APP下载

Carbon Capture and Storage (CCS) policy for China: Implications from Some Representative Countries and Regions

2014-03-22XudongWuQingYangTianhuaWuGuoqianChenStateKeyLaboratoryforTurbulenceandComplexSystemsCollegeofEngineeringPekingUniversityBeijing0087China

Xudong Wu, Qing Yang, Tianhua Wu, Guoqian ChenState Key Laboratory for Turbulence and Complex Systems, College of Engineering, Peking University, Beijing 0087, China

2Hubei Key Laboratory of Industrial Fume & Dust Pollution Control, Jianghan University, Wuhan 430056, PR China

3State Key Laboratory of Coal Combustion, Huazhong University of Science and Technology, Wuhan 430074, China

4Department of New Energy Science and Engineering, School of Energy and Power Engineering, Huazhong University of Science and Technology, Wuhan 430074, China

Carbon Capture and Storage (CCS) policy for China: Implications from Some Representative Countries and Regions

Xudong Wu1, Qing Yang2,3,4†, Tianhua Wu3,4†, Guoqian Chen11State Key Laboratory for Turbulence and Complex Systems, College of Engineering, Peking University, Beijing 100871, China

2Hubei Key Laboratory of Industrial Fume & Dust Pollution Control, Jianghan University, Wuhan 430056, PR China

3State Key Laboratory of Coal Combustion, Huazhong University of Science and Technology, Wuhan 430074, China

4Department of New Energy Science and Engineering, School of Energy and Power Engineering, Huazhong University of Science and Technology, Wuhan 430074, China

In recent years carbon capture and storage (CCS) emerged as a promising low-carbon technology to tackle climate change by storing the captured CO2underground. Varied countries and regions have promulgated or proposed specific CCS policies to accommodate with CCS development in their jurisdictions. However, CCS policies seem to be in a vacancy in China. Presented in this paper is a general overview for CCS policies in some representative countries and regions including the United States, Canada, United Kingdom and Australia that are making substantial contributions to the establishment of CCS policy framework in their own jurisdictions as well as their implications for construction of CCS policy framework in China. CCS policies in China are also reviewed and compared with those of the typical economic entities in detail. The result demonstrates that prescriptive standards and regulations, economic incentives as well as supportive measures are not sufficient to smooth CCS deployment in China. Policy recommendations are thus raised to guide CCS progress in China, with a suggested policy package including enactment of CCS regulatory framework, multi-source funding mechanism, elaborated measures to raise public awareness of CCS. The outcome has essential policy implications supportive to a further expansion of CCS deployment in China.

© 2014 L&H Scientific Publishing, LLC. All rights reserved.

Submission Info

Communicated by Zhifeng Yang

Received 13 December 2013

Accepted 8 February 2014

Available online 1 April 2014

Carbon capture and storage

Climate change

CCS policies

Representative countries

China

1 Introduction

Over the past century, the world has witnessed a stunning economic growth instigated by the worldwide speedup of urbanization, which directly induces a tremendous consumption of fossil fuel energy. Energy-related CO2emissions are thus climbing to an unprecedented level than ever. A number of studies have been carried out to investigate into the carbon emissions on global (Vetőné Mózner, 2013; Chen and Chen, 2011; Chen and Chen, 2011; Pani and Mukhopadhyay, 2011) national (Chen and Chen, 2010; Chen and Zhang, 2010; Zhang, et al.,2014; Robaina Alves and Moutinho, 2013) urban (Chen, et al., 2013; Guo and Chen, 2013; Zhou, et al., 2010; Vause, et al., 2013; Dong, et al., 2013) and engineering scale (Chen, et al., 2011; Matthias and Paul, 2013). According to International Energy Agency (IEA), in the past 40 years, our energy demand has more than doubled, from 250 EJ to 500 EJ and the related CO2emissions has soared from 15 Gt to over 30 Gt (IEA, 2012). The associated climate change concern, widely recognized as being triggered by excessive CO2emissions into the atmosphere (Milner, et al., 2012; Susan, 2007), is therefore rising as one of the key issues that will significantly impact our future. To comply with the 2 ℃ target reached at the Cancun conference, the world needs to cut energy-related CO2emissions by 50% from today’s level by 2050 (Priddle, 2002).

The situation is particularly severe in China. The dazzling economic growth in the last 30 years has given rise to a soaring increase in fossil fuel consumption and hence rated China as the largest CO2emitter in the world. Confronted with sustained international pressure, China made a commitment to reduce CO2emissions per unit of GDP by 40%-45% by 2020 than that of 2005’s level in Copenhagen conference. To attain such a drastic emission reduction, especially carbon emission mitigation in coal-dominated power sector in which over 60% of coal consumption is used for power generation (Zhang and Cheng, 2009; Chandran Govindaraju and Tang, 2013), a package of low-carbon technologies encompassing greater energy efficiency, increased renewable energies, nuclear power and the near-decarbonisation of fossil fuel-based power generation could be employed. It is estimated that coal will keep up its dominant position to satisfy the energy delivery of China in the near future. In this scenario, carbon capture and storage, which captures and transports CO2from major emission sources to a storage site where the CO2is injected underground and then trapped in porous geological formations deep below the surface (Almendra, et al., 2011; Hidalgo and Carrera, 2009; Wu and Chen, 2014), has emerged as a promising technology with great capacity for CO2reductions in coal-fired power plants (Metz, et al., 2005; Meadowcroft and Langhelle, 2009; Markusson, et al., 2012). In IEA’s scenario, CCS would contribute about one-fifth of the emissions reductions on the globe to achieve the ambitious climate goal at a reasonable cost. This is particularly important to realize deep emissions reduction in China, which is advancing with an ongoing expansion of urbanization and currently exhibits no sign of slowing down its fossil fuel consumption.

Despite a late comer in CCS, Chinese government is making some preliminary efforts to promote CCS deployment. In 2006, the State council released the national medium-and long-term science and technology development plan that incorporated CCS in the plan as a cutting-edge technology to achieve high efficient utilization and near-zero emission of fossil fuels. Afterwards, in 2007 China’s National Climate Change Program identified CCS as one of the key carbon emission abatement technologies. In the same year, China’s Science & Technology Action on Climate Change was issued to design a technology roadmap for CCS.

Currently CCS demonstration projects are rather vigorous in China. However, these activities are still far from enough to guarantee the anticipated goal of CO2emissions reduction (Li, et al., 2011). An additional large number of large-scale CCS projects are required to be implemented to make China fully prepared for CCS deployment. In this situation, in response to such expansion of CCS technology a number of policyrelated and regulatory issues are thus raised to govern CCS activities as well as provide economic incentives for CCS development, which has been broadly accepted by numerous policy makers in varied countries. Representative countries and regions, such as the United States, Canada, European Union, the United Kingdom, Australia, are making substantial contributions to setting up CCS policy framework in their own jurisdictions with specific CCS legislations and policy incentives carried out. With regard to China, while CCS researches and demonstration projects are already underway in China, a comprehensive domestic policy framework specifically for CCS has not yet been developed. A policy package for CCS, including policy incentive and specific CCS regulations, are therefore urgent to be established in China for successful deployment of CCS.

Vast studies have been conducted to discuss CCS on the policy front in various countries. As CCS specific regulations are crucial to warrant safe geological CO2sequestration, a number of studies lay emphasis on theestablishment of a national or multilateral CCS regulatory framework (Reiner and Herzog, 2004; Mace, et al., 2007; Wilson, et al., 2007; Bode and Jung, 2006; IEA, 2010; Pollak, 2011). Some other scholars, however, focused on the policy incentives to drive CCS development in various countries (Groenenberg and Coninck, 2008; von Stechow, et al., 2011; Groenenberg, 2011; Scrase and Watson, 2009; Jürgen-Friedrich, 2009; Condor, 2011). Founding on an interview of Chinese government experts, Liang and Wu (2009) gave an analysis of four crucial aspects for CCS deployment in China and put forward CCS policy incentives for CCS implementation. Han et al. (2013) conducted detailed analyses on strengths, weaknesses, opportunities and constraints on CCS with suggested prioritized incentives. Li et al. (2011) presented the strength, barriers, opportunities and risks facing CCS in China and proposed targeted policies for large-scale, fully integrated CCS projects. Compared with these, some researchers conducted comparative studies for CCS policies in different countries. Wilson et al. (2011) compared political and institutional context for CCS policy framework in China and US. Yuan and Lyon (2012) presented a contrast for CCS political context in US and China and discussed incentives to promote global CCS research and development by US-China collaboration.

However, to our knowledge, none of the associated studies undertake an integrated comparison for CCS policies in China with those in some typical countries and regions that possess a relatively comprehensive policy and regulatory framework, on the basis of a review for CCS policies in the representative entities.

In this study, it aims to review CCS policies in the selected countries and regions (including abovementioned representative entities and China) and compare CCS policies in China with those of the representative countries and regions to find the potential gap as well as put forward policy outlook for CCS implementation in China, with due consideration of the latest progress in this field. The outcome could have essential policy implications supportive to a further spread of CCS deployment in China. The rest of this paper is organized as follows: Section 2 presents an overview for CCS policy package in selected countries and regions; Section 3 compares CCS policies in China with those in the typical countries and regions to assess the potential gap as well as evaluate whether the adequacy of policy priority is given to CCS demonstration in China, with policy suggestions raised for effective CCS policy making; finally concluding remarks are given in the Section 4.

2 Review on CCS policies for selected countries and regions

This section will generally review CCS policies in six selected economic entities encapsulating China and five representative countries and regions that include the United States, Canada, European Union, the United Kingdom and Australia. Some other countries like Japan have also become involved in CCS and have indeed contributed preliminary endeavors to implementing CCS regulatory framework in recent years. However, given their unconspicuous efforts in comparison to the five representative countries and regions, they are not directed attention to in this paper. The macroscopic classification criteria put forward by Tanaka (2011) are employed here, which sort the policy package into three main policy groups as prescriptive policies, economic policies, and supportive policies. In this paper, prescriptive policies for CCS refer to emissions performance standard (EPS) and regulations for CO2storage that directly govern performance of the projects. Economic policies are emission trading scheme (ETS) and subsidies (e.g., feed-in tariff, government grants, preferential loans, tax credit and special fund) that intend to make CCS implementation more cost-effective. Supportive policies indicate cooperative measures with other countries or organizations, and public engagement that help to build a favorable environment in which CCS projects could be deployed more smoothly.

2.1 The United States of America

United States has been a leader in CCS related research, development and demonstration on the globe with 23 large-scale CCS projects in operation or in various stages of development (GCCSI, 2013), which proves to be the largest amount for any country or region. Corresponding policy package for CCS has been established on the federal and regional scale to stimulate CCS progress.

2.1.1 Prescriptive policies

1) CO2EPS

A straight forward way to introduce CCS in power sector is to set an emission benchmark for the power plants to abide by, which directly regulates carbon pollution of power plants. EPS serves as a rather flexible measure to govern emissions performance of power plants by allowing the emitters to gradually fulfill their obligations in CO2emissions deduction. The penalty on the excessive carbon emissions may drive the operators in traditional power plants to plunge into research & demonstration for low-carbon technologies (CCS included) as alternatives, which is effective to pave the way for attracting investment from the electricity sector into CCS and helps smooth the transition to a CCS stage in the power plants. Such legal measures have been promulgated by US Environment Protection Agency (EPA). On 20 September 2013 the EPA released its proposed EPS for new fossil-fuelled power plants, limiting greenhouse gas emissions (GHG) emissions to 454 kg CO2per megawatt hour (EPA, 2013). For new power plants with clean energy technologies like CCS, they are offered an alternative to meet the standard on new average over a certain span of years. The standards define and separate responsibility of newly established fossil fuel plant as well as present priority for power plants equipped with CCS facilities in fulfilling emission reduction task, thus directly boosting the adoption of CCS facilities in fossil-fueled power plants. In addition, several US states have already obtained an operational EPS for power plants in their jurisdictions, as indicated in Table 1 (Talberg, 2011).

Table 1Emissions performance standard in selected countries

2) Regulations on CO2storage

CO2storage remains as the most complex part in CCS chain, with a number of environment, liability and property issues to be addressed. Specific regulations have been proposed to the US federal government. However, most of them do not win approval or are being halted in the Senate. Only one legislation specific for regulating CO2storage is currently in force on the federal level in the USA. In December 2010, EPA published the Federal Requirements Under the Underground Injection Control (UIC) Program for Carbon Dioxide (CO2) Geological Sequestration (GS) Wells Final Rule (USEPA, 2012). Under the rule, a new class of wells, Class VI is defined and requirements are established to protect underground sources of drinking water, containing a package of provisions on siting, construction, operation, monitoring, post-injection site care of the geological sequestration wells. Besides, to accommodate with Class VI Rule, in August 2011, EPA proposed to exclude CO2from EPA’s hazardous waste regulations under the Resources Conservation and Recovery Act if they meet certain conditions (IEA, 2012), which helps resolve the environment concern in underground CO2injection.

2.1.2 Economic policies

1) ETS

It is being increasingly agreed that without a flexible mandatory ETS, the most cost-effective emission reductions could not be achieved. When applied to CCS activities, CCS operators may benefit from trading unused emission allowances with other entities covered under the ETS. No federal-level mandatory emissions trade schemes are currently in force in the US. Two federal climate Acts, the America Clean Energy and Security Act of 2009 and America's Climate Security Act of 2007 which sought to create a national cap-tradescheme, were proposed to the federal government but were defeated in the Senate. Despite that, the ACE Act is worthy of a description here as it sets a model for the latter proposals. Under the Act, a nationally total amount of GHG allowances was identified and the covered entities may buy or sell permits on the market. Besides, a $ 60 billion subsidy from the revenues generated in ETS is proposed under the Act to support carbon capture and sequestration (Wikipedia, 2013).

2) Subsidies

a) Government grants

The US federal economic incentives to facilitate CCS deployment have mainly emphasized on financial support for CCS research and development. Currently more than $ 3 billion is allocated on research and development for CCS to back CCS research and demonstration projects, including the $ 27 million for CO2storage research, the $ 1 billion grants injected into CCS oxy-combustion project (ZERO, 2013).

b) Tax credit

Tax credit could in a way instigate investment in CCS by reducing the tax liability of operators employing the technology. Federal legislation in the USA has covered tax credit as an incentive for CCS. The Energy Act 2005 set aside $ 1.3 billion for a Qualifying Advanced Coal Project Tax Credit, of which $ 350 million is authorized for the development of certain specific gasification project attributes such as CCS and renewable fuels (Baker and Mckenzie, 2009).

c) Special fund

Special fund could serve as an important financial contribution to support CCS demonstration projects, especially for the post-closure stewardship of storage site. Oklahoma in United States has set a model for other states in the legislative process of including special funds as a financial contribution for CCS. The Geologic Storage of Carbon Dioxide Act puts forward a fee to be placed on each ton of CO2injected for storage to form the Carbon Dioxide Geologic Storage Trust Funds, which may be utilized solely for longterm monitoring of the site (Hamilton, et al., 2009). In this way, it helps ease the financial burden of the longterm costs on the relevant authority and ensure a safe geological sequestration.

2.1.3 Supportive policies

1) Cooperative measures

A number of cooperative measures have been undertaken by US government to facilitate CCS deployment. The most representative one is the FutureGen announced by former US President George in 2003, which accumulates international efforts to build the zero-emissions coal-fired IGCC power plants using carbon capture and storage. Currently FutureGen alliance is comprised of 10 power producers and electric utilities from the globe, including Chinese largest power company (the Huaneng power group).

2) Public engagement

Governments’ initiative in raising public awareness of CCS and engaging the public may effectively avoid the potential public opposition and resistance on CCS implementation and is hence particularly important. The UIC Class VI final rule specifies the public engagement under the existing UIC public participation requirements, regulating that relevant information of Class VI permit shall be provided by the owners and permitting authority via print media or Internet. Besides, a public comment period is required to receive comments from the public and the permitting authority shall give full consideration to the public comment and hold public hearing if possible.

2.2 Canada

CO2sequestration has received extensive attention as an effective way to mitigate GHG emissions in Canada with one claimed largest CCS project in the world. Corresponding CCS specific policies have been carried out to help accelerate CCS deployment, the progress of which is especially remarkable in Canadian provinces.

2.2.1 Prescriptive policies

1) EPS

On 27 August 2011,the Government of Canada issued Reduction of Carbon Dioxide Emissions from Coal-Fired Generation of Electricity Regulations that was projected to be in force on 1 July 2015, in which an EPS was proposed for power plants. Under the proposed regulations, the performance standard is set at a benchmark similar to that of natural gas combined cycle technology and will be fixed at 375 tonnes of CO2/GWh (Gazette, 2011). Meanwhile, new units equipped with CCS facilities could receive a temporary exemption from the standard until 2025, which would cast a strong incentive on the power generators to employ CCS. The regulation also sets a buffer period for both the old and new units to adapt to the EPS. The power plants are thus rendered sufficient time to investigate the feasibility of employing CCS as well as settle technological and financial barriers standing in the way. In addition, on the state level, one ETS is currently on operation in Alberta, as listed in Table 1.

2) Regulations on CO2storage

In Canada no federal legislations deal with regulatory issues related with CO2storage. On the regional scale, two regulations in Alberta province, Carbon Capture and Storage Statutes Amendments Act 2010 and Carbon Sequestration Tenure Regulation, are closely correlated with regulating CO2storage. Carbon Capture and Storage Amendments Act came into effect in 2010 in Alberta and addressed several key issues correlated with CO2storage including the ownership of pore space of storing CO2and long-term liability transfer (Massicotte, 2011). With regard to the Carbon Sequestration Tenure Regulation, it brings forth requirements under which the evaluation permit is granted and raises the preconditions for acquiring a sequestration lease, with detailed depiction of the elements contained in monitoring, measuring and verification plans and closure plans.

2.2.2 Economic policies

1) ETS

Up to present there exists no federal mandatory ETS in Canada, with only one regional mandatory cap-andtrade scheme in operation in Alberta. The Alberta Climate Change and Emissions Management Amendment Act establishes a local cap-and-trade scheme applicable to all emitters that let out more than 100,000 tonnes of GHG a year in Alberta. This mandatory scheme encourages the industrial facilities to make some technical improvement. CCS as an abatement option may provide great potential for the power plants to decrease CO2emissions, thus accelerating CCS employment in power plants.

2) Subsidies

Remarkable funding for CCS deployment has been warranted from the federal government. In the past five years the government has committed $ 795 million for clean energy research, including $ 650 million for large-scale CCS projects (ZERO, 2013).

2.2.3 Supportive policies

Canada participated in the Asia-Pacific Partnership in 2006 and worked together with other members to investigate into clean coal technologies, including CCS. Besides, Canada and America has made a joint effort to work on clean energy technologies.

2.3 The European Union

2.3.1 Prescriptive policies

1) EPS

So far European Union has established no legislation that sets up EPS for CCS in the member states.

2) Regulations on CO2storage

On 6 April 2009, EU Directive 2009/31/EC (CCS Directive) was passed by the Council of Ministers to govern the geological storage of carbon storage within the territory of EU member states and came in effect on 25 June 2009. The CCS Directive formulates requirements across the lifespan of a storage site, covering site selection, storage permits, liability in closure and post-closure period. Under the Directive, extensive requirements for site selection are laid down and a comprehensive monitoring & reporting plan for the closure and post-closure period is established. In addition, it is ruled in the Directive that no storage site may be used without a permit and the competent authority may withdraw the permits in certain conditions, thus setting up an approval mechanism for permits and bringing down the risks in environment damage caused by inappropriate operations.

2.3.2 Economic policies

1) ETS

The European Commission released the Emission Trading Directive (Directive 2003/87/EC) in 2003 that claimed the member states to establish a scheme for GHG allowance within the community and was afterwards amended by subsequent Directives. The EU ETS officially started running on 1 January 2005. As the world’s largest multi-country and multi-sector GHG ETS, the EU ETS requires each member state to create a national allocation plan that identifies the total number of allowances as well as how it intends to allocate these allowances to various installations covered by the scheme. Under the scheme, when a covered installation emits more CO2equivalent than allowances granted, they may purchase the extra allowances on the market. The revised EU Emission Trading Directive (Directive 2009/29/EC) recognizes CCS as a climatechange mitigation technology and incorporates CCS activities into the regime, which provides a flexible carbon market that directly enables CCS power plants to benefit from trading the unused allowances.

Table 2Current and Proposed CCS Legislations in UK

2) Subsidies

The revised ETS Directive (2009/29/EC) rules that up to 300 million allowances in the new entrants’ reserve (NER) will be set aside until 31 December 2015 to help stimulate the construction and operation of up to 12 CCS demonstration projects as well as renewable energy projects (EUR-Lex, 2013).

2.4 The United Kingdom

CCS is likely to play a key role in the UK future energy portfolio due to the dominant role of fossil fuels in its energy system. A detailed UK CCS roadmap has been launched in 2012, setting out a comprehensive package to guide the United Kingdom to accomplish their objective of the commercialization of CCS projects in the2020s. Meanwhile major steps have been taken by the UK government to lay down key policies and regulations in support of the technology.

2.4.1 Prescriptive policies

1) EPS

On 29 November 2012 the Secretary of State for Energy and Climate Change confirmed the introduction of the 2012 Energy Bill to the House of Commons. An EPS is raised in the Bill to limit the amount of CO2emissions from new fossil fuel power stations to 450 kg/MWh. Coal units that are part of CCS demonstration projects are provided exemptions under the EPS. This directly sends out a signal that those carbon intensive power plants will not be permitted to be built unless equipped with decarbonisation facilities, which in a way may facilitate the newly built power plant to seek CCS as an alternative so as to meet the performance standard.

2) Regulations on CO2storage

A package of UK legislations regulating CO2activities is listed in Table 2 (GCCSI, 2013).2.4.2 Economic policies

1) ETS

The United Kingdom is among the first several countries to introduce ETS in the world. The UK voluntary emission trading market was launched in March 2002, covering 33 participants from the public sector and private. Under the regime a discount on energy was offered to enterprises that introduced measures to cut down emissions. The UK ETS was later incorporated into EU-ETS and the domestic carbon market in UK is now operating under the mandatory regulatory framework of EU-ETS.

2) Subsidies

a) Government grants

The UK CCS Roadmap was launched in April 2012 containing a 4-year (2011~2015) £ 125 million crossgovernment CCS research and understanding, development and innovation programme, which by now has assisted around 100 separate projects in total (DECC, 2013). Besides, a £1 billion CCS Commercialization Programme that applied to gas and coal-fired power plants was announced by UK government in April 2012 to support the practical experience in commercial CCS projects. This may help accumulate the experience on the initial stage and bring down the costs of CCS.

b) Feed-in tariff

The UK has been a pioneer in introducing feed-in tariff. The UK Department of Energy and Climate Change published an Electricity Market Reform paper on 12 July 2011, setting out reforms intended to drive decarbonization. One of them is the Long term contracts in the form of a feed-in tariff, which serves as an agreement for a low-carbon project(CCS included) to receive a fixed price for per kWh of electricity produced and could offer stable financial incentives to propel investment in the low-carbon projects. This offers the power plant operators a price that surpasses the market price to compensate for the high cost of CCS deployment (Mitchell, et al., 2006) and provides a steady mechanism against price fluctuation.

2.4.3 Supportive policies

UK has been an active player in cooperation with foreign countries and organizations and is part of Zero Emissions Platform, Carbon Sequestration Leadership Forum, EU-China near zero emissions coal (ZERO, 2013).

2.5 Australia

CCS, together with solar and geothermal power, is accounted as a crucial low-carbon technology in Australia and has received vast support. Relevant policies for CCS have been carried out nationally or in the jurisdictions including Queensland, South Australia, Victoria and Western Australia.

Table 3Federal CCS regulations in Australia

2.5.1 Prescriptive policies

1) EPS

A list of current situation of EPS in Australia is presented in Table 1.

2) Regulations on CO2storage

An overview of federal and state regulations on CO2storage is respectively listed in Table 3 and Table 4 (GCCSI, 2013).

Table 4State CCS regulations in Australia

2.5.2 Economic policies

1) ETS

Australia hasn’t got an operational mandatory ETS on the federal level. The approval of relevant Acts has encountered a divergence among the different political parties. As a result, installation of a domestic federal emission trading market is halted. The only regional ETS on operation in Australia is the Greenhouse Gas Reduction Scheme in New South Wales, with the aims to slash GHG emissions in electricity production as well as encourage the development of those activities mitigating GHG emissions (CCS included). It requiresthe electricity retailer to manage their emissions benchmark so as to satisfy the requirements of GHG emissions standard. This could have a positive impact on the operators of carbon intensive power plants to consider CCS option for CO2emissions deduction.

2) Subsidies

a) Government grants

Australia government has contributed a significant amount of capital to advocate CCS. In the 2009-2010 Budget, the Australian Government made a commitment to contribute AUD 2 billion to the CCS Flagships Programs over nine years as part of the Government’s Clean Energy Initiative, targeting at supporting construction and demonstration of large-scale CCS projects. Meanwhile, the Australian government has declared an annual funding of AUD 100 million Australian dollars to establish Global CCS Institute that serves as an international platform to bring together projects, policy-makers and researchers to overcome challenges facing CCS.

b) Special fund

In 2006 Australia Coal Association, a group of the major Australia coal mining industry members established the $ 1 COAL21 fund that will raise $ 1 billion over the next decade from a voluntary levy on coal production produced by coal industry to fund CCS commercialization by 2020.

2.5.3 Supportive policies

Australia government has been engaged in a number of international cooperation on CCS. The most remarkable one is the aforementioned Global CCS Institute. The Institute is launched by Australia government in April 2009 and has built a collaborative international Membership constituted of 374 government industry, non-government and research organizations from around the world (GCCSI, 2013). It serves as a platform for the members to learn from each other as well as provides CCS related knowledge to public audience, thus advancing the understanding of a series of technical, economic and regulatory barrier facing CCS.

2.6 China

2.6.1 Prescriptive policies

Currently there are no operational or proposed EPS for power plants nor any regulation specifically for CO2storage in China.

2.6.2 Economic policies

1) ETS

China currently possesses no national mandatory ETS in service. Over ten emissions exchanges have been established to promote voluntary emissions reduction in China, including Beijing Environmental Exchange, Shanghai Environment and Energy Exchange, China Shenzhen emission Exchange, etc. However, the deficiency of compulsory ETS unfolds a gloomy prospect for the exchanges. As a consequence, in October 2011 the National Development and Reform Commission (NPRC) has approved eight provinces and cities consisting of Beijing, Shanghai, Tianjin, Chongqing, Hubei, Guangdong, Shenzhen, of launching carbon trading pilot programs in an official announcement, with a plan to expand it to a national ETS by 2015. The pilot work is carried out as scheduled. It is estimated that experimental unites in some cities and provinces could be on operation by the end of 2013. The first industries incorporated into the trading scheme will come from those intensive emissions sources including cement sector, steel sector, electricity sector, etc. Under the scheme, the gross carbon emission allowances are initially identified and will be then allocated to firms covered by the scheme. When the firms emit more than allocated, they will need to pay for the extra emissions. Power plant, as a carbon intensive emitter, is therefore driven to make some technologicalimprovement, thus in a way promoting the adoption of CCS in the power plants to cut down CO2emissions. Meanwhile power plants may benefit from CCS by selling the unused carbon allowances.

2) Subsidies

Limited grants specifically for CCS have been elaborated in the energy Budget in China. Currently government funds allocated to the research for CCS mainly lie on several government supported programs, including the 36 million RMB for Geological Carbon Storage with Enhanced Oil Recovery (National Basic Research Program of China) from 2006-2010 and 30 million RMB for Carbon Capture and Storage (National High-tech Research & Development Program of China) from 2008 to 2010, etc.

2.6.3 Supportive policies

1) Collaborative measures

As demonstrated in previous sections, vast cooperation between the typical countries and China has been conducted, such as FutureGen in US, US-China Clean Energy Research Center, EU-China near zero emissions coal, among which collaboration between US and China is particularly remarkable. China has also been a member of the international Carbon Sequestration Leadership Forum, Zero Emissions Platform and the Asia-Pacific Partnership on Clean Development and Climate.

2) Public engagement

Chinese government’s initiative to raise public cognition of CCS is yet very limited. Currently China is working with Carbon Sequestration Leadership Forum (CSLF) to establish the first website focusing on CCS technologies and its development in China.

3 A contrast with the representative countries and regions on policy front and policy suggestions

As indicated in the above, compared with the representative countries and regions, China’s CCS policies have not been reflected in the relevant laws and regulations, but only in some articles and speeches with ambiguity and uncertainty (Liang and Wu, 2009). A policy package specifically for CCS is in its vacancy, which strongly impacts the expansion of CCS deployment in China and makes it rather difficult to obtain the anticipative goal. A detailed contrast with the typical countries and regions on the policy front is analyzed as follows with policy outlook to advance CCS progress in China.

3.1 Deficient of EPS

EPS serve as a relatively direct option for power plants to take CCS facilities into account by setting up the baseline of CO2emissions. It is particularly effective in forcing those carbon intensive power plants to employ CCS and may also work as a complementary measure to ETS. The representative countries and regions have already reflected this measure in their national or regional legislations. Power plants equipped with CCS are rendered an advantage in meeting the EPS. While in China, such kinds of standards have not been performed for power plant on CO2emissions.

3.1.1 Policy suggestions

A specific EPS ought to be set up for power plants in China, which shall clearly define the carbon emission level per output unit. Existing EPS legislations in America, Canada, UK and Australia could be used as reference. To support CCS adoption in power plants, the basis benchmark for the EPS may be set similar to that of a high-efficiency technology in power plants, such as natural gas combined cycle. In this way, operators have to turn to some new abatement technology like CCS to attain such a drastic deduction. However, given the technical immaturity and financial risks, it is not practical to expect that all the newly established power plants be immediately equipped with CCS facilities. As a result, to facilitate the adoptionof CCS facilities in power plants, adequate priority shall be rendered to those equipped with CCS in meeting the standard. This could be in the form of a temporary exemption from the standard for CCS power plants or allowing the CCS power plants alternatives to achieve the reduction, such as a fixed quantity of emissions deduction in a span of certain years. Integrated with other CCS incentives, EPS is surely to help push forward CCS deployment.

3.2 Absence of regulations for CO2 storage

CO2storage, as the most complex part in CCS chain, is associated with a number of regulatory issues, which requires a number of regulations to be in place. It could be observed from above that specific regulations for CCS have been included into the legislation in those representative countries and regions, such as Requirements for Class VI wells in US, European Directive on the Geological Storage of Carbon Dioxide, the Offshore Petroleum Amendment Act 2008 in Australia. Among them, EU CCS Directive is particularly remarkable as it establishes a comprehensive framework to regulate CCS activities. With respect to China, no dedicated regulations for CCS have been established or proposed. This makes it particularly difficult to deal with unique issues associated with CO2storage, including licensing authority, monitoring & reporting plans, corrective and remediation measures, liability during the project operation and post-closure period, thus directly suspending the process of CO2storage activities. However, it shall be acknowledged that CCS regulations are not in a blank state in China. Some of the existing related laws, such as Law on Prevention and Control of Water Pollution and Environmental Impact Assessment Law, are closely correlated with CCS activities and may be directly applied or modified to adapt to storage activities. Consequently, the existing legislations shall be paid due consideration in building CCS regulatory framework in China.

3.2.1 Policy suggestions

The construction of CCS regulatory framework shall be put in the primary place of CCS deployment on the government agenda to address issues throughout the lifespan of CO2injection. At present, while it still remains uncertain for the effectiveness of dedicated legislations for CCS in the representative countries and regions, a temporary pilot regulation framework for CCS may be carried out, in which the risks of CO2leakage needs to be fully addressed in the regulations, encompassing an approval system for storage site selection, evaluation standards for environmental impact assessment, a comprehensive mechanism for monitoring & reporting, corrective measures in case of CO2leakage, and an appropriate liability regime. Property issues associated with CCS are also recommended to be defined in the regulations, such as the rights of captured CO2as well as pore space ownership. The CCS regulations in the typical countries and regions, in particular EU CCS Directive, set a model for China to take as reference. However, the construction of a brand newly CCS specific regulatory framework shall not directly imitate those adopted in other countries or regions, because the regulations may be different in China, as discrepancy in existing regulatory framework calls for greater detail on issues stretching from environmental health and safety to property use (Deborah, et al., 2010). As illustrated in the previous section, China already obtains a series of law on which to establish a CCS regulatory framework. This implies that part of the existing laws could be directly applied to or modified to be applicable to CCS projects. As a result, when establishing temporary CCS pilot regulatory framework, Chinese government shall learn from the CCS dedicated legislations in those typical countries and regions while paying attention to the unique regulatory environment in China. With experience accumulated from the pilot framework over time, government may then consider implementing a comprehensive regulatory framework in China.

3.3 Insufficient economic incentives

In the early stage of CCS implementation, due to the technical immaturity and intensive energy penalty, CCS projects are confronted with high extra costs. Investors are reluctant to commit large sums of money to CCSprojects under such situation. Economic incentives are therefore of significant importance to consolidate investors’ confidence in contributing capital to CCS. As illustrated above, a number of economic incentives have been embodied in the policy package in the representative countries and regions, such as ETS, government grants, feed-in tariff, tax credit, CCS special fund, etc. In contrast, currently the policy incentives to subsidize CCS are so limited in China, as elaborated below.

· Lack of ETS

Mandatory ETS is deemed as a precondition for CCS implementation as it identifies the reduction responsibility of the power plants and offers a flexible market to cope with the financial challenges confronted with CCS. National or regional mandatory ETS currently exists in some of the typical countries and regions, with some proposed ones waiting to be passed. EU has done particularly well in this aspect, with a federal operational mandatory ETS from 2005 to allocate CO2allowances to EU members. It has included CCS in the EU ETS and has clearly clarified how CCS projects are running under the scheme. China, however, currently has no operational mandatory ETS in place, let alone the inclusion of CCS in ETS. Pilot schemes for CO2trading have been proposed in several districts, which are anticipated to be on stage in the near term. Nevertheless, it will be plenty of time before ETS could offer a sound performance in China. As the pilot ETS will be in its primary age, the coverage of the ETS is likely to be very modest. Besides, the current regulatory framework for the pilot program is not adequate to satisfy the market needs.

· Lack of subsidies

The ETS could not fully address the financial issues faced with CCS deployment. It is reported in the literature that life cycle costs for CCS are estimated to be 24-35 EUR/t CO2avoided (Davison, 2007). However, within EU carbon market, CO2price is reported by the Guardian to drop to around 3 EUR/t CO2in January 2013, much lower than CCS cost. Without supplementary financial incentives, the electricity producers may choose to pay for the excessive emissions rather than turn to CCS. Currently, CCS stays at the demonstration stage in China. In this situation, policy subsidies, such as government grant, tax credit, feed-in tariff, are required to bring down the high production costs. In the representative countries and regions, such kinds of incentive measures have been in service or proposed to the government. However, subsidies specifically for CCS are yet so limited in China. Take government grants for instance, in the early age of CCS deployment, to bring down the high extra cost of CCS requires a mass of research and demonstration projects. In the typical countries and regions, CCS researches and demonstration activities have been included in the national energy legislations with extensive government capital distributed. Besides, some CCS researches or programmes supported by government grants have been established in cost-sharing with industry. With regard to China, government financial support for CCS is rested on several limited “973” Programs or “863”Programs and the funds for CCS demonstration projects in China mainly originate from state-owned firms and international clean energy funds. The invested capital from government to promote CCS is far not enough. The lack of subsidies directly frustrates operators to deploy CCS in electricity sector.

3.3.1 Policy suggestions

Economic incentives for CCS deployment shall not be constrained within certain limited measures. A multisource financial mechanism ought to be built to accelerate CCS implementation.

· Build a multi-source financial mechanism

· Enact an effective ETS

A well-operated mandatory ETS shall be enforced in China. The experience could be gained from European practice. It is however not advisable for China to totally imitate European experience. China covers a vast geographic area with the provinces varying in cultural and economic conditions. Advocating a national integrated emission trading market is not suitable and practical in the near term. Regional ETS shall be first enforced within provinces in China, just like the pilot scheme. In this process, the coverage of the ETS shall be gradually expanded and a management mechanism shall be established to regulate the ETS, including market supervision, penal measures for not being able to fulfill the agreement, etc. In addition, a CCS plan ought to be contained in the pilot scheme to gain the learning experience in the initial age. In the next period, with the experience and confidence gained from the pilot regional ETS programs, a more market-oriented national ETS may be in place, which is expected to contain an elaborated CCS plan to cover CCS facilitiesunder the scheme as well as a national plan to allocate the CO2allowances in conjunction with various situations in different districts.

· Include CCS in CDM regime

CDM, which provides an important contribution to low-carbon technologies in developing countries, ought to raise our attention. It allows developed countries to fulfill their responsibilities by purchasing certified emission reductions from projects that reduce emissions in the developing world. It has been a long controversial debate on whether to incorporate CCS in CDM. Some opponents argue that CDM is not an adequate mechanism to deal with the complexities of CCS, such as long-term liability of storage, and that including it would prevent development of renewable energy and other low-carbon technologies (UNFCCC, 2008; Bakker, et al., 2010; de Coninck, 2008; Liu and Liang, 2011; Shackley, et al., 2009). Finally, at the 2011 Climate Change Conference (COP/MOP) in Durban, agreements on the modalities and procedures for inclusion of CCS in CDM were reached, which is deemed as a great success and represents that CCS is recognized as an efficient technology in mitigating greenhouse gas emissions. China, as the largest CO2emitter, is endowed with tremendous potential to receive CDM funding. However, China now possesses no regulations to accommodate with the procedures to incorporate CCS in CDM. Therefore, proper measures shall be acknowledged in the policy package in China. More research should be assured to investigate into the CCS to accommodate with the modalities and procedures of incorporating CCS within CDM. At the same time, the first several demonstration CCS projects shall be speeded up to obtain the basic data for the overall evaluation of CCS , thus paving a way for the verification of CER and project management and in a way accelerating their commercial running as CDM.

· Render more subsidies

· Increase government grants

In the early stage of CCS implementation, government grants remain as the most important contributor in CCS research and demonstration. It is recommended that more capital inputs shall be injected into CCS related research to seek the most cost-effective way to deploy CCS and to ensure the safety of long-time CO2storage, which demands sufficient government grants to be embodied in the national energy budget to be contributed to CCS in purpose of acquiring initial knowledge and experience. Besides, it seems also necessary for the government to strengthen the connection with domestic industries to carry out more demonstration projects.

· Build price-based support schemes

· Feed-in tariff

Feed-in tariff is considered as a viable option for CCS. Under the mechanism, the operators are offered a long-term revenue assurance. It is easier for them to receive loans from banks, thus easing the financial burden. At present China owns no feed-in tariff schemes for CCS. However, a feed-in tariff scheme has been built up for renewable energy to compensate for the high costs, which are governed by Trial Measures for Administration of the Allocation of the Price and Expense of Electricity Generated From Renewable Energy issued in 4 January 2006 (Baker and Mckenzie, 2009). Serving as part of the low-carbon energy portfolio to mitigate GHG emissions, renewable energy and CCS are confronted with similar financial problems. As a result, they could share similar policy incentive to drive the deployment. The establishment of FIT in the policy package to offer price priority to electricity produced by CCS power plants could be based on the experience gained from renewable energy.

· Guaranteed CO2price for CCS

As indicated in the above, the carbon price on the emission trading market is too low to stimulate operators in the power sector to deploy CCS. A guaranteed CO2price scheme has been proposed by Heleen and Heleen (Groenenberg and de Coninck, 2008) to be introduced for CCS in the early age of CCS implementation, in which the government commits to buying back CO2allowances generated by CCS against a fixed price. This could in a way help prevent CCS power plants from the fluctuation of carbon price on the market, thus assuring investors and operators stable streams of revenues. In this circumstance, the financial and operational risks associated with early deployment of CCS are reduced to a certain extent. When CCS technology becomes fully proven at commercial scale, with the accumulation of learning experience and gradual perfection of emission trading market, an evident drop is projected to be emerging for CCS costs and CO2price in the carbon market could surpass the CCS costs. In this phase guaranteed CO2price may gradually fade away and CCS power plant could be well operated under the market. Policy makers in China shall pay attention to this incentive mechanism to investigate the possibility to make it fit into the market.

· Tax break Similar to feed-in tariff, when CCS comes on commercial stage, tax break appears to be a favorable option for CCS by reducing the tax liability of operators and investor. For the operators, the annual income of CCS power plants may be exempted from a tax levy for a span of certain years. With regard to the investors, their investment to CCS power plants could enjoy a preferable tax deduction. Researches shall be conducted to look into the effectiveness of this measure and the feasibility to turn it into policy.

· Establish a special fund

A special fund is particularly important to contribute to CCS research & demonstration in early age and may serve as a stable source to govern post-closure stewardship of CCS projects. However, currently no such funds exist in China. It is recommended that central or regional government shall coordinate the industrial efforts to establish CCS specific funds and expand the sources of fund as much as possible. The funds may come from the auctioning of GHG allowances created under an upcoming ETS or from a surcharge on the electricity generated by fossil fuels.

3.4 Not adequate initiative in pubic engagement

As indicated in the previous sections, some of the representative countries and regions have introduced several measures to raise the public awareness of CCS and to engage them in the establishment of relevant policies through public consultation or public hearing. This helps remove public concern of the potential environment and human health damage brought about by CCS activities, greatly preventing potential public opposition and resistance in CCS deployment. While in China, such kinds of activities are in a vacancy. Though the strong and high-efficient administrative force of in China could enable commercial CCS projects to be carried out smoothly once the feasibility of CCS is demonstrated, the scarce knowledge of CCS in the public will not be beneficial for the long-time CCS development.

3.4.1 Policy suggestions

Elaborated measures shall be covered in CCS policy package to raise public awareness and to encourage public engagement. China government and project operators may make full use of the social media, such as Internet, newspaper, television to inform the public of CCS related information and the latest progress, thus creating a favorable environment for CCS projects. A public hearing may be in place to solicit public opinions about possible policy incentives as well as regulations for CCS, thus involving the public in the decision-making process.

4 Concluding remarks

CCS is a promising abatement option for drastic CO2emissions in China that relies heavily on fossil fuels to boost the economy. The precondition for smooth CCS deployment resides with the enactment of relevant CCS policies. In this paper we review CCS policies in some representative countries and regions and compare them with those in China.

From the study it is apparent that those typical countries and regions have policies specific for CCS. The most common CCS policies employed in these countries and regions encompass prescriptive policies such as EPS and dedicated CCS regulations, economic policies including ETS, government grants, feed-in tariff, tax credit, special fund, and supportive policies in terms of cooperative measures and public engagement. However, by contrast with those representative countries and regions on CCS policy front, it could be found that CCS policy package is in a great vacancy in China. No EPS or dedicated CCS legislations currently exist in China. Besides, economic incentives in China are only limited to several proposed regional pilot ETS andfew subsidies that are mainly rested on several “973” Programs or “863” Programs. In addition, though extensive cooperation with other countries and international organizations has been conducted, few efforts have been be made to raise public awareness of CCS as well as engage public in the establishment of CCS policy framework.

A specific policy package is proposed for CCS development in China in this paper. In the early stage, CCS legislations regulating CCS activities throughout the lifespan of CO2injection shall be enforced to provide preliminary basis. In this course suggestions are recommended to help raise public awareness of CCS as well as engage public in enactment of CCS policy framework, which in a way creates a favorable environment for CCS deployment. In addition, a multi-source financial mechanism plays a crucial role in CCS power plant demonstration. CDM allows developing countries to receive financial aids from developed countries for lowcarbon projects. Subsidies like government grants, feed-in tariff and tax breaks offer CCS power plants a balanced revenue. Besides, a pilot emission trading scheme may be carried out to gain learning experience in the initial age. The portfolio of economic incentives may help address the drawbacks rooted in single incentive policy. When CCS power plants has made their way to a mature period and becomes fully competitive, market-oriented policies like national emission trading scheme may be in place to facilitate the process. By then subsidies like government grants, feed-in tariff may be gradually phased out. Furthermore, in the process of setting up elaborated CCS policy package, it shall be noted that relevant policies in those typical countries and regions could be taken as reference, while more attention shall be paid to the specific national condition in China and emphasized on how these policies and regulations fit in with the institutional environment in China.

Acknowledgements

This work is supported by the open foundation of Hubei Key laboratory of Industrial Fume & Dust Pollution Control (HBIK203-03), the Natural Science Foundation of China (grant no. 51306067) and the Natural Science Foundation of Hubei Province (grant no. 2013CFB179).

Almendra, F., West, L., Zheng, L. and Forbes, S. (2011), CCS Demonstration in Developing Countries: Priorities for a Financing Mechanism for Carbon Dioxide Capture And Storage, World Resources Institute Working Paper, Washington, DC, USA.

Baker and Mckenzie (2009), Strategic Analysis of the Global Status of Carbon Capture and Storage Report 3: Country Studies the United States.

Bakker, S., De Coninck, H. and Groenenberg, H. (2010), Progress on including CCS projects in the CDM: Insights on increased awareness, market potential and baseline methodologies, International Journal of Greenhouse Gas Control,4(2), 321-326.

Bode, S. and Jung, M. (2006), Carbon dioxide capture and storage-liability for non-performance under the UNFCCC, International Environmental Agreements,6, 173-186.

Chandran Govindaraju, V.G.R. and Tang, C.F. (2013), The dynamic links between CO2 emissions, economic growth and coal consumption in China and India, Applied Energy,104(0), 310-318.

Chen, G.Q. and Chen, Z.M. (2010), Carbon emissions and resources use by Chinese economy 2007: A 135-sector inventory and input-output embodiment, Communications in Nonlinear Science and Numerical Simulation,15(11), 3647-3732.

Chen, G.Q. and Chen, Z.M. (2011), Greenhouse gas emissions and natural resources use by the world economy: ecological inputoutput modeling, Ecological Modelling,222(14), 2362-2376.

Chen, G.Q. and Zhang, B. (2010), Greenhouse gas emissions in China 2007: Inventory and input-output analysis, Energy Policy,38(10), 6180-6193.

Chen, G.Q., Chen, H., Chen, Z.M., Zhang, B., Shao, L., Guo, S., Zhou, S.Y., and Jiang, M.M. (2011), Low-carbon building assessment and multi-scale input-output analysis, Communications in Nonlinear Science and Numerical Simulation,16(1), 583-595.

Chen, G.Q., Guo, S., Shao, L., Li, J.S., and Chen, Z.M. (2013), Three-scale input-output modeling for urban economy: Carbon emission by Beijing 2007, Communications in Nonlinear Science and Numerical Simulation,18(9), 2493-2506.

Chen, Z.M. and Chen, G.Q. (2011), Embodied carbon dioxide emission at supra-national scale: A coalition analysis for G7, BRIC, and the rest of the world, Energy Policy,39(5), 2899-2909.

Condor, J., Unatrakarna, D., Asghari, K., and Wilson, M. (2011), Current status of CCS initiatives in the major emerging economies, Energy Procedia,4, 6125-6132.

Davison, J. (2007), Performance and costs of power plants with capture and storage of CO2, Energy,32(7), 1163-1176.

Deborah, S., Yue, L., Sarah, F., Zhang, D., and Logan, W. (2010), CCS in China: Toward an Environmental, Health, and Safety Regulatory Framework, World Resources Institute.

DECC (2013), Department of Energy & Climate Change. UK Carbon Capture and Storage: Government Funding and Support. Available from: https://www.gov.uk/uk-carbon-capture-and-storage-government-funding-and-support [accessed May 2013].

de Coninck, H. (2008), Trojan horse or horn of plenty? Reflections on allowing CCS in the CDM, Energy Policy,36(3), 929-936.

Dong, G., Mao, X., Zhou, J. and Zeng, A. (2013), Carbon footprint accounting and dynamics and the driving forces of agricultural production in Zhejiang Province, China, Ecological Economics,91(0), 38-47.

EPA (2013), Environmental Protection Agency. News Releases from Headquarters. Available from: http://yosemite.epa.gov/opa/ admpress.nsf/bd4379a92ceceeac852. 5735900400c27/da9640577ceacd9f85257beb006cb2b6! opendocument [accessed May 2013].

EUR-Lex (2013), Directive 2009/29/EC of the European Parliament. Available from: http://eur- lex.europa.eu/LexUriServ/Lex UriServ.do?uri=CELEX:32009L00 29:en:NOT [accessed May 2013].

Gazette, C. (2011), Reduction of Carbon Dioxide Emissions from Coal-Fired Generation of Electricity Regulations Available from: http://www.gazette.gc.ca/rp-pr/p1/2011/2011-08-27/html/reg1-eng.html [accessed June 2013].

GCCSI (2013), Global CCS Institute. Dedicated CCS Legislation-Australia. Available from: http://www.globalccsinstitute.com/ networks/cclp/legal-resources/ dedicated-ccs-legislations/australia#fed [accessed September 2013].

GCCSI (2013), Global CCS Institute. The Institute at a glance. Available from: http://www.globalccsinstitute.com/institute [accessed September 2013].

GCCSI (2013), Global CCS Institute. CCS in the United States. Available from: http://www.globalccsinstitute.com/location/unitedstates [accessed September 2013].

GCCSI (2013), Global CCS Institute. Carbon Capture Legal Programme: United Kingdom. Available from: http://www.global ccsinstitute.com/networks/cclp/ legal-resources/dedicated-ccs-legislation/uk [accessed September 2013].

Guo, S. and Chen, G.Q. (2013), Multi-scale input-output analysis for multiple responsibility entities: carbon emission by urban economy in Beijing 2007, Journal of Environmental Accounting and Management,1(1), 43-54.

Groenenberg, H. and de Coninck, H. (2008), Effective EU and Member State policies for stimulating CCS, International journal of greenhouse gas control,2(4), 653-664.

Groenenberg, H., Seebregts, A. and Boot, P. (2011), Policy instruments for advancing CCS in Dutch power generation, Energy Procedia,4, 5822-5829.

Hamilton, M.R., Herzog, H.J. and Parsons, J.E. (2009), Cost and US public policy for new coal power plants with carbon capture and sequestration, Energy Procedia,1(1), 4487-4494.

Han, M.Y., Yang, Q., Wu, X.D., Wu, T.H. and Chen, G.Q. (2013), SWOC analysis on CCS: A case for oxy-fuel combustion CO2 capture system, Journal of Environmental accounting and management,1(4), 333-343.

Hidalgo, J.J. and Carrera, J. (2009), Effect of dispersion on the onset of convection during CO2sequestration, Journal of Fluid Mechanics,640, 441-452.

IEA (2010), Carbon capture and storage: Model Regulatory Framework, OECD.

IEA (2012), Carbon Capture and Storage Legal and Regulatory Review-Edition 3, OECD: Paris.

IEA (2012), IEA statistics. Available from: http://www.iea.org/stats/index.asp [accessed April 2013].

Jürgen-Friedrich, H., Hubert, H., Olga, S., and Jochen, S. (2009), CCS for Germany: policy, R&D and demonstration activities, Energy Procedia,1(1), 3917-3925.

Li, Z., Zhang, D.J., Ma, L.W., Logan, W., and Ni, W.D. (2011), The necessity of and policy suggestions for implementing a limited number of large scale, fully integrated CCS demonstrations in China, Energy Policy,39(9), 5347-5355.

Liang, D.P. and Wu, W.W. (2009), Barriers and incentives of CCS deployment in China: Results from semi-structured interviews, Energy Policy,37(6), 2421-2432.

Liu, H.W. and Liang, X. (2011), Strategy for promoting low-carbon technology transfer to developing countries: The case of CCS, Energy Policy,39(6), 3106-3116.

Mace, M.J., Hendriks, C., and Coenraads, R. (2007), Regulatory challenges to the implementation of carbon capture and geological storage within the European Union under EU and international law, International journal of greenhouse gas control,1(2), 253-260.

Markusson, N., Shackley, S., and Evar, B. (2012), The Social Dynamics of Carbon Capture and Storage: Understanding CCS Representations, Governance and Innovation, Routledge.

Massicotte, M.G. (2011), Canada: Carbon Capture And Storage: The Changing Regulatory And Legislative Landscape. Availablefrom:http://www.mondaq.com/canada/x/140070/Environmental+Law/Carbon+Capture+And+Storage+The+Changing+Regulatory +And+ Legislative+Landscape [accessed May 2013].

Matthias, F. and Paul, K. (2013), Carbon footprint and life cycle assessment of organizations, Journal of Environmental Accounting and Management,1(1), 55-63.

Meadowcroft, J. and Langhelle, O. (2009), Caching the carbon: the politics and policy of carbon capture and storage, Edward Elgar Publishing.

Menz, T. and Welsch, H. (2012), Population aging and carbon emissions in OECD countries: Accounting for life-cycle and cohort effects, Energy Economics,34(3), 842-849.

Metz, B., Davidson, O., De Coninck, H., Loos, M., and Meyer, L. (2005), IPCC Special Report on Carbon Dioxide Capture and Storage: Prepared by working group III of the intergovernmental panel on climate change, IPCC, Cambridge University Press: Cambridge, United Kingdom and New York, USA,2.

Milner, J., Davies, M. and Wilkinson, P. (2012), Urban energy, carbon management (low carbon cities) and co-benefits for human health, Current Opinion in Environmental Sustainability. Available from: http://discovery.ucl.ac.uk/1378676/1/1378676.pdf [accessed May 2013].

Mitchell, C., Bauknecht, D. and Connor, P.M. (2006), Effectiveness through risk reduction: a comparison of the renewable obligation in England and Wales and the feed-in system in Germany, Energy Policy,34(3), 297-305.

Pani, R. and Mukhopadhyay, U. (2011), Variance analysis of global CO2emission - A management accounting approach for decomposition study, Energy,36(1), 486-499.

Pollak, M., Phillips, S.J. and Vajjhala, S. (2011), Carbon capture and storage policy in the United States: A new coalition endeavors to change existing policy, Global Environmental Change,21(2), 313-323.

Priddle, R. (2002), World Energy Outlook 2002, International Energy Agency, IEA/OECD, Paris.

Reiner, D.M. and Herzog, H.J. (2004), Developing a set of regulatory analogs for carbon sequestration, Energy,29(9), 1561-1570.

Robaina Alves, M. and Moutinho, V. (2013), Decomposition analysis and Innovative Accounting Approach for energy-related CO2(carbon dioxide) emissions intensity over 1996-2009 in Portugal, Energy,57(0), 775-787.

Scrase, J.I. and Watson, J. (2009), Strategies for the deployment of CCS technologies in the UK: a critical review, Energy Procedia,1(1), 4535-4542.

Shackley, S., Reiner, D., Upham, P., de Coninck, H., Sigurthorsson, G., and Anderson, J. (2009), The acceptability of CO2capture and storage (CCS) in Europe: An assessment of the key determining factors: Part 2. The social acceptability of CCS and the wider impacts and repercussions of its implementation, International journal of greenhouse gas control,3(3), 344-356.

Susan, S. (2007), Climate change 2007-the physical science basis: Working group I contribution to the fourth assessment report of the IPCC, Cambridge University Press.

Talberg, A. (2011), Performance Standards to Reduce Energy Emissions, Available from: http://www.aph.gov.au/About_ Parliament/

Parliamentary_Departments/Parliamentary_Library/pubs/BN/1011/PerformanceStandardsemissions#_ftn1 [accessed July 2013]. Tanaka, K. (2011), Review of policies and measures for energy efficiency in industry sector, Energy Policy,39(10), 6532-6550.

UNFCCC (2008), Synthesis of views on technological, methodological, legal, policy and financial issues relevant to the consideration of carbon dioxide capture and storage in geological formations as project activities under the clean development mechanism.

USEPA (2012), United States Environmental Protection Agency. Geologic Sequestration of Carbon Dioxide. Available from: http://water.epa.gov/type/groundwater/uic/wells_sequestration.cfm [accessed March 2013].

Vause, J., Gao, L., Shi, L. and Zhao, J. (2013), Production and consumption accounting of CO2emissions for Xiamen, China, Energy Policy,60(0), 697-704.

Vetőné Mózner, Z. (2013), A consumption-based approach to carbon emission accounting - sectoral differences and environmental benefits, Journal of Cleaner Production,42(0), 83-95.

von Stechow, C., Watson, J. and Praetorius, B. (2011), Policy incentives for carbon capture and storage technologies in Europe: A qualitative multi-criteria analysis, Global Environmental Change,21(2), 346-357.

Wikipedia (2013), American Clean Energy and Security Act. Available from: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_Clean_Energy_and_Security_Act [accessed November 2013].

Wilson, E.J., Friedmann, S.J. and Pollak, M.F. (2007), Research for deployment: Incorporating risk, regulation, and liability for carbon capture and sequestration, Environmental science & technology,41(17), 5945-5952.

Wilson, E., Zhang, D. and Zheng, L. (2011), The socio-political context for deploying carbon capture and storage in China and the U.S, Global Environmental Change,21(2), 324-335.

Wu, Z. and Chen, G.Q. (2014), Approach to transverse uniformity of concentration distribution of a solute in a solvent flowing along a straight pipe, Journal of Fluid Mechanics,740, 196-213.

Yuan, J.H. and Lyon, T.P. (2012), Promoting global CCS RDD&D by stronger US-China collaboration, Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews,16(9), 6746-6769.

ZERO (2013), Zero Emission Resource Organisation. Canada. Available from: http://www.zeroco2.no/projects/countries/canada [accessed July 2013].

ZERO (2013), Zero Emission Resource Organisation, United States, Available from: http://www.zeroco2.no/projects/countries/usa [accessed July 2013].

ZERO (2013), Zero Emission Resource Organisation. United Kingdom: Energy & Climate Change-policy and Progress Available from: http://www.zeroco2.no/projects/countries/united-kingdom [accessed July 2013].

Zhang, L.X., Wang, C.B., and Bahaj, A.S. (2014), Carbon emissions by rural energy in China, Renewable Energy,66(0), 641-649.

Zhang, X.P. and Cheng, X.M. (2009), Energy consumption, carbon emissions, and economic growth in China, Ecological Economics,68(10), 2706-2712.

Zhou, S.Y., Chen, H., and Li, S.C. (2010), Resources use and greenhouse gas emissions in urban economy: Ecological input-output modeling for Beijing 2002, Communications in Nonlinear Science and Numerical Simulation,15(10), 3201-3231.

†Corresponding author.

Email address: qyang@mail.hust.edu.cn (Q. Yang); thwu@hust.edu.cn (T.H. Wu).

ISSN 2325-6192, eISSN 2325-6206/$- see front materials © 2014 L&H Scientific Publishing, LLC. All rights reserved.

10.5890/JEAM.2014.03.004


登录APP查看全文