APP下载

大学儒学组织的运行与演变逻辑

2024-05-13康晓光,李亚兰

湖南大学学报(社会科学版) 2024年2期

康晓光,李亚兰

[摘要] 借鉴克拉克的学术权力理论,选取15家大学儒学组织,采用多案例分析方法,基于学科与学科组织的发展需要资源这一事实,以学科资源定义权力和权力主体,界定掌握学科资源的政府、院校、教师、社会四类权力主体,揭示影响大学儒学组织发展的基础逻辑。结果表明,政府-院校-教师之间呈现明显的权力等级结构,儒学组织所拥有的学科资源与其结构-功能之间存在对应关系,权力主体通过配置自己所掌控的学科资源,将学科资源投入儒学组织,决定了儒学组织的发展阶段。

[关键词] 儒学组织;学科资源;权力结构

[中图分类号]  B222[文献标识码] A[文章编号] 1008-1763(2024)02-0110-09

The Operation and Evolutionary Logic of University Confucian Organizations:An Empirical Study of Power-Resource Theory Based on Discipline Development

KANG Xiaoguang,LI Yalan

(School of Public Administration and Policy, Renmin University of China, Beijing100872, China)

Abstract:Drawing on Clarks theory of academic power, this paper based on the fact that the development of disciplines and disciplinary organizations requires resources,

selects 15 university Confucian organizations, adopts a multi-case analysis method, defines power and subjects of power in terms of disciplinary resources, and defines the four types of subjects of power, namely, government, institutions, teachers, and  society, which holds disciplinary resources, and reveals the underlying logic that affects the development of university Confucian organizations, i.e., there is a clear hierarchy of power between the government. There is an obvious power hierarchy between institutions and teachers.There is a correspondence between the disciplinary resources possessed by Confucian organizations and their structure-function. The power subject determines the stage of development of Confucian organizations by allocating the disciplinary resources under its control and investing disciplinary resources into Confucian organizations.

Key words: Confucian organizations; disciplinary resources; power structures

一 引言

20世紀90年代以来,民间和官方“复兴中华文化”的呼声日益高涨,形成了全国性的浪潮。儒家文化是中华文化的主干,儒家文化复兴是中华文化复兴的核心要义,而“制度化”是文化复兴的必然要求,所以儒家文化制度化是中华文化复兴的必然要求。大学,作为最重要的现代文化建制,是儒家文化制度化的主战场。在现代大学中,儒家文化制度化就是儒学学科化,儒学作为一个学科的成熟程度也就是其制度化的程度。由此可知,近20年来,各类冠名“国学”“儒学”“经学”的学院、研究院、研究中心、研究所(以下统称“儒学组织”),在大学中接连出现并获得蓬勃发展绝非偶然,自有其合理性与必然性。

现代高等教育系统是围绕知识的生产和传播组织起来,进行劳动分工并高度制度化的系统,是按照学科和院校这两个基本组织维度,纵横交叉组成的庞大而复杂的矩阵结构[1]33。……

登录APP查看全文