APP下载

On the Systemic Assessment of a Sustainable University

2014-03-22FrancescoGonella

Francesco Gonella

Department of Molecular Sciences and Nanosystems, Venice Ca' Foscari University, Dorsoduro 2137, 30123 Venezia, Italy

On the Systemic Assessment of a Sustainable University

Francesco Gonella†

Department of Molecular Sciences and Nanosystems, Venice Ca' Foscari University, Dorsoduro 2137, 30123 Venezia, Italy

In this paper, some motivations are discussed for an integrated approach in the study of complex environmental and socio-economic systems, based on the necessity of a systemic perspective wherever the drivers and the flows that control a system stability and evolution are strictly connected each other. The validity and the efficacy of the emergy-based analysis is then outlined for the general sustainability assessment of a University, and in particular for Venice Ca' Foscari University in Italy.

© 2014 L&H Scientific Publishing, LLC. All rights reserved.

Submission Info

Communicated by Sergio Ulgiati

Received 10 January 2014

Accepted 8 February 2014

Available online 1 April 2014

Complex systems

University sustainability

Emergy analysis

'…You never even hear any hints dropped on a Campus that wisdom is supposed to be the goal of knowledge. You hardly even hear the word 'wisdom' mentioned!' (Franny Glass).

1 Introduction

Since the 70s, an increasing awareness has grown among scholars from different disciplines about the need of a systemic approach (Von Bertalanffy, 1969) when dealing with ecosystems and socio-economic systems. As a matter of fact, any analysis of a complex system, and therefore any decision-making process, must take into account the network of cause-effect relationships and feedbacks between forces and flows that drive the evolution of the system at issue. In the tradition of environmental and socio-economic studies, a system is described starting from how its components work, and at the same time a body of phenomenological (or even empirical) laws and principles are set to describe the observed behavior in a predictive framework. Depending on the objective of the study, the descriptors and indicators used in the analyses pertain to different well separated fields, ranging from hard sciences to politics, economics, ecology, social sciences and so on. This set of descriptive parameters might be called (intrinsically) reductionist, in the sense that they are part of analyses that are -even quantitatively- focused on one single aspect of the system. For example, one does not expect to find in the same study of the sustainability of the Venice lagoon both the indicators "currency exchange rate" and "biodiversity", since the analysis will be almost certainly explicitly dedicated -let say- either to the sustainability of tourism or to the sustainability of the lagoon aquaculture. Indeed, this actually conveys an incorrect message, that the exchange rate and the lagoon fauna have nothing to do each other.

Sciences are challenged by problems related to complex environmental and technology-based systems that are extremely extended in both space and time. Keywords like "globalization", "sustainability", and "climate change" refer to systems whose evolution cannot be effectively foreseen or even described without an integrated and multi-disciplinary approach. In general, all the actions inspired by the concept of Sustainable Development have to adopt a systemic view in order to effectively account for all the driving forces responsible for the observed behaviors, so to provide a realistic description of the system evolution. Indeed, complex environmental systems exhibit behaviors that are not predictable from the simple knowledge of how their components work, presenting emergent properties originated from an embedded network of feedbacks between their subsystems. It is then necessary to address methods, approaches, variables and indicators able to describe and quantify the system sustainability as a whole (Georgescu-Roegen, 1971). We might call them, in contrast to the reductionist parameters, holistic parameters. This appears to be further necessary as long as policy makers have to manage social and environmental problems that require this kind of multi-disciplinary approach. Unfortunately, as a matter of fact, the burden of analyzing the environmental as well as the socioeconomic systems has been taken mostly by economists, whose analyses are focused in money transfers and are therefore anthropocentric by definition, thus preventing them to provide any sustainable solution to local and global challenges.

For example, market globalization and the dramatic supply decrease of fossil energy sources were almost unknown to most economists until 25 years ago, but in many respects their management today is framed in a conceptual background that is more than 25 years old. Decision makers are in this sense scientifically illiterate "by any rational definition of science literacy" (Goodstein, 1992). On the other hand, an ever increasing awareness of the global environmental impact of human activities has undoubtedly grown in many respects, and environmental issues are now considered together with economic and social issues in several aspects of planning and managing processes. A cross-disciplinary approach is then essential whenever a decision has to be taken inspired by an integrated sustainability concept. In this respect, the understanding of a complex system is based on techniques and analytical tools that enlighten the common "universal" features in the behavior of the system at issue, for example, the non-equilibrum Thermodynamics or the graph theory. The capability to investigate the emergent properties of a system operation will then reflect the role of the University in providing the knowledge necessary to face sustainability challenges in different spatial and temporal levels.

2 Emergy analysis

An integrated description in the quantitative analysis of a complex system may actually be carried out following two approaches, possibly balanced, but which are epistemologically different. The first one shifts the language and the descriptors from the definitions and the (generalized) laws that describe the system components to definitions and laws referred to the emergent properties exhibited by the system as a whole. This is the case for example of swarm flight as well as of the human brain, whose behavior as a whole cannot be directly connected to the way their components -bees and neurons- work, but is also the case for social, economic and environmental systems, such as stock market fluctuations. The second approach does not draw the attention to the emergent properties of the complex system, but rather to the possibility of putting together in the same analytical language all the -always already known- aspects related to how a system works. As far as a system is driven by forces and fluxes that have different origin and are concerned with different quantities, a common baseline is set, in this second approach, for the quantities and processes involved in the description of the studied system. In this way, at least in principle, the role played most of all by the feedback loops that rule the system may be effectively pointed out, helping both its understanding and managing.

In the case of environmental and socio-economic systems, a quantity suitable to quantitatively link the actual flows that drive the system, i.e., matter, energy, information and money, is emergy. Emergy (from "embodied energy") accounting was developed by Howard T. Odum (1983), who defined emergy as "the available energy of one kind that is used up in transformations directly and indirectly to make a product or service". Odum has then applied extensively emergy-based concepts in several fields, establishing a quite original discipline in the context of environmental and societal accounting (for a comprehensive list of Odum's books and papers, see the Center for Environmental Policy website at the University of Florida, 2013).

The emergy concept is therefore clearly related to the quality of energy itself, addressing the need of accounting for the expenses of the conversions and transformations that make that energy available. This in turn quantifies how much energy was used to "create" a product or service, that is, how much energy is embedded in it. By expressing all the quantities that enter in the system operation under the common baseline of the solar energy -the unit of emergy is called emjoule- one can quantify the available energy of one kind involved in transformations for all the processes occurring within the system at issue. But what is mostly relevant is the perspective of putting in the same computation quantities and variables pertaining to different formal reference settings, thus computing the emjoules of solar energy required to produce the respective contributions to a system or network, linked to the respective flows into and out of the system. For instance, the emergy related to the generation of one unit of economic product -in currency- allows one to include money transfers into processes measured by emergy units, so pointing out quantitatively the role played by money in the system operation even when the focus of the analysis is not the economic one.

The use of holistic indicators such as emergy appears to be quite suitable from at least two points of view: on one hand, it allows one to take into account the network of feedbacks ruling a system's operation and, on the other hand, it may provide a quantitative integrated analysis of the system in terms of its contribution to an economy, or in terms of its environmental loading. In this respect, a University appear to be a particularly interesting subject for an emergy-based analysis

3 A sustainable University

The idea of a "sustainable University" is indeed multifaceted, insofar as it reflects the different meanings acquired by the very concept of Sustainability in different contexts. Generally speaking, in any of its meanings sustainability has to do with the capability of a system to keep its "performance" (whatever it may be) in a long-term stationary state, without compromising its future operation in terms of interaction with its environment. Performance, operation and environment will be referred from time to time to different concepts, depending on the type of system one deals with, be it economical, social, physical, ecological, and so on. On one hand, besides its social role as a knowledge provider -both to the graduating students and to the society- a public University is sustainable to the extent it is able to keep the highest level of cultural contribution to the society, helping to establish a long-term global sustainability towards biophysical and social concerns. In this sense, the global economic crisis, as well as the role universities took on in facing the environmental global challenges, has pushed forward the idea that University has to pursue a tangible engagement in sustainability, for both what it does and what it is. On the other hand, various short-term objectives are usually referred to as pertaining to sustainability because they have to do with the public Universities resilience upon marketrelated issues. In particular, the competitive high education environment drives the institutional strategies toward the prestige given by a sustainable University. For all these reasons, the sustainability of a University in its various aspects well represents that of a society, where ecological, social and political concerns demand for the systemic approach and tools claimed for in this paper. The capability of a University to set itself as "sustainable" is then conveyed by the skilled, well prepared graduates provided to the community as well as by its local (as a particular University) and global (as part of an Institution) impact on the Society.

An increasing consensus has taken place about the important role played in the sustainable development by the University, intended both as an Institution of Research and Teaching that produces knowledge and wealth, and as a physical site influencing the environment in its widest sense. The University should be the place where educated people learn to observe, describe, interpret and manage the reality in the most integrated and holistic way. Even at the most basic level, the University itself (at least, a public Universities) should be a primary example of a sustainable system witnessed by the student. As claimed in the "Greening Universities Toolkit" by the United Nations Environment Programme (UNEP, 2013), "Universities, as the pinnacle of formal, organized education, thus have a particular responsibility both to help define and also to become exemplars of environmental best practice". But the truth is that a University student is more likely to learn -and much faster- how a corporation works in doing as much money as possible, rather than what an integrated sustainable managing means, and how it may be established.

The idea of a sustainable University or, more modestly, a sustainable Campus, entered in the last decades the strategic plans of almost all universities worldwide. But, as sharply pointed out by Madeleine Green (2012), the clarity and the effectiveness of an institution's actions depend on the clarity of the institution's goals, which in turn are found in their very definitions and in the correct evaluation of metrics of success, since they indicate what is valued. The general drivers that inspire the University's actions are clearly multifaceted. Even though quite a distinction should be made between public and private Universities, we can distinguish scientific, economic, social, and ethical issues that reinforce each other by more or less evident feedback actions. Indeed, several of the commitments of a modern public University have to do with globalization, for example, preparing students for "global citizenship" and workforce, contributing to the knowledge production on global issues, or even helping to find solutions to global problems. On the other hand, more "traditional" issues are the enhancing of the teaching and research quality, the strengthening of institutional prestige and visibility, and so the capability to generate revenue or to contribute to economic development.

As pointed out by an anonymous reviewer of this paper, the so-called maximum power principle can be taken as an effective indicator of the University operation for what concerns its sustainability, insofar competition and income growth become part of its self-organization. As far as sustainability goals are taken for competitive advantages, this can be regarded as a consequential systemic process of power optimization and, in this sense, a sustainable University comes to be seen as one providing larger production systems with suitable "tools" in terms of both graduates and knowledge. Indeed, the maximum power principle is not only a leading concept in energy system self-organization and analysis, but it may also sheds light on how University may consider its own sustainability in different ways, ultimately based on different social and political Weltanschauungen.

Specific actions have been taken in recent years to define and pursue the sustainability of universities, among which the UNEP Toolkit offers one of the most comprehensive assessment of indicators and strategies for improving the "degree of sustainability" of a University. It first defines the strategies necessary to initiate a sustainability policy for a University, from the making of commitments in terms of visions, missions, values and declarations, to the stakeholders engagement, the selection of indicators, objectives and targets, the development of action plans, and finally the processes of evaluation and communication. With the idea that only what can be measured can be managed, four broad categories are set for the definition of sustainability targets, namely, energy management and carbon emissions, water consumption and management, use of land, and materials flows. This categorization is followed by the definition of very specific actions, that cover the whole range of objectives in a quite systematic way. Nevertheless, some universities -especially in Europe- present strong specific peculiarities that sometimes make it difficult to comply with these indicators.

The challenge of such targets is exemplified by Ca' Foscari University in Italy. Ca' Foscari is located in the Venice island, mostly in sites and ancient buildings that are scattered across the city and that have significant historical and artistic relevance (by the way, they have therefore substantial embodied values not addressed in most metrics). This means that some of the objectives and some of the actions recommended for a sustainable University are in this case just unfeasible, for example, those one related to energy supply, water management, transportation, maintenance and renovation of existing buildings and infrastructures -often limited by the necessity of preserving the historical and artistic characteristics of the site. Moreover, other specific aspects strongly affect the operation of Venice University in several respects, for example, the majority of students are day trippers from the mainland. But, most of all, Ca' Foscari life, activity and operation are tightly bound to the city of Venice and to the lagoon ecosystem, both of them having quite peculiar specific problems as well as fragile equilibria. The appeal provided by Venice allows its university to strengthen very much its visibility, with several positive consequences from all viewpoints, and at the same time the environmental problems -one for all, the "high water" phenomenon- address Ca' Foscari University as one of the main actors called to provide a major contribution to the knowledge production on these issues, as well as to the finding of suitable solutions.

The concern with the transition from fossil fuel civilization to one based on renewable sources has to do with the time range of the sustainability issue for University. Three-years planning is typical for a University, at least in Italy, whereas several sustainability issues present a time horizon up to 100 years. Ca' Foscari is in this sense, again, particularly interesting, since a systemic analysis of its operation should embrace in turndifferent time spans, owing to the long-lasting cultural role of Venice as a city, coming from an all-renewable civilization. As soon as the use of a long list of objectives, indicators and actions is established as the sustainability policy of a University, it becomes crucial to analyze the internal relationships by which they are linked each other, pointing out how an action that enhances the sustainability of a part may influence other targets or indicators values. The very existence of feedbacks and auto-catalytic processes within the University is the reason that ultimately pushes towards an integrated analysis, such as that provided by the emergy accounting, as a tool for understanding and managing the institution. In the late 70s, H.T. Odum first outlined an energy diagram for a public University, the University of Florida, which contained the fundamental elements for the emergy analysis of a university. In his book of 1996 (Odum, 1996), he also addressed quantitatively the emjoule/$ related to the flows in the University, namely, the incoming contributions by environment, services, resources, students and faculty against the outgoing graduates, services, research and sports. community, with people and tools able to manage a sustainable world. In some sense, we might say that this makes Nature itself a receiver of the University services. Besides a similar contribution in terms of new knowledge and information, a private University has by definition a different output -educational qualifications, and a different customer -the students themselves, the latter "buying" the former mostly to have access to profitable employment.

Fig. 1.Emergy diagram of a public University. Circles are the sources (forcing functions), tank symbols are the storage units, bullet-like symbols are the producer units, and diamonds indicate transfers of money, whose flow is represented by the dashed arrows.

As concerns Ca' Foscari University of Venice, several peculiarities will have to be addressed following the diagram structure, permitting us to quantify their relative importance and the feedback mechanisms influencing their operation. First of all, it is worth stressing the importance of the University image. Needless to say, the location on the island of Venice, the historical centre of the municipality, has an enormous positive impact in terms of visibility and appeal, also for the capability of attracting cultural assets that boost significantly even the research activities. The Venetian cultural environment has always been in this sense a guarantee for the academic activities, such as for example those related to internationalization and fund raising. On the other hand, the very same location explains the scattering among different sites and gives rise to a series of drawbacks. Internal transfer among the different departments are time consuming and uncomfortable (quite often, professor offices or labs and teaching classrooms are in different buildings); infrastructures and services become quite expensive, and while the image has a positive effect toward the enrolment and the attraction of external funds (see figure), basic services can be worsened. For example, the quality of the scientific activity is linked to the availability of efficient and modern laboratories. Students residential facilities are also generally too expensive or logistically unfeasible, whereas an efficient or renewable energy supply planning has been shown to be strongly site-dependent (Ca' Foscari, 2012).

Without entering into the details of a quantitative accounting, the emergy analysis is expected to provide a powerful insight in the mechanisms that drive the Ca' Foscari operation, and thus its sustainability. In particular, the strong links between the Venice tourism-based economy, the environmental vulnerability of both the city and the lagoon ecosystem, and the role of Venice as cultural centre, must be analyzed and interpreted as parts of an integrated picture, in which various traditional indicators merge in giving effective operational tools of analysis. Even if this is beyond the aim of this paper, it is worth stressing that the emergy accounting for Ca' Foscari is expected to address the energy hierarchy in the energy flows and transformations, as pointed out in Odum's work, and this should reveal how they have been changing during the system life.

A final point must be addressed. The University should be the place where some kind of wisdom is pursued. If the society, in its widest sense, has to find its leaders and its policy makers in the universities output, the University itself must be the place where some universal culture is taught. Teaching an integrated awareness of the unity of things should be a focus not only from an abstract cultural point of view, but also at the level of quantitative analytical approaches to the challenges and the global problems we are facing. A renovation of the didactic programmes is therefore claimed, in which integrated courses are delivered within the undergraduate curricula of any discipline, teaching the systemic thinking that has already entered the research activity in many fields, but is still quite difficult to explicitly introduce in educational activities. In particular, energy systems language and emergy synthesis are one of the possible cultural tools to be included in almost any higher education programme, since it represents a way to understand and describe the role of environment in the definition and planning of systems, processes, and products. A series of items should be delivered in these specific interdisciplinary courses, at least within the curricula of scientific, economic and social sciences. A possible short list should certainly include, for example, the principles of Thermodynamics and their relation with the environment, the fundamentals of Systems Theory, the basics of self-organization, and the introduction to some concepts like feedback, emergent properties, and critical states. In this respect, it is worth noting that emergy-based approaches have been in turn related to the general complex system framework, evaluating its effectiveness in terms of states space analysis (Brown et al., 2009; Giannetti et al., 2012).

4. Conclusions

Different sustainability analyses of a complex environmental and socio-economic system reflect the different disciplinary issues addressed from time to time by the very objective of any single approach. The result is a modelling which is a priori biased, so restricting its effectiveness into the boundaries of one of the many as-pects that combine to drive the system operation, stability and evolution. An emergy analysis can effectively overcome this partitioning, providing a way to quantitatively keep into account the complex network of contribution and feedbacks between the drivers and the flows ruling any environmental and socio-economic system. The University, both as a physical system and as an institution, is particularly suitable to be described by an emergy-based analysis, since it can provide an insight into sustainability from different viewpoints, connecting economic, social and scientific aspects and giving an effective contribution to the definition of operational strategies. In particular, investigating Ca' Foscari University of Venice reveals the profound differences with respect to traditional campus-based universities, such as those addressed in the various international documents of sustainability criteria and strategies. Concerning the University role in its widest sense, to teach sustainability is in turn a powerful tool for pursuing sustainability. In the words of David Orr (1992), "To teach Economics, for example, without reference to the laws of Thermodynamics or those of Ecology is to teach a fundamentally important ecological lesson: that Physics and Ecology have nothing to do with the Economy. That just happens to be dead wrong".

Acknowledgements

I would like to thank the anonymous Referees for the quality of their suggestions and comments.

Brown, M.T. and Ulgiati, S. (1997), Emergy-based indices and ratios to evaluate sustainability: monitoring economies and technology toward environmentally sound innovation, Ecological Engineering,9, 51-69.

Brown, M.T., Cohen, M.J. and Sweeney, S. (2009), Predicting national sustainability: the convergence of energetic, economic and environmental realities, Ecological Modelling,220, 3424-3438.

Ca' Foscari University (2012), Sustainability Report 2012, http://www.unive.it/nqcontent.cfm?a_id=157848.

Center for Environmental Policy, University of Florida, http://www.cep.ees.ufl.edu/emergy/publications/odum.shtml.

Georgescu-Roegen, N. (1971), The Entropy Law and the Economic Process, Harvard University Press, Cambridge, USA.

Giannetti, B.F., Almeida, C.M.V.B., and Bonilla, S.H. (2012). Can emergy sustainability index be improved? Complementary insights for extending the vision, Ecological Modelling,244, 158-161.

Goodstein, D. (1992), The Science Literacy Gap: A karplus lecture, Journal of Science Education and Technology,1, 149-155.

Green, M.F. (2012), Universities must be clear and honest about internationalisation, University World News,217, http://www.universityworldnews.com/article.php?story=2012041114440954.

Odum, H.T. (1983). Systems Ecology: An Introduction, John Wiley, New York.

Odum, H.T. (1996), Environmental Accounting: Emergy and Environmental Decision Making, John Wiley and Sons, New York.

Orr, D.W. (1992), Ecological Literacy: Education and the Transition to a Postmodern World, New York State Univ. Press, New York.

UNEP, (2013), United Nations Environment Programme, Greening Universities Toolkit 2013, http://www.unep.org/training/docs/Greening_University_Toolkit.pdf.

Von Bertalanffy, L. (1969), General System Theory; Foundations, Development, Applications, G. Braziller: New York.

†Corresponding author.

Email address: gonella@unive.it (F. Gonella).

ISSN 2325-6192, eISSN 2325-6206/$- see front materials © 2014 L&H Scientific Publishing, LLC. All rights reserved.

10.5890/JEAM.2014.03.005


登录APP查看全文