APP下载

学术出版场域变革与欧美学术出版机构的差异化策略

2020-01-08肖超

出版科学 2020年6期

[摘 要] 学术出版场域由科研资助机构、学术出版机构、大学、科研机构、图书馆占据的各种位置之间存在的一系列客观历史关系构成,场域中的资本主要有经济资本、学术资本、知识资本、内容资本、社会资本和符号资本6种类型。图书馆出版的快速发展、S计划的发布、学术资源获取方式多元等因素使得学术出版场域内各种资本形式的数量分布和结构发生改变,进而导致欧美学术出版场域结构发生变革。在各自不同学术出版惯习的指示下,商业出版社、大学出版社和学会出版社结合其拥有的资本数量和结构,生成了差异化出版策略。面对欧美学术出版场域的变革,商业出版社采取妥协与兼并策略,大学出版社采取创新与合作的策略,学会出版社采取合作与高质量发展策略。

[关键词] 学术出版 场域 资本 惯习 开放获取

[中图分类号] G237[文献标识码] A[文章编号] 1009-5853 (2020) 06-0109-09

The Transformation of Academic Publishing Field and the Diversified Strategies of European and American Academic Publishing Institutions

Xiao Chao

(School of Journalism& Communication,Shaanxi Normal University,Xian,710119)

[Abstract] The academic publishing field is composed of a series of objective historical relationships between various positions occupied by scientific research funding institutions,academic publishing institutions,universities,scientific research institutions and libraries. There are six main types of capital in the academic publishing field: economic capital,academic capital,intellectual capital,content capital,social capital and symbolic capital. The rapid development of library publishing,the proposal of the S plan,and the multiple ways of obtaining academic resources have changed the quantity distribution and structure of various capital forms in the academic publishing field,which has led to changes in the structure of the academic publishing field in Europe and America. Stimulated by their different habits,commercial publishers,university presses and society publishers have generated differentiated publishing strategies based on the amount and structure of capital they own. Facing changes in the academic publishing field in Europe and America,commercial publishers adopted a strategy of compromise and merger,university presses adopted a strategy of innovation and cooperation,and society publishers adopted a strategy of cooperation and high-quality development.

[Key words] Academic publishing Field Capital Habit Open access

1 学术出版场域及其资本

场域(Field)这一概念由法国社会学家布尔迪厄(Bourdieu)提出。一个场域可以被定义为在各种位置之间存在的客观关系的一个网络,或一個构型[1]。学术出版场域由科研资助机构、学术出版机构、大学、科研机构、图书馆占据的各种位置之间存在的一系列客观历史关系构成。学术出版场域是自主性的场域,距离权力场域相对较远。从知识生产方面来说,学术出版是针对学术同行的有限生产,因而学术出版场域更加遵循场域内部的规则。学术出版场域也是一个充满斗争的场域,学术出版机构、大学、图书馆、科研资助机构等在场域内部不断争夺资本与权力,试图维持或者提升他们在学术出版场域中的位置。……

登录APP查看全文