APP下载

著作权法上独创性概念的澄清与重释

2024-05-13付继存

湖南大学学报(社会科学版) 2024年2期

付继存

[摘要] 由于个性、创造性、智力劳动等概念比较抽象,一部作品是否具有独创性通常取决于预设的私人立场。这种判定模式会不合理地损害著作权保护的预期。从我国的作品定义看,独创性是一部作品区别于其他作品的内在尺度。独创性既表明了特定作品的特有属性,又表达了与其相关的权益归属。这一内涵与著作权法的内外价值一致。依此逻辑,独创性是指作品的相对差异,并暗示作品进入市场的机会与作品价值的二分。按照相对差异标准,作者享有依照著作权法提出保护的应然权利。

[关键词] 著作权法;独创性;相对差异标准

[中图分类号]  D923.41[文献标识码] A[文章编号] 1008-1763(2024)02-0136-09

Clarification and Reinterpretation of the Concept of Originality in Copyright Law

FU Jicun

(Civil and Commercial Economic Law School, China University of Political Science and Law, Beijing100088, China)

Abstract:Due to the abstract concept of personality, creativity, intellectual labor, etc., the originality of a work usually hinges on the predetermined personal position. This mode of judgment will unreasonably harm the expectations of copyright protection. In terms of the definitions of works in our country, originality is an internal scale that distinguishes one work from  others. Originality not only indicates the unique attributes of specific single works, but also shows the ownership of its related rights. This connotation  is consistent with the internal and external values of copyright law. According to this logic, originality refers to the relative differences among works. According to the relative difference standard, authors have the right to seek protection under copyright law.

Key words: copyright law; originality; relative difference standard

著作權法实施30余年来,独创性的规范意蕴及术语表达依然缺乏应有的共识。从中国裁判文书网收录的最高人民法院的裁判文书看,独创性可被解释为个性、最低限度的创造性、简单的创作高度、较高的独创性、一定的独创性高度、足够的创作高度、不同于公有领域和已有作品、显著差异、足够的美学方面的独特性与智力劳动等。

部分裁判文书又将多个释义嵌套在一起。标准的不统一,一方面会导致利益相关者为实现利益诉求,就同一主题接连诉讼。例如,春节联欢晚会直播画面的独创性判定,就先后经历了缺乏独创性、内容选择与编排具有独创性三个阶段。另一方面,当面对新型作品并无经验可依时,利益相关者会基于前述的结果激励,重启接连诉讼的过程。……

登录APP查看全文