An Interval-Parameter Fuzzy Linear Programming Approach for Accounting and Planning of Energy-Environmental Management Systems
2014-03-22CongDongGuoheHuangYanpengCaiWencongYueQiangqiangRongMOEKeyLaboratoryofRegionalEnergyandEnvironmentalSystemsOptimizationResourcesandEnvironmentalResearchAcademyNorthChinaElectricPowerUniversityBeijing006China
Cong Dong, Guohe Huang, Yanpeng Cai, Wencong Yue, Qiangqiang RongMOE Key Laboratory of Regional Energy and Environmental Systems Optimization, Resources and Environmental Research Academy, North China Electric Power University, Beijing 006, China
2State Key Laboratory of Water Environment Simulation, School of Environment, Beijing Normal University, Beijing 100875, China
3Institute for Energy, Environment and Sustainable Communities, University of Regina, Regina S4S 7H9, Canada
An Interval-Parameter Fuzzy Linear Programming Approach for Accounting and Planning of Energy-Environmental Management Systems
Cong Dong1, Guohe Huang1, Yanpeng Cai2,3†, Wencong Yue2, Qiangqiang Rong21MOE Key Laboratory of Regional Energy and Environmental Systems Optimization, Resources and Environmental Research Academy, North China Electric Power University, Beijing 102206, China
2State Key Laboratory of Water Environment Simulation, School of Environment, Beijing Normal University, Beijing 100875, China
3Institute for Energy, Environment and Sustainable Communities, University of Regina, Regina S4S 7H9, Canada
In this paper, an energy systems planning (ESPM) model was developed for supporting the planning of an energy management system where the environmental protection was considered under uncertainty. This model was solved based on the interval-parameter fuzzy linear programming, which incorporated the fuzzy linear programming and interval-parameter linear programming into a general optimization framework. Through the conduction of this study, (a) complexities regarding energy activities and environmental conservation in energy management systems could be identified and analyzed, (b) uncertainties of parameters in energy management systems could be incorporated into the planning process on the basis of interval numbers and fuzzy sets, (c) the interval form solutions could enhance the adaptation of ESPM to uncertain conditions, (d) the trade-off between energy activities and environmental protection measures as well as that between optimality and reliability of energy systems could be reflected through the introduction of satisfaction degrees (λ±), and (e) desirable cost-minimized schemes for energy activities such as energy resources allocation, technological development, facility capacity expansion and pollutant emission control could be provided for decision makers.
© 2014 L&H Scientific Publishing, LLC. All rights reserved.
Submission Info
Communicated by Bin Chen
Received 12 December 2013
Accepted 2 January 2014
Available online 1 April 2014
Energy management system
Environmental consideration
Interval parameter
Fuzzy sets
Decision making
Uncertainty
1 Introduction
Energy is essential for economic and social development of a region or a country. However, the consumption of energy resources (particularly fossil fuels) is one of potential driving forces of air pollution and climate change. It is essential for sustainable development of a region to improve energy efficiency and promote development of low-carbon economy. Therefore, an effective energy systems planning method is required to mitigate this challenge, which is crucial for securing technically safe, economically efficient and environmen-tally friendly energy management systems at multiple scales (Ramachandra, 2009; Cai et al., 2009; Cai et al., 2011a and 2011b).
In the past decades, a number of modeling approaches have been applied for supporting the planning of energy management systems. For instance, Cormio et al. (2003) proposed a bottom-up energy system optimization model based on the energy flow optimization model (EFOM). It was used to support policy making in promotion of renewable energy sources and making of detailed schemes such as the primary energy sources (including biomass, solid waste, process byproducts) exploitation, power and heat generation, emissions and end-user consumption. Bakken et al. (2007) presented an optimization model named as ‘eTransport’ to determine system planning and operation patterns where multiple energy carriers, the topology of multiple energy infrastructures and the technical and economic properties of different investment alternatives were considered. Daniel et al. (2009) developed an EFOM-based environmental-friendly regional energy planning procedure for the state of Tamil Nadu in India. Mirzaesmaeeli et al. (2010) described a deterministic multiperiod mixed-integer linear programming model for the power generation planning of electric systems. Amirnekooei et al. (2012) simulated and analyzed the long-term energy planning for Iran by applying a longrange energy alternative planning method. Yeo et al. (2013) proposed an environment and energy geographical information system database to reduce energy use for environmentally friendly urban planning. Mourmouris and Potolias (2013) adopted a multi-criteria decision analysis process for planning exploitation of renewable energy sources at the regional level.
However, due to the complex and dynamic characteristics of energy management systems, it is rather hard to gain deterministic data related to energy activities (e.g., energy exploitation, conversion, and allocation), environmental emissions, and economic benefits. Therefore, inexact modeling methods should be introduced into the planning process of energy management systems. Specifically, Lin and Huang (2008) proposed an interval-parameter energy systems planning model for dealing with uncertainties expressed as intervals in energy systems. Zhu et al. (2014) proposed an inexact mixed-integer fractional energy system planning model for supporting sustainable energy systems management under uncertainty. Borges and Antunes (2003) studied fuzzy multiple objective linear programming problems illustrated by an energy-economy planning model. Sadeghi and Hosseini (2006) used a fuzzy linear programming model, including fuzzy objective coefficients of investment costs for optimizing the energy supply system of Iran. Cai et al. (2009) developed a fuzzyrandom interval programming model to identify optimal strategies in the planning of energy management systems under multiple uncertainties. Kanudia and Loulou (1998) adopted a multi-stage stochastic programming approach to formulate flexible long-term energy planning for Québec. Guo et al. (2008) presented an inexact chance-constrained semi-infinite programming method for an energy management system under functional interval uncertainties.
Among these inexact modeling approaches, the stochastic linear programming requires the probability distribution information of random parameters, which is possibly unavailable in real world. Relatively, the interval linear programming (ILP) can directly deal with uncertainties that are expressed as interval numbers with deterministic lower and upper bounds. However, ILP cannot reflect the fuzziness of parameters existing in energy systems. And in fuzzy linear programming (FLP), the flexibilities and fuzziness can be expressed as fuzzy sets and denoted as ‘fuzzy constraints’ and a ‘fuzzy goal’ through introducing degrees of satisfaction. Therefore, in this study, an interval-parameter fuzzy linear energy systems programming (IPFLP) model will be developed through the combination of fuzzy linear programming and ILP approaches. Uncertain information in energy systems planning will be parameterized as intervals and fuzzy sets. IPFLP will be used to tackle with an advanced energy systems planning model. The optimal solutions obtained from IPFLP will provide decision makers with desirable strategies for energy activities including energy resources allocations, technological development and corresponding capacity expansion, as well as pollutant emission reduction under various system-satisfaction levels. In addition, IPFLP will allow an in-depth analysis of the trade-off between energy systems development and environmental protection, as well as that between optimality and reliability of energy systems.
2 Methodology
2.1 Interval-parameter linear programming
Firstly proposed by Huang et al. (1992), the interval-parameter liner programming (IPLP) is a useful tool for inexact optimization problems where uncertain parameters are expressed as a pair of lower and upper bounds. An IPLP model can be expressed as follows.

subject to:


2.2 Interval-parameter fuzzy linear programming
On the basis of the fuzzy flexible programming (Huang et al., 1993 and 1995; Li et al., 2013), both of the flexibility in the constraints as well as the fuzziness in the system objective can be assigned membership functions and represented by fuzzy sets. ‘Fuzzy constraints’ and a ‘fuzzy goal’ can then be expressed as membership grades (λ) corresponding to the overall satisfaction degree of constraints and the objective. By incorporating an interval membership grade (λ±) into the existing IPLP model, an interval-parameter fuzzy linear programming model (IPFLP) can be expressed as follows:

subject to:

where f-and f+are the lower and upper bounds of the objective’s aspiration level, respectively; λ±is a control variable corresponding to the satisfaction degree for the fuzzy decision (Huang et al., 1993 and 1995; Li et al., 2013).
According to a two-step solution algorithm (Huang, 1995), this model would be transformed into two submodels. The first sub-model corresponding to the upper bound of λ±can be formulated as

subject to:

Based on the optimal solutions from model (11)-(17), the second sub-model corresponding to the lower bound of λ±can be presented as follows:

subject to:

The lower and upper bounds of decision variables, membership grades and objective function values can be obtained through combining solutions from two sub-models.

3 Case study
3.1 Overview of energy management system
In this study, the micro energy management system mainly consists of three principle sectors, i.e., energy resources, energy conversion pattern and energy end-users. As presented in Figure 2, seven types of energy re-sources (i.e., coal, natural gas, diesel, gasoline, oil, biomass, and electricity) provide energy supply for multiple end-users (e.g., resident, industry, commerce, transportation, and tourism). As for the power generation, six energy sources (i.e., coal, natural gas, diesel and biomass fired, as well as wind and solar power) are utilized. In the central heating sub-system, coal and natural gas are the most frequently used two resources owing to the maturity of technologies. Besides, in this study region, an oil-refining industry is required to process oil products. All these factors are not independent but interactive with each other. Complex interactions exist throughout the energy system, from energy resources import to the utilization of end-users.

Fig. 1Formulation of IPFLP.
Moreover, energy related activities are associated with environmental protection and socio-economic development, which further complex energy management systems. The process of energy development and utilization is influenced by pollutant (i.e., CO2and SO2) discharge, pollution control measures, population, natural resource availabilities, socio-economy and the related policies and regulations. Actually, the energy or environmental policy can restraint energy processing patterns, and further affect the energy resources types. For example, renewable energies (e.g., wind and solar power) will be encouraged by strict environmental regulations. Therefore, in order to better plan the energy management system in this study region under uncertainty, effective inexact modeling works are required to balance the tradeoff between socio-economic and environmental interests. Finally, the optimal strategies for energy-related activities such as energy resources allocations, technological development, facility-capacity expansion and pollutant emission reduction as well as the corresponding system cost would be obtained.

Fig. 2Energy management system.
3.2 Modeling formulation
An energy system programming model (ESPM) where environmental protection is considered is presented as follows (Dong et al., 2013). The study time horizon includes 15 years divided into three planning periods. The objective of the developed inexact energy systems planning model is to minimize the total system cost (f±) which mainly includes the costs for energy resources development, expansion of conversion technologies (i.e., generation, heating, and oil refining), and environmental protection.

(a) Purchasing costs for primary energy supply (i.e.,PICf±)

(b) Fixed and variable costs for power generation (i.e.,PGf±)

(c) Fixed and variable costs for heating (i.e.,HTf±)

(d) Fixed and variable costs for oil refining (i.e.,ORf±)

(e) Costs for contamination reduction (i.e.,CEf±)

Constraints of the developed ESPM model consist of thirteen groups of inequalities or equalities for restraining energy and environmental activities. Specifically, constraints (a) to (h) are mass balance for energy resources (i.e., coal, natural gas, diesel, gasoline, oil, biomass, electricity, and heat), which ensure their adequate supplies. Then constraints (i) to (k) set up restricts for energy processing activities associated with oilrefining, power generation, and heating. Constraint (l) is used to control the total pollutant emissions of CO2and SO2.
(a) Balance constraints for coal supply and demands:

(b) Balance constraints for natural gas supply and demands:

(c) Balance constraints for diesel supply and demands:

(d) Balance constraints for gasoline supply and demands:

(e) Balance constraints for oil supply and demands:

(f) Balance constraints for biomass supply and demands:

(g) Balance constraints for electricity supply and demands

(h) Balance constraints for heat supply and demands:

(i) Oil refining constraint

(j) Electricity constraints

(k) Heating constraints

(l) Environmental quality constraints:

(m) Technical constraints:

where
f = expected net system cost (billion Yuan) in the energy management system;
t = time periods (1, 2, 3);
i = types of energy sources (i.e., i = 1 for coal, 2 for natural gas, 3 for diesel, 4 for gasoline, 5 for oil, 6
for biomass, and 7 for electricity production);
k = types of electricity conversion technologies, (i.e., k = 1 for coal-fired power, 2 for gas-fired power, 3 for diesel-fired power, 4 for wind power, 5 for solar power, and 6 for biomass);
o = capacity expansion options (1, 2, 3);
h = types of heating technology (i.e., h = 1 for coal-fired boiler, and 2 for gas-fired boiler);
p = types of pollutant (i.e., p = 1 for CO2, and 2 for SO2);
α= power transportation efficiency;
3.3 Modeling solution
The proposed interval-parameter fuzzy linear programming (IPFLP) method is introduced into the solving of ESPM. The ESPM model is converted into two sub-models. The sub-model corresponding to λ+(where the objective function is to be maximized) is firstly formulated as follows:

subject to:
(a) Balance constraints for coal supply and demands:


(b) Balance constraints for natural gas supply and demands:

(c) Balance constraints for diesel supply and demands:

(d) Balance constraints for gasoline supply and demands:

(e) Balance constraints for oil supply and demands:

(f) Balance constraints for biomass supply and demands:

(g) Balance constraints for electricity supply and demands:

(h) Balance constraints for heat supply and demands:

(i) Oil refining constraint:

(j) Electricity constraints:

(k) Heating constraints:

(l) Environmental protection constraints:

(m) Technical constraints:

Given the solution of the first sub-model, another sub-model corresponding to λ-is formulated and calculated in succession. Finally, the interval-form optimal planning schemes of the energy management system can be obtained.
4 Results and discussions
The price and cost for energy generation and heating are presented in Tables 1 and 2. Through solving the developed ESPM model, the optimal solutions associated with energy resources allocation, technological patterns (e.g., energy generation, heating, and oil-refining) and corresponding capacity expansion under desirable satisfaction degrees would be obtained. As shown in Table 3, the variation of energy supply in three periods would be different (λ±= [0.983, 0.124]). Since the maturity of coal-fired generation and heating technologies, coal would still be the primary energy resources in the near future and decrease a small amount in period 2, which would be [906666.83, 963867.53] × 104tonnes. The second largest energy resource, i.e. natural gas, would obtain a sudden increase to [71839.17, 72516.24] × 104m3in period 2, and then reduce to [55601.94, 57632.41] × 104m3in period 3. In comparison, the allocated amounts of diesel, crude oil, and biomass would be on the rise. As for diesel, its supply would increase from [10173.04, 14710.54] and [12192.63, 14752.98] to [14212.22, 16843.69] × 104tonnes in periods 1 to 3, respectively. A steady growth would occur in the crude oil supply, from 325 to 525 × 104tonnes in periods 1 and 3. The supply of biomass would obtain significant rise from [15000, 23760] to [30000, 36551.72] × 104tonnes for power generation in periods 1 and 3. Finally, a downward trend in the supplies of gasoline and electricity prove the enhancement of oil-refining and generation capacities, leading to decreased imports. Specifically, gasoline would decreasefrom [124.58, 137.59] through [112.47, 123.62] to [100.36, 109.66] × 104tonnes in the three periods, respectively. Duo the increased generation capacity in the study region, electricity production supply would drop to zero in period 3, totally depending on local generation plants instead of imports.

Table 1Energy price ($/104tonnes)
In this study, six types of power generation technologies were utilized, i.e. coal, gas, oil, biomass, wind and solar power. As presented in Figure 3, the coal, gas and wind power would occupy the first three slots, and biomass-fired plants would generate the least quantity. Moreover, the increasing power demand in the three periods would lead to an upward trend in the amount of electricity generation. To be specific, coal-fired generation would increase from [18333.33, 23650] through [23333.33, 25586.21] to [28500, 31647.06] × 104KWh in periods 1 to 3, respectively. The electricity generated from gas-fired plants would rise to [21250, 23301.72] and [27083.33, 29362.07] × 104KWh in periods 2 and 3. The clean generation, wind power would supply [13444.45, 15480], [17400, 20220.68] and [21900, 22655.17] × 104KWh, and solar power would provide [9000, 12300], [12750, 14482.76] and [16500, 18362.07] × 104KWh of electricity in periods 1 to 3, respectively. The electricity generated from oil-fired plants would increase from [5729.17, 8250] through [6875, 8297.41] to [8020.83, 9482.76] × 104KWh in the three periods. Biomass-fired technology would provide [1875, 2970], [2916.67, 3706.9], and [3750, 4568.97] × 104KWh in periods 1 to 3, respectively.

Table 3Solutions for energy supplies (104tonnes)

Fig. 3Solutions for power generation (104KWh).
As presented in Table 4, coal- and gas-fired technologies are two principle ones for heating. Among them, coal-fired heating plants would generate 2.5 × 106GJ in period 1, and [1.55, 1.7] × 106GJ of heat would be supplied by gas-fired plants. In period 2, the heat volume from coal-fired technology would reduce to [1.95, 2.07] × 106GJ, which would be compensated by [2.27, 2.27] × 106GJ of gas-fired heat. In period 3, the heat volume from coal-fired plants would increase to [2.49, 2.54] × 106GJ, compared with [1.84, 1.89] × 106GJ from gas-fired ones. Restrained by local processing capacity and oil imports, 325, 425, and 525 × 104tonnes of crude oil would be refined in periods 1, 2, and 3, respectively. The deterministic outcomes mean they are not sensitive to the uncertain inputs, limited by the practical conditions, such as plant capacity and resources supply.

Table 4Solutions for heating and oil-refining

Heating (106GJ) Coal-fired 2.5 [1.95, 2.07] [2.49, 2.54] Gas-fired [1.55, 1.7] 2.27 [1.84, 1.89] Oil-refining (104tonnes) Oil-refining 325 425 525

Table 5Capacity expansion for generation, heating, and oil-refining (Lower bound)
To satisfy demands for electricity, heat and oil productions, capacities of related energy processing plants need to be expanded. Since all plants have fixed rated power, these technologies should be expanded at a regular amount. Three fixed expansion capacity options are provided in the developed ESPM model. Table 5 displays the capacity expansion for electricity generation, heating, and oil-refining (lower bound) facilities. In detail, owing to the clean feature of wind power, 250 MW (option 3) would be expanded in period 1, and 150 MW (option 1) in periods 2 and 3. Other electricity generation technologies would be all expanded with option 1 in the three periods. As for heating which is the primary technology, coal-fired plants would expand 300 MW (option 3) in period 1, and 100 MW (option 1) in periods 2 and 3. Besides, 150 MW (option 1) would be added to gas-fired plants in the three periods. Corresponding to periods 1 to 3, oil-refining facilities would expand 200 MW (option 3), 100MW (option 1), and 100MW, respectively.
The value of λ±represents the satisfaction degree of the objective function and constraints under the given system conditions. It is in accordance with decision makers’ preference regarding the tradeoffs between system reliability and cost. The lower bound of λ±corresponds to a higher system cost, while the upper bound corresponds to a lower system cost. The overall tendency of ranges of optimal system costs maintains upward when λ±decreases (Li et al., 2013). The variation of optimal system cost ranges (lower and upper bounds) under different satisfaction degree (λ±) is displayed in Figure 4. In detail, the system cost would increase from $ [9.281, 9.782], [9.308, 9.785], [9.331, 9.79], [9.347, 9.795], [9.372, 9.799], and [9.397, 9.803] × 1012when λ±decreases from [0.124, 0.983], [0.118, 0.937], [0.109, 0.896], [0.101, 0.869], [0.094, 0.827], and [0.087, 0.784], respectively. Thus, decision makers could execute a deterministic energy systems management scheme after balancing the tradeoff between system costs and reliability (or satisfaction degree). Specifically, decision makers can adopt lower λ±value to ensure system reliability while a higher system cost is required. In contrast, decision makers may also chase lower system cost while the system reliability is decreased accordingly.

Fig. 4System cost under different satisfaction degree.
5 Conclusions
In this study, an energy system planning model (ESPM) was developed for planning energy management systems with the environmental consideration under uncertainty. In this model, an interval-parameter fuzzy linear programming (IPFLP) was adopted, which incorporated the fuzzy linear programming (FLP) and intervalparameter linear programming (IPLP) into a general optimization framework. In detail, this study can: (a) analyze the energy management system and identify the existing complexity regarding energy and environmental problems; (b) effectively tackle the uncertainties expressed as interval numbers and fuzzy sets in the managing process of energy system; (c) generate optimal interval solutions under various system satisfaction degrees; (d) help decision makers identify desirable energy related schemes, containing energy resources allocations, technological patterns and corresponding capacity expansion, as well as pollutant emission reduction, through balancing the trade-offs between economy and environment, as well as those between system optimality and reliability.
Acknowledgements
This paper was sponsored by the National Science Foundation for Innovative Research Group (No. 51121003), and the special fund of State Key Lab of Water Environment Simulation (11Z01ESPCN).
Amirnekooei, K., Ardehali, M.M. and Sadri, A. (2012), Integrated resource planning for Iran: development of reference energy system, forecast, and long-term energy-environment plan, Energy,46, 374-385.
Bakken, B.H., Skjelbred, H.I., and Wolfgang, O. (2007), eTransport: Investment planning in energy supply systems with multiple energy carriers, Energy,32, 1676-1689.
Borges, A.R. and Antunes, C.H. (2003), A fuzzy multiple objective decision support model for energy-economy planning, European Journal of Operational Research,145, 304-316.
Cai, Y.P., Huang, G.H., Tan, Q., and Liu, L. (2011a), An integrated approach for climate-change impact analysis and adaptation planning under multi-level uncertainties Part I: Methodology, Renewal Sustainable Energy Reviews,15, 2779-2790.
Cai, Y.P., Huang, G.H., Tan, Q., and Liu, L. (2011b), An integrated approach for climate-change impact analysis and adaptation planning under multi-level uncertainties Part II. Case study, Renewal Sustainable Energy Reviews,15(6), 3051-3073.
Cai, Y.P., Huang, G.H., Yang, Z.F., and Tan, Q. (2009), Identification of optimal strategies for energy management systems planning under multiple uncertainties, Applied Energy,86, 480-495.
Cormio, C., Dicorato, M., Minoia, A., and Trovato, M. (2003), A regional energy planning methodology including renewable energy sources and environmental constraints, Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews,7, 99-130.
Daniel, J., Dicorato, M., Forte, G., Iniyan, S., and Trovato, M. (2009), A methodology for the electrical energy system planning of Tamil Nadu state (India), Energy Policy,37, 904-914.
Dong, C., Huang, G.H., Cai, Y.P., and Liu, Y. (2013), Robust planning of energy management systems with environmental and constraint-conservative considerations under multiple uncertainties, Energy Conversion and Management,65, 471-486.
Guo, P. and Huang, G.H. (2008), ICCSIP: An inexact chance-constrained semi-infinite programming approach for energy systems planning under uncertainty, Energy Sources (Part A),30, 1345-1366.
Huang, G.H. (1995), Grey integer programming: an application to waste management planning under uncertainty, European Journal of Operational Search,83, 594-620.
Huang, G.H., Baetz, B.W., and Patry, G.G. (1993), A grey fuzzy linear programming approach for municipal solid waste management planning under uncertainty, Civil Engineering Systems,10, 123-146.
Huang, G.H., Baetz, B.W., and Patry, G.G. (1992), A grey linear programming approach for municipal solid waste management planning under uncertainty, Civil Engineering Systems,9, 319-335.
Huang, G.H., Baetz, B.W., and Patry, G.G. (1995), Grey fuzzy integer programming: An application to regional waste management planning under uncertainty, Socio-Economic Planning Science,29, 17-38.
Kanudia, A. and Loulou, R. (1998), Robust responses to climate change via stochastic MARKAL: The case of Québec, European Journal of Operational Research,106, 15-30.
Li, W., Huang, G.H., Dong, C., and Liu, Y. (2013), An inexact fuzzy programming approach for power coal blending, Journal of Environmental Informatics,21(2), 112-118.
Lin, Q.G. and Huang, G.H. (2008), IPEM: An interval-parameter energy systems planning model, Energy Sources (Part A),30, 1382-1399.
Mirzaesmaeeli, H., Elkamel, A., Douglas, P.L., Croiset, E., and Gupta, M. (2010), A multi-period optimization model for energy planning with CO2 emission consideration, Journal of Environmental Management,91, 1063-1070.
Mourmouris, J.C. and Potolias, C. (2013), A multi-criteria methodology for energy planning and developing renewable energy sources at a regional level: a case study Thassos, Greece, Energy Policy,52,522-530.
Ramachandra, T.V. (2009), RIEP: Regional integrated energy plan, Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews,13, 285-317.
Sadeghi, M. and Hosseini, H.M. (2006), Energy supply planning in Iran by using fuzzy linear programming approach (regarding uncertainties of investment costs), Energy Policy,34, 993-1003.
Yeo, I.A., Yoon, S.H., and Yee, J.J. (2013), Development of an environment and energy geographical information system (E-GIS) construction model to support environmentally friendly urban planning, Applied Energy,104, 723-739.
Zhu, H., Huang, W.W., and Huang, G.H. (2014), Planning of regional energy systems: An inexact mixed-integer fractional programming model, Applied Energy,113, 500-514.
†Corresponding author.
Email address: yanpeng.cai@bnu.edu.cn (Yanpeng Cai).
ISSN 2325-6192, eISSN 2325-6206/$- see front materials © 2014 L&H Scientific Publishing, LLC. All rights reserved.
10.5890/JEAM.2014.03.002
杂志排行
Journal of Environmental Accounting and Management的其它文章
- Hydropower’s Contribution to the Environmental Integrity of the Embryonic Chinese Carbon Market
- Sustainability Assessment of Certified Tropical Forestry using Emergy Analysis
- On the Systemic Assessment of a Sustainable University
- Carbon Capture and Storage (CCS) policy for China: Implications from Some Representative Countries and Regions
- Urban Environmental Management Performance Assessment by Fuzzy Analytical Hierarchy Processing (FAHP)
- The Urban Metabolism of the City of Uppsala (Sweden)
