APP下载

Urban Environmental Management Performance Assessment by Fuzzy Analytical Hierarchy Processing (FAHP)

2014-03-22ManouchehrOmidvariMaryanGhandehari

Manouchehr Omidvari, Maryan Ghandehari

Industrial and Mechanical Engineering Faculty, Islamic Azad University, Qazvin Branch, Qazvin, Iran

Urban Environmental Management Performance Assessment by Fuzzy Analytical Hierarchy Processing (FAHP)

Manouchehr Omidvari†, Maryan Ghandehari

Industrial and Mechanical Engineering Faculty, Islamic Azad University, Qazvin Branch, Qazvin, Iran

In recent decades, the world’s population growth and concentration in mega cities have caused several environmental, social and economic problems. Environment management audit has always been considered as a major challenge in urban management. Providing an appropriate model for the raters makes their personal judgments routinely minimized and obtains a more realistic assessment of the present situation. Using Fuzzy Analytical Hierarchy Processing and collating it with audit programs can help them to achieve this goal. In the present research study, using standards, the environmental indices have been determined in urban management and then using Fuzzy Analytical Hierarchy Processing method, the weight and importance level of the indices have been set and the evaluation pattern was presented. The present study was conducted with the aim of presenting a model for auditing the environment and one of Tehran’s municipality regions was selected to do a case study. The results showed that the most important problems in the field of environmental management in a megacity like Tehran are in areas such as transport and traffic management, waste-water installation and solid waste management which have been unsatisfactory in some areas under study. Applying the proposed model has provided urban management with the possibility to identify weaknesses of its collection and remove discrepancies by investing in the issue and causing a continuous improvement of the environment in their management zone.

© 2014 L&H Scientific Publishing, LLC. All rights reserved.

Submission Info

Communicated by Zhifeng Yang

Received 10 December 2013

Accepted 10 February 2014

Available online 1 April 2014

Environment

Urban management

Performance assessment

FAHP

1 Introduction

Measuring the performance of work place is played important role on doing better work. During the past few years, many techniques have become popular among researchers as a technique for measuring the performance of business units (Atafer, et al., 2013). Environmental performance assessment is important in urban management. Many elements are effective on environmental performance in urban management. It is necessary to establish a balance between its constituent elements in order to protect and improve the urban envi-ronment. It is also necessary for the balance that its constituent elements need to be in appropriate conditions of quality and quantity and communication. Adopting in appropriate policies, approving weak programs and implementing false urban projects and activities will be the origins of chaos, destruction and pollution of the city, therefore the fate of citizens in each city depends on its current and future state and also on the nature and performance quality of the related projects. In this course, the role of urban environmental management is important in achieving a sustainable development, reducing and eliminating environmental problems. According to its definition and practical tasks, urban management system is required to plan for urban development and implement related programs, plans and projects.

In a study on the use of AHP1- Analytical Hierarchy Processingand its application, Monitto et al. pointed out some non-determined indices in this model of the decision-making. In this study, applying fuzzy logic in solving the assessment problem by using FAHP2- Fuzzy Analytical Hierarchy Processinghas been suggested in a way that one can manage uncertainty and consider productivity and flexibility issues. In this study, Mau-Crimins, et al. (2005) conducted a study at the University of Arizona, in order to increase public participation in preserving the forests and determining the effective parameters of participation, they introduced AHP as a means of improving public participation. In this study, AHP method was recommended to determine the main environmental priorities for increased popular participation

(Mau-Crimins, et al., 2005). Chen et al in a book on FAHP introduced this method as an efficient procedure for solving multi-criteria decision-making issues. They also argue that this method is efficient in such cases in which the same option scan has different effects on decision-making. The method could also be applied in making decision on environmental issues. In this study, the decision making methods was suggested for prioritizing the environmental effective parameters (Chen, et al., 2001). Li, et al. (2009) in a paper on the use of FAHP in investigated, using this method for environmental vulnerability assessment of environmental impacts in an area of China where oil tanks are placed in this study. In another paper, Yang, et al. (2011) acknowledged FAHP as a powerful tool for environmental issues assessment in OGP3- Oil and Gas Processingprocess. In this regard, Zheng, et al. (2012) introduced FAHP tool as a perfect system for making decisions when choosing an appropriate strategy to control the adverse factors, especially weather conditions in the working environment. In a study on assessing environmental aspects, Kaya and Kahraman suggested that FAHP method and its combination with ELECTRE are to be used; in this study, an approach based on FAHP method was proposed for environmental impact assessment in urban planning. Population density and land used were the most important environmental issues in urban planning. The research investigated the environmental impacts generated in six different industrial districts of Istanbul (Kaya and Kahraman, 2011). In a study on the environmental dimension of sustainable urban development by using the combination of AHP and GIS and by examining some factors such as the scope of the access, ramp and adaptation, it is concluded that which place is environmentally more suitable for the use of training ground. In this study using AHP in GIS environment is highly stressed especially in location finding based on expert systems and environmental parameters. The study noted that because of the environmental parameters are uncertain; using AHP in Fuzzy (FAHP) instead of AHP was recommended (Javadian, et al., 2011). Environmental performance indices are the most fundamental measurements criteria and vital symptoms and indicator of environmental performance status in an organization. This information can be representative of municipalities’ environmental performance condition and this indicates that whether the system is improving or declining or being stable and unchanged. The overall goal of the presenter search conducted as a case study in zone-one municipality of Tehran megacity is to provide a model for accessing the urban environmental estate. Using the results of the study, a model can be presented for performance quantitative assessment in environmental units of urban management in order to compare all urban areas with each other.

2 Material and Methods

2.1 The steps of research

This research is a descriptive-case model solving in which a model has been offered for performance measurement of environmental management in urban management area. Implementations stages of the study are shown in Fig 1.

The research has been conducted in two parts: the first part defined and weighted the performance indices of the urban environment and presented an audit-management model. In the second part and as a case-study, the presented model has been used to investigate and evaluate environmental problems in one of the biggest municipality zones of Tehran.

In this study expert is the one who has adequate information about evaluating urban environmental system and who is familiar to FAHP. In this study, Number of expert is 5.

Fig. 1The algorithm of study.

2.2 Giving an evaluation model using FAHP model

At this stage, and as the first step, urban environment indices were identified and divided in to 9 alternative and 4 criteria (the level of cost of control, management ideal, availability, enforcement) using experts' ideas as professionals in environmental issues and urban management. Then, the sub-indices were determined in every category, after that, the sub-indicators were determined and defined in two levels. Nine main groups and two subgroups of indices are shown in Tables 1 and 2. To better understand the conditions of indices and their grouping method, a schematic plan of the hierarchy structure is shown in Figure 2. According to opinion experts none of Criteria’s and indices do not depended together.

Fig. 2Hierarchical structure for Tehran’s environment assessment.

Table 1Criteria at the first level of evaluation

In this study, considering the uncertainty conditions and the range of governing changes on criteria of the issue, multiple-criteria decision-making approach in fuzzy was taken into account and fuzzy logic numbers and calculations were used. Fuzzy phenomenon is more dominant on explaining the systems in which the decision-making involves complex systems and manpower (Saaty, 1996). The AHP method in fuzzy mode is also used to solve the problem, with the main objective of evaluating Tehran’s environment. Alternative weighted by Expert Choice software indicated that our assessment alternative for evaluating Tehran city, donot have the same degree of importance and the intended range is determined for doing fuzzy calculation. The purpose of using fuzzy analytic hierarchy process is to identify reference options and ranking the alternative by taking all decision-making criteria into account at the same time.

In this method, triangular fuzzy values are replaced for vague databased on answers given to questions by decision makers and paired-comparisons matrix is formed for a particular level of the hierarchy (Hu, et al., 2009). So after weighing the importance level of the alternatives by questionnaire, the selected options are transformed into the following scales (Table 3) including triangular fuzzy numbers, and they are generalized to be used in doing calculations and analyzing the results.

Table 3TFNs and Reciprocal TFNs for FAHP Levels of Importance

Fig. 3Fuzzy judgment matrix.

As mentioned earlier, in this paper we use a form of triangular fuzzy numbers shown as: A = (a1, a2, a3).

Here, we use the extended analysis method for developing the analytic hierarchy process into fuzzy space. This method has been developed based on the arithmetic average of the experts’ opinions, hourly normalized method and by using triangular fuzzy numbers. The implementation stages of the method are as follows:

Stage1: Drawing hierarchical tree:

In this stage, the structure of decision hierarchy is drawn by using objective criteria levels and option (see Figure 2).

Stage2: Forming paired-judgment matrix:

From agreement matrices: in accordance with the decision tree and by using experts’ ideas in terms of triangular fuzzy numbers and in the form of the matrix below (Figure3).

In this matrix, Pijis the number of participants giving opinions for i rather than j priority.

Stage3: Arithmetic mean of Reviews:

Calculate the arithmetic mean of the reviews of decision makers’ to achieve the following matrix (Figure 4).

Fig. 4Arithmetic mean of decision makers’ opinions.

Stage4: Calculating the sum of row elements:

Calculate the sum of elements in rows (Eq. 2).

Stage5: Normalization:

Normalize the sum of rows. If is shown as (li, mi, ui), it will be calculated by

Stage6: Determining the degree of greatness probability:

Calculate the degree of greatness probability of each Mito other Mj(j ≠ i ), named by d( Ai)

where

Thus the matrix of weight vector is obtained, i.e.,

Stage7: Normalization:

Through normalizing the weight vectors (w), you can obtain the normalized weights as

The above weights are the indisputable and certain weights.

Since the amount of deviation is natural in the judgments of decision-makers (especially in large matrices with large numbers of Judgment), it is necessary to define a threshold and a limit for them and small amounts also need to be considered as acceptable amounts. Therefore, by randomly producing many matrices of all sizes, Saati compared the CI index for them as presented in Table4 (Saati et al., 2002).

Table 4Random Inconsistency index (RI)

Saati suggests that if the incompatibility index of a matrix is not over 10% of random inconsistency index, it can be tolerated and one can rely on the weights produced by that matrix (Saati et al., 2002). So if the inconsistency rate (CR4- Consistency Ratio) is less than 0.1, the matrix is considered consistent. The following steps are taken to calculate the inconsistency rate:

Step1: Calculating the weight sum vector:

Multiply the paired comparison, matrix into the column vector "relative weight" to get a new vector which is called weight Sum Vector.

Step2: Calculating the consistency vector:

Divide the elements of the weighted sum vector on the priority vector. The resulting vector is called consistency vector.

Step3: Obtaining the λ max:

It gives the mean of consistency vector elements λ max.

Step4: Calculating the Consistency Index:

Consistency index is defined as follows:

Step5: Calculating the Consistency Ratio:

It is obtained by dividing the consistency index on random index.

The state of zone-one municipality can be determined in terms of environmental issues based on the data obtained from questionnaires and the weights obtained through the fuzzy approach (Table 5). Based on the results obtained, the consistency ratio of the matrix is not over 10% (CR=0.073).

Table 5The final weight for each index using FAHP algorithm

Table 6Levels of the criteria related to the evaluation indices of urban environment management

Table 7Checklist results of zone-one

3 Results

As mentioned above, the present study was conducted to present a model of environmental audit. The results of the proposed model are as follows:

The results showed that with the most score of 0.1881" the environmental governance" index was considered as the most important alternative for evaluating the environmental performance (Table 6).

The criteria of "electricity and energy", "land and buildings application", "transportation", "the waste", "water waste-water system installations, Health system and refineries", "Health, security and environment", "Industries and city Jobs " and "Privacy" were prioritized by the weights 0.1090, 0.0881, 0.0913, 0.1092, 0.1174, 0.1104, 0.1024 and 0.0841 respectively.

In the next step, case study was conducted in zone-one of the municipality which is one of the largest districts of Tehran and where the environmental issues are of particular importance determine the reliability and validity of the proposed model. The results of the evaluation using the provided checklist are presented in Table 7.

According to the above table, you can see that the "sixth area" with the total weight of 0.852 has a better performance than other areas and in contrast, the "first area" with the total weight of 0.708 has had the weakest performance. Areas of "3", "9", "4", "7", "10", "5", "2" and "8" are ranked in the order of their weights of 0.790, 0.788, 0.786, 0.786, 0.774, 0.770, 0.752 and 0.724. It is also obvious that privacy index (H) is just examined in the "Area 9". The result was showed, that there is no significant deference between deferent area (P>0.05).

4 Discussion

Using MCDM5Multi Criteria Decision MakingModels makes it possible to minimize the subjective judgments of the experts. In a research one valuating the performance of automatic manufacturing systems, Monitto used the FAHP method and he stated that this method not only can identify the factors influencing the system but also it can be used to provide a model to evaluate the system (Monitto, et al., 2002).

In this regard and in their paper, Nouri et al. pointed out that for evaluating the performance in critical situations, one can use the incorporation of AHP and risk models, and obtain more improved evaluation conditions without the influence of personal judgments (Nouri, et al., 2011). In relation to this issue in another article written by Nouri, et al. (2010), they provided a risk assessment model by combining AHP and the FMEA6Failure Mode & Effect Analysismodels. In this paper, it has been pointed out that using AHP model can minimize the personal judgment problems of the evaluators’ in risk assessment (Nouri, et al., 2010).

5 Conclusion

According to the results that are showed in table 6 the most important of indices are Environmental Governance, Transportation system and Waste management. Waste production, Superior network and public transport, Integration of law and the rule of law, Segregation of waste, Education and Culture, Responsibility, Use of Renewable Energy are the most important of criteria of urban environmental management performance. In case study stage (table 7) is showed that there is not significant deference between studied regions, because of these regions were managed by single management system.

Considering the results of this research it is hoped that a step could be taken to improve the environment condition in which the key priority in planning for qualitative and quantitative improvement of the environment culture is the collaboration of other organizations Such as the Media and the Department of Education with Municipalities. In order to achieve perfect results in the areas of environment, it is crucial to focus on promoting environmental indices. Therefore, to resolve these problems it is necessary to coordinate several organizations for taking actions. Using AHP method is highly efficient in providing a model for "environment performance evaluation” in urban management and generally to choose the superior option in performance. The efficiency is because of the possibility of comparing and evaluating different criteria and selecting the optimal criterion regarding the given criteria. Because it is a logical method to compare the options and select the optimal option with respect to all effective features; FAHP provides a suitable framework to participate in decision-making process. Also, due to the flexibility, low cost, quick access to result, FAHP method is suitable for solving such problems. But as we know, in FAHP an informed and appropriate choice of weights will provide a great help to set the desired goals; one of the factor weighting methods is using the expert knowledge. Here, appropriate factors are determined and weighted by using the experience and knowledge of experts’ in the intended area of application with regard to the characteristics of the study area, however; this method is simple and factual, it includes some disadvantages such as the possibility of making mistakes by the experts in determining the weights and the problems of standardizing their subjective measurement units. Using fuzzy logic (FAHP) in this way, we can achieve more precise results at the time of indices indefiniteness.

Acknowledgements

We appreciate Islamic Azad University Qazvin Branch for creating the survey and assessment possibility. We also thank Dr. Hassan Halleh because of his guidance in doing this study.

Atafar, A., Shahrabi, M.A., and Esfahani, M.J. (2013), Evaluation of university performance using BSC and ANP, Decision Science Letters,2, 305-311.

Gamelin, F.X., Baquet, G., Berthoin, S., Thevenet, D., Nourry, C., Nottin, S., and Bosquet, L. (2009), Effect of high intensity intermittent training on heart rate variability in prepubescent children, European Journal of Applied Physiology,105, 731-738.

Hu, A.H., Hsu, C.W., Kuo, T.C., and Wu, W.C. (2009), Risk evaluation of green components to hazardous substance using FMEA and FAHP, Expert Systems with Applications,36(3), 7142-7147.

Chen, Q. and Triantaphyllou, E. (2001), Estimating Data for Multi-criteria Decision Making Problems: Optimization Techniques, In: Pardalos, P.M., and Floudas, C., (Eds.), Encyclopedia of Optimization,2, 27-36.

Javadian, M., Shamskooshki, H., and Momeni, M. (2011), Application of sustainable urban development in environmental suitability analysis of educational land use by using AHP and GIS in Tehran, Procedia Engineering,21, 72-80.

Kaya, T. and Kahraman, C. (2011), An integrated fuzzy AHP-ELECTRE methodology for environmental impact assessment, Expert Systems with Applications,38(7), 8553-8562.

Li, L., Shi, Z., Yin, W., Zhu, D., Ng, S., Cai, C.F., and Lei, A. (2009), A fuzzy analytic hierarchy process (FAHP) approach to ecoenvironmental vulnerability assessment for the Danjiangkou reservoir area, China, Ecological Modeling,220(23), 3439-3447.

Mau-Crimins, T., De-Steiguer, J.E., and Dennis, D. (2005), AHP as a means for improving public participation: A pre-post experiment with university students, Forest Policy and Economics,7, 501-514.

Monitto, M., Pappalardo, P., and Tolio, T. (2012), A new fuzzy AHP method for the evaluation of automated manufacturing systems, CRIP-Annals Manufacturing Technology,51(1), 395-398.

Nouri, J., Mansouri, N., Abbaspour, M., Karbasi, A.R., and Omidvari, M. (2011), Designing a developed model for assessing the disaster induced vulnerability value in educational centers, Safety Science,49(5), 679-685.

Nouri, J., Omidvari, M., and Tehrani, S.M. (2010), Risk assessment and crisis management in gas stations. International Journal of Environmental Research,4(1), 143-152.

Saati, M., Mamariani, A., and Jahanshahloo, G.R. (2002), Efficiency analysis and ranking of DMUs with fuzzy data, find out how to access preview-only content, Fuzzy Optimization and Decision Making,1(3), 255-267.

Saaty, T.L. (1996), The Analytic Network Process-Decision Making with Dependence and Feedback, Pittsburgh, PA: RWS Publications.

Yang, M., Khan, F., and Sadiq, R. (2011), Prioritization of environmental issues in offshore oil and gas operations: A hybrid approach using fuzzy inference system and fuzzy analytic hierarchy process, Process Safety and Environmental Protection,89(1), 22-34.

Zheng, G., Zhu, N., Tian, Z., Chen, Y., and Sun, B. (2012), Application of a trapezoidal fuzzy AHP method for work safety evaluation and early warning rating of hot and humid environments, Safety Science,50(2), 228-239.

†Corresponding author.

Email address: Omidvari88@yahoo.com (Manouchehr Omidvari).

ISSN 2325-6192, eISSN 2325-6206/$- see front materials © 2014 L&H Scientific Publishing, LLC. All rights reserved.

10.5890/JEAM.2014.03.003


登录APP查看全文