我国PBL+LBL与PBL教学模式在外科教学中比较的Meta分析
2016-01-29刘阳刘清峰吉鸿陆宏伟黎一鸣
刘阳 刘清峰 吉鸿 陆宏伟 黎一鸣
我国PBL+LBL与PBL教学模式在外科教学中比较的Meta分析
刘阳 刘清峰 吉鸿 陆宏伟 黎一鸣
【摘要】目的 评价我国外科教学中PBL+LBL模式与PBL模式相比的效果。方法 收集我国2015年2月6日前所有已发表的在外科教学中用PBL+LBL模式与PBL模式相比较的随机对照研究,并分析两种方法对学生理论成绩、实践成绩、总成绩及学生满意度的差异。结果PBL+LBL组与PBL组相比,学生的理论成绩、总成绩及学生的满意度,P<0.05,差异具有统计学意义,而两组相比学生的实践成绩,P >0.05,差异不具有统计学意义。结论 在我国外科教学领域,PBL+LBL教学模式较PBL模式具有一定优势,能够提高学生的理论成绩、总成绩及学生满意度。
【关键词】PBL;LBL;外科;教学;Meta分析
作者单位:710004西安交通大学第二附属医院普通外科
基金支持:西安交通大学第二附属医院教改项目(13BY02)
Meta Analysis the Comparative of Problem Based Learning Combine Lecture Based Learning and Lecture Based Learning in Surgical Teaching in China
LIU Yang LIU Qingfeng JI Hong LU Hongwei LI Yiming the Second Affiliated Hospital of Xi’an Jiaotong University General Surgery, Xi’an 710004, China
[Abstract]Objective To evaluate the effect on comparative of problem based learning combine Lecture based learning and problem based learning in surgical teaching in China. Methods Selected all of enunciable in surgical teaching of control study with problem based learning combine Lecture based learning and Lecture based learning before 6th February
2015 and analyzed difference the score of theory, score of practice, total score and degree of satisfaction. Results Compared with problem based learning combine Lecture based learning and problem based learning the score of theory, total score and degree of satisfaction, P<0.05, had difference statistically significance, while compared the score of practice in two groups, P>0.05, had no difference statistically significance. Conclusion Problem based learning combine Lecture based learning has advantage in surgical teaching in China. It could improve the student’s theoretical score, practical score and satisfaction rate.
[Key words]Problem based learning, Lecture based learning, Surgical, Teaching, Meta-analysis
PBL(Problem Based Learning),即以问题为基础的教学方法,是目前国际上流行的一种教学方法,近年来在国内各医学院校广泛推广。PBL教学法使学生在学习过程中化被动为主动,并较传统的LBL(Lecture Based Learning)相比具有诸多优势,但其理论学习差的劣势客观存在。因此,在外科教学中部分教师尝试PBL联合LBL的教学方法,但该种教学法的效果如何,尤其是在是否能够提高学生满意度及成绩方面尚存争议[1-6]。对多中心的随机对照资料用循证医学的方法进行析,以判断PBL+LBL模式较PBL是否具有更好的教学效果。通过检索外科教学领域的文章并进行分析,具体报道如下。
1 对象与方法
1.1 资料来源
检索万方数据知识服务平台、维普网、中国知网数据出版平台、Pubmed。……
