Distribution of 137Cs and 60Co in plough layer of farmland:Evidenced from a lysimeter experiment using undisturbed soil columns
2021-03-17WenxiangLIUYongLIHanqingYUSurinderSAGGARDaozhiGONGandQiongZHANG
Wenxiang LIUYong LI∗Hanqing YUSurinder SAGGARDaozhi GONG and Qiong ZHANG
1Institute of Environment and Sustainable Development in Agriculture,Chinese Academy of Agricultural Sciences,Beijing 100081(China)
2Guangxi University,Nanning 530005(China)
3Manaaki Whenua-Landcare Research,Private Bag 11052,Palmerston North 4442(New Zealand)
4Nuclear and Radiation Safety Center,Ministry of Environmental Protection of China,Beijing 100082(China)
(Received September 4,2019;revised September 16,2020)
ABSTRACT Radionuclide fallout during nuclear accidents on the land may impair the atmosphere,contaminate farmland soils and crops,and can even reach the groundwater.Previous research focused on the field distribution of deposited radionuclides in farmland soils,but details of the amounts of radionuclides in the plough layer and the changes in their proportional distribution in the soil profile with time are still inadequate.In this study,a lysimeter experiment was conducted to determine the vertical migration of 137Cs and 60Co in brown and aeolian sandy soils,collected from the farmlands adjoining Shidaowan Nuclear Power Plant(NPP)in eastern China,and to identify the factors influencing their migration depths in soil.At the end of the experiment(800 d),>96% of added 137Cs and 60Co were retained in the top 0-20 cm soil layer of both soils;very little 137Cs or 60Co initially migrated to 20-30 cm,but their amounts at this depth increased with time.The migration depth of 137Cs was greater in the aeolian sandy soil than in the brown soil during 0-577 d,but at the end of the experiment,137Cs migrated to the same depth(25 cm)in both soils.Three phases on the vertical migration rate(v)of 60Co in the aeolian sandy soil can be identified:an initial rapid movement(0-355 d,v=219±17 mm year−1),followed by a steady movement(355-577 d,v=150±24 mm year−1)and a very slow movement(577-800 d,v=107±7 mm year−1).In contrast,its migration rate in the brown soil(v=133±17 mm year−1)was steady throughout the 800-d experimental period.The migration of both 137Cs and 60Co in the two soils appears to be regulated by soil clay and silt fractions that provide most of the soil surface area,soil organic carbon(SOC),and soil pH,which were manifested by the solid-liquid distribution coefficient of 137Cs and 60Co.The results of this study suggest that most 137Cs and 60Co remained within the top layer(0-20 cm depth)of farmland soils following a simulated NPP accident,and little reached the subsurface(20-30 cm depth).Fixation of radionuclides onto clay minerals may limit their migration in soil,but some could be laterally distributed by soil erosion and taken up by crops,and migrate into groundwater in a high water table level area after several decades.Remediation measures,therefore,should focus on reducing their impact on the farmland soils,crops,and water.
Key Words:aeolian sandy soil,brown soil,deposited radionuclide,migration depth,radionuclide,vertical migration rate
INTRODUCTION
Nuclear power is considered to be a reliable energy supply for economic development in many countries including China,where many nuclear power plants(NPPs)have been constructed in the coastal areas such as Qinshan,Dayawan,and Shidaowan.However,in the event of a NPP leakage or accident(such as Chernobyl and Fukushima nuclear accidents),large amounts of radionuclides(e.g.,137Cs and60Co)are released into the atmosphere(Hirose,2016)and deposited,and then contaminate the surface soil(Vahabi-Moghaddam and Khoshbinfar,2012).Most of the fallout radionuclides are adsorbed by clay minerals,and some could be taken up by plants from the contaminated soil and subsequently join the food chain(Shanthiet al.,2012;Teramageet al.,2014),causing radioactive contamination of food.The remaining radionuclides may migrate into the groundwater,leading to water pollution(Gupta and Walther,2014;Fujimuraet al.,2015).After the Chernobyl and Fukushima nuclear accidents,emergency decontamination practices,including clearing trees and litter(López-Vicenteet al.,2018)and applying wood chips(Cresswellet al.,2016),were used to reduce radioactive contamination.However,residual radionuclides still have an impact on agricultural soils and groundwater,and it is necessary to determine the migration dynamics of radionuclides in farmland soil and to develop decontamination strategies.
Currently,numerous studies on the migration of radionuclides in soils have already been conducted after various nuclear weapon tests and nuclear accidents(Jagercikovaet al.,2015).A soil survey in the Mediterranean region shows that deposited137Cs was mainly concentrated at the top 12 cm depth of uncultivated sloping lands and at a depth of 0-2 cm in forest soil,but its migration can even go deeper in some soils(Gaspar and Navas,2013;Guillénet al.,2015).Some studies have shown that twenty years after the Chernobyl nuclear accident,the137Cs migrated into the soil to a depth of 25.5 cm,and in some locations up to a depth of 60 cm(Bondarkovet al.,2011).In another experiment,14 and 26 years after the Chernobyl nuclear accident,deposited137Cs in grassland soil was mainly contained in the surface layer(at depths of 4 and 5 cm)(Bossewet al.,2004;Karadenizet al.,2015).Similar migration studies were also conducted in soil after the Fukushima nuclear accident.It was found that two years after the Fukushima nuclear accident,70% of the137Cs was contained in the top 50 cm layer in forest and grassland soils,but it migrated to the subsurface layer(5-10 cm depth)in paddy soils(Takahashiet al.,2015).Research also showed that at 108,320,536,and 641 d after the Fukushima nuclear accident,137Cs in farmland migrated to soil depths of 1.8,3.0,3.8,and 4.5 cm,respectively(Shiozawa,2013).There have been few studies examining the migration of60Co in agricultural soils.A 9-year lysimeter experiment in Austria showed that the vertical migration depth of60Co reached a soil depth of 25 cm(Shinonagaet al.,2005).Another study,conducted on the Chinese Loess Plateau(Liet al.,2003),reported that most60Co migrated to a soil depth of 14 cm under natural conditions after two years of field investigation.However,previous studies lacked detailed information on the proportional distribution of radionuclides in farmland due to the sampling methodology.To obtain specific and accurate characteristics of radionuclide migration,more detailed sampling is essential.
Generally,fallout radionuclides can bind to solid surfaces by a number of processes that are often classified under the broad term of sorption.The degree of radionuclide sorption on the solid phase is often quantified using the solid-liquid distribution coefficient(Kd).The greater theKdvalue is,the stronger adsorption capacity the soil has,with lower migration of radionuclide(Kamei-Ishikawaet al.,2008;Mishraet al.,2015).Soil properties such as particle size and soil organic carbon(SOC)content have different impacts on the migration rate of radionuclides(Navaset al.,2002;IAEA,2010;Dragović.,2012;Sucharaet al.,2016).Fine soil particles allow a faster adsorption rate of radionuclides(Koarashiet al.,2012).Hossainet al.(2012)also found that the migration of137Cs and60Co in soil with particle sizes≤90µm was slower than that in relatively coarse textured soil(90-2 000µm).In most soil types,137Cs is more readily adhered by clay minerals than by large particle minerals due to highly selective reversible adsorption and immobilization processes(Tsukadaet al.,2008;Konoplevet al.,2018).Additionally,soil organic matter may play a key role in accelerating the137Cs fixation process(Dumatet al.,1997;Forkapicet al.,2017).Many studies have found that SOC and137Cs have a close relationship,because organic matter is the primary and preferential sorbent of137Cs(Chibowski and Zygmunt,2002;Stauntonet al.,2002;Teramageet al.,2013,2016).Wauterset al.(1994)reported that humic acid has a positive effect on radionuclide fixation in soils.Hence,it is important to analyze the effects of soil properties on migration of radionuclides in different soils.
From a review of studies on migration of radionuclides described above,it is evident that these studies were focused on the distribution of deposited radionuclides in soils by field investigation after nuclear accidents(Mishraet al.,2015;Dowdallet al.,2017),and on calculating migration parameters using either analytical or numerical solutions(Bunzlet al.,2000;Bossew and Kirchner,2004).However,details regarding the amounts of radionuclides at different layers of farmland soils were lacking,and it was not possible to quantitatively determine the changes in the proportional distribution of radionuclides in the soil profile with time.In this study,we monitored the detailed vertical distributions of137Cs and60Co in soil profiles using a scraper plate in two types of farmland soils(brown and aeolian sandy soils).Our objectives were i)to determine the temporal changes of137Cs and60Co concentrations in the two farmland soils using a lysimeter experiment with undisturbed soil columns,ii)to determine the vertical migration depths of137Cs and60Co in the test soils,and iii)to identify the effects of soil properties on the migration of137Cs and60Co in the two soils.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Study site
The study site is located near the Shidaowan NPP in Rongcheng County(36°41′46′′-37°35′14′′N,121°43′33′′-122°36′2′′E),Shandong Province,eastern China(Fig.1).The terrain of the study area is tilted from northwest to southeast with an average elevation of 25 m.The region has a warm temperate climate.The annual average temperature is 12°C and the region receives approximately 2 600 h of sunshine annually.The average annual rainfall is 800 mm.The major soil types are aeolian sandy and brown soils,distributed within the ranges of 0-10 and 10-40 km away from the NPP,respectively.Two sampling sites were selected representing the two soils with altitudes of 9 and 68 m,respectively.These sites have grown wheat(Triticum aestivumL.)and maize(Zea maysL.)for several decades.The soil was plowed to a depth of 25 cm and then tilled twice to a depth of 10 cm using a rotary cultivator after the maize harvest.
Collection of undisturbed soil columns and background soil samples

Fig.1 Sketch map of the study site near the Shidaowan Nuclear Power Plant(NPP)in Rongcheng County,Shandong Province,eastern China.Selected sampling sites represent two soil types,brown and aeolian sandy soils.
A lysimeter experiment was established for farmland soils using a plexiglass column.Eight undisturbed soil columns were collected from the typical aeolian sandy soil and brown soil at 9 and 30 km away from NPP,respectively.Plexiglass columns(320 mm in diameter,1 000 mm in length,which can reduce wall effect on water and solute transport),with a sharp ring in the bottom of each column,were used(Fig.S1,see Supplementary Material for Fig.S1).These columns were pressed downwards into the soil to a depth of 30 cm by hammering.Then soil outside the columns was excavated from a circular pit(400 mm in inside diameter,1 000 mm in outside diameter)around the columns to reduce soil compaction during collection.Afterwards,the soil around the columns was scrapped.Columns were then further driven into the soil with repeating hammering,excavation,and scrapping steps each time.Finally,undisturbed soil columns were collected to a depth of 70 cm.The soils(0-70 cm depth)adjacent to the undisturbed soil column sampling points were collected at depth increments of 10 cm using a hand operated core sampler,which represent background soils.Three cores were collected at each 10-cm soil layer.A total of 21 samples(3 cores×7 depths)were obtained for each soil type.The background soil was analyzed for the radionuclide concentrations and soil properties.The sampling points selected for undisturbed soil columns were far away from roads and trees to reduce the spatial singularity of soil characteristics.Soil columns and background soil collection were conducted from March 24,2014 to April 2,2014.
Setup of lysimeter experiment
The lysimeter experiment was conducted in soil columns after137CsCl and60CoCl2solutions(pH=5)were spread onto the soil surface through a pulse for a onetime uniform injection(Fig.S2,see Supplementary Material for Fig.S2).The total amount of added137Cs(half-life 30.2 year)and60Co(half-life 5.3 year)in each column was 300 and 500 Bq,respectively.Tracer solutions of137Cs and60Co were produced by the China Atomic Energy Research Institute.The experiment was carried out in a laboratory-simulated environment that was consistent with the local meteorological conditions,including rainfall based on a 10-year average level(800 mm per year,Fig.S3,see Supplementary Material for Fig.S3)and solar radiation(7 h of irradiation by high pressure sodium lamp).To maintain soil properties and avoid bacterial growth,the outer wall of soil columns was shaded with black plastic sheeting.In order to study the temporal changes in the vertical distribution of137Cs and60Co in soils,the lysimeter experiment was carried out between February 2015 and April 2017(a duration of 800 d)and four observations were conducted at 175,355,577,and 800 d of the experimental period.
Scraper sampling for measurement of migrated radionuclides
To accurately track the vertical migration of radionuclides,a special scraper tool with a sampling area of 706 cm2(300 mm in diameter)was used to obtain large sample volumes at small depth increments(Takahashiet al.,2015).The device used in this study has two components:a metal concentric circular frame placed in the soil column,and an adjustable metal scraper that can scrape or remove soil at fixed depth increments within the frame.Samples were taken at 2 mm increments for soil depths of 0-20 cm and at 5 cm increments for soil depths of 20-70 cm.In order to avoid contamination from the surface soil,which can fall down from the wall of the sampling hole,spray glue was used to fix the wall(Katoet al.,2012).Soil sampling was undertaken four times over the 800-d period(on 175,355,577,and 800 d)for both brown and aeolian sandy soils.Two undisturbed soil columns,as replicates for each soil type,were scraped at each sampling time to obtain137Cs and60Co soil samples.During the experimental period,the leachate samples from the columns were collected after every simulated irrigation.All leachate samples were used for radionuclide measurements.
Laboratory analysis of soil samples
All soil samples were air-dried and sieved through a 2-mm sieve.The concentrations of137Cs and60Co in the soil samples and leachate samples were detected using a broadenergy high-purity germanium detector(Canberra BE5030,Mirion Technologies,USA)with a high relative detection efficiency(50.9%).The detection system uses a Canberra 747E lead chamber with a 100-mm wall thickness,and the concentrations of137Cs and60Co were analyzed using a DSA 1000 digitizer and Genie 2000 spectroscopic analysis software.The range of measurable gamma ray energy is 3 keV to 3 MeV and the energy peaks of137Cs and60Co were 661.6 and 1 332.5 keV,respectively.Calibration and quality control of the gamma spectrometer were performed following the protocol of Shakhashiro and Mabit(2009).The spectra were accumulated for 30 000-40 000 s,sufficient to provide an analytical precision of±10% for137Cs and60Co.The analytical laboratory(CAAS-ALMERA Laboratory,Beijing,China)had achieved a high score in a radionuclide determination proficiency test organized by the International Atomic Energy Agency(IAEA)in 2006(Liet al.,2011).
Soil particle fractions were determined using a laser particle size analyzer(Chappell,1998).Soil pH was determined at a soil:water ratio of 1:2.5(weight:weight)using a pH meter(Pageet al.,1982).Soil organic matter was determined using the potassium permanganate volumetric method(Dane and Topp,2002).
TheKdof radionuclides in soil was determined using the static batch method(Relyea,1982).The soil sample collected from the background soil was transferred into a test tube and centrifuged at 3 000 r min−1after the addition of local groundwater,and the supernatant was discarded.After being repeated three times,the washing residual liquid weight was recorded as wet soil weight minus dry soil weight.The soil and added tracer solution(1:10,weight:weight)were fully mixed using a constant temperature oscillator with a 72 h equilibrium time at 25°C(Kamei-Ishikawaet al.,2008).After centrifugation,the supernatant was collected for measurement of radionuclides.TheKd(mL g−1)of radionuclides can be expressed as:

whereVis the tracer volume(mL),Wis the solid sample weight(g),Bis the original solution specific activity(Bq mL−1),Eis the specific activity of the supernatant in the sample tube(Bq mL−1),andXis the volume of the solution remaining in soil(mL).
The concentrations of added60Co and137Cs in the soil profiles were calculated using the total concentrations of the radionuclides minus the background values.The soil depth was defined as the migration depth of radionuclide when the mean concentration was more than 2σ(twice the standard deviation of the measured values)at the aforementioned depth.The migration rates of137Cs and60Co in soil were calculated by their migration depth divided by the observation time.
Statistical analysis
The distributions curves of added radionuclides in the soil profiles were fitted using exponential model with SigmaPlot 12.5.The differences in the soil properties andKdvalues between the different soils were determined using a one-way analysis of variance with SPSS 19.0 statistical software.
RESULTS
Background concentrations of 137Cs and 60Co in soil profiles
The concentrations of background137Cs in two soil types are shown in Fig.2.The maximum concentrations of background137Cs in the brown and aeolian sandy soils were 2.5±0.2 and 1.6±0.1 Bq kg−1,respectively.Background137Cs was present mainly in the surface soil(0-30 cm depth)and decreased with increasing soil depth.The mean total background137Cs was 124 Bq in the lysimeters containing the brown soil and 67 Bq in the lysimeters containing the aeolian sandy soil.No background60Co was detected in either of these two soils.

Fig.2 Background concentrations of 137Cs in the brown soil(BS)and aeolian sandy soil(SS).Horizontal bars indicate standard errors of the means(n=3).
Dynamic changes of 137Cs and 60Co concentrations in soil profiles
The concentrations of137Cs and60Co during the experimental period were the highest in the surface layer(0-2 mm soil depth),exceeding 100 Bq kg−1in both the brown and aeolian sandy soils(Figs.3 and 4).The amounts of137Cs and60Co in the soil profiles decreased with increasing soil depth,while the concentrations of137Cs and60Co in deep depth increased with time.With the exception of the surface layer(0-2 mm),the concentrations of137Cs and60Co at other depths of the aeolian sandy soil were higher than those of the brown soil.No137Cs or60Co was detected in the leachate samples from both soils during the 800-d period of this experiment.
Periodic migration depth of added 137Cs and 60Co in soils profiles

Fig.3 Dynamic migration of the added 137Cs in the profiles of brown(BS)and aeolian sandy soils(SS).Each value represents the mean of 137Cs concentration in two undisturbed soil columns.

Fig.4 Dynamic migration of the added 60Co in the profiles of brown(BS)and aeolian sandy soils(SS).Each value represents the mean of 60Co concentration in two undisturbed soil columns.
The migration depth of137Cs in both soils during the experimental period increased from 5.2 to 25 cm from 175 to 800 d(Fig.5).In the aeolian sandy soil,it migrated 10%-46%deeper than in the brown soil during 0-577 d,but reached the same depth(25 cm)at 800 d in both soils.The proportion of137Cs to the total input decreased with increasing time,from 95% to 80% in the brown soil and from 97% to 88% in the aeolian sandy soil at 0-10 cm soil depth.Only<2% of137Cs migrated to 20-30 cm depth in both soils at the end of the experiment(Table I).

Fig.5 Variations in migration depths of 137Cs and 60Co added in the brown(BS)and aeolian sandy soils(SS)during the 800-d experimental period.Vertical bars indicate standard errors of the means(n=2).

TABLE IProportion of 137Cs and 60Co to total input at 0-30 cm depth of brown and aeolian soils measured periodically during the 800-d experimental period
The migration depth of60Co in soil changed from 8.1 to 30 cm from 175 to 800 d.The migration change of60Co in the aeolian sandy soil occurred in three phases:an initial rapid movement(0-355 d),followed by a steady movement(355-577 d)and a very little movement(577-800 d).The migration rate of60Co in the brown soil was steady throughout the 800-d experimental period.At the end of experiment(800 d),the amounts of60Co in the brown and aeolian sandy soil surface(0-10 cm)were 80.67%±2.31% and 88.67%±0.60%,respectively(Table I).Similarly,the proportion of60Co to the total input decreased with increasing time,from 97% to 81% in the brown soil and from 99% to 89% in the aeolian sandy soil at 0-10 cm soil depth.About 3% of60Co migrated to 20-30 cm depth in both soils at the end of the experiment.
Potential impact of soil properties on migration of 137Cs and 60Co in soil profiles
Both soils had similar bulk density and textures(low clay(2%-5%)and sand(13%-15%)and high silt(80%-83%))(Table II).The SOC was between 3.9 to 12.1 g C kg−1in the brown soil and 0.3 to 11.0 g C kg−1in the aeolian sandy soil.The brown soil was more acidic(pH=4.90-6.49)than the aeolian sandy soil(pH=5.88-7.54).The electrical conductivity(EC)significantly(P<0.05)decreased with depth for both soils and the EC of the brown soil was higher than that of the aeolian sandy soil.TheKdvalue of137Cs was much higher than that of60Co(Table III).There was no significant difference inKdwithin 0-30 cm soil depth for the two soils,whileKddecreased significantly(P<0.05)with depth below 30 cm soil depth,with the exception of theKdof137Cs at 50-60 cm soil depth.
DISCUSSION
Migration depths of 137Cs and 60Co in farmland soils
Our results showed that the maximum migration depths of137Cs and60Co were no greater than the plough layer(25-30 cm),and that137Cs and60Co were mostly constrained in the surface(0-10 cm)of the brown and aeolian sandy soils at the end of the experiment(800 d)(Table I).Takahashiet al.(2015)reported that the migration depth of137Cs in the agricultural soil with high bulk density increased with time and varied from 1.8 cm at 108 d to 4.5 cm at 641 d after the Fukushima nuclear accident.Equally,137Cs in the cultivated red soils of Poland and Sweden migrated to a soil depth of 25.5 cm twenty years after the Chernobyl nuclear accident(Bondarkovet al.,2011).The variation in migration depth observed in our study was consistent with previous studies,which found that the high activity concentration of137Cs was constrained in the surface soil layer of farmland near Fukushima power plant(Nakano and Yong,2013;Shiozawa,2013).The limited studies on the migration of60Co in agricultural soils found that the vertical migration of60Co was concentrated in the top soil layer(0-20 cm)and only about 3% of the added60Co or less reached the deeper soil layers(20-25 cm)after nine yearsof lysimeter experiment(Shinonagaet al.,2005).Another study on the Chinese Loess Plateau(Liet al.,2003)reported that most of the60Co was retained in the surface loess,while little of the60Co had migrated to 10 cm depth in the loess under natural conditions after two years of field investigation.The migration depth of60Co in our study was consistent with these studies,in that little60Co reached deeper soil layers(20-30 cm).

TABLE IIPhysicochemical propertiesa)at different depths of of brown and aeolian sandy soils

TABLE IIISolid-liquid distribution coefficient(Kd)of 137Cs and 60Co at different depths of brown and aeolian sandy soils
The variation in the migration depths of137Cs and60Co observed in different studies is closely related to soil types,experimental methods,and meteorological conditions(Liet al.,2003;Shinonagaet al.,2005;Bondarkovet al.,2011;Nakano and Yong,2013;Shiozawa,2013;Takahashiet al.,2015).The migration rates(v)of137Cs and60Co(v=107-133 mm year−1)in our study were higher than in farmland and paddy field near the Fukushima Dai-ichi Nuclear Power Plant(FDNPP)(v=40-50 mm year−1),due to the lower clay content in our test soils than in the agricultural soil near the FDNPP(Takahashiet al.,2015).In addition,unlike the field investigation near the FDNPP,our lysimeter experiment was conducted in the laboratory under simulated weather conditions,which resulted in a higher migration rate in our study and avoided extreme climate events to disturb experiment conduction.Different meteorological conditions can also cause different migration rates of radionuclides in soils.For example,high evapotranspiration(1 830 mm per year)and low rainfall(390 mm per year)in the loess of North China(Liet al.,2003)can result in upward transportation of137Cs and60Co(Shinonagaet al.,2005).
Direct and indirect influencing factors on migration of 137Cs and 60Co in farmland soils
Our results showed that137Cs and60Co in the aeolian sandy soil migrated faster than in the brown soil prior to 577 d at 0-20 cm soil depth.However,the migration rates of137Cs and60Co were slower in the aeolian sandy soil than in the brown soil at the end of the experiment at 20-30 cm soil depth(Fig.5).Soil properties,including soil particle size fractions,SOC,pH,andKd,have direct impacts on the vertical distribution of radionuclides in soil(IAEA,2010;Sucharaet al.,2016).To assess the effect of soil properties on the migration of radionuclides in the two soils,the ratios of clay+silt fraction,SOC,pH,Kd,and radionuclide migration depth(D)in the aeolian sandy soil to those in the brown soil were used as indicators(Fig.6).The ratios ofDfor137Cs and60Co prior to 577 d of the experimental period(at 0-20 cm soil depth)were larger than 1,and they decreased(<1)with time between 577 and 800 d of the experimental period(at 20-30 cm soil depth).Radionuclides can adhere more readily to fine fractions(clay and silt)of soils,due to the larger surface area that results in highly selective reversible adsorption and immobilization processes(Tsukadaet al.,2008;Koarashiet al.,2012;Konoplevet al.,2018).In addition,soil organic matter,particularly simple low-molecular-weight organic acids and fulvic and humic acids,contains functional groups that can form complexes with radionuclides in the soil profiles(Dragovićet al.,2012),and can therefore affect the vertical distribution of radionuclides in soils(Koarashiet al.,2012).Soil particle size fraction can also reflect the magnitude of saturated and non-saturated hydraulic conductivity(Pachepsky and Park,2015).It has been reported that saturated hydraulic conductivity is negatively correlated with soil clay content,but positively correlated with137Cs specific activity in soil(Dragovićet al.,2012).Our results were consistent with these findings,which showed that the137Cs and60Co in soil solution were observed to penetrate faster in the aeolian sandy soil than in the brown soil at 0-20 cm soil depth,due to the lower silt and SOC contents in the aeolian sandy soil.Similarly,the radionuclides infiltrated faster at 20-30 cm depth in the brown soil than in the aeolian sandy soil due to higher silt and SOC contents in the aeolian sandy soil.
The ratio of pH also increased with time and was larger than 1 after 577 d of the experimental period(Fig.6),suggesting that the pH at 20-30 cm depth in the aeolian sandy soil was higher than in the brown soil and that more137Cs and60Co became immobile.This is because the higher pH in the test soil will regulate the affinity and activity of radionuclides by increasing the amount of negative charge on the surface edges of the clay for variable-charged clay types(Van Der Graafet al.,2007;Sucharaet al.,2016),which results in competitive adsorption by clay minerals between radionuclides and ions.This is also supported by the ratios ofKdfor137Cs and60Co,which increased with time during the experimental period,indicating that more137Cs and60Co were absorbed at 20-30 cm depth in the aeolian sandy soil than in the brown soil.That means137Cs and60Co migrated faster in the brown soil than in the aeolian sandy soil after 577 d of the experiment(at 20-30 cm soil depth).
Additionally,agricultural management practices,such as tillage and fertilization,affect soil properties(Šimanskýet al.,2019);therefore these practices have indirect impacts on the migration of137Cs and60Co in farmland soils.Tillage has an impact on the ability of the soil to adsorb and retain water and solute,and it depends on the level of soil disturbance(Alvarez and Steinbach,2009;Blanco-Canquiet al.,2017).Tillage can increase water infiltration by disrupting compacted layers and loosening soil bulk density,relative to no-till management(Salemet al.,2015).It may also cause the redistribution of deposited radionuclides in farmland soil after a NPP accident,due to soil mixing by plowing(Takahashiet al.,2015).Fertilization can increase straw residue and root biomass input into soil systems,eventually causing an increase in the SOC content and soil aggregation(Tianet al.,2015).In our study,with a long-term history of growing wheat and maize,soil properties were homogenous in the plough layer due to the mixture by frequent and intensive agricultural management practices.Long-term tillage and fertilization on the agricultural soils resulted in uniform soil properties and lead to similar migration rates of radionuclides in the soil plough layers.

Fig.6 Ratios of soil organic carbon(SOC),clay+silt fraction,pH,and solid-liquid distribution coefficient(Kd)and migration depth(D)of 137Cs and 60Co in the aeolian sandy soil to those in the brown soil during the 800-d experimental period.
Implication of released 137Cs and 60Co on surface water,plants and groundwater
The results of this study indicated that137Cs and60Co was predominantly bound to fine particles in the top layer(0-10 cm)of farmland soil(Figs.3 and 4).After fixation in the surface soil,heavy rainfall-and flood event-induced water erosion would transfer radionuclides to low-lying areas through lateral redistribution(Lepageet al.,2016),and radionuclides can subsequently migrate to the surface water system(Yoshimuraet al.,2015).In addition,during strong wind events,significant volumes of contaminated sediments can be transported to downstream due to wind erosion(Evrardet al.,2013).
The released radionuclides not only impact surface water,but also pose a threat to farmland system.Our results suggested that137Cs and60Co were distributed across almost the entire plough layer of the farmland soil at the end of the experiment.The plough layer is rich in nutrients,and some of radionuclides may be absorbed by roots and accumulate in plants when the crop roots take up nutrients from the soil(Shanthiet al.,2012).Crops enriched in radionuclides can cause food contamination and endanger human health(Walther and Gupta,2015).Various crops with different absorptive capacities and transfer factors are often used for plant remediation.A study reported that the transfer factors of137Cs and60Co for wheat were 0.021-0.027 in stems and 0.009-0.012 in grains,and for maize were 0.041-0.066 in stems and 0.005-0.013 in grains(Gerzabeket al.,1998).Recently,Fujimuraet al.(2015)reported that the transfer factor of137Cs for rice was 0.011-0.031,which decreased with time.At our study site,it was found that more than 2% of deposited radionuclides could be enriched in wheat and maize when crops took up nutrients from contaminated soils,based on transfer factors of 0.009-0.021 and 0.005-0.041,respectively(Gerzabeket al.,1998).More than 4%of absorbed radionuclides can enter the food chain in the absence of remediation measures after a nuclear accident.
The results showed that only<4% of added137Cs and60Co migrated to 20-30 cm depth in both soils at 800 d.Moreover,no137Cs or60Co was detected in leachate samples,indicating that137Cs and60Co did not infiltrate into beyond 20-30 cm soil depth during the experimental period.However,the migration rates of137Cs and60Co in the two test soils were 107-134 and 140-170 mm year−1,respectively.Based on these migration rates,the137Cs and60Co released from a nuclear accident may be expected to migrate into the local groundwater(3 m level)after several decades.
Therefore,emergency measures must be taken after a nuclear accident to protect human health and environment safety.Removing the contaminated soil immediately from highly confined contaminated areas after a nuclear accident can effectively eliminate the impacts of radionuclides on soil,water,and human health.In addition,a combination of chemical remediation(ion exchange method and oxidationreduction method)and biological remediation(microbial remediation and phytoremediation)can be adopted under these circumstances at the same time.
CONCLUSIONS
This study showed that137Cs and60Co deposited on farmland soils from a simulated nuclear fallout remained within the plough layer(0-30 cm soil depth).After 800 d of experiment,80%-89% of both radionuclides were present in the top soil layer(0-10 cm depth)in both the brown and aeolian sandy soils;9%-16% migrated to 10-20 cm depth and only<2% of137Cs and about 3% of60Co migrated to 20-30 cm depth in both soils.Some of these radionuclides may subsequently migrate into the groundwater with high water table level after several decades.Among the soil properties studied,soil clay+silt fraction,SOC content,soil pH,andKdof the radionuclides were the major factors that influenced the migration of radionuclides in the study area.Hence,to mitigate the impacts of deposited radionuclides on farmland soils surrounding NPPs,agricultural management practices should be prohibited,and integrated measures must be urgently taken to protect human health and environment safety.
CONTRIBUTION OF AUTHORS
Dr.Wenxiang LIU and Mrs.Hanqing YU contributed equally to this work.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
We would like to thank the IAEA Project(No.18176)and the National Science and Technology Major Projects of China(No.2013ZX06002001)that supported this work.This work is part of the project supported by the National Key Research and Development Program of China(No.2017YFC0505402).
SUPPLEMENTARY MATERIAL
Supplementary material for this article can be found in the online version.
杂志排行
Pedosphere的其它文章
- Notes to Authors
- Agricultural and environmental challenges in agroecosystems
- In Commemoration of Professor Tianren YU’s 100th Anniversary
- Microbial diversity assembled from series-diluted suspensions of diseasesuppressive soil determines pathogen invasion resistance
- Global patterns of phosphorus transformation in relation to latitude,temperature and precipitation
- Chemical and spectroscopic characteristics of humic acid from a clay loam soil in Ontario after 52 years of consistent fertilization and crop rotation
