APP下载

Enhanced anaerobic degradation of hexachlorobenzene in a Hydragric Acrisol using humic acid and urea

2021-03-17CuiyingLIUJianlingFANXianghuaXUandYuWU

Pedosphere 2021年1期

Cuiying LIU∗Jianling FANXianghua XU and Yu WU

1Jiangsu Key Laboratory of Agricultural Meteorology,School of Applied Meteorology,Nanjing University of Information Science and Technology,Nanjing 210044(China)

2Key Laboratory of Soil Environment and Pollution Remediation,Institute of Soil Science,Chinese Academy of Sciences,Nanjing 210008(China)

3Jiangsu Key Laboratory of Atmospheric Environment Monitoring and Pollution Control,Jiangsu Collaborative Innovation Center of Atmospheric Environment and Equipment Technology,School of Environmental Science and Engineering,Nanjing University of Information Science and Technology,Nanjing 210044(China)

(Received July 29,2019;revised August 26,2020)

ABSTRACT Humic substances acting as an electron shuttle and nitrogen transformation process influence remarkably the electron transfer in anaerobic reaction systems and thus may affect the reductive dechlorination of hexachlorobenzene(HCB).In order to develop an efficient agricultural strategy for the remediation of organochlorine-contaminated soils,a batch incubation experiment was conducted to study the effects of humic acid,urea,and their interaction on the reductive dechlorination of HCB in a Hydragric Acrisol with high iron oxide content.After 44 d of anaerobic incubation,the five treatments,sterile control,control,humic acid,urea,and humic acid+urea decreased HCB residues by 28.8%,47.8%,64.7%,57.8%,and 71.3%,respectively.The amendment of humic acid or urea significantly decreased soil Eh values and accelerated Fe(III)reduction to Fe(II),thus promoting markedly reductive dechlorination of HCB.Humic acid had a larger dechlorination effect than urea.Since there was a synergistic interaction between humic acid and urea that accelerated HCB dechlorination,the treatment having both amendments together was the most efficient for HCB dechlorination.The results showed that the combination of -N supplied by a fertilizer and humic substance is a feasible strategy for the remediation of organochlorine-contaminated soils with abundant iron oxide.

Key Words:electron-transfer mediator,biological iron reduction,persistent organic pollutant,polychlorinated organic compound,reductive dechlorination,soil amendment,soil remediation

INTRODUCTION

In recent decades,pollution from polychlorinated organic compounds(PCOCs),such as organic chlorinated pesticides and polychlorinated biphenyls,has become an important environmental problem owing to the high toxicity and persistence of these compounds(Liuet al.,2007).Soils are the final acceptor for the majority of PCOCs released to the environment(Liuet al.,2015).Among PCOCs,hexachlorobenzene(HCB)is one of the persistent organic pollutants(POPs)listed under the Stockholm Convention(Wanget al.,2010).Although the commercial production of HCB has been prohibited for decades all over the world,it is still produced as an industrial by-product(Jianget al.,2018).The HCB pollution in soil poses a serious challenge around the world,including the USA,Germany,Australia,Japan,and Brazil(Jianget al.,2018).In China,the cumulative production of HCB was 79 278 t by 1988(Leading Group for National Implementation Plan Compiling of China,2007).Hexachlorobenzene is found in most soils,and the mean concentration in soil was 8.01 ng g−1in Anhui Province,China(Wanget al.,2010;Songet al.,2017).Therefore,the remediation of HCB-contaminated soils is a serious and continuing challenge.

Reductive dechlorination is a key degradation pathway for PCOCs under anaerobic conditions,which is mainly completed by anaerobic microorganisms in the presence of electrons(Liuet al.,2010).Therefore,the redox reaction of nitrogen(N)species,such as urea,will probably influence the microbial reductive dechlorination process.Nevertheless,the effect of N supply on the degradation of organic contaminations reported in the literature is quite divergent.Some publications reported that N supply increased the degradation of organic compounds by enhancing microbial activity(Johanssonet al.,2001;Liuet al.,2010),while some others reported that N addition had negative effect on the degradation of organic contaminants since N addition altered the enzymatic systems responsible for degradation and inhibited the activity of specific degraders(Entry,1999;Abdelhafidet al.,2000).Furthermore,a previous study indicated that the application of a low amount of urea or NH4HCO3(with soil C/N ratio adjusted to 15/1)enhanced the reductive dechlorination of HCB,but the addition of high amounts of urea or NH4HCO3(with soil C/N ratio adjusted to 10/1)inhibited it.Even the addition of a low amount of-N from NaNO3served as an electron acceptor and inhibited HCB dechlorination(Liuet al.,2010).Therefore,urea was chosen as the N fertilizer to investigate the specific relationship between N transformation and the reductive dechlorination of HCB in this study.

Numerous studies have indicated that humic substances from soil organic matter played an important role in many redox reactions owing to the redox-active moieties in these macromolecular substances(Scottet al.,1998;Aulentaet al.,2010;Fanget al.,2013).Previous studies have found that humic substances could serve to shuttle electrons and influence microbial redox degradation of PCOCs(Chenet al.,2016;Zhanget al.,2017;Liet al.,2019).Considerable evidence has proven that quinone moieties in humic acids are the important electron-mediating groups that accelerate the reductive degradation of PCOCs(Scottet al.,1998;Rodenet al.,2010;Fanget al.,2013).It has been reported that quinone moieties in humic acids serve as an efficient electron-transfer mediator between electron acceptors and anaerobic microorganisms in microbial redox reactions.First,quinone obtains electrons from electron donor substances to form hydroquinone,and then hydroquinone serves as an electron donor for the reductive dechlorination of PCOCs,such as pentachlorophenol,after which hydroquinone returns to quinone(Fig.S1,see Supplementary Material for Fig.S1)(Fieldet al.,2000;Zhang and Katayama,2012).Second,humic acids could influence the bioavailability of HCB and,therefore,have an important role in the biodegradation of HCB in soil(Yaoet al.,2007;Liuet al.,2017).However,the specific mechanisms of how humic acid affects HCB degradation in soil have not been elucidated.

Hydragric Acrisols,containing high iron oxide content,are widely distributed in southern China.Previous reports suggest that iron oxides enhance the reductive degradation of PCOCs under anaerobic conditions(Liet al.,2009;Caoet al.,2012).Our previous study has shown that natural iron oxides in Hydragric Acrisols under a prevalent submerged condition enhance the reductive dechlorination of dichlorodiphenyltrichloroethane(DDT)(Liuet al.,2015).Furthermore,some studies indicated that iron was involved in the transformation of N and organic contaminants(Borchet al.,2010;Yuet al.,2014).Under anaerobic conditions,the reduction of Fe(III)can be combined with ammonium oxidation,and Fe(II)can effectively accelerate the reductive dechlorination(Clémentet al.,2005;Liuet al.,2015).Moreover,N as a necessary nutrient element for microorganisms can influence their growth and abundance and,therefore,affect the biochemical transformation of iron and reductive dechlorination(Borchet al.,2010;Yuet al.,2014).Furthermore,research has shown that quinone moieties in humic acids as an electron shuttle can accelerate Fe(III)reduction to Fe(II)efficiently(Jiang and Kappler,2008;Wuet al.,2013;Liet al.,2014).Meanwhile,humic acids can also improve the bioavailability of iron oxides by complexing Fe(III)or Fe(II)(Royeret al.,2002).Therefore,the effects of interactions among iron oxide,urea,and humic acid on reductive dechlorination of PCOCs require further investigation.

In this study,a batch anaerobic incubation experiment was performed using a Hydragric Acrisol to explore the effect of humic acid and urea applications on the reductive degradation of HCB.The primary objectives were:1)to clarify the effect of humic acid or urea addition on the reductive dechlorination of HCB and possible mechanisms;2)to elucidate the impact of natural iron oxides on the reductive degradation of HCB in Hydragric Acrisols under anaerobic conditions;3)to study the interactive role of humic acid,urea,and iron oxide in the reductive degradation of HCB by natural microorganisms in Hydragric Acrisols;and 4)to seek an efficient measure to enhance the degradation of PCOCs.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Chemicals and reagents

Standard samples of HCB and its dechlorinated products(purity>99.5%),including pentachlorobenzene(PeCB),monochlorobenzene(MCB),all isomers of tetrachlorobenzene(TeCB),trichlorobenzene(TCB),and dichlorobenzene(DCB),were purchased from Dr.Ehrenstorfer GmbH(Augsburg,Germany).Sodium sulphate(Na2SO4,from Nanjing Chemical Reagent Co.,Nanjing,China)was oven dried at 400°C for 4 h before use.Silica gel(Nanjing Chemical Reagent Co.,China)was activated at 130°C for 18 h and deactivated by 3.3% deionized water,according to the U.S.Environmental Protection Agency(US EPA)Method 3630(US EPA,1996).Other analytical grade chemical reagents were also obtained from Nanjing Chemical Reagent Co.,Nanjing,China.

Soil preparation

The test soil,a Hydragric Acrisol(World Reference Base for Soil Resources),was obtained from the Experimental Station of Red Soil Ecology,Chinese Academy of Sciences(28°15′N,116°55′E).The main physicochemical properties of the soil were:Fe(III)to Fe(II)ratio of 20.7,27.1 g kg−1of free ferric oxide,2.2 g kg−1of amorphous iron oxide,33 g kg−1of organic matter,40.3 mg kg−1of dissolved organic carbon(DOC),1 g kg−1of total N,18.6 mg kg−1of-N,5.3 mg kg−1of-N,0.5 g kg−1of total phosphorus,21 g kg−1of K2O,and a pH of 5.6.The background content of HCB in the test soil was 5.6 ng g−1.Soil pH was determined using a glass electrode at a soil to water ratio of 1:2(volume/volume).For DOC,fresh soil(10 g on an oven-dried basis)was incubated with 50 mL distilled water for 30 min on an end-over-end shaker at 25°C and then centrifuged for 20 min at 8 000 r min−1.The extracted solutions were passed through a 0.45-µm filter paper and analyzed on a Shimadzu C analyzer(TOC Vcph,Shimadzu,Kyoto,Japan)(Liuet al.,2013).

The HCB-contaminated soil was spiked artificially.First,50 mg HCB dissolved in acetone was added to 140 g of quartz sand powder and then stirred constantly until the acetone evaporated completely.Then,5 g of contaminated quartz sand and 500 g test soil were mixed thoroughly and transferred to the incubation flask.The measured HCB content in the spiked soil was 10.7µmol kg−1.Soil samples for the sterile control were sterilized by irradiation withγrays before being used with a60Co source and a dose of 50 kGy,according to Chenet al.(2013).

Experimental design

A batch anaerobic incubation experiment was performed in a closed system with N2gas in the headspace of flasks.The experiment composed of five treatments(based on 500 g of HCB-contaminated soil):1)sterile HCB-contaminated soil(sterile control,SCK),2)HCB-contaminated soil(control,CK),3)HCB-contaminated soil+1 g kg−1humic acid(HA),4)HCB-contaminated soil+0.6 g kg−1urea(U),and 5)HCB-contaminated soil+1 g kg−1humic acid+0.6 g kg−1urea(HA+U).All treatments were replicated three times.The humic acid used was obtained from the test soil and was further purified according to the process described by Guoet al.(2018).A total of 270 mL of deionized water was added to keep the soil saturated throughout the incubation period.The flasks were incubated at 25°C in darkness for 44 d.On Days 4,8,12,16,20,28,36,and 44,oxidation-reduction potentials(Eh)of the reaction systems were measured,and about 10 g of soil was sampled to analyze-N,-N,Fe(II),HCB,and its metabolites.

Measurement methods

The Eh values for each reaction system were measured with an mV meter(PHB-06,Nanjing Jiaoyuan Analytical Instrument Co.,Nanjing,China).For measuring the concentrations of-N and-N in the reaction systems,3 g of sampled soil was extracted with 30 mL of 2 mol L−1KCl solution,and then the extracts were analyzed using the indophenol blue spectrophotometric method and the ultraviolet spectrophotometric assay,respectively(Bolleteret al.,1961;Norman and Stucki,1981).The Fe(II)was extracted with 0.5 mol L−1of HCl solution for 1.5 h before filtering with a 0.22-µm membrane and then determined using the 1,10-phenanthroline colorimetric assay(Picardalet al.,1995).

The HCB and its dechlorinated products(PeCB,TeCB,TCB,DCB,and MCB)in soil were extracted with an accelerated solvent extraction instrument(ASE 200,Dionex,Sunnyvale,USA),using a hexane-acetone(3:1,volume/volume)solution for extraction.The extracts were cleaned with solid-phase extraction(SPE)cartridges,which contained 1 g Na2SO4at the bottom,1 g silica gel in the middle,and 1 g Na2SO4at the top,and eluted using a hexanedichloromethane(9:1,volume/volume)solution.The quantification of HCB and its dechlorinated products was done with a gas chromatography(Agilent 6890)equipped with an HP 7683 auto-sampler,DB-5 capillary column,and63Ni electron capture detector(Agilent Technologies,Palo Alto,USA).The carrier gas was N2.The temperature program was as follows:the initial temperature of 60°C was maintained for 2 min,then increased to 190°C at 5°C min−1and to 280°C at 20°C min−1,and finally kept at 280°C for 7 min.The temperature was 240 and 290°C for the injector and detector,respectively.The recoveries for HCB,PeCB,TeCB,and TCB determined were between 83% and 96%,and those for DCB and MCB determined were between 65% and 73%.

Statistical analysis

The Windows-based SPSS version 18.0 was used for analysis of variance(ANOVA),with the significance level atP=0.05.

RESULTS AND DISCUSSION

Soil Eh values

Soil Eh values for the five treatments during the incubation period are presented in Fig.1.The SCK treatment resulted in the highest soil Eh values because sterilization would restrict the reductive process of variable-valence elements by soil microorganisms.The application of humic acid decreased soil Eh values compared to CK.This could be explained by the humic acid acting as an electron shuttle between the anaerobic microorganisms and the electron acceptor in the reductive process that then stimulated the reducing reaction in the soil(Kappler and Haderlein,2003;Guoet al.,2018).Urea applications decreased soil Eh values compared to CK,which was due to the increase in-N produced by urea hydrolysis(Clémentet al.,2005).The synergistic interactive effect between humic acid and urea on soil Eh was significant(P<0.05),and the HA+U treatment produced a significantly lower soil Eh than both the HA and U treatments.

Soil NH+4-N and NO−3-N content

Fig.1 Soil Eh values in the five treatments during 44-d incubation of a Hydragric Acrisol:sterile hexachlorobenzene(HCB)-contaminated soil(sterile control,SCK),HCB-contaminated soil(control,CK),HCBcontaminated soil+1 g kg−1 humic acid(HA),HCB-contaminated soil+0.6 g kg−1 urea(U),HCB-contaminated soil+1 g kg−1 humic acid+0.6 g kg−1 urea(HA+U).Values are means with standard deviations shown by vertical bars(n=3).

Fig.2 Soil -N(a)and -N(b)contents in the five treatments during 44-d incubation of a Hydragric Acrisol:sterile hexachlorobenzene(HCB)-contaminated soil(sterile control,SCK),HCB-contaminated soil(control,CK),HCB-contaminated soil+1 g kg−1 humic acid(HA),HCB-contaminated soil+0.6 g kg−1 urea(U),HCB-contaminated soil+1 g kg−1 humic acid+0.6 g kg−1 urea(HA+U).Values are means with standard deviations shown by vertical bars(n=3).

Soil Fe(II)content

Fig.3 Soil Fe(II)contents in the five treatments during 44-d incubation of a Hydragric Acrisol:sterile hexachlorobenzene(HCB)-contaminated soil(sterile control,SCK),HCB-contaminated soil(control,CK),HCBcontaminated soil+1 g kg−1 humic acid(HA),HCB-contaminated soil+0.6 g kg−1 urea(U),HCB-contaminated soil+1 g kg−1 humic acid+0.6 g kg−1 urea(HA+U).Values are means with standard deviations shown by vertical bars(n=3).

Soil Fe(II)content initially rose and then declined during the 44 d-incubation for all the treatments except SCK(Fig.3).Soil Fe(II)content was always much lower in the SCK treatment than in other four treatments.In the four treatments,soil Fe(II)contents were generally in the order:HA+U>HA>U>CK.These results showed that the application of either humic acid or urea enhanced Fe(II)generation,and the effect of humic acid was greater than that of urea.The combined supply of humic acid and urea had the greatest effect as there was a significant synergistic interaction that accelerated the formation of Fe(II)(P<0.05).The sterile treatment restricted the dissimilatory reduction of Fe(III)to Fe(II)by soil microorganisms.The application of humic acid that served as an electron-transfer mediator enhanced the microbial reductive reaction of iron oxide and improved the bioavailability of iron oxide by complexing Fe(III)or Fe(II)(Royeret al.,2002;Kappler and Haderlein,2003;Guoet al.,2018).This,in turn,increased soil Fe(II)content.Application of urea that might serve as an electron donor accelerated the dissimilatory reduction of iron oxide.Moreover,since urea acted as an N resource,it might stimulate the microbial transformation of iron oxide,thereby increasing soil Fe(II)content.

Extractable HCB residues in soil

The extractable HCB residues decreased dramatically during the first 4 d and then declined slowly from Day 4 to Day 44(Fig.4).The HCB residue was the highest in the SCK treatment and decreased by only 28.8% over the 44-d incubation.For CK,the extractable HCB residues were reduced by 47.8% over the 44-d of incubation.The HA treatment reduced the extractable HCB residues by 64.7%.The HCB residues decreased by 57.8% over 44 d in the U treatment.The residues in this treatment were also lower than those in CK,but higher than those in the HA treatment during the entire duration of incubation.For the interactive system(the HA+U treatment),the extractable HCB residues were reduced by 71.3% over the incubation period.This treatment always had lower HCB residues when compared with the other four treatments.

Formation of HCB metabolites in soil

As shown in Fig.5,the primary metabolite of HCB detected was PeCB in the present study.During incubation,the content of PeCB produced was much lower in the SCK treatment than in the other four treatments(Fig.5a).For the four treatments,the PeCB content kept rising during the whole incubation period and was in the order of HA+U>HA>U>CK,with differences between the treatments being significant during the whole incubation period(P<0.05)except that between the HA and U treatments from Day 16 to Day 44.

After Day 20,1,2,3,4-TeCB and 1,2,3,5-TeCB were detected in all the treatments except SCK,with the content of 1,2,3,5-TeCB being higher than that of 1,2,3,4-TeCB(Fig.5b,c);1,2,3-TCB,1,2,4-TCB,and 1,3,5-TCB were detected also after Day 20,with the content of 1,3,5-TCB being the highest among these three forms of TCB(Fig.5d-f).These results indicated that 1,2,3,5-TeCB and 1,3,5-TCB were further metabolites for HCB dechlorination,which was consistent with results of previous studies(Brahushiet al.,2004;Liuet al.,2010).

Fig.4 Contents of hexachlorobenzene(HCB)residues in soil in the five treatments during 44-d incubation of a Hydragric Acrisol:sterile hexachlorobenzene(HCB)-contaminated soil(sterile control,SCK),HCBcontaminated soil(control,CK),HCB-contaminated soil+1 g kg−1 humic acid(HA),HCB-contaminated soil+0.6 g kg−1 urea(U),HCBcontaminated soil+1 g kg−1 humic acid+0.6 g kg−1 urea(HA+U).Values are as means with standard deviations shown by vertical bars(n=3).

Moreover,PeCB was the dominant metabolite of HCB,while TeCB and TCB were of minor importance(Fig.5).The half-life of HCB is longer than that of others,and HCB and PeCB have been recognized as POPs by the Stockholm Convention(Liuet al.,2017).In addition,HCB,PeCB,1,2,4,5-TeCB,and 1,2,4-TCB are listed as the priority pollutants by the US EPA(Songet al.,2012).Therefore,finding practices that enhance PeCB degradation is particularly important.

The sums of the contents of the dechlorinated products for HCB,including PeCB,TeCB,and TCB,are shown in Fig.6.The sum of the contents of the HCB metabolites for the SCK treatment was very small,with the maximum value of 0.14µmol kg−1at the end of incubation,which accounted for only 1.2% of the initial HCB content.For CK,HA,U,and HA+U treatments,the values were 1.8,2.6,2.3,and 3.4µmol kg−1at the end of incubation and were 15.9%,22.9%,20.5%,and 29.7% of the initial HCB content,respectively,generally being the highest in the HA+U treatment,followed by the HA treatment and then the U treatment,and the least in CK.Lower values were observed in the SCK treatment than in the other four treatments.These results indicated that the degradation of HCB under anaerobic conditions was mainly achieved by microorganisms and that the amendment of either humic acid or urea accelerated HCB dechlorination.The HA+U treatment was most efficient in enhancing the HCB dechlorination because the significant synergistic interaction between humic acid and urea enhanced HCB degradation(P<0.05).

Fig.5 Contents of hexachlorobenzene(HCB)metabolites detected,pentachlorobenzene(PeCB)(a),1,2,3,4-tetrachlorobenzene(TeCB)(b),1,2,3,5-TeCB(c),1,2,3-trichlorobenzene(TCB)(d),1,2,4-TCB(e),and 1,3,5-TCB(f),in soil in the five treatments during 44-d incubation of a Hydragric Acrisol:sterile HCB-contaminated soil(sterile control,SCK),HCB-contaminated soil(control,CK),HCB-contaminated soil+1 g kg−1 humic acid(HA),HCBcontaminated soil+0.6 g kg−1 urea(U),HCB-contaminated soil+1 g kg−1 humic acid+0.6 g kg−1 urea(HA+U).Values are shown as means with standard deviations shown by vertical bars(n=3).

Fig.6 Sums of the contents of hexachlorobenzene(HCB)metabolites in soil in the five treatments during 44-d incubation of a Hydragric Acrisol:sterile HCB-contaminated soil(sterile control,SCK),HCB-contaminated soil(control,CK),HCB-contaminated soil+1 g kg−1 humic acid(HA),HCB-contaminated soil+0.6 g kg−1 urea(U),HCB-contaminated soil+1 g kg−1 humic acid+0.6 g kg−1 urea(HA+U).Values are shown as means with standard deviations shown by vertical bars(n=3).

For the SCK,CK,HA,U,and HA+U treatments,the decreases in extractable HCB residues were 3.1,5.1,6.9,6.2,and 7.7µmol kg−1(Fig.4),while the sums of the contents of all HCB metabolites at the end of incubation were only 0.1,1.8,2.6,2.3,and 3.4µmol kg−1,respectively(Fig.6).The volatilization losses of HCB and its metabolites from submerged soils would be negligible due to their low vapor pressures and high octanol/water partition coefficients.It has been confirmed that non-extractable HCB and its metabolites can be bound in soil because the organic matter and clay particles can adsorb and bind organic pollutants(Yaoet al.,2007)and the non-extractable residues of organic pollutants bound in soil can account for nearly half of the total quantity of HCB(Brahushiet al.,2004).Therefore,the difference between the decreasing amounts of extractable HCB residues and the sum of the contents of all HCB metabolites was due to the non-extractable HCB and its metabolites and their losses during the analysis process.

Influence of humic acid and urea amendment on HCB degradation

The above-mentioned results showed that the humic acid application enhanced HCB dechlorination remarkably throughout the incubation.This occurred because the humic acid significantly reduced the Eh value of soil(Fig.1),which in turn increased the reductive degradation rate of HCB.Also,the humic acid enhanced Fe(II)formation(Fig.3),probably because humic acid can serve as an electron-transfer mediator between iron oxides and iron-reducing bacteria.In addition,humic acid can also improve the bioavailability of iron oxides by complexing Fe(III)or Fe(II),thereby enhancing microbial Fe(III)reduction.The resulting Fe(II),which is an effective electron donor,could enhance the reductive degradation of HCB(Royeret al.,2002;Liet al.,2010).Humin,humic acid,and quinone compounds could enhance Fe(III)reduction to Fe(II),but only humin could accelerate the reductive dechlorination(Zhang and Katayama,2012;Guoet al.,2018).This may be because humin molecules contain some metallic compounds,which has interactive effects with quinone and other redox-active groups in the humin molecule,then increasing reductive dechlorination.Our results showed that humic acid increased HCB reductive dechlorination in the Hydragric Acrisol tested,probably owing to the abundant iron oxides in the soil.Therefore,the natural humic substances in Hydragric Acrisols had an important potential capacity for remediation of PCOC contamination.

The application of urea enhanced HCB dechlorination,which can be explained by the following reasons.First,the reductive dechlorination of HCB was enhanced by the increases in-N content(Fig.2a)that reduced the soil Eh value(Fig.1)to enhance the formation of Fe(II)(Fig.3).Second,urea as an N source could stimulate microbial activity,including dechlorinating microorganisms,thus accelerating the biodegradation of HCB,as reported by Johanssonet al.(2001)and Liuet al.(2010).Third,there were anaerobic microorganisms that could participate in the ammonium oxidation in submerged soils(Watanabeet al.,2009),and the-N hydrolyzed from urea would therefore enhance the reductive degradation of HCB.

Since there was a synergistic interactive effect between humic acid and urea on the acceleration of HCB dechlorination,the application of humic acid and urea together was most efficient in accelerating HCB dechlorination.This would be due to several factors.First,the lowest Eh values compared to those of the other four treatments(Fig.1)accelerated the reductive degradation of HCB efficiently.Second,urea as a reductant could produce more electrons,and the added humic acid would transfer electrons between iron-reducing bacteria and iron oxides,which could stimulate Fe(III)reduction(Fig.3).The generated Fe(II),as an effective electron donor,would then increase the reductive degradation rate of HCB.Third,urea application could enhance the activity of anaerobic microorganisms,and then the supplied humic acid accelerated electron transfer by the stimulated anaerobic microorganisms,thereby increasing the reductive dechlorination rate of HCB.Therefore,this study provided convincing evidence that the combined supply of-N fertilizer and humic substance is a feasible strategy to accelerate the degradation of PCOCs in contaminated soils that contain abundant iron oxides,offering useful information for the remediation of soils contaminated with PCOCs.

CONCLUSIONS

The application of humic acid and/or urea in an anaerobic Hydragric Acrisol decreased soil Eh values and accelerated Fe(II)formation,enhancing HCB dechlorination.The effect of humic acid was greater than that of urea.The combined supply of humic acid and urea had the largest effect in enhancing HCB degradation owing to a synergistic interaction between humic acid and urea.Therefore,the combined application of humic substance with an-N source was an effective measure to enhance PCOC degradation in contaminated fields.In addition,the primary metabolite of HCB detected was PeCB;this finding highlights the importance of developing practices to enhance degradation of PeCB since it is a persistent pollutant of international concern.

ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS

This research was supported by the Key Laboratory of Soil Environment and Pollution Remediation,Institute of Soil Science,Chinese Academy of Sciences(No.SEPR2017-4)and the National Natural Science Foundation of China(No.41671318).We greatly appreciate Dr.Brian McConkey from Swift Current Research and Development Centre,Agriculture and Agri-Food Canada for his help in preparing the manuscript.

SUPPLEMENTARY MATERIAL

Supplementary material can be found in the online version.


登录APP查看全文