APP下载

Effect of P fertilizer reduction regime on soil Olsen-P,root Fe-plaque P,and rice P uptake in rice-wheat rotation paddy fields

2021-03-17HaoCHENYuWANGJiahuiYUANWenbinZHUGuangleiCHENandShenqiangWANG

Pedosphere 2021年1期

Hao CHENYu WANGJiahui YUANWenbin ZHUGuanglei CHEN and Shenqiang WANG∗

1State Key Laboratory of Soil and Sustainable Agriculture,Changshu National Agro-Ecosystem Observation and Research Station,Institute of Soil Science,Chinese Academy of Sciences,Nanjing 210008(China)

2College of Resource and Environment,University of Chinese Academy of Sciences,Beijing 100049(China)

3College of Resources and Environmental Sciences,Nanjing Agricultural University,Nanjing 210095(China)

(Received November 17,2018;revised February 27,2019)

ABSTRACT In agricultural systems,it is vital to use limited yet optimal phosphorus(P)resources,because excessive P fertilizer application leads to the accumulation of P in soil,increasing the risk of environmental pollution and causing the waste and exhaustion of P resources.In a rice-wheat rotation system,omitting P fertilizer application in the rice-growing season is a good alternative;however,how this P fertilization reduction influences changes in P in the soil-root-aboveground system is unclear.In this study,after a seven-year rice-wheat rotation at the Yixing(YX)and Changshu(CS)sampling sites,China,compared with P fertilization in rice-and wheat-growing seasons(PR+W),reduced P fertilization(no P fertilizer application in either season,P0;P fertilization only in wheat-growing seasons,PW;and P fertilization only in rice-growing seasons,PR)did not result in substantial variation in crop biomass.The PW treatment did not reduce crop total P,root iron(Fe)-plaque P,and soil Olsen-P at three stages of rice growth(seedling,booting,and harvesting stages)at the YX and CS sites.In contrast,concentrations of soil Olsen-P,aboveground crop total P,and root Fe-plaque P decreased in the P0 treatment by 45.8%-81.0%,24.6%-30.9%,and 45.6%-73.4%,respectively.In addition,a significant negative correlation was observed between the root Fe-plaque P and crop biomass at the two sites.Significant positive correlations were also observed between root Fe-plaque P and root total P,crop total P,and soil Olsen-P.In addition,the results of a redundancy analysis revealed that soil alkaline phosphatase(ALP)played a major role in the supply of P in soil,and was closely associated with root Fe-plaque P.The results of this study will enhance the understanding of the changes in P in the soil-root-aboveground system,particularly under P fertilizer reduction regimes.

Key Words:crop biomass,crop total P,iron plaque,reduced P input,rice-growth stage,soil-root-aboveground system

INTRODUCTION

Phosphorus(P)is an essential element for primary production in ecosystems and for agricultural production(Blakeet al.,2005).However,an inappropriate or excessive application of phosphate fertilizer could negatively affect agricultural sustainability and cause environmental pollution(Luet al.,2012).In China,rice(Oryza sativa)is a major crop and constitutes a major component of the diet of the population(Penget al.,2009).In rice-growing areas,paddy soil is a unique soil environment,which is subjected to alternating wet and dry periods in paddy-upland rotation systems.The concentrations of available P increase significantly during the rice-growing season following soil flooding(Hupfer and Lewandowski,2008).In addition,Søndergaardet al.(2003)reported that reduction-oxidation(redox)reactions influence the release of P because of the redox-mediated transformation of P-bound iron(Fe)and aluminum compounds in the soil.

Previous studies have revealed that reduced P-input regimes could sustain crop yield while providing adequate available P for crop growth for several years(Wanget al.,2016).In addition,reduced P input could decrease the total P concentration in runoff(Wanget al.,2014).However,in the rice-growing season,the processes of P transportation from soil to crops require investigation,particularly during waterlogged periods when P fertilizers are not applied.In addition,Fe plaque coatings on rice roots potentially play key roles in the transportation of P from the soil to crop roots.

Iron plaque refers to deposits of reddish-brown Fe oxides(hydroxides and oxyhydroxides)observed on the root surfaces of aquatic plants(Amaralet al.,2017),includingOryza sativa(Shaiburet al.,2015),Phragmites australis(Battyet al.,2002),andTypha latifolia(Hanselet al.,2001).The accumulation of Fe plaque is more widespread around the root tips(Chenet al.,1980),and Fe oxides have a high specific surface area and a high affinity for phosphates(Wanget al.,2013).During the formation of Fe plaques,the roots of wetland plants first extract soluble Fe through the action of the transpiration stream to their surfaces,accompanied by the spontaneous precipitation of Fe because of shifting redox potentials and oxygen release from roots(Xuet al.,2009).Therefore,the role of Fe plaque in the P concentration in the roots of aquatic plants is important.However,a debate persists regarding the effects of Fe plaque on P uptake by roots.According to Greipsson(1995),Fe plaque outside of rice root surfaces does not inhibit P accumulation in leaves.Crowder and Macfie(1986)observed lower P concentrations inCarexandTyphaplants without Fe plaque than in individuals with Fe plaque.Other studies have also reported that Fe plaque acts as a nutrient reservoir during periods of reduced nutrient supply(Zhanget al.,1999;Lianget al.,2006;Roseet al.,2013;Meiet al.,2014).However,Fe plaque has also been reported to inhibit P uptake because of immobilization(Otteet al.,1989;Christensen and Sand-Jensen,1998;Liuet al.,2004;Piet al.,2011).Therefore,it is necessary to understand Fe plaque dynamics in the soil and their effects on plants,particularly during different rice-growing stages.

In the present study,we employed a reduced P-input field experiment to investigate changes in P concentrations at three rice-growth stages,in addition to determining how Fe plaque influences P transportation activities.The overall goal was to determine changes in P in the soil-root-aboveground system under a reduced P fertilization scheme in various rice seasons in paddy-upland rotation cropping systems.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Field experiment

The field experiment was conducted at two sites:the Changshu Institute of Agriculture Sciences(CS site;120°40′E,31°41′N)and Yixing Agro-Environment Research Base,National Agroecosystem Observatory and Research Station of Changshu(YX site;119°54′E,31°16′N),China.The two sites are close to Taihu Lake and have mild annual average temperatures of 15.4 and 14.7°C,respectively,and an average rainfall of 1 454 and 1 174 mm,respectively.The two regions are typical rice-wheat(Triticum aestivum)cropping rotation areas.The field experiment was established in June 2010 when the rice-growing season began.Physicochemical properties of the soils in the two regions,including total nitrogen(N),total P,total potassium(K),organic matter,Olsen-P,cation exchange capacity,and pH are summarized in Table I(Wanget al.,2016;Zhuet al.,2016).A detailed description of the experiment is presented in Wanget al.(2016).Briefly,fertilizer regimes used in this experiment included P fertilization only in the wheat-growing season(PW),P fertilization only in the rice-growing season(PR),P fertilization in the rice-and wheat-growing seasons(PR+W)(conventional farming practice),and P fertilization in none of the seasons(P0)(control).The four P fertilization regimes were applied based on a completely randomized design with three replicates.Phosphorus fertilizer was applied at a rate of 40 kg P2O5ha−1.Urea fertilizer was applied at a rate of 240 kg N ha−1(at the tillering stage and at the jointing stage;basal fertilizer was applied and recovered at a ratio of 3:4:3),and the basic rate of application of K fertilizer was 60 kg K2O ha−1.

TABLE IPhysicochemical properties of the soils at the Changshu(CS)and Yixing(YX)sites

Soil and crop sampling

Soil and crop samples were collected in the rice-growing season in 2016(the seventh year of the field experiment,from June 22 to October 20,2016),including the seedling stage(July 1,2016),booting stage(September 2,2016),and harvesting stage(October 20,2016).Soil adhering to the roots of the rice plants was collected,air-dried,ground,screened using a 2-mm sieve,and stored at room temperature for further chemical analyses.Crop samples were separated into belowground(roots)and aboveground(grain and straw)sections,ground,and screened using a 2-mm sieve after oven-drying at 75°C for 48 h.

Chemical analysis

Soil properties after the completion of the field experiment were analyzed using the conventional analytical methods described by Li(1983).Soil pH was determined from a 2.5:1(volume/weight)water/soil mixture using a pH meter(ORION STAR A211;Thermo Fisher Scientific Inc.,Beverly,USA).Olsen-P was extracted using sodium bicarbonate(0.5 mol L−1NaHCO3,pH=8.5)for 0.5 h(Olsenet al.,1954)and the concentration was determined using the spectrophotometric method(UVmini-1240;SHIMADZU,Corporation,Japan).Crop total P concentrations were determined following H2SO4-H2O2extraction and using molybdenum blue colorimetry by the spectrophotometric method(apparatus:UVmini-1240).Soil acid phosphatase(ACP)and alkaline phosphatase(ALP)were measured using the method described by Tabatabai(1994).Fe plaque surrounding the roots was extracted using the dithionite-citrate-bicarbonate(DCB)method(Otteet al.,1989).A 0.45-µm pore sized nylon filter was then used to filter the DCB extraction solution,and then stored at 4°C for further analyses.Finally,the roots were dried in an oven at 75°C for 48 h and weighed.

Statistical analysis

A one-way analysis of variance(ANOVA)and the Duncan test were used to analyze the influence of different P fertilization treatments on soil P.APvalue of 0.05 was considered significant.Line regression was used to analyze the relationship between root Fe-plaque P concentration and crop biomass,root total P concentration,and crop total P concentration.The above statistical analyses were conducted using IBM SPSS Statistics 17.0.A redundancy analysis(RDA)was used to analyze variability,relationships,and patterns among soil Olsen-P,root Fe plaque,and key environmental parameters,such as phosphatase activities and pH.The RDA analysis was performed using CANOCO 4.5.

RESULTS

Crop biomass and P uptake

Crop biomass was calculated based on straw yield at the rice seedling or booting stage,and based on straw and grain yields at the harvest stage(Fig.1).Compared to the PR+W treatment,the PR and PW treatments revealed no significant differences during the three rice-growth stages at both the YX and CS sites.However,crop biomass significantly decreased in the P0 treatment by 27.5% and 26.1% in the rice-seedling and booting stages,respectively(P<0.05)at the CS site,although no significant change was observed in crop biomass at the rice-harvesting stage at the two sites.

Crop total P was divided into aboveground and belowground P concentrations(Fig.2).Compared to the PR+W treatment,the PR and PW groups showed no considerable difference in crop total P;however,aboveground P uptake in the P0 treatment at the YX and CS sites significantly decreased by 24.6%-26.6% and 28.3%-31.0%,respectively,and belowground P uptake decreased by 13.8%-21.9% and 19.7%-46.4%(P<0.05),respectively,during the three rice-growth stages.No differences occurred for belowground P uptake during the harvesting stage.

Root Fe-plaque P

The concentrations of root Fe-plaque P during the three rice-growth stages occurred in the following order:harvest stage<booting stage<seedling stage(Fig.3).Compared to the concentration of root Fe-plaque P in the PR+W treatment,the concentrations in the PR and PW treatments revealed no significant changes,excluding a 45.6% decrease in the rice-booting stage in the PW treatment at the CS site.However,the root Fe-plaque P concentration significantly decreased in the P0 treatment at both the YX and CS sites(P<0.05),excluding the rice-seedling stage at the YX site.In addition,a significant negative correlation between root Fe-plaque P and crop biomass was observed at the YX(P<0.01,R2=0.76)and CS(P<0.01,R2=0.57)sites,respectively(Fig.4).Furthermore,there was a significant positive correlation between root Fe-plaque P and root total P(P<0.01;R2=0.96 andR2=0.93 for the YX and CS sites,respectively),and root Fe-plaque P and crop total P(P<0.01;R2=0.88 andR2=0.84 for the YX and CS sites,respectively)(Fig.4).

Fig.1 Crop biomass at the three rice-growth stages under four P fertilization treatments in the seventh year of the field experiment at the Yixing(YX)and Changshu(CS)sites.The crop biomass at the seedling and booting stages of the two sites consists of straw biomass and at the harvest stage is the sum of straw biomass and grain production.Error bars are standard errors of means(n=3).*indicates a significant difference(P<0.05)between the reduced P fertilization treatments(no P fertilization in either season(P0),P fertilization only in the rice-growing season(PR),and P fertilization only in the wheat-growing season(PW))and the P fertilization treatment in the rice-and wheat-growing seasons(PR+W).

Fig.2 Crop total P at three rice-growth stages under the four P fertilization treatments in the seventh year of the field experiment at the Yixing(YX)and Changshu(CS)sites.Error bars are standard errors of means(n=3).*indicates a significant difference(P<0.05)between the reduced P fertilization treatments(no P fertilization in either season(P0),P fertilization only in the rice-growing season(PR),and P fertilization only in the wheat-growing season(PW))and the P fertilization treatment in the rice-and wheat-growing seasons(PR+W).

Soil Olsen-P

Compared to the PR+W treatment,soil Olsen-P concentration in the PR treatment did not exhibit a significant difference during the three rice-growth stages(Fig.5).However,soil Olsen-P concentrations declined by 67.6% and 36.6%in the rice-seedling stage at both the YX and CS sites,respectively,whereas no change was observed in the booting and harvesting stages.Soil Olsen-P concentrations in the P0 treatment significantly decreased(P<0.05)by 66.1%-81.0% and 50.0%-54.1% during the three rice-growth stages,excluding the harvesting stage at the CS site.In addition,a significant positive correlation was observed between root Fe-plaque P and soil Olsen-P(P<0.01;R2=0.27 andR2=0.48 for the YX and CS sites,respectively)(Fig.6).

Relationships among soil Olsen-P,root Fe-plaque P,and environmental factors

The RDA results revealed the influence of some environmental factors,such as soil ACP,pH,and ALP on soil Olsen-P and root Fe-plaque P concentrations(Fig.7).According to the result,soil ACP,pH,and ALP explained 23.8%of the variation in soil Olsen-P and root Fe-plaque P at the YX site.The first RDA axis explained 23.5% of the variation at the site.Conversely,at the CS site,the soil properties only explained 7.6% of the variation in soil Olsen-P and root Fe-plaque P concentrations.However,there was a significant correlation between soil Olsen-P and ALP and between root Fe-plaque P and soil ALP.

DISCUSSION

Soil Olsen-P concentration is a key index used to assess the P supply capacity of soil for plants(Baiet al.,2013).In the seventh rice-growing season,compared to the soil Olsen-P concentration in the PR+W treatment(traditional P fertilization),the soil Olsen-P concentration in the PW treatment significantly decreased during the seedling stage,whereas there was no change during the booting and harvesting stages.In addition,crop total P concentration did not exhibit any marked changes.The results were potentially caused by the application of P fertilizer as the base fertilizer.In addition,considering the extended growing period,soil P could be released under flooding conditions,which could have increased Fe,Mn,and Ca-bound P solubility(Scalengheet al.,2002),as well as considerably increased P desorption(Quang and Dufey,1995).

In the P0 treatment,soil Olsen-P concentration decreased significantly at the three stages of rice growth.The sustained depletion of soil P led to P deficiency in the soil.Similar to our results,some studies have reported significant decreases in soil Olsen-P under long-term cultivation without the application of P fertilizers(Caoet al.,2012;Shenet al.,2014).Notably,the P0 treatment maintained similar levels of crop biomass,which is consistent with the findings of our previous study(Wanget al.,2016).However,crop total P concentration(aboveground)significantly decreased during this year.

Fig.3 Root Fe-plaque P at three rice-growth stages under four P fertilization treatments in the seventh year of the field experiment at the Yixing(YX)and Changshu(CS)sites.Error bars are standard errors of means(n=3).*and**indicate significant differences at P<0.05 and P<0.01,respectively,between reduced P fertilization treatments(no P fertilization in either season(P0),P fertilization only in rice-growing season(PR),and P fertilization only in the wheat-growing season(PW))and the P fertilization treatment in the rice-and wheat-growing seasons(PR+W).

According to the results of some previous studies,under European soil conditions and various types of soil,the reduction or omission of P fertilization did not influence crop yield(Ellmeret al.,2000;Gransee and Merbach,2000).However,a 15-year long-term winter wheat-maize(Zea mays)crop rotation experiment showed that wheat and maize grain yield decreased significantly without P fertilization(Blakeet al.,2000).In a 15-year field study,the lack of the application of P led to a considerable decrease in soil Olsen-P and crop P uptake(Tanget al.,2008),whereas in a three-year wheat-rice rotation field experiment,crop total P and soil Olsen-P concentrations declined under a no P fertilization treatment during both the wheat-and rice-growing seasons relative to that under P fertilization exclusively applied during the rice-growing season(Maet al.,2005).All the findings could be influenced by soil types and cropping systems.In addition,in the rice-growing season,root Fe-plaque potentially influences P uptake from soil to the crop.

The Fe plaque can bind P by adsorption and coprecipitation;therefore,it influences P transportation and accumulation in plants(Piet al.,2011;Khanet al.,2016).In the present study,we studied three rice-growth stages in a longterm field experiment,which was different from previous studies based mainly on hydroponic cultures.There was no significant difference in the root Fe-plaque P concentrations in the PW treatment compared with the PR+W and PR treatments;however,the Fe-plaque P concentration in the P0 treatment significantly decreased,which is attributable in differences in the P supply capacity.These results were consistent with the variations in soil Olsen-P and crop total P concentrations.In addition,root Fe-plaque P concentrations were significantly positively correlated with root total P and crop total P concentrations.Root Fe-plaque acts as a nutrient reservoir for P in the rhizosphere and facilitates the acquisition of more P in rice for growth(Caiet al.,2003;Lianget al.,2006).Xinget al.(2018)also reported that Fe plaque on the root surfaces ofVallisneria natansenriched P and Fe and enhanced P uptake in the plants.Fe plaque could also enhance the accumulation of P in the belowground and/or aboveground parts of plants(Zhanget al.,1999;Yanget al.,2011;Caoet al.,2013).A potential mechanism for the accumulation of P in plant tissues is that P could be exchanged or form a complex with OH groups in Fe plaque,which would serve as a P reservoir,in turn enhancing the diffusion of P into the roots of the wetland plants and increasing P concentrations in the shoots(Zhanget al.,1999;Khanet al.,2016).In addition,the RDA results showed that under the four P fertilization treatments,root Fe-plaque P and soil Olsen-P concentrations exhibited significant correlations with soil ALP,which is vital for P cycling for crop nutrition in flooded soils and widely exists in water and soil(Zhuet al.,2013).Soil alkaline phosphatase could significantly increase the rate of conversion of organic P into inorganic P,in addition to the composition and concentration of labile P(Heet al.,2006).Zhuet al.(2013)also reported that soil ALP adsorbed onto minerals,such as goethite,clay,and montmorillonite,could hydrolyze Fe-bound P and increase soil labile P,and that root Fe plaque was mainly composed of ferrihydrite and goethite,which implied that soil ALP significantly influenced root Fe-plaque P.

Fig.4 Correlations of root Fe-plaque P with crop biomass,root total P,and crop total P under the four P fertilization treatments in the seventh year of the field experiment at the Yixing(YX)and Changshu(CS)sites.

Phosphatase exists widely in numerous soil types and plays a major role in soil P turnover(Turner and Haygarth,2005).According to Nashet al.(2014),soil ALP can catalyze the hydrolysis of soil P compounds from organic P into inorganic P compounds,which could increase the concentrations of soil available P.This has also been reported by Wanget al.(2016),who suggested that soil ALP has a significant and positive relationship with labile P.Conversely,according to Liuet al.(2007),soil ALP has a positive correlation with soil total P but had a negative correlation with dissolved inorganic P in sediments.Therefore,the relationships between phosphatase and P concentrations and between phosphatase and P fractions in soils and sediments remain unclear.Consequently,further studies are required to elucidate such relationships.

Fig.5 Soil Olsen-P at the three rice-growth stages under the four P fertilization treatments in the seventh year of the field experiment at the Yixing(YX)and Changshu(CS)sites.Error bars illustrate standard errors of means(n=3).*and**indicate significant differences at P<0.05 and P<0.01,respectively,between the reduced P fertilization treatments(no P fertilization in either season(P0),P fertilization only in the rice-growing season(PR),and P fertilization only in the wheat-growing season(PW))and the P fertilization treatment in the rice-and wheat-growing seasons(PR+W).

Fig.6 Correlations between soil Olsen-P and root Fe-plaque P under the four P fertilization treatments in the seventh year of the field experiment at the Yixing(YX)and Changshu(CS)sites.

Fig.7 Redundancy analysis(RDA)results revealed the effects of some environmental factors on soil Olsen-P and root Fe-plaque P concentrations for 36 soil samples collected at three rice-growth stages under four P fertilization treatments in the seventh year of the field experiment at the Yixing(YX)and Changshu(CS)sites.ACP=acid phosphatase;ALP=alkaline phosphatase.

CONCLUSIONS

Our seven-year field study focusing on the rice-growing seasons at two rice-wheat rotation sites in the Taihu Lake region revealed that P fertilization only in the wheat-growing season could not only ensure adequate soil P supply and rice P uptake but also maintain rice crop biomass.In contrast,a lack of application of P fertilizer during both seasons significantly decreased the soil P supply and rice total P concentration.

ACKNOWLEDGEMENT

This work was funded by The National Key Research and Development Program of China(No.2017YFD0800103),the National Natural Science Foundation of China(No.41671304),and the Key Projects in the National“948” Program during the Twelfth Five-Year Plan Period(No.2011-G30).


登录APP查看全文