scaffolds and MBG-loaded scaffolds were compared in wettability,mechanical strength,release profile of bioactive ions,as well as biocompatibility in terms of adhesion and proliferation of hBMSCs.

2.Materials and experimental details

2.1.Materials

Ammonium fluoride (NH4F),ethylene glycol (EG),tetraethyl orthosilicate (TEOS),triethyl phosphate (TEP),calcium nitrate tetrahydrate (Ca(NO3)2·4H2O),hydrochloric acid (HCl) and tris-hydroxymethyl aminomethane were purchased from Sinopharm Chemical Reagent Co.,Ltd.(Shanghai,China).Nonionic block copolymer EO20PO70EO20(P123,average MW=5800) was purchased from Sigma-Aldrich.All these chemical reagents were used directly without any treatment.

2.2.Fabrication of titanium alloy scaffolds

A medical-grade Ti–6Al–4V powder (grade 23) supplied by Advanced Powders and Coatings (AP&C,Boisbriand,QC,Canada) with a median particle size of 31.6 μm and spherical morphology was used as the starting material to fabricate porous titanium alloy implants.Porous samples in the form of cylindrical specimens (d=10 mm;h=2 mm)were printed with a selective laser melting (SLM) machine (Realizer,SLM-125,Borchen,Germany) equipped with YLM-400-AC ytterbium fiber laser (IPG Photonics Corporation,Oxford,MA,USA) under an inert argon atmosphere with oxygen content below 0.2%.The scaffolds had a diamond lattice structure and a strut thickness of 300 μm,Corresponding to a porosity value of 68% (design value).In addition,cylindrical samples with a diameter of 10 mm and a height of 10 mm and with the same structural parameters were prepared for surface modification and then for mechanical testing.The as-fabricated scaffolds are referred to as 3D-Ti in this study.

2.3.Formation of TiO2 nanotubes on scaffold surface

A two-step anodization method was employed to form ordered TiO2nanotubes on 3D-Ti scaffold surface[38].Prior to anodization,samples were ultrasonically cleaned in acetone,ethyl alcohol and water,and then dried in air.During anodization,the 3D-Ti scaffold acted as the anode and a thin platinum net served as the cathode.The electrodes were immersed in an ethylene glycol electrolyte solution containing deionized water (2.5 vol%),and NH4F (0.5 wt%) and stirred magnetically.A constant voltage of 60 V was applied for the first 20 min,and then the sample was taken out and ultrasonicated in deionized water for 5 min to form an ordered template on the surface.This sample was used once again as the anode for the second-step anodization at 60 V for 20 min.The whole anodizing setup was connected to a programmable power supply(Kikusui,Japan)for voltage control through the LabVIEW software (Kikusui,Japan).After anodization,the prepared sample was washed with deionized water thoroughly and dried in air.The as-anodized titanium scaffolds with titanium nanotubes on surface were referred to as 3D-Ti-NTs hereafter.For comparison purpose,part of 3D-Ti-NTs samples were subjected to a heat treatment at 550 °C for 5 h.

2.4.Loading of MBG into nanotubes

An MBG precursor solution was prepared,following the procedure described in a previous publication [39].Briefly,12 g EO20PO70EO20(P123),20.1 g tetraethyl orthosilicate (TEOS),4.2 g Ca (NO3)2·4H2O,2.19 g triethyl phosphate (TEP) and 3 g 0.5 M HCl were dissolved in 180 g ethanol solution,and the resultant mixture was stirred at room temperature for 24 h.Then,3D-Ti-NTs samples was immersed in the MBG precursor solution and vacuumed for 3 min.After excess surface solution was removed,the samples were dried at room temperature to allow alcohol to evaporate for 24 h.Finally,the samples were heattreated at a heating rate of 1°C/min to 550°C and kept at 550°C for 5 h to remove organic compounds in order to form a mesoporous structure.The as-heat-treated titanium scaffolds are referred to as 3D-Ti-NTs-MBG hereafter.To prepare MBG powder as a reference material,the MBG precursor solution was dried to form a dried gel at room temperature by using an evaporation-induced self-assembly method,followed by the same heat treatment.

2.5.Characterization of the scaffolds

The surface microstructure of the 3D-Ti-NTs samples was characterized by using a scanning electron microscope (S-4800,Hitachi)operating at an acceleration voltage of 2.0 kV.The phases present in the 3D-Ti and 3D-Ti-NTs samples were identified by using an X-ray diffractometer (D8 ADVANCE,Bruker AXS GmbH,Germany) with Cu Kα radiation from 20° to 80°.The surface wettability of the samples was determined,using a water contact angle (WCA) tester (Solon Tech Co.,Ltd,Shanghai,China).The MBG powder was characterized by wideangle XRD and small-angle XRD.The MBG powder was ultrasonically dispersed in alcohol and its mesoporous structure was confirmed by transmission electron microscopy (TEM,2100F,JEOL,Japan) at an acceleration voltage of 120 KV.The structural characteristics of the MBG powder were taken as the representative of the MBG loaded into nanotubes,because those of the MBG in TiO2nanotubes could not be revealed without damaging TiO2nanotubes.Elemental mapping by means of energy-dispersive x-ray spectrometry (EDS) working at an acceleration voltage of 10.0 kV was performed to verify the elements present in the MBG loaded inside TiO2nanotubes.

2.6.Mechanical tests

Compressive testing was performed at room temperature according to the requirements of ASTM E9-89a [57].3D-Ti,3D-Ti-NTs,3D-Ti-NTs-MBG cylindrical specimens(d=10 mm;h=10 mm)were used to determine their mechanical properties.The tests were conducted by using a universal testing machine(Instron-5592,Boston,MA,USA)at a crosshead speed of 0.5 mm/min.Four specimens were used for each group and the average value of compressive strength was calculated.

There were three nails on the left wall, on which hung his clothes yesterday. After he lived in the room, he removed all the clothes boxes and bought her a desk in the spared room because he knew she loved writing and drawing.

2.7.Bioactive ion release from 3D-Ti-NTs-MBG

To understand the degradation behavior of the MBG loaded into the nanotubes of the scaffolds and the accompanied ion release profiles,the 3D-Ti-NTs-MBG samples were soaked in the human mesenchymal stem cell basal medium(MSCBM)which was kept in an incubator at 37°C for 1,3,5 and 7 days.The MSCBM was refreshed and collected at the selected time points.Ca and Si ion concentrations were determined by inductively coupled plasma atomic emission spectroscopy (ICP-AES;Vista AX,Varian,USA).Three samples were used at each time point for reproducibility.

2.8.Cytotoxicity evaluation

To observe the adhesion and morphology of cells on samples,human bone mesenchymal stem cells(hBMSCs)purchased from Cyagen Biosciences (Guangdong,China) were cultured in the MSCBM.Cells were fixed on various scaffold surfaces for imaging using SEM.More specifically,2×105hBMSCs were cultured with the 3D-Ti-NTs and 3DTi-NTs-MBG samples for 12 h.Then,the medium was removed and washed with phosphate-buffered saline (PBS) for three times.Finally,cells were fixed with a 2.5% glutaraldehyde solution for 1 h,and dehydrated with graded alcohol(30,40,50,60,70,80,90,95,and 100 v/v%) for 5 min.After drying at room temperature,the morphology of hBMSCs was observed using the same SEM (S-4800,Hitachi,Japan).

Cell proliferation was assessed by the Cell Counting Kit-8 (CCK-8)assay (Dojindo Molecular Technologies,Kumamoto,Japan).To study the proliferation of hBMSCs on samples,hBMSCs were cultured on the 3D-Ti-NTs and 3D-Ti-NTs-MBG scaffolds in 24-well plates under a 5%CO2atmosphere at 37 °C for 1,3,and 7 days.At each time point,the medium was removed and 500 μL of CCK-8 mixed solution(10%CCK-8 and 90% hBMSCs basal medium) was added.After incubation at 37 °C for 1 h,100 μL mixed solution was extracted and added to a 96-well plate.Then,absorbance was measured at 450 nm with a microplate reader (Epoch Microplate Spectrophotometer,BioTek Instruments,Winooski,VT,USA).For each group,four samples were prepared.

2.9.Statistical analysis

All the data are expressed as the mean ± standard deviation (SD).Data were analyzed by t-tests;p <0.05 was marked as statistically significant.

3.Results and discussion

3.1.Surface characteristics of the 3D-Ti,3D-Ti-NTs and 3D-Ti-NTs-MBG scaffolds

The surface morphologies of the 3D-Ti,3D-Ti-NTs and 3D-Ti-NTs-MBG scaffolds are shown in Fig.2.It is obvious that the overall appearance of the scaffolds after two-step anodization and after MBG loading did not differ much from that of the as-fabricated scaffolds(Fig.2a,d,g).At a high magnification,SEM revealed spherical particles of various sizes(over a range of 5–50 μm)adhered to the surface of the as-fabricated scaffolds,as shown in Fig.2b.The surface of these particles was viewed as flat surface at a nanometer level (Fig.2c).

After two-step anodization,while the overall morphology of the scaffolds was retained (Fig.2d),TiO2nanotubes with a diameter of about 80 nm and a length of about 2 μm were formed on the surface of the scaffolds,as shown in Fig.2e and f.The surface feature with adhered particles survived the anodization process,but the entire surface(including the particles and the underlying substrate) became composed of TiO2nanotubes (Fig.2f).The cracks were visible on the surface of 3D-Ti-NTs,which were probably caused by TiO2nanotubes that radially grew on the curved surface of titanium outwards,as described by other researchers [40].Apparently,these surface features all resulted from the two-step anodization applied.At the first step of anodization,the surface of titanium scaffold was actually subjected to a pretreatment,which provided an ordered imprint as a template for the growth of TiO2nanotubes during the second step.The two-step anodization process indeed led to uniformly sized,orderly TiO2nanotubes[41,42],as well as good bonding with the substrate [43].

The macromorphology of the 3D-Ti-NTs-MBG scaffolds (Fig.2g)showed no discernible differences from that of the 3D-Ti-NTs scaffolds.SEM at a high magnification however revealed spilled MBG on the top of the anodized surface of the 3D-Ti-NTs-MBG scaffolds (Fig.2h).Fine particles,assumed to be MBG,penetrated into TiO2nanotubes(Fig.2i).

3.2.3.2.Phase constitution of the 3D-Ti and 3D-Ti-NTs scaffolds

XRD (Fig.3a) revealed the presence of martensite as the single prime phase (α′-Ti) in the as-fabricated 3D-Ti scaffolds,instead of the(α+β) dual phase normally formed under the equilibrium condition for the Ti–6Al–4V alloy.It indicated highly non-equilibrium solidification occurring during SLM [44] and no post-SLM heat treatment was applied.

After the two-step anodization and heat treatment,both rutile and anatase appeared in the XRD pattern of the 3D-Ti-NTs sample(Fig.3b),indicating the partial transition of crystal structure from anatase to rutile[45].Despite the exposure to the elevated temperatures of 550°C during the heat treatment,the metastable martensite α′ phase in the substrate near nanotubes,largely remained [58],as shown by the XRD pattern (Fig.3b).

3.3.Water contact angles of the 3D-Ti and 3D-Ti-NTs scaffolds

Water contact angle (WCA) was used to indicate the effect of twostep anodization on the surface properties of the scaffolds in terms of wettability.The surface of the 3D-Ti scaffold was found to be hydrophobic,with a WCA value of 121° (Fig.4a).By contrast,with the presence of nanotubes,the surface of the scaffolds became highly hydrophilic and WCA could not even be measured (Fig.4b),because water droplets quickly spread on the surface of the sample.TiO2is a photocatalytic material.Under the influence of visible light radiation,a hydrophilic region is created on the photocatalytic surface,due to oxygen vacancy adsorption generated by photoexcitation,which makes TiO2films have super hydrophilic properties [46].The hydrophilic surface is conducive to protein adsorption [47],which may further promote cell adhesion,and therefore is of great significance for osteogenesis.

3.4.Characteristics of MBG

Because MBG formed inside TiO2nanotubes could not be extracted,we prepared the MBG powder as a reference material in the same way and performed analysis instead.Wide-angle XRD analysis revealed no obvious crystal peaks,but a broad SiO2peak with a low intensity(Fig.5a).Over a small 2θ range of 0–2°(Fig.5b),the MBG powder had a diffraction peak at 1.5°,which is regarded as a characteristic peak of mesoporous materials[48].TEM confirmed that the MBG powder had a well-ordered and uniform mesoporous channel structure with a pore size of about 5 nm (Fig.5c).

To reveal the MBG loaded inside TiO2nanotubes,the surface of the 3D-Ti-NTs-MBG sample was sectioned(Fig.6a).EDS elemental analysis was performed in the red framed region indicated in Fig.6b).EDS analysis revealed the main elements in this region:oxygen,titanium and silicon (Fig.6c).In order to verify whether MBG indeed remained intact and present inside TiO2nanotubes,the 3D-Ti-NTs-MBG samples were subjected to ultrasonic vibrations as an attempt to force MBG to detach and then EDS analysis was performed once again.Element mapping of TiO2nanotubes showed the presence of Ti,Al,V,O,Si,Ca,and P (Fig.6d).Clearly,Ti,Al and V stemmed from the substrate and part of oxygen from titanium dioxide,as found by other researchers[49].As Si,Ca,O and P are the main elements of MBG [50],the presence of these elements inside nanotubes after ultrasonic vibration indicated that MBG deeply penetrated into TiO2nanotubes and remained firmly attached to tube inner walls.Although the structure of the MBG inside TiO2nanotubes could not be confirmed,we speculated that the MBG inside TiO2nanotubes would also have a mesoporous structure,being the same as that of the MBG powder,as shown earlier.Clearly,the nanotubes acted as reservoirs for MBG,whose amount could be far more than the MBG on the top of TiO2nanotubes,considering the large inner surface area of nanotubes.The large loading capacity of nanotubes could provide the possibility of releasing bioactive ions from the MBG inside nanotubes over an extended period,thereby overcoming the drawback of the MBG coating on 3D printed titanium alloy scaffolds[33].

3.5.Mechanical properties of the scaffolds

Fig.7 shows the compressive strengths of the 3D-Ti,3D-Ti-NTs,3DTi-NTs-MBG scaffolds over a range of 48.5–51.2 MPa.Statistical analysis showed no statistically significant differences between the three groups.In other words,TiO2nanotubes on the scaffolds and MBG loading in nanotubes had little effect on the mechanical strength.It is well known that the porosity of scaffold and the size of struts affect the mechanical strength of the scaffold the most [51].Anodization occurred only at the very surface of struts,leading to the formation of titanium dioxides.The thickness of the nanotube layer was much smaller than the sizes of titanium alloy particles adhered to the surface.Moreover,the overall porosity of the scaffold remained unchanged.It is likely that the heat treatment at 550 °C might lead to the start of decomposition of martensite inside struts and thus to a marginal increase in strength because of retained small α/α′lamella width and the release of residual stress [44].As the compressive strength of cancellous bone ranges from 0.25 to 15.9,the scaffold also meets the criteria for cancellous bone replacement [59].

3.6.Ion release from the 3D-Ti-NTS-MBG scaffolds

Fig.8 shows the changes of the concentrations of Ca and Si ions released from the 3D-Ti-NTs-MBG during immersion in the cell culture solution for different periods.The release profiles of Ca and Si ions from the 3D-Ti-NTs-MBG scaffolds appeared to be similar to each other,but the concentration of Ca ions was all the time higher than that of Si ions and the differences became larger over time.At the first day,the concentrations of Ca and Si ions released from the 3D-Ti-NTs-MBG scaffolds were 120 and 50 ppm,respectively.During the following days,the release rates of Ca and Si ions decreased and then stayed stable until day 7 when 131 ppm Si and 289 ppm Ca were released.This finding proved the hypothesis that 3D-Ti-NTs-MBG could release bioactive Ca and Si ions steadily and continuously.The sustained release of bioactive ions,i.e.,Ca ions and Si ions,can provide sufficient nutrients for cells,which will help promote cell proliferation and long-term osteogenesis[52].The results obtained from the present research marks an important step forward in the development of biofunctionalized 3D printed titanium alloy scaffolds from the previous study where the release of bioactive ions significantly decreased after the first day [33].The steady and continuous release of biological active ions from the 3DTi-NTs-MBG scaffolds could be attributed to the tubular space of TiO2nanotubes where MBG had great staying power before being released from TiO2nanotubes,as confirmed by the results obtained from elemental mapping after ultrasonic vibration (Fig.6d).Such release profiles could equip the 3D printed titanium alloy scaffolds with long-term capability of nutrient supply for bone repair,thus achieving a long-term bone repair effect.

3.7.Cell adhesion and proliferation

Fig.9 shows the adhesion and proliferation behaviors of hBMSCs cultured on the 3D-Ti-NTs and 3D-Ti-NTs-MBG scaffolds.HBMSCs spread well on the surfaces of these two groups.Cells spread on nanotubes and spread more widely on the surface with MBG (Fig.9a–d).Pseudopods grew on 3D-Ti-NTs (Fig.9a,c) and 3D-Ti-NTs-MBG surfaces (Fig.9b,d),which indicated great biocompatibility of TiO2nanotubes.Due to the hydrophilic nature of TiO2nanotubes that is conducive to protein adsorption,the surface-modified scaffolds promote cell adhesion[47].In a previous study,it was found that MBG released Ca ions and Si ions into the surrounding physiological environment and its presence could enhance human osteoblast cellular adhesion[53].In the present work,the observations that hBMSCs spread on 3D-Ti-NTs-MBG,pseudopods grew,and the close contact of hBMScs with the surface of the scaffolds was maintained,both indicated that the 3D-Ti-NTs-MBG scaffolds could well support cell adhesion.Cell adhesion and spread reflect cytoskeletal tension.The changes in cell shape and cytoskeletal tension are of great importance in determining the commitment of hBMSC to osteogenesis [54].

The results obtained from the CCK-8 assay of hBMSCs cultured on the 3D-Ti-NTs and 3D-Ti-NTs-MBG scaffolds for 1,3,and 7 days(Fig.9e)showed that the cells cultured on the 3D-Ti-NTs-MBG scaffolds presented no significantly different proliferation rates,when compared with those on the 3D-Ti-NTs scaffolds.It can be seen that on day 1 and day 3,the proliferation rates of hBMSCs on the 3D-Ti-NTs scaffolds were slightly lower than those of the 3D-Ti-NTs-MBG scaffolds.On the 7th day,however,the growth status of hBMSCs on the 3D-Ti-NTs scaffolds and 3D-Ti-NTs-MBG scaffolds became nearly the same.Previous studies have shown that TiO2nanotubes can offer a biocompatible and safe environment for cell attachment without any adverse effects and can even enhance cell proliferation [17,55,56].In the present research,hBMSCs cultured on the 3D-Ti-NTs scaffold and 3D-Ti-NTs-MBG scaffold showed similar cell proliferation rates,suggesting that the 3D-Ti-NTs-MBG scaffolds could also provide a biocompatible surface.As good biocompatibility is of great importance to achieve long-term bone repair,the 3D-Ti-NTs-MBG scaffolds are thus worth further evaluation in terms of bone regeneration capacity.

4.Conclusions

In this work,a novel method has been developed to equip 3D printed titanium alloy scaffolds with enhanced bioactivity by forming TiO2nanotubes on the surface through two-step anodization and loading MBG into TiO2nanotubes.With the presence of TiO2nanotubes,the hydrophilicity of the scaffolds is dramatically improved.The surface modification does not affect the compressive strength of the scaffolds.Bioactive ions,i.e.,Si and Ca ions,are readily and continuously released from MBG,which is beneficial for long-term bone repair.The CCK-8 assay of hBMSCs shows cell adhesion and proliferation on the 3D-Ti-NTs-MBG scaffolds and thus good biocompatibility.All the results demonstrate that combining nanostructure with bioactive ions is indeed a feasible approach to biofunctionalizing the surface of 3D printed titanium alloy scaffolds.

Declaration of competing interest

The authors declare that they have no known competing financial interests or personal relationships that could have appeared to influence the work reported in this paper.

Acknowledgements

The authors acknowledged the financial support from the National Key Research and Development Program of China (No.2017YFB1104101),Natural Science Foundation of China (No.81671830),Science and Technology Commission of Shanghai Municipality(19441902300),and Shanghai Nature Science Foundation(19ZR1464800).


登录APP查看全文