Determination of the constant mi in the Hoek-Brown criterion of rock based on drilling parameters
2022-09-07HotengWngMingmingHeZhiqingZhngJiweiZhu
Hoteng Wng ,Mingming He,b,*,Zhiqing Zhng,b ,Jiwei Zhu,c
a State Key Laboratory of Eco-hydraulics in Northwest Arid Region,Xi’an University of Technology,Xi’an 710048,China
b Shaanxi Key Laboratory of Loess Mechanics and Engineering,Xi’an University of Technology,Xi’an 710048,China
c Research Center of Eco-hydraulics and Sustainable Development,The New Style Think Tank of Shaanxi Universities,Xi’an 710048,China
Keywords:Constant mi in the H-B criterion Analytical model Friction angle Drilling parameters Triaxial compressive strength
ABSTRACT The constant mi in the Hoek-Brown(H-B)criterion is a fundamental parameter required for determining the compressive strength of rock.In this paper,drilling parameters provide a new basis for determining the constant mi.An analytical relationship between the drilling parameters and constant mi is established in consideration of the contact response between the drilling bit and the cut rock in the crushed zone.New models are developed to predict the triaxial compressive strength (TCS),internal friction angle φ and cohesion c of rock.Drilling tests are carried out on 6 rock types to study the correlation between φ and mi.A comparison between the predicted values of rock mechanical properties and the measured values from the laboratory is performed to verify the accuracy of the proposed model (yielding an error less than 10%).The TCSs and constant mi values of fifteen rocks are cited to validate the accuracy of the proposed model.The result shows that the proposed model predicts the TCS and constant mi within a maximum error of 20%.The method can be conveniently applied to the rock mechanical properties.
1.Introduction
Rock strength characteristics under different confined pressures are important to understand in rock engineering applications,especially for the safety assessment of tunnel excavation and mining [1–3].In addition to the standard measurement methods suggested by the International Society of Rock Mechanics (ISRM),there are several reliable criteria for the prediction of the triaxial compressive strength (TCS) of rock masses,such as the Drucker-Prager (D-P) criterion [4],Joseph-Barron (J-B) criterion [5],and Mohr-Coulomb(M-C)criterion[6].In particular,based on the brittle fracture theory introduced by Griffth [7] and Mclintock and Walsh [8],Hoek and Brown [9,10] proposed an empirical failure criterion.The Hoek-Brown(H-B)criterion is a well-known method for determining theTCSof rock masses [11–18].
There are two constants,sandmi,in the H-B criterion.Constantsis considered as the degree of rock fragmentation.miis a fitting parameter,and ranges from 0.001 to 25.There are several definitions ofmiaccording to different perspectives,such as from the perspectives of geological information,experimental evaluation,and rock properties.However,different methods for determining the value ofmimay result in a large error for the same rock [13].Geological information was initially accepted to be the main reference for determiningmi.Nevertheless,the quality of the geological information obtained depends on the experience of the exploration engineers.With the ISRM-suggested method,a lack of test data,low-quality test results and differences in test conditions can also negatively impact the determination of the constantmi[16,19].With substantial data,to illustrate the applicability of H-B criterion,statistical methods,including those presented in relevant codes[9,10],the R-index method[13,20,21],and unconfined compressive strength (UCS)-based models [22,23],have been used to reliably and rapidly determinemi.Although the abovementioned methods can easily estimate the constantmibased on lithological classifications and rock properties,there is an urgent need to establish analytical models based on mechanical parameters to directly determine the constantmi.In Sari’s research [13],the integration of theTCSwith respect to the deformation modulus was considered to determinemiwith an error of approximately 20%.In the research of Zuo et al.[24],the constantmiwas defined as an indicator related to the micromechanical principles of brittle rock.According to microfracture and linear elastic fracture mechanics,a nonlinear strength model was established by Zuo et al.[25],

where μ and κ are the coefficients of the model established by Zuo et al.[25];σtthe tensile strength;and σctheUCS.Clearly,the nonlinear failure criterion proposed by Zuo et al.[25]is similar to the HB criterion.Compared with the H-B criterion,this nonlinear criterion gives an analytical solution to the constantmibased on the fracture coefficients and σt.However,there are some limitations in determining the constantmi,such as the strong dependence ofmion the tensile strength measured from laboratory tests and the difficulty in measuring the fracture coefficients [26,27].Thus,the value of constantmiis hard to obtain by considering this physical meaning.In engineering applications,the measurement ofmishould be determined from the perspective of field testing and rock macroscopic mechanical properties.
Focusing on the perspective of field tests,logging while drilling is a common method to evaluate rock quality due to the rapid and continuous collection of parameters during drilling.Core drilling using the diamond bit is an important prerequisite for laboratory measurement of rock mechanics parameters.Since 2013,several models based on the ultimate force balance and energy conservation have been established to estimate rock strength [28],including the shear model [29,30],point bit model [31,32] and indentation model [33].As presented in previous studies [28-33],theoretical models occasionally assume that the cutting debris has no effect on the subsequent cutting action.Thus,the compaction and friction effects of the axial thrust on the cutting debris may be ignored.Although complex failure types are observed in boreholes,the mechanisms that lead to complex failures are not clear.Furthermore,when the H-B criterion is considered in the drilling model,is it possible to obtain the solution for the constantmi?
An analytical relationship between the drilling parameters and constantmiis established to give a new physical meaning to the constantmi.Then,analytical models are developed to predict theTCS,internal friction angle and cohesion of rock.Drilling tests using diamond bit on 6 rock types are carried out to provide the model with drilling parameters to predict the constantmiandTCSs under different confining pressures.Laboratory tests are carried out on the same rock types to verify the reliability of the proposed method.Moreover,many rockTCSresults are collected from the literature to verify the reliability of the proposed model.A comparison between the predictedTCSvalues and collectedTCSvalues verifies the good accuracy of the proposed method;the cohesion and internal friction coefficient are also accurately predicted.Thus,the proposed method can provide a reliable prediction of the strength properties of rocks.
2.Development of an analytical model
Core drilling induces two forces,rotational torque forceFtand compressive forceFn,to break the rock.Rotary cutting and compression are both involved in rotary penetration [34,35].Correspondingly,the drilling process can be divided into two stages,depending on which action is dominant.The rapid development of compressive indentation arises in the first stage.The action of the drill bit results in crushing and smashing in the axial direction.Crushing and smashing under vertical compression generates the drilling cuttings and friction.Furthermore,vertical compression provides effective contact between the drill bit and the rock during the rotational cutting,and the rotational blade removes the drill cuttings and eliminates the friction that arises between the drilling cuttings and the intact rock.In the second stage,rotary cutting and compression ensure a stable drilling process.The combination ofFtandFnplays an important role during drilling[36].In particular,FnandFtmaintain a balanced relationship [37].A force equilibrium model of diamond particles impregnated on the drill bit [30] is established as shown in Fig.1.The cross-sectional shape of a diamond particle on the drill bit is assumed to be trapezoidal,including 4 shape parameters: inner and outer edge widthslandL,rake angle α and holding angle β.Because a hydrostatic state is maintained in the crushed zone,the bit holding angle β is considered to be zero.Therefore,the drilling process involves only the rake angle α.Rock cutting should be considered homogeneously in the revised model,without the effects of the spatial anisotropy of the material properties or thermal conditions [30].The force analysis involved in the model includes 3 parts: the diamond particle,the crushed zone and the potentially damaged intact rock(fragment).When the diamond particles initially cut the rock,a crushed zone is quickly formed.Then friction occurs between the crushed zone and the fragment to transfer the drill load.As the drill bit continues to penetrate,the original crushed zone was squeezed into the small fragments.Drilling loading is transferred to the intact rock through the fragments to form a new crushed zone.
When the drill bit rotates,crushed area is formed.This area is correlated with several drilling indicators,such as the blade shape,the drilling parameters namely thrust forceFn,tangential forceFt,drilling speed v and rotating speed ω,the tangential contact at the cutting surface,and a small space in the borehole (fixes the position of the drill cuttings).This crushed zone between the bit and the rock can also be interpreted as being controlled by the initial force,whose value is equal to the component(along the vertical direction in Fig.1).Another component,is transmitted to the bottom of the borehole through the compressed crushed zone.The length of the transmission is the same as the accumulated cutting amount of multiple rotation cycles.The tangential forceFtis provided by the rotational torque.The thrustFnin the penetration direction is provided by the normal load.
The decomposition of bothFtandFncan be expressed as the combination of the cutting componentFcand the frictional componentFw,as shown in then-torthogonal system;then,we obtain:


where α is the bit rake angle;θ the rock-contact friction angle at the cut face and end face of the bit;φ’the friction angle between the compressed zone and intact rock;τ0the shear stress in the compressed zone and rock mass;σ0the normal stress between the crushed zone and intact rock;andAthe effective cutting crosssectional area,which can be calculated as π∙(R2-r2),respectively.
Using Eqs.(2)–(6),the force combination of the drill blade can be obtained as:

Fig.1.A theoretical model of diamond particles cutting into rock for drilling analysis,modified from [30].

Referring to Eqs.(6)–(8),the stress correlation of the potential failure surface in the fracture zone is calculated as:

During rock breaking,fragments form in the crushed area facing the drill bit.The failure surface and fragments are under the same stress condition with a static pressure of σ0.This stress condition also results in fragments spreading in the linear direction of shear[37].A new fracture zone continuously expands along a certain angle when sufficient loading is applied on the rock surface.

where ψ represents the propagating angle of the fracture zone.
The H-B failure criterion of rock [18,24] is introduced as follows:

wheremiandsare two indicators;σctheUCSof rock;σ and τ the compressive stress and shear stress,respectively;σ1and σ3the two components of σ.The relationship between the compressive stress and shear stress is expressed as follows:

where φ is the angle between σ and τ equal to θ[6].Eq.(14)is substituted into Eq.(13).Then,the H-B failure criterion is expressed in the shear stress form [26] as follows:

After the algebraic simplification by substituting Eqs.(7),(11)and (12),Eq.(15) can be expressed as:

σ0is considered in the most efficient case[31]in which the substituted value of ψ is obtained as:

The function of σ0shown in Eq.(16)contains 3 drilling variables and one constant,as follows:

Then,the correlation ofFtandFncan be derived from Eq.(7):

With reference to the cutting cross-sectional areaAequal to π∙(R2–r2),Eq.(20)is revised by substituting Eq.(19)andA.Thus,after some mathematical operations,Eq.(20) can be simplified to:

Eq.(21) is a linear function betweenFnandFt,and includes 4 drilling angles φ,φ’,θ,and α and a constantmi[34].The slope tan θ describes the stable friction effect between the drill bit and rock [38,39].The intercept expression contains an indicatormiin the H-B criterion,whose value is constant,to express the relationship between the tangential forceFtand thrust forceFn.To calculate the internal friction angle φ,α and tan (α+θ) are substituted to express φ′.Eqs.(3),(4) and (10) are substituted into Eq.(20)to obtain the expression of φ’:

Referring to the friction angle relationship introduced by Kerisel[40] and Gerbaud et al.[41],Eq.(9) is substituted into Eq.(8) to obtain tan φ.Subsequently,the internal friction angle can be calculated as follows:

where φ is the internal friction angle of the rock.Eq.(24)is the simplified form of Eq.(21) after substituting Eq.(23):

The intercept of Eq.(24)is replaced with a constantb,and then a solution of constantmiis calculated as follows:

To determine theUCSin theTCSprediction,the M-C criterion is introduced as:

Referring to the model established by Kalantari et al.[30]based on drilling parameters,theUCSdetermination is expressed as:

wherecand φ are the mechanical parameters of rock.Eqs.(25)and(27) are substituted into Eq.(13) to predict theTCS:

where constantshas a value of 1.0 for intact rock.
3.Tests
3.1.Drilling tests
A drilling process measuring apparatus(DPMA)is a field device used to measure the drilling parameters required for analysis with the proposed model[34,35]to predict the mechanical indicators of rock masses,as illustrated in Fig.2.The DPMA includes the following components:an electric-control system,a hydraulic system,an oil pump transmission system,a real-time monitoring and data acquisition system and a diamond-impregnated drill bit.The hydraulic system can apply a maximum thrust of 18 kN from the hydraulic pump,and the torsion system can provide a maximum torque of 2458 N∙m by a torque servo motor.The torsion resource is produced with a drive motor and a transmission gearbox.The drive gearbox has 4 gears,each associated with a different grade of surrounding rock.A hollow bit with a 70 mm outer diameter(OD) and 60 mm inner diameter (ID) size is used with the DPMA to carry out the field drilling tests.The DPMA must be activated in accordance with the specified operating procedure to start a drilling test.

Fig.2.Drilling process measuring apparatus (DPMA) and its system components.
There are 2 operation modes of DPMA:normal mode and collection mode.The normal mode is used to determine the depth of the test section.The equipment runs at a fast rate for predrilling.For different rock types,there is an effective load range for thrust force and torque in the collection mode.If the thrust force does not match the rotational torque,the drill blade will spin idly (thrust force is lower than the normal force) or wear out (thrust force exceeds the normal force),thereby decreasing the drilling efficiency [42].According to the machine control method,the initial values of the drilling and thrust loads and rotational torque are set in the ranges of 4 to 12 kN and 500 to 1500 N∙m,respectively(following the previous geological report,the ranges corresponding to different rocks are 4–5 kN and 500–800 N∙m for shale and limestone,5–8 kN and 700–1200 N∙m for slate and granite,and 9–12 kN and 1000–1500 N∙m for diorite and marble).During the drilling process,the drilling parameters are recorded every second,i.e.,the pure drilling timet(min),penetration depthh(cm),thrust forceFn(kN),torqueFt(kN),rotating speed ω (r/min),and drilling speed v(cm/min).The drilling logging data are recorded for subsequent determining of the mechanical parameters.Flat and uniform rock surfaces are selected for the location of the drilling test,which is convenient for machine installation.Prior to the commencement of formal testing,pre-drilling is carried out for 3–5 times at the selected site to ensure that the distribution of drilling parameters has no significant fluctuation [42-44].In addition,each rock type is tested more than 5 times to avoid potential problems during drilling.For 6 rock types,the DPMA operation is set at a rotating speed of 500–800 r/min,and the drilling speed ranges from 0.2 to 2.3 cm/min.When the DPMA operates at a certain rotating speed ω and drilling speed v,the depth of penetration per rotationhcan be calculated as a function of ω and v,

wherenis the number of diamond particles embedded in the cutters.Even as the drilling bit gradually wears out,the depth of each cutting rotation is assumed to be the same [30].
3.2.Conventional triaxial tests
Conventional triaxial compression tests are performed on the WDT-1500 type multifunctional rock material compression test machine [34,35] controlled by the digital DOLI equipment,as presented in Fig.3.This rock testing machine is equipped with EDC full digital servo measurement and control device produced by German DOLI company.This experimental equipment is composed of an electrical control system,a sonic detection system,and a loading system.For the loading performance of this equipment,the axial load capacity is 1800 kN,and the maximum confining pressure is 80 MPa.

Fig.3.WDT-1500 type multifunctional rock material compression test machine with the deformation measuring device.
The deformation measuring device (Fig.3) can detect a maximum axial displacement of 100 mm and a maximum lateral displacement of 5 mm.The error ranges of the load and displacement are both within 0.1%.The test procedure follows the standard suggested by the ISRM [42].The tested confining pressures are applied by the pressure cylinder with the values of 5,10,15,20 and 25 MPa (Fig.3).To ensure the consistency (such as permeability,density,brittleness and other factors that may affect the accuracy of the proposed method)of sample in core drilling test and laboratory test,the samples used in the laboratory test are from the on-site core drilling test [43].The sample is wrapped with a flexible rubber film to prevent the penetration of pressurized oil during testing [44].A spherical seat is used on the top to minimize the error caused by the uneven bottom surface of the sample (Fig.3).In the unconfined and triaxial compression test,2 heat-treated hardened smooth plates are placed on both ends of the sample to ensure that there is no friction[45].To eliminate the variability caused by rock heterogeneity,the average values ofUCSandTCSare obtained for further investigation after measuring 3 samples of each rock type.Following the test procedures and precautions recommended by the ISRM [46],the tested samples are standard cylinders with a height of 100 mm and a diameter of 50 mm [47].The bottom and top surface of the cylindrical specimen must be completely flat to ensure a uniform load effect;the allowable error of the flatness and size is controlled within ±0.02 mm.In addition,rock samples in which defects and joints are observed are discarded.
3.3.Selection of rock types tested
Referring to the rock strength grades,6 rock types,limestone(low strength),shale (normal strength),slate (medium–high strength),granite (medium–high strength),diorite (high strength)and marble (very high strength),are obtained from engineering in the Weihe River Basin in Shaanxi,China,for this study.
The basic mineralogy of the tested rock is provided for reference.Some differences in the brittleness of slate,limestone and granite are due to their different mineral compositions.The shale consists of medium-sized particles of feldspar and quartz and fine-grained calcite.The particle size distribution ranges from 0.3 to 1.5 nm,and there is no obvious mineral anisotropy.The granite is mainly dark cloudy quartz and feldspar,including 49% quartz,35%plagioclase and 16%biotite.Its density is 2.59 g/cm3,its water content is 0.41%,and its longitudinal wave velocity is 4653 m/s.No significant evidences suggest that the difference in failure type is related to mineralogy.The slate has a clastic structure (volcanic chips),and its major mineral component is potash feldspar.Its texture is fully compact with a porosity of 10%,so the natural density is 2.51 g/cm3.Its moisture content is 1.27%,and its longitudinal wave velocity is 3721 m/s.The limestone is composed of gray calcareous grains,mud particles,calcite,dolomite,and pyrite.Because its structure includes diagonal cracks,the density of the limestone is 2.48 g/cm3;additionally,its moisture content is 2.53%,and its longitudinal wave velocity is 2504 m/s.These skeletal grains contribute to a small amount of fracturing in the sample.The marble is gray and contains dolomite and calcite particles with diameters of less than 60 μm,so its texture is hard (Fig.4).
4.Results
Table 1 lists the physical and mechanical properties measured by the ISRM-recommended method.

Fig.4.Six types of cored samples for laboratory testing.
The logging data for the borehole,drill speed v,rotating speed ω,tangential forceFt,and thrust forceFnare plotted in Fig.5.Taking shale as an example,the variations in drilling forcesFnandFtwith the penetration depth is plotted to analyze the drilling efficiency.The corresponding drilling speed and rotating speed change with increasing time to further investigate during drilling process.The rock surface undergoes an initial cutting for approximately 20 s,until the diamond-impregnated bit makes full contact with the rock.Then,the drilling parameters v and ω are steady at 3.5 cm/min and 300 r/min,respectively(Fig.5b).Correspondingly,FtandFnincrease with increasing drilling depthh.However,whenhreaches a critical depth(0.11 mm in Fig.5a),the slope of the linear relationships betweenFtandFnversushchange.Before a depth of 0.11 mm,the slopes of the axial direction and plane direction results are 21.89 and 42.28 kN/mm,respectively.After the critical depth,the slope of the plane direction results decreases to 6.74 kN/mm.In contrast,the slope of the axial direction results is 58.39 kN/mm.The clogging of rock cuttings is believed to be the main cause of the change in slope[48],which is generally controlled by the cutting and friction.From the drilling energy perspective [49],the input energy is consumed when the drill bit cuts the rock before reaching a depth of 0.11 mm.Rock cuttings are washed away by cooling water.Cooling water does not easily cause friction or consume energy[50].Thus,the energy consumed by the cutting force is basically the same as the work done by the torque.As the drilling depth increases,a crushed zone is formed by a large amount of chips clogging the bottom of the hole,causing friction and dissipating energy[50].The component of the friction force along a principal axis remains constant,and the corresponding effective contact stress is limited to a fixed value [51].In this sense,the drilling efficiency is associated with friction depending on the drilling depth.
SinceFtandFnhave different responses to the same drilling depthh,the relationship between the ratio ofFtandFnversus drilling depth is established to directly describe the rock break behavior of the drill bit.TheFnandFtvalues are measured and recorded by the drilling equipment at different depths to establish the correlation betweenFtandFnfor different rocks,as drawn in Fig.6.Due to the dispersion and fluctuation of drilling data(Fig.5),error bars are adapted instead of the data points to present the relationship betweenFtandFnclearly.Table 2 lists the measured drilling parameters and the intercept of the fitting curve for determining the constantmiaccording to Eq.(21).For different rock types,two stages are observed by a curved path determined by the drilling force ratio andhaccording to the friction.The cutting stage passes through the origin,but the compression stage has a nonzero intercept.There is almost no negative impact on cutting before the critical depth.Due to the cooling water,the initial friction is very low in the cutting stage(Fnbelow the thrust force at thecrucial depth).The bottom abrasion caused by the drill blade is so low that it can be ignored.Furthermore,friction from the rock sidewall also has little effect on cutting at shallow depths [52].Thrust forceFnensures full contact between the rock only at the bottom of the borehole rock and the drill bit.Therefore,the drilling performance is positively correlated with the tangential forceFt,which represents the drilling efficiency in a sense.In the compression stage (Fnexceeds the thrust force at the crucial point),the drilling cuttings from the previous stage of cutting pile up in the borehole[53],which affects the logging efficiency.The reduction in the drilling force ratio at the critical point(Fig.6)proves that as the depth exceeds the critical value,compression is the main mechanism of rock breaking,and a large amount of drilling cuttings is produced.When thrust force is applied constantly,the formation of the crushed zone is closely related to the accumulation of compacted drill cuttings.Thus,the compression stage is the stable drilling process,which includes friction and cutting at the same time.This stage is also of significance for model establishment and constantmidetermination.Additionally,the angle between the extended dashed line of the fitting curve at the cutting stage and the fitting curve in the compression stage quantitatively describes the friction effect on cutting.For shale,slate and limestone,these angles are 17.6°,15.0°,and 18.6°,respectively,which are smaller than the angles of 27.6°,28.6°,and 21.3° of diorite,marble and granite,respectively.This indicates that the thrust force increases more in hard rock than in soft rock at the compression stage.

Table 1Physical and mechanical properties of the tested rocks suggested by the ISRM method.

Table 2Average values of drilling parameters measured with the DPMA for different rock types.

Fig.5.Relationships among different drilling parameters,taking shale as an example.

Fig.6.Curves of the tangential force versus thrust force for different rocks.
In the rotary penetration cycle,the bit initially produces an indentation in the rock,forms cuttings and finally creates a crushed zone.FnandFtchange significantly during drilling,but their fitting correlation coefficientR2is higher than 0.90,indicating the calculation accuracy.To obtain theTCSand constantmi,the fitting intercepts of different rocks (Fig.6) are calculated with Eqs.(24)and(28),including the following variables:rake angle α,contact angle θ of the cutting surface,contact angle θ’of the lateral wall,and internal friction angle φ.When the drilling speed v is very low,the sidewall friction is less affected by the velocity gradient,which makes the sidewall contact angle θ’fixed as a constant value[30].θ’can be considered equal to θ for the convenience of calculation [30].TheUCSs are calculated and substituted into the M-C criterion to obtain theTCSs of different rocks based on the drilling method shown in Eq.(27).Moreover,cand φ are also obtained from the above equation.The predicted rock strength and the corresponding drilling data are presented in Table 3.
To investigate the strength characteristics based on the drilling parameters,the predictedTCSenvelopes and measuredTCSenvelopes for the 6 rock types according to the H-B criterion and the MC criterion are shown in Fig.7.Compared with theTCSenvelopes obtained in the laboratory,the predictedTCSenvelopes describe the rock failure accurately(error bar below 13.5%).This result suggests that the drilling parameters are effective in analytically determining the constantmiin the H-B criterion.In this study,the hard granite and marble exhibit strong brittleness.Their predictedTCSerror has a range within 5%.The predictedTCSof soft rock,such as slate and limestone,has an error below 15%,as shown in Fig.7.The error difference between hard rock and soft rock can be explained by the better adaptability of the H-B criterion to hard rock [54].This better prediction performance for hard rock is also related to the increasing confining pressure.A comparison of thecand φ results is illustrated in Fig.8.The predictedcand φ are usually 10% smaller than the laboratory-measuredcand φ due to the difference in test procedure.The advantage of using drilling parameters to determine the strength,compared with the laboratory method,is that there is no need for sampling and transportation,which avoids possible error in the strength measurement[55,56].Nevertheless,the predictedcis larger than the measuredcfor the shale,limestone and diorite,as observed in Fig.8c.In Fig.8a,there is also a similar trend shown for the constantmi.The laboratory-obtainedmiis 8% larger than the predictedmifor limestone and slate.Compared with the predicted value,the laboratory-measuredmiof granite and marble is 5% greater.This difference can be explained by the difference in the dominant force of rock breaking.Hard rock has a high compressive strength,while soft rock is prone to damage under compression.Cutting hard rock requires more torque,and cutting soft rock requires more pressure[57].Therefore,the predictedmifor hard rock is smaller than that for soft rock (Table 4).
5.Discussion
The relationship betweenFtandFnis presented as two linear segments in accordance with the different drilling stages.The two linear segments have the same variables of constantmi,rake angle α,friction angle φ,and bit-rock contact angle θ.The stable drilling stage of different rock types is fitted as a function,shown in Fig.6.According to Eq.(25),the fitting correlation coefficient ofFtandFnis greater than 0.90,indicating that the drilling efficiency is stable.The constantmican also be solved from the fitting intercept of the compression stage[55].Hence,the solutions of the constantmiandTCSare derived by the proposed models Eqs.(25)and (28) with the drilling parameter method.Then,ccan be obtained by considering the M-C criterion.However,when the bit squeezes the rock,its shape changes temporarily until it is fully in contact with the rock.Then,the drilling stabilizes,and the bit shape no longer changes [31].Thus,the rake angle α should be determined as an intermediate index to investigate the dependence of the constantmion the bit-rock contact angle θ.There are correlations among the drilling angles α,θ,and φ’,as shown in Eqs.(22) and (23).To determine the quantitative relationship between the crushed rock characteristics and bit shape,α and θ are combined as one variable and associated with the friction angle of the crushed zone φ’(Fig.9a).An obvious increase in φ’can be observed in different rocks.The tan (α+θ) range of shale is from 0.2 to 1.0,and the associated φ’increases from 3.27° to 32.5°.The increasing trend of φ’for different rocks is expressed as linear function,which is marked in the figure.The friction angle between the crushed zone and intact rock φ’is the largest for the granite and marble,and can reach 70°–90°.Referring to the θ results of the different rocks in Table 3,the relationship between θ and φ’is established in Fig.9b.The correlated trend of φ’drops gently and then stabilizes with increasing θ.The description of themidependence on θ is drawn in Fig.9c.The constantmiversus θ has a linear trend with a slope of 1.02 and an intercept of -32.1.The fitting correlation coefficient is 0.97,indicating a strong dependence ofmion the contact angle θ.The constantmiis obtained as 18.3,8.7,11.2,22.1,8.0 and 23.7 at the corresponding θ values of 48.5°,37.8°,42.3°,51.1°,39.9° and 53.8° for the granite,shale,slate,marble,limestone and diorite,respectively.In addition,the rock-bit contact angle θ is closely affected by the shape and material of the drilling bit [59].Therefore,when using drilling parameters to determine the constantmi,the relevant indicators of the drill bit should also be considered.

Table 3Predicted strength and drilling data of different rocks with DPMA approach.

Fig.7.Comparison of the failure envelopes of the M-C criterion and H-B criterion based on the drilling method and laboratory method.

Fig.8.Predicted value and measured value of the mechanical properties mi,φ and c of different rocks.
The constantmialso has a fracture mechanics-based solution[25],including the ratio of theUCSandTS(tensile strength) andthe coefficient ratio μ/β.To evaluate the drilling parameter-basedmisolution,the fracture mechanics-based solution and the confined strength information from Hoek and Brown [20] are introduced.AdditionalTSmeasurements are made for the 6 rock types (with the ISRM test method [46]) to solve the constantmibased on fracture mechanics.In the fracture mechanics solution,the coefficient β is denoted as(1-v/2)κ,where v is Poisson’s ratio,and κ is the proportion factor of the mixed fracture criterion.According to the maximum energy release rate criterion,the value of κ is 1.0.Referring to the research of Paterson and Wong[11],the friction coefficient μ has a constant range from 0.2 to 0.8,which is related to the rock brittleness [58].Following the definition proposed by Zuo et al.[25],the friction coefficient μ is the ratio of the shear stress and normal stress acting on the pre-existing crack surface,which is equal to the tan φ’value in Eq.(7).Therefore,the friction coefficient μ is calculated as 0.65,0.37,0.56,0.67,0.46,and 0.78 for granite,shale,slate,marble,limestone and diorite,respectively.As shown in Table 1,the Poisson’s ratio of different rocks is substituted into (1-v/2)κ to calculate the coefficient β,and the coefficient ratio μ/β values are determined to be 0.38,0.51,0.69,0.47,and 0.76 for the sandstone,granite,limestone,shale,diorite and marble,respectively.A comparison of the relationship between theUCS/TSratio and constantmifor different rocks from different methods is presented in Fig.10.There is a 9.5%difference between the two solutions for different rocks.The fitted slope of the relationship between the constantmiand the strength ratio is 0.81,which is close to the fixed value of 0.7.Themivalues for the granite,shale,slate,marble,diorite,and limestone are calculated to be 17.48,9.28,11.24,22.1,8.61,and 23.6,respectively.The drilling-basedmivalues for the limestone,shale and marble are less than the fracture mechanics solutions.For strong rock such as granite and diorite,the fracture mechanics solution ofmiis greater than the drilling parameter solution ofmi.Due to the different fracture modes of different rocks,the method proposed by Zuo et al.[25] tends to give reasonable values for rocks with typical brittle fracture characteristics.In particular,for slate,miis equal to 11.2 with both methods.Compared to the fracture mechanics method,the drilling method overestimates theUCS/TSratio.The M-C criterion is adopted in the drilling parameter-based determination ofUCS,which implies that compression failure rather than tensile failure,mainly arises during drilling.This result confirms that the proposed method has an efficient coverage area for measuring the appropriatemivalue of a rock mass.

Table 4Functions and fitting coefficients R2 of two strength envelopes based on the M-C criterion and H-B criterion for different rocks.

Fig.9.Relationship between different drilling parameters to determine the constant mi.

Fig.10.Relationship between the ratio σc/σt and constant mi of different rocks and comparison with the results of the proposed method.
To further verify the benefits of the drilling determination ofTCS,15 rock types (common rock types) from different studies are cited for comparison.In Fig.9d,the relationship between the constantmiin the H-B criterion and the rock friction angle φ is expressed as a linear fitting correlation.On this basis,the constantmiis calculated by substituting the corresponding φ into the fitting function.Then,the friction angle φ is substituted into Eqs.(22)and(23) to calculate the drilling angle variables φ’,α,and θ.The constantmiand the drilling angle variables are substituted into Eq.(28) to calculate the rockTCSunder different confining pressures σ3.The calculation results ofTCSand constantmifor the cited rocks are listed in Table 5.The predictedTCSfitting line is introduced to compare to theTCSenvelope under different confining pressures,as shown in Fig.11.A summary of the rock strength range using the revised H-B criterion and its indictors is listed in Table 5.TheTCSrange for different rock types is 134 to 275 MPa.The correlation coefficientsR2of the cited rock information are greater than 0.90,indicating the accurately of theTCSprediction from the proposed model based on using drilling parameters.The potential correlation between the rockTCSand constantmiin the H-B criterion is considered to be positive.

Table 5Summary of the rock strength range using the revised H-B criterion.
The predictedmiis also compared with themiobtained by the fitting method for different rock types in Fig.12.The comparison suggests that the predictedmiranges from 3.5 to 52.7 with an error below 15% in Fig.12.The predictedmivalues of the Vosges sandstone of Besuelle et al.[60],Doddington sandstone of Santarelli and Brown[64],sandstone of Yang et al.[61],coal measures sandstone of Farmer [66],Gosford sandstone of Ayling et al.[68],and Adamswiller sandstone of Wong et al.[62] are 23.9,17.2,47.6,28.1,40.8 and 12.7.The difference between the maximum and minimum values is almost 35,which exceeds the traditional range of the constantmi.In Yang’s research [61],the failure mode of red sandstone is quite different from that of regular sandstone.Shear fractures with local tension cracks appear under high confining pressures and show strong brittle characteristics.Thus,the necessity of a field test to determine the constantmivalue is confirmed again.
A reliable definition of the constantmiin the H-B criterion is an emerging research focus of rock mechanics.Whether the constantmiis defined by mechanical derivation or field measurement,it is difficult to balance the speed and accuracy of such work.Based on the drilling parameters,the proposed definition can take into account on-site measurement and failure criteria.Nevertheless,several shortcomings in this study must be emphasized.The differences in the shape and material of the drill bit necessitate the establishment of different force balance models.The response of more rock properties to drilling methods should also be investigated.It is not clear that the drilling parameters are related to the critical point in the drilling process.As the depth increases,the velocity of conventional logging and drilling in hard rock decreases quickly.The established analytical model can be explained from the perspective of the drilling analysis.The continuous accumulation of cutting debris and rock powder gradually fills the gap between the drill bit and the rock,resulting in a sharp increase in friction.The influence of in situ stress at depth expansion also hinders drilling efficiency.Thus,torque must increase with increasing depth to provide a sufficient cutting force for stable and efficient drilling.However,as the torque reaches the motor power limit,the continued increase in the drill cuttings eventually stops the drilling operation.The core of solving this practical problem is to determine the critical point between cutting and compression and clean up drill cuttings in time to reduce the loss of drilling efficiency.The model proposed in this paper provides a theoretical method of drilling analysis to improve efficiency.

Fig.11.Prediction of different rock TCSs obtained with the proposed model.

Fig.12.Comparison of constant mi values from the proposed method with the value obtained by the fitting method.
6.Conclusions
In this paper,the proposed models based on drilling parameters are established to obtain the mechanical properties of rock through the H-B failure criterion.Some conclusions are summarized as follows:
(1) A theoretical solution of the constantmibased on drilling parameters is derived to substitute into the H-B failure criterion.Then,the proposed model is established to calculate the rockTCS,cand φ.The indicatorsin the H-B criterion is taken as 1.0,which is associated with intact rock.The envelope intercept of the friction and cutting stages is a function ofmi,and the envelope function includes 3 drilling variables θ,φ’,and α.After some mathematical derivation,the drilling variable involved in the function is θ.
(2) Drilling tests on granite,shale,slate,marble,limestone and diorite are carried out to measure the drilling parameters for themicalculation.When the contact friction angle θ reaches its maximum value,micorrespondingly remains stable.The laboratory-measuredc,φ,TCSandUCSof rocks are obtained in the laboratory to perform a comparison between the values predicted with drilling data and values measured in the laboratory.The results suggest that the predicted values have a 20%maximum error compared with the measured value.
(3) The mechanical parameters obtained by the drilling method are smaller than those obtained by the laboratory method.This difference of mechanical parameters is affected by the variable drilling parameters,which are closely related to the joints,structural planes and defect disturbance in the drilling test site.The fracture mechanics definition of constantmiis introduced to examine the advantages of the drilling method.A comparison is also conducted,and the advantage of the proposed method is confirmed.
(4) Public information on 15 types of rocks is cited to verify the prediction accuracy of the proposed method.The prediction error for these data is within 10%,suggesting that good predictions are provided by the drilling method.In summary,the multifaceted assessment of this method supports its scientific value in field applications,and the drilling definition of the constantmiis proven to be effective.
Acknowledgements
This study is sponsored by the National Natural Science Foundation of China(Nos.42177158,11902249 and 11872301),Natural Science Foundation of Shaanxi Province (Shaanxi Province Natural Science Foundation) (No.2019JQ395) and Education Bureau of Shaanxi Province|Scientific Research Plan Projects of Shaanxi Education Department in China (No.20JS093).The financial support provided by this sponsor is greatly appreciated.The authors would like to thank Prof.Fengqiang Gong,Prof.Qi Wang and Dr.Hongke Gao for their help and suggestions in preparing the manuscript.
杂志排行
矿业科学技术学报的其它文章
- Effect of deep oxidation of chalcopyrite on surface properties and flotation performance
- Adsorption behavior and mechanism of copper ions in the sulfidization flotation of malachite
- Insights into the adsorption performance and mechanism of hydrated Ca ion on talc (001) basal surface from DFT calculation
- Effect of bastnaesite as reductant on hematite reduction during in-situ suspension magnetization roasting of refractory iron ore under neutral atmosphere
- Application of multi-stage dynamic magnetizing roasting technology on the utilization of cryptocrystalline oolitic hematite: A review
- A review of flotation and selective separation of pyrrhotite:A perspective from crystal structures
