Environmental risks for application of iron and steel slags in soils in China:A review
2021-03-17XiaobinWANGXiuyingLIXiangYANChengTUandZhaoguoYU
Xiaobin WANG,Xiuying LI,Xiang YAN,Cheng TU and Zhaoguo YU
Institute of Agricultural Resources and Regional Planning,Chinese Academy of Agricultural Sciences,Beijing 100081(China)
(Received February 28,2019;revised April 30,2019)
ABSTRACT Iron and steel slags are smelting wastes,mainly including blast furnace slag(BFS)and steel slag(SS)produced in the iron and steel industry.Utilization of iron and steel slags as resources for solving the problem of slag disposals has attracted much attention with increasing iron and steel smelting slags in China.Because the iron and steel slags contain calcium(Ca),magnesium(Mg),phosphorus(P),and silicon(Si),some have tried to use them as Si-and P-fertilizers,for producing Ca-Mg-P fertilizers,or as soil amendments in agriculture.However,in the iron metallurgical process,several pollutants in iron ores can inevitably transfer into iron and steel slags,resulting in the enrichment of pollutants both in BFS(mainly nickel(Ni),copper(Cu),mercury,zinc(Zn),cadmium(Cd),chromium(Cr),arsenic,lead,selenium,fluorine(F),and chlorine(Cl))and in SS(mainly Ni,Cr,Cd,Zn,Cu,F,and Cl),in which some of pollutants(especially Cr,Ni,F,and Cl)exceed the limits of environmental quality standards for soils and groundwater.The elements of manganese,barium,and vanadium in iron and steel slags are higher than the background values of soil environment.In order to ensure soil health,food safety,and environmental quality,it is suggested that those industrial solid wastes,such as iron and steel slags,without any pretreatment for reducing harmful pollutants and with environmental safety risk,should not be allowed to use for soil remediation or conditioning directly in farmlands by solid waste disposal methods,to prevent pollutants from entering food chain and harming human health.
Key Words:blast furnace slag,environmental safety risk,heavy metal,industrial solid waste,iron and steel industry,soil pollution
INTRODUCTION
The iron and steel industry(or ferrous slag),also known as the black metallurgical industry,is an industry with ferrous metals,iron(Fe),manganese(Mn),and chromium(Cr),as the main objects of mining,smelting,and calendaring,while the metallurgical slags of iron and steel industry refer to blast furnace slag(BFS),steel slag(SS),and ferroalloy slag produced in the smelting production(Wei,2010),in which BFS and SS account for up to 80%-90%(thus called iron and steel slags).At present,iron and steel slags in China are mainly utilized in industrial uses:i)as paving or building materials,ii)for producing cement,and iii)to return to the smelting process as sintering materials.Some also suggested using iron and steel slags for producing fertilizer or as soil amendment agents in agricultural soils.However,these are still at the research and experimental stages(Qinet al.,2013).Because iron and steel slags contain some elements needed for plant growth(such as calcium(Ca),magnesium(Mg),phosphorus(P),and silicon(Si)),some tried to use them as Si-,P-,and Ca-Mg-P-fertilizers or as Si-Ca-fertilizer in agriculture,mainly in some rice-producing countries,such as Japan and Korea,where the SS was used to supplement Si in rice,while in some countries dominated by upland crops(wheat and cotton),such as in western Europe and USA,SS has been used as a lime fertilizer(Yang,1999).During the 1960s,in China,research on SS as fertilizer,mainly as phosphate fertilizer,was carried out,but suspended due to a number of intractable problems(Yang,1999).In recent years,some experiments were conducted in China to try to use BFS as a Si-fertilizer(Yanget al.,2007;Maet al.,2016)and use SS as a Si-fertilizer(Li,2011;Liang and Guo,2016;Maet al.,2016;Weiet al.,2018)or a SS-based Si-Ca-fertilizer(Ning,2014;Mi,2015;Zhanget al.,2017),and as a soil amendment(Denget al.,2011;Liang,2016;Zhang,2016;Weiet al.,2017).However,because SS contains a certain amount of heavy metals(Zhouet al.,2014),its utilization in agriculture has not been officially suggested(Fanet al.,2017),and its potential risks of environmental safety for agricultural application are very concerned.
We reviewed the literature related to iron and steel slags(BFS and SS),mainly focused on their environmental impacts,and evaluated the risks of environmental safety for the use(disposal)of the iron and steel slags on farmland.CURRENT STATUS OF OUTPUT OF IRON AND STEEL SLAGS IN CHINA
Output of iron and steel slags in China
The smelting slags of iron and steel industry refer to BFS,SS,iron alloy slag,and iron-containing sludge produced in smelting production.According to the Annual Report on Comprehensive Utilization of Resources in China(2014)issued by the National Development and Reform Commission(NDRC,2014),the proportion of each part is about 59%,25%,13%,and 3%,respectively,of which the amount of BFS and SS approximately accounted for 84% of the total amount of smelting slags,usually called as iron and steel slags.According to the statistics,China’s crude steel output in 2016 was 808 million tons.Based on the calculation of China Iron and Steel Industry Association(CISA),the average output of industrial solid wastes(ISWs)from iron and steel enterprises of China in 2016 was about 400 million tons,of which BFS and SS accounted for about 250 million and 100 million tons,respectively.According to the statistics released by the CISA,at present,the utilization efficiency of the ISWs related to BFS and SS(mainly converter slag)in China is up to 95%,which are mainly used as primary building materials,such as cement and concrete.After magnetic separation from SS,the actual utilization efficiency of SS tailings is only about 30%-40%,while the comprehensive utilization efficiencies of BFS and SS in some countries,such as USA,Japan,and Europe,are close to 100%(Wanget al.,2017).
According to Steel Statistical Yearbook 2018(WSA,2018),world crude steel production reached 1 690.5 million tons in 2017.The crude steel production in China(49.2%),Europe(12.6%),Japan(6.2%),India(6.0%),and USA(4.8%)accounted for 78.8% of the total world crude steel production(Fig.1).Guoet al.(2018)reviewed SS utilization in Japan,Europe,USA,and China,showing that the utilization approach of SS in these four regions mainly includes the following fields:internal recycling(20.8%,11.0%,and 7.5%in Japan,Europe,and China,respectively),road construction(36.4%,43.0%,49.7%,and 2.6% in Japan,Europe,USA,and China,respectively),cement production(3.4%,5.0%,3.3%,and 9.3% in Japan,Europe,USA,and China,respectively),civil engineering(30.9%,3.0%,16.0%,and 10.1%in Japan,Europe,USA,and China,respectively),agriculture(3.9% and 3.0% in Japan and Europe,respectively),other uses(7.0%,3.0%,15.4%,and 10.1% in Japan,Europe,USA,and China,respectively),interim storage(19.0% in Europe),and final disposal(13.0%,15.6%,and 70.5% in Europe,USA,and China,respectively).

Fig.1 World crude steel production(data source:WSA,2018).
Sources of iron and steel slags
In the process of iron and steel smelting,a large amount of iron and steel slags is produced and mainly divided into BFS and SS.At present,about 0.6-0.8 tons of BFS in China,compared to 0.27-0.30 tons of BFS in Japan and USA,are discharged when producing 1 ton of raw iron;whereas in the process of steel smelting,about 0.15-0.25 tons of SS are discharged when producing 1 ton of steel(Zhao,2014).The BFS,produced during iron smelting in the blast furnace and formed by the gangue in the ore,the ash in the coke,and the flux,is mainly a component of calcium silicate and calcium aluminosilicate(Zhang,2013).The BFS is a glass state substance formed by the sudden cooling of the BFS when the molten slag of the blast furnace is too cold to crystallize into a vitreous substance(Yuet al.,2015).Furthermore,the vitreous body formed during water quenching has a potential hydraulicity(Zhu and Sun,2015).The BFS has a similar chemical composition to that of cement and a similar strength to that of natural rock(Zhu,2015)because of its chemical composition,including CaO,SiO2,Al2O3,and MgO,accounting for more than 90% of the total(Zhang,2013).As for SS,it is mainly produced from basic oxygen furnace(BOF or converter-furnace)and electric arc furnace(EAF),which are both used in steel making.It is thus divided into BOF-SS and EAF-SS(Proctoret al.,2000).During stainless steel production,EAF-stainless SS and argon oxygen decarburization-stainless SS are generated(Shen and Forssberg,2003).In China,the BOF-SS is larger,accounting for 87.5%,compared to the EAF-SS,accounting for only 12.5% of the total SS(Zhao,2014).The SS is the oxidized material that is generated when lime,dolomite,and other auxiliary materials are added,and oxygen is blown onto the pig iron produced by a blast furnace to remove carbon,phosphorus(P),sulfur(S),and other components to produce crude steel in a BOF(Guoet al.,2018).During the process of steel smelting,the SS is formed by the melting of the impurities in the metal furnace materials(such as mud sand),which is mainly a component of oxides,such as CaO,MgO,FeO,SiO2,and MnO(Guoet al.,2018),and also contains a part of fluorine(F),S,and SS particles(Zhang,2013).The SS is a crystalline material when it is slowly cooled or quenched,in which the proportion of C2S and C3S accounts for more than 50% of the total,thus called as over-fired silicate clinker(Zhu and Sun,2015).The physical properties of SS are similar to those of the over-fired clinker,thus having a potential hydraulicity after superfine grinding(Xinget al.,2015).
ENRICHMENT OF HARMFUL ELEMENTS IN IRON AND STEEL SLAGS
Harmful elements in iron ores
China has been a big importer of iron ores in the world,of which the imports of iron ore accounted for about 68% of the total world imports of iron ore in 2017(WSA,2018).The types of the imported iron ores mainly include fine ore,lump ore,and pellet ore,supplied by more than 30 countries,with Australia,Brazil,and India as the main suppliers(Xu,2010).However,it was reported that in recent years,China imported large amounts of iron ores with high price but low quality,in which even solid wastes were doped by some foreign traders,thus detecting heavy metals and other harmful elements exceeding the standard limits and radioactive elements in some imported samples(Jiet al.,2015;Zhanget al.,2016;Liuet al.,2017).For instance,in March 2014,Rizhao port of China accepted a batch of imported iron ore powder from South Korea.After identification of solid waste properties,the sample analysis showed that imported iron ore was smuggled with solid wastes,such as scrap metal and oxide skin(Jiet al.,2015).Clearly,imported iron ores contain a variety of harmful associated elements,such as arsenic(As),chromium(Cr),lead(Pb),cadmium(Cd),mercury(Hg),and fluorine(F),and some are associated with small amounts of radioactive elements,such as uranium,thorium(Th),radium(Ra),and radon,eventually,they can be transferred to the iron and steel slags(Renet al.,2007).It has been reported(Zhonget al.,2006;Renet al.,2007)that in the process of iron ore smelting,some heavy metal elements in the iron ores,such as As and copper(Cu),are easily reduced into crude iron in the blast furnace,and further enter the steel products in the steel-making process.While Cd and Pb partially remain in the residue slags,Cr mostly remains in the iron and steel products and residue slags,and Hg and F volatilize into the atmosphere during the smelting process.
According to the data analysis sampled from 50 batches of imported iron ores in Beilun port in Ningbo,China in 2004(Renet al.,2007),19 batches of imported iron ores in Tianjin port,China in 2004,132 batches of imported iron ores in Shenzhen port,China during 2001-2004(Zhonget al.,2006),and 229 batches of imported iron ores in Majishan port in Shengsi,China in 2015,it was found that the harmful elements,such as Cd,As,Pb,Cr,zinc(Zn),Cu,Hg,F,and chlorine(Cl)in the iron ores imported from some countries were generally high(Table I).Another report(Liuet al.,2017)on the monitoring of toxic and harmful elements sampled from 4 374 batches of imported iron ores in Jiangsu port,China during April 28,2015-August 1,2017 showed that Pb and As were up to 10 020 and 2 750 mg kg−1,respectively(samples from Brazil),Cd and Hg were up to 35 and 1.47 mg kg−1,respectively(samples from Malaysia),and F and Cl were 4 980(samples from Iran)and 2 214(samples from Peru)mg kg−1,respectively.

TABLE IStatistical dataa)of concentrations of elements in imported iron ores and soil environmental background values in China
Because the properties of iron ores are close to those of the soil,it has been suggested to use the soil as a reference,and usually evaluate the levels of toxic and harmful elements in iron ores with the soil environmental quality standards.The toxic and harmful elements can overflow in the smelting of iron ores under high temperature,thus when the smelting residue slag enters the soil,the pollutant elements in the residue slag will migrate into soil and groundwater,being harmful to humans through pollutant accumulation in water environment and food chain(Zhonget al.,2006).As shown in Table I,compared with China’s soil environmental background values(Weiet al.,1991),the concentrations of heavy metals in the imported iron ores detected were about 38,7,and 5 times higher for Cd,Cu,and Hg,respectively,about 3 times higher for As and vanadium(V),and about 1-2 times higher for Pb,Zn,and Ni.
Main pollution elements in iron and steel slags
The BFS and converter SS are the slags produced in the blast furnace and in the converter-making steel,respectively,which are the ISWs with the largest amount of discharges from iron and steel plants(Zhanget al.,2014).Iron smelting in the blast furnace is a reduction process,that is,some elements of Fe,Cd,Mn,V,titanium(Ti),Cu,and Zn in iron ores are reduced under high temperature with the reducing agents(coke,coal,etc.),and then enter into steel liquid or iron liquid.However,some elements of Si,Ti,P,S,and As,brought in by raw materials in the process of iron smelting,are retained in the iron slag in the form of different compounds and discharged out of the furnace(Wuet al.,2017).Converter-making steel is a redox process,in which the molten iron is used as the main raw material and the scrap steel as the auxiliary material,and the lime,limestone,dolomite,fluorite,silica stone,and bauxite as the solvents.In all steel-making processes,some elements of Fe,Mn,Si,Cr,and Ni in the iron liquid and scrap steel can form oxides into the slag(Wuet al.,2017).As for fluorine pollutants,it involves a large number of industries,including the steel industry,for instance,in which a large amount of fluorine dust,waste water,and residue can be produced when fluorite is added during the steel-making process(Tan,2015).Theiron and steel slags also contain radioactive elements,such as226Ra,232Th,and40K.

TABLE IIStatistical dataa)of concentrations and environmental risk coefficientb)of radionuclides in iron and steel slags
Table II summarizes the statistical data of the concentrations of radioactive elements in iron and steel slags from some steel plants in China and lists the soil background values of natural radionuclides in China(Chenet al.,1988).As shown in Table II,the concentrations of226Ra,232Th,and40K are up to 170,2 620,and 309 Bq kg−1in BFS and 140,799,and 482 Bq kg−1in steel slag,respectively.Compared with the soil background values of natural radionuclides,232Th and226Ra in BFS are about 34 and 2 times higher than the soil background values of natural radionuclides,respectively,and232Th in SS is about 6 times higher than the soil background value of natural radionuclide.
ENVIROMENTAL RISK OF IRON AND STEEL SLAGS IN AGRICULTURE
Soil pollution risk for application of iron and steel slags in farmland
Table III summarizes the statistical data of the concentrations of pollutants in iron and steel slags from some areas in China and lists the concentrations of pollutant elements in iron ores(Table I),China’s soil environmental background values(Weiet al.,1991),the risk screening values for soil contamination of agricultural land in Soil Environmental Quality Risk Control Standard for Soil Contamination of Agricultural Land(GB 15618-2018)(MEE and SAMR,2018),and the refereed critical values for related elements(Wanget al.,1990;Zhang,1994;Liet al.,2005).As shown in Table III,Cr,F,Hg,Cu,Zn,Pb,and Ni enriched in BFS(the ratio of the concentrations of pollutants in BFS to those in iron ores)were about 77,47,33,14,4,4,and 2 times higher,as compared to the pollutant elements in iron ores(Table I).Percentages of V,Cl,As,and Cd transferred from the iron ores to BFS were about 100%,80%,70%,and 40%,respectively,whereas F,Cr,Ni,Zn,V,and Cl enriched in SS(the ratio of concentrations of pollutants in SS to those in iron ores)were about 196,12,4,3,2,and 2 times higher than iron ores,respectively.
As for BFS,the pollutant element concentrations were about 160,129,98,87,15,and 14 times higher for Hg,Cr,Cu,selenium(Se),Cd,and F,respectively;about 4-5 times higher for V,Pb,and Zn;and about 2-3 times higher for As,Mn,and Ni,as compared to China’s soil environmental background.As for SS,the concentrations of pollutant elements were about 59,20,and 10 times higher for F,Cr,and Mn,respectively;about 6-7 times higher for Ni,Se,Cd,and V;and about 2-4 times higher for Hg,Zn,and barium(Ba),as compared to China’s soil environmental background.As for the elements of Mn,Ba,and V,the concentrations were,on average,higher in SS(5 984,2 073,and 552 mg kg−1,respectively),compared to those in BFS(1 434,528,and 331 mg kg−1,respectively).
In comparison with the risk screening values for soil contamination of agricultural land(GB 15618-2018)(MEE and SAMR,2018)and the reference critical value of related elements(Wanget al.,1990;Zhang,1994;Liet al.,2005),the current statistical data of the concentrations of pollutant elements in iron and steel slags from some steel plants in China are shown in Table III.The BFS contains several pollutant elements,of which some exceeded the risk screening values for soil contamination of agricultural land(GB 15618-2018)(MEE and SAMR,2018)or the refereed critical value(Wanget al.,1990),accounting for about 38%-67%of the total samples for Pb,As,Cr,Cd,Zn,Hg,and Cl,and up to 100% for Ni,Cu,Se,and F.Some elements in SS also exceeded the limits,accounting for about 50%-60% of the total samples for Ni and Cr,about 18%-19% for Cu,Zn,and Cd,about 6%-10% for Hg and As,and up to 100% for F and Cl.In addition,BFS and SS had high pH values,ranging 9-11 and 8-14(about 10-11 on average),respectively.
At present,there are still doubts about the environmental safety of iron and steel slags,especially for SS in agricultural use.As reported,the SS,discharged from the steel-making process,is not suitable for direct application in agriculture because SS contains many heavy metals,such as Cr,Cd,Pb,and Zn,which are harmful to soil environment.In addition,about 8% of the reduction slag produced during the steelmaking process contains high levels of S and As(Wuet al.,2017).Another report showed that application of SS,especially stainless SS,into the soils as a calcium-silicate fertilizer,had a potential risk of heavy metal Cr transfer from the SS to soil-plant-groundwater ecosystems(Ning,2014).In addition,as reported,the SS application abroad in fertilizer production are mainly used in forestry,and SS viscous and hydraulic properties can cause soil compaction.Therefore,SS application in agriculture is still a dispute in China(Li,2007).
Extraction risks of harmful elements in iron and steel slags
The extraction of harmful elements in iron and steel slags has certain risks of water environmental safety.There have been many reports on the determination of the concentrations of pollutants in extraction solutions of harmful elements in iron and steel slags(Sun and Wang,2005;Zhanget al.,2008,2012;Shiet al.,2010;Maet al.,2015;Wanget al.,2015;Liuet al.,2016;Yin,2016;Zhuet al.,2016).As a study(Wanget al.,2015)on the determination of heavy metal concentrations in the extraction solution of the blast furnace water quenched slag and referred to Identification Standards for Hazardous Wastes,Identification for Extraction Toxicity(GB 5085.3-2007)(SEPA and AQSIQ,2007),Discharge Standard of Water Pollutants for Iron and Steel Industry(GB 13456-2012)(SEPA and AQSIQ,2012a)or Integrated Wastewater Discharge Standards(GB 8978-1996)(SEPA,1996),Standards for Groundwater Quality(GB/T 14848-2017)(AQSIQ and SAC,2017),and Standards for Drinking Water Quality(GB 5749-2006)(MOH and SAC,2006),the results are shown in Table IV.The leachable concentrations of Cr(0.15 mg L−1)in the blast furnace water quenched slag exceeded the limits(Class V,>0.1 mg L−1)of groundwater quality standards,and leachable concentrations of Ni(0.04 mg L−1)exceeded the limits(Class IV)of groundwater quality standards or the drinking water quality standard limit(<0.02 mg L−1)(MOH and SAC,2006).

y it al qu al nt nme ro vi en il so pH V., 2007;Zhou,2015 al et ng Ya al g,2010;Liu et an Zh.,2016 02 41.9.1 59.10 54 10 38 0.5.80 2.9.3.6.3 421 38 1.33 82 3 41 1.0 4.;., 2011;Qiu et al.,2012; Zhou et al., 2012;Ning,2014;Sun, 2015;Yao et al.,2016;He et al.,2016;Zhang et al.,2017;Wei et al., 2017;Pei et al.,2017;Yang et al., 2017 al et al.,1997 g et an ng Zh De 6;;et al.,2012 g.,2015;Yuan,201 et al.,2011 an g al an et Zh Zh Ma d)ue in nt co be o(t d an s,nt eme el of ntc)ie effic co sk ri nt nme ro vi en d an Ba Mn Cl F al g,2010;Liu et an Zh.,2016., 2007;Zhang,2010;Lin, 2013;Liu et al.,2016 al et ng n, 2013 Ya Li,;ng 13 Ka 20., 2010;Lin, 2013 al et o Ba 62 6.9.15 8.3 412 88 6.52 8.31 15 1 1.1 83.4.6 0.4.33 4 4.820 4313 4113 46 5 2.00 1.1.37 6.4..2.7 616 56 28 15 8 63 0.66 00 0.0.0.9 0..0 80 90 8584 50 0.2.3 0.257 614 10 47 14 10.,2010;Zhang et al.,2011;Ma et al.,2015 al et i Sh i;;;;et al.,2008 17 g 11 et al.,2011 g g.,2015;Yuan,2016;We et al.,2012 al 20 an 20 an an et.,Zh,al Li Zh Zh Ma et,ng 13 Ka 20 g;d an92al et 20 en19.,,Sh al i Li., 2011;Tan14 We et ntb)ie effic co Se u16 Li 20 g,2010;an.,Zh al et.2 0 45.32.3.5 25 8 13 6.0.2 87 0.10,11al.;et 20 i,17 Li We 20 nt me ch ri en Zn;,al.83 19;Ya et.0,n99 Du Re ng et al.,2007; Zhang,2010;Kang,2013;Liu et al.,2016.0 19 15 93 28 13 24 1.7 3..0 40 6.41 7 10 3.4 5.60;;,;i;;et al.,2008 10 Sh;a15 17 g 20 11 20al.i g,2010;20 We 20,an an.,an g g et al.,2012 an,;,;M ng et Zh Zh al,13 ng 14.,o16 al.et Li et al.,2011 Zh Zh Ka 20 Ni al 20 et Ya 20 et a,in Ch in ts an pl l ee st d an Cu Ni;,al.83 19;Ya et,n99 Du ng et al.,2007; Zhang,2010 Re 19 u16 Li 20 g,2010;an.,Zh al et 0 0..000 754 15 8.7 0.463 17 26 0.0 5.22 0.63 13.8.2 0 0.25213 98 10 0.1.5.3 0.92 52 2 26 2.4 3.10,7;et al.,2008 g al;Ya,;W an et i Zh.,2010;Li,2011;Zhang et al.,2011;Zhang et al.,2012;Ning,2014;Suno Sh 15 al.16 20 et ei et al.,201 20;,;a15 20;M g,;an,ng 01 et i et al.,2008 Xi 16 al 20 Zh.,2010;Zhang et al.,2011;Yao et al.Sh al.20 et on ir me so om fr s ag sl l ee st Cr Pb;g., 1999;Yan07 7 al u 5 3 et 20 Li 5.19.7.,84741.an al.6 16 47 3.n Re al.7 8..0 et g,2010;,;Wu et al.,201 Zh et 20 100 0.29 71203 476 12 50;,n99.,1995;Re al.u17 al 19 et 20.,;,et ng 071.9 al 07 an.6.5 Su Zh Ya g,2010;W al.0.6.9.05 et 20 et 811 34 11 12 45 4.4.37;,,,;a15 20al.;,;g;M,et;,;ng an 01 et an et g i Xi.,2010;Li,2011;Zhang et al.,2011;Ning,2014;Sun et al.,2008 al i 15 Sh al.o16 16 17 Zh 20 20 et 20 Ya Yu 20 et al.,2017al.an Zh We 20;ng,;an g 01.,2010;Li,2011;Zhang et al.,2011;Zhang et al.,2012;Ning,2014;Ma et al.,201 i al Xi 20 et al.,2008 et Zh Sh 5; Yao et al., 2016;Zhang et al.,2017;Wei et al., 2017 d an on ir in s nt eme el of ns As Cd 7 u Li g,2010;an Zh.,2016;al et Wu et al.,201.,1995;Ya al et Su ng et al.,2007; Zhang,2010;Wu et al.,2017.4 0 62.48 00 00 70.5..4.1.0 25 27 20 8.0.3 2.50 48 95.2.1 1.74 1.4 0.0.15 57,;et,;;g.,2010;Li,2011;Zhang et al.,2012;Ning,2014;Sun an al et i ng 01 an i Xi 20 et al.,2008 Sh Zh 15 g 20 et al.,2017al Zh;., 2017 We;,,;et al.,2017al.20,;;Ya16 et al.,2008;al g g,ng an 01 et an et i i Xi 20 Zh.,2010;Li,2011;Ning,2014;Suno Sh 15 al.20 17 et Zh We 20 io at tr en al nc.,2017 co s ofrd Hg g,2010;Wu et an Zh da taa)an ag sl st e I l II da ac s l ro rn LE ca nt ce ti fu ur TAB co is t at sk ag So as St ri Sl Bl,;g.,2010;Ning,2014;Zhang et al.,2017;Wei et al.07,;al 10.0.301 82.4 5 et 9..7 ng an i 01 17 30.30 107.33 15 66 Xi 20 Sh et al.,2008 20 Zh))kg−1)19.ze al risk coefficient kg−1(mg kg−1)(mgkg−1 nt si si le(mg)nme(mg le me s mp x.n.ro(%ch Ma ag Source e.SD ri vi CV Av Sa Mi nt coefficient ze over-limit ratio(%)mp sl En En Sa l ee St

68 2 pH 2894.9.3.2 7.13 39 11 1.12 00 6.2.V 524 83 68 1.2..3 55 29 1 41 2.7 6.050 05.2.5.3 Ba 0.43 426 07 578.72315 4 4.0 0.5 Mn 90 1.933 13 47 4.2.98 4 334.5446.3 10 00 9.9.Cl 566 75 0 5..3.2 70 49 1 63 2.0 0.10 00g)≤2 0 00.0.F131050 469 59 1.9.0 36 650.6 28 22055.119.3 59 0 0.10)00f≤8 e)Se 50 20.3.88 1.8 1.6.1 6.0 0.≤3 0 5.317 Zn 16599 5.5.6.9.228 73 6 10 2.8 3..8 18 00≤2 n.io at ri va Cu .0 115 4.60 0 Ni 04.80.50 0 0..0.3 30 13 17 2 20.09 5.2..3 16 20 9 26 3.3 1.1 6..2 18.0 50 0≤5 0≤6 of nt ieffic oe=c CV n;io 0127 0.2.5.1..9 Cr 25056 2.22 96 03 611411.0 20.0 60 50≤1 at.vi I)de le.rd ab I)da(T le an e ab st lu(T va.0.4.2.6 0 es Pb 240 nd 0.50 13 18 5 45 0.5 0.0 0.≤7 SD=or ou on e;gr ir ag ck in er av ba at il.0).0 As 210.6 th 0.90 1 9.22 22 8.0.8 0.5 9.≤2 e.=so to 18 to Av ag 20 ag,sl in sl m;63 Cd 00 2100 36 74.0.3 2 5≤0 nnSAMR in mu.0.5.0.1.0.0.6.19 io xi io maat d at 0)tr an tr.99 en.E 5)4)x.=en(1 nc nc 9900 Maco(2al .(ME(1 it et)0.35 0 1800.5≤0 ed 1.co 0..382 Hg 132 4 6 nt nt gal.nu 0.2.5.lim an)09.m;eme eme ng et))ti Zh kg−1 kg−1 al risk coefficient Wa mu el 18 on(c ze nt ni el Li of 20 om 8-ze over-limit ratio(%)om om I si)fr frfr(mg nt coefficient II nme mi)kg−1 le(mg lim td)me si oo le 61(%ddd ch ro n.n.=ti x.LE ti mp e.ri vi mp mi ed ra ra ce ce 15 ce Sa ur of SD TAB ur(mg kg−1)(mgkg−1 Mi Ma CV Av En En ur Sa li rr ee ag fe Th Sl(mg GB it (mg kg−1)Re Mi GB So So a)b)Th c)d)e)So f)g)
The leachable concentrations of pollutants in SS were generally higher(Sun and Wang,2005;Zhanget al.,2008,2012;Shiet al.,2010;Maet al.,2015;Yin,2016;Zhuet al.,2016)than in BFS.As shown in Table IV,the leachable concentrations of Hg,Cd,As,Pb,Cr,Ni,Mn,Ba,and cyanide(CN−)in SS exceeded the limits(Class V)of Groundwater Quality Standards(GB/T 14848-2017)(AQSIQ and SAC,2017),and the leachable concentrations of Cr,Pb,Mn,and CN−exceeded the limits of Water Pollutant Discharge Standard for Iron and Steel Industry(GB 13456-2012)(SEPA and AQSIQ,2012a)(or Integrated Wastewater Discharge Standards(GB 8978-1996)(SEPA,1996)).The leachable concentration of V in SS exceeded the limits(≤0.05 mg L−1)of Quality Standards for Surface Water(GB 3838-2002)(AQSIQ,2002).
It is suggested that the extraction of heavy metal elements in SS is mainly due to the damage of the structure of Ca2SiO4·H2O(C-S-H)(Maet al.,2015).Some studies on the identification for extraction toxicity of heavy metals in stainless SS showed that the maximum leachable concentrations of Cr and Ni in stainless SS of a steel plant were up to 38.8 and 7.0 mg L−1,respectively(Sun and Wang,2005),which exceeded the limits(<15 and<5 mg L−1,respectively)of Identification Standards for Hazardous Wastes-Identification for Extraction Toxicity(GB 5085.3-2007)(SEPA and AQSIQ,2007),belonging to hazardous wastes.The results indicated that some of the pollutants in iron and steel slags,especially in SS,may infiltrate into groundwater,posing a potential threat to soil and water environmental safety.
Prediction of long-term accumulation of pollutants from iron and steel slags in farmland
Whether iron and steel slags can be used in agriculture or not,it should be considered about the aspects of yield benefit performance,but also the environmental safety,especiallythe long-term impacts of iron and steel slags applied in farmland soils.The annual application amount of iron and steel slags is one of the important factors to evaluate the risks of soil environmental safety.As reported,the range of the annual dosage of iron and steel slags in China is about 2-50 t ha−1(Yanget al,2007;Denget al.,2011;Li,2011;Ning,2014;Mi,2015;Maet al.,2016;Liang and Guo,2016;Liang,2016;Zhang,2016,2017;Weiet al.,2017,2018).For example,if the iron and steel slags at a large dose is applied to farmland in a long-term,the pollutants carried by the slags may gradually accumulate in soil over years.Table V shows the estimated over-limit years(based on predicted cumulative loading of elements)associated with different rates of the slags in farmland,according to the concentration of pollutants in both BFS and SS,as compared with the risk screening values for soil contamination of agricultural land(GB 15618-2018)(MEE and SAMR,2018).

TABLE IVComparison between leachable concentrations of the elements in iron and steel slagsa)and limits of national environmental quality standard for hazardous pollutants
Taking Cr as an example,according to the concentrations of Cr in BFS and SS(up to 29 476 and 6 560 mg kg−1,respectively)(Table III),the estimated cumulative amount of Cr in soil could be about 66 and 15 t ha−1year−1,respectively(assuming the input of each slag is 2.25 t ha−1year−1,with no leaching).Thus,the accumulation of Cr from un-contaminated to contaminated soils(up to 337.5 kg ha−1,equivalent to 150 mg kg−1),beyond the risk screening values for soil contamination of agricultural land(MEE and SAMR,2018),would need 5 and 23 years,respectively.If the input of each slag is 9 t ha−1year−1,with no leaching,the accumulation of Cr,Hg,Cd,Ni,and F from uncontaminated to contaminated soils would need 1,4,15,88 and 25 years,respectively,for BFS,and 6,93,15,30 and 3 years,respectively,for SS.It could be concluded that BFS or SS is added at a large dose each year,the accumulation of pollutants in soil might exceed the limits of the risk screening values for soil contamination of agricultural land,thus having the infiltration risks of pollutants into groundwater,especially for some pollutants in SS,such as Cr and Ni,but also Hg,Cd,As,Pb,Mn,Ba and CN−(Table IV).
DISCUSSION
In China,the comprehensive utilization efficiency of SS is relatively lower(about 30%)than that of BFS(about 82%)(NDRC,2014),but it is also lower compared with that of SS in Europe(about 87%).As Guoet al.(2018)reported,SS is largely used for internal recycling,road construction,civil engineering,and cement production(for instance,about 92%,62% and 66%,in Japan,Europe and USA,respectively),but in China,it is mostly treated by land disposal(about 71%).Among the various uses,only a small amount of SS is used in agriculture(about 3% in Europe in 2000)(EUROSLAG and EUROFER,2012).However,in northern Europe,such as in Germany,there is a long tradition of using SS as fertilizers and liming materials(Brancaet al.,2014).Several studies have reported the use of SS for acidic soil amendment,such as in northern Europe(Lopezet al.,1995)and Guilan of Iran(Ali and Shahram,2007),or for replacing commercial fertilizers,such as in Brazil(Pereiraet al.,2004)and western Spain(Peregrinaet al.,2008),but also for balancing negative Na effects in alkaline Mediterranean soils,such as in Italy in only few studies(Brancaet al.,2014).Although the use of SS for agricultural purposes is not new,the use of SS may affect human health and environment because of the heavy metals inside,which can leach into groundwater or be transferred to surface water,and accumulate in soils and food chain.However,until now,fewstudies have investigated the possible risks associated with the presence of trace elements,and the lack of knowledge regarding the bioavailability of trace metals in SS application to agricultural soils,especially the most abundant,Cr and V,is one of the main concerns(Mäkeläet al.,2012).Some recent investigations have focused on the assessment of risks to the environment based on SS application in agriculture as discussed below.

TABLE VAssumed cumulative loadings of elements that could result from iron and steel slag application to soil and estimated over-limit years(hypothetical assumption)
Environmental impacts affected by iron and steel slags in land application
Generally,SS is thought to be one of the main contamination sources affecting the environment.This is due to the contamination by heavy metals in soil and nearby water where SS has accumulated(Gómez-Nublaet al.,2017).According to EUROSLAG and EUROFER(2012),in Europe,SS in particular is often considered as waste,especially in liquid state and before treatment.Many studies observed that the massively deposited SS could lead to the pollution of soil and groundwater due to the leaching of certain potentially toxic elements,such as Cd,Cr,Cu,Pb,Ni,and Zn(Roadcapet al.,2005).Garcia-Guineaet al.(2010)also reported that high heavy metal(mainly Cr,Pb,Cu,Co,Zn,and V)concentrations,due to heaps of deposited SS accumulated during more than 40 years,have been found in several pathways and farmland soils from the southern part of Madrid(Spain).Recent and specific investigations(Pistocchiet al.,2017)carried out to evaluate the effects and possible risks of the use of BOF-SS in agriculture,through a 3 year lysimeter trial in Italy soils,observed that the wheat yield was lower in the SS-amended soil,although the SS decreased the exchangeable Na percentage.This study indicated that the lower productivity of durum wheat could be attributed to V,or a combined effect of V and Cr added with SS,thus suggesting that the accumulation in topsoil and the bioavailability of trace metals,particularly V and Cr,are some of the most important aspects to take into account when planning repeated applications of SS.Another study on the application of steel industry waste,which is produced through EAF-SS,generating two types of slags,black and white slags,as a filler in two forest tracks of the Basque Country(northern Spain),filled with black and white slags 19 and 35 years ago,respectively,showed that some of the more leached elements from the black slag(Cr,Se,W,Mn,and Mo)and white slag(Na,Co,Ni,and Cu)coincided with the elements of highest concentrations found in the soil samples(Gómez-Nublaet al.,2017).This study indicated that some areas of both forest tracks could be considered contaminated by Cr according to the standard values from the Basque regulation,posing a risk to human health as they are recreational areas.In a study on forest soil amendment with SS in Northern Finland,Mäkeläet al.(2012)also found that the use of SS led to significant increases in the total concentrations of Cr and V,with about 80.6% of the total Cr(370 mg kg−1)in the residual fraction,but 46.0% of the total V(2 470 mg kg−1)in the easily reduced fraction,indicating potential bioavailability.In a study on the environmental impacts of SS reused in road construction,Chaurandet al.(2007)reported that V,which was predominantly present in the 4+oxidation state,seemed to become oxidized to its pentavalent form(the most toxic form)during leaching.
Persistent organic pollutants associated with emissions of iron and steel industry
Except for inorganic pollutants discharged from iron and steel industry as above mentioned,there are also several organic contaminants,called persistent organic pollutants(POPs),including polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons(PAHs),polychlorinated biphenyls(PCBs),polychlorinated naphthalenes(PCNs),and polybrominated diphenyl ethers(PBDEs),and polychlorinated dibenzo-p-dioxins and dibenzofurans(PCDD/Fs)(Odabasiet al.,2016;Liet al.,2017),which are generated from the three main processes(coal carbonization coking,EAF smelting,and sintering processes)of the iron and steel industry(Donget al.,2014)and exposed at iron and steel enterprise sites.As Li and Liu(2016)reported,the POPs at iron and steel enterprise sites in China are usually adsorbed by soil and accumulate in unsaturated layers.When the concentration of POPs in the soil is at a high level and exists for a long time,the POPs can migrate downward along the soil pores.Liet al.(2017)measured several POPs produced during iron ore sintering processes in China,and found that PCBs were the most abundant compounds by mass,while PCNs were the next most abundant,contributing 51% and 42% to the total POP concentration,respectively.However,PCDD/Fs were the dominant contributors to the chlorinated and brominated POP toxic equivalent concentrations,contributing 89% to the total toxic equivalent concentration.Odabasiet al.(2016)investigated the spatial distributions of POPs in the Iskenderun industrial region in Turkey,where the iron and steel plants are the most important POP sources.They found significant correlations of ambient air levels to those measured in soil,litter,and tree components,showing that POPs were exchanged between atmosphere and these compartments.The results also showed that in terms of the overall inventory,including trees,litter,and soil,the highest accumulated quantities of POPs were found in soil followed by trees and litter,indicating that in addition to soil,vegetation is a notable reservoir accumulating POPs.
As Liuet al.(2018)reviewed on emissions of POPs(PCDD/Fs)from iron and steel industry in China,the data(in 2004)showed that the emissions from the Chinese iron and steel industry(data including other metal production)were the largest contributor for the total emissions of PCDD/Fs in China(about 45%).In order to control and reduce the emissions of PCDD/Fs from iron ore sintering process in China,the Emission Standard of Air Pollutants for Sintering and Pelletizing of Iron and Steel Industry(GB 28662-2012)(SEPA and AQSIQ,2012b)was implemented on January 1,2015,which stipulates the limits of PCDD/Fs emissions for existing-and newly-built enterprises(1.0 and 0.5 ng toxic equivalent quantity m−3,respectively).Since POPs,classified as carcinogenic to humans by the International Agency for the Research on Cancer(IARC,1997),persist in the environment,can bioaccumulate through the food chain and pose a risk of causing adverse effects to human health and environment.The potential environmental risks of POP pollution,especially those exposed at iron and steel enterprise sites,have gained increasing attention in recent years.
Environmental regulations and standards regarding land application of iron and steel slags
As mentioned above,the use of iron and steel slags for agricultural purposes has a long history in Europe,and the slag application to agricultural soils is allowed in some European countries.However,to date,there is no common regulation in the European Union(Pistocchiet al.,2017).For instance,in Italy,BFS is used for cement production,whereas BOF-SS without iron(inert slag)is used as landfill cover,in compliance with Italian legislation(Brancaet al.,2014).According to Pistocchiet al.(2017),in Italy,the application of slags to agricultural soils is forbidden because slags are classified as waste.According to EUROSLAG and EUROFER(2012),the classification of ferrous slags is not uniform in European countries,as in some member states,they are considered as non-wastes,products,or by-products,but they have a waste status in some other countries due to collective expertise and agreements with environmental authorities in various countries.Steel slag,in particular,is often considered as waste,especially in the liquid state and before treatment.Concerning the health and environmental protection,national regulations are still to be applied as no common European standards or regulations regarding the evaluation of harmful substances are yet available.Most European countries have developed their own directives and regulations as a basis for marketing by-products or secondary raw materials/products.
In USA,slags are surface materials that are present in both industrial and residential settings,and reuse of land containing slag is commonplace.However,the concentrations of some elements in the various slag types exceed generic environmental guidelines based on multiple exposure pathways(Piataket al.,2015).For instance,according to a review from Piataket al.(2015),as compared to soil screening levels for slag use,the elements present at concentrations that exceed the environmental criteria in ferrous slags are As,Cr,and Mn.Nearly all ferrous slag samples exceeded the As and Mn residential guideline(USEPA,2010).The Cr in the samples of nearly all SS and a few BFS(reaching 32 700 and 9 580 mg kg−1,respectively)exceeded agricultural,residential,and industrial(64,64,and 87 mg kg−1,respectively)soil screening guidelines(CCME,2007).
China faces the current environmental problems of soil and water pollution related to the large amount of ISW discharge and stackpiling.Several environmental policies,regulations,and standards for soil pollution prevention and control have been successively promulgated,in which strict restrictions on the disposal of ISWs to farmland have been set.For instance,in 2015,the Environmental Protection Law of China was implemented,saying that those solid waste and waste water that do not conform to the agricultural standards and the environmental protection standards should be forbidden to apply into farmlands(in Article 49).In 2016,the Action Plan for Soil Pollution Prevention and Control was released by the State Council(China),stating that it should be strictly prohibited to use municipal waste,sludge,and ISWs directly as fertilizers.In 2017,the Identification Standards for Solid Wastes General Rules(GB 34330-2017)was issued by SEPA and AQSIQ(2017),which involved the identification,disposal,recycling,and management of solid wastes,clearly stipulating that the solid waste residues from industrial production processes,including BFS and SS produced in the process of ferrous metal smelting or processing,are classified as solid wastes(in Article 4.2);and that the solid wastes directly applied to the land as a soil amendment,or used in land reclamation,land restoration,and other land use patterns are still considered as solid waste management(in Article 5.1).In 2018,the Soil Pollution Prevention and Control Law of China was issued,stipulating that ISWs,domestic wastes,or contaminated soils with high levels of heavy metals or other toxic and harmful pollutants which exceed the national standard-limits should be prohibited to use for land reclamation(in Article 33).
According to GB 34330-2017,the identification standard of solid waste strictly defines whether the industrial wastes are a solid waste or a product.As a product produced by using ISWs,the following three critical conditions must be met:i)the limits of relevant national,local,or prevailing industrial quality standards used for substituted raw materials;ii)the requirements of relevant national pollutant discharge standards or technical specifications.In case of no relevant national pollution control standards,the contents of harmful components in the products by using solid wastes are not higher than that in the products by using substituted raw materials;and iii)the market demands.Failure to meet the above three conditions is classified as solid waste management(in Article 5.2).With regard to the utilization of ISWs as resources,for smelting slags(excluding hazardous waste),referring to solid waste generated in the metal smelting process,mainly including BFS,BOF-SS,EAF-SS,ferroalloy slag,and other metal smelting slags,the comprehensive utilization as products has been listed mainly as building materials,such as slag powder,concrete and mineral admixture;cement and cement clinker,sintering flux,and flue gas desulfurizer in the National Catalogue of Products for the Comprehensive Utilization of Industrial Solid Waste Resources issued by the No.26[2018]of the Ministry of Industry and Information Technology(MIIT,2018).
Ferrous slag,especially SS,contains many heavy metals,especially Cr and V,which can potentially leach into nearby waters,and are found in agricultural soils(Garcia-Guineaet al.,2010;Pistocchiet al.,2017)and recreational areas(Gómez-Nublaet al.,2017).It has also been found in residential soils where slags are used for construction purposes(Chaurandet al.,2007;Piataket al.,2015).The use of SS may affect soil quality and result in the accumulation of pollutants in vegetables,and finally in human food chain,posing a risk to human health(Gómez-Nublaet al.,2017).Therefore,environmental regulations and standards,especially regarding the use of iron and steel slags for agricultural purposes or soil remediation,should be taken into consideration to evaluate and avoid the environmental risks.
CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS
In order to solve the problem of the disposal of iron and steel slags,some tried to use them as fertilizer or as soil amendment in agriculture.However,related studies on pollutants in iron and steel slags show that several poisonous and harmful elements transfer into iron and steel slags during the process of iron ore smelting,resulting in environmental safety risks in the use of BFS and SS.Firstly,the risks of heavy metal pollution exist from iron and steel slags.Some heavy metals in BFS exceeded the limits of the risk screening values for soil contamination of agricultural land(GB 15618-2018),accounting for about 38%-67% of the total samples for Pb,As,Cr,Cd,Zn,and Hg and up to 100% for Ni and Cu;while Ni and Cr in about 50%-60% of the total SS samples exceed the limits,with about 18%-19% for Cu,Zn,and Cd and about 6%-10% for Hg and As.For Mn,Ba,and V,the concentrations in the iron and steel slags are higher than the soil environmental background values.The Mn and V in BFS are about 3-4 times higher,and the Ba,V,and Mn in SS are about 4-10 times higher than soil environmental background values.In addition,the leachable concentrations of some pollutant elements,such as Cr,Ni,Pb,Mn,and Ba,in the iron and steel slags,especially in SS,also exceed the limits(Class V)of Groundwater Quality Standard(GB/T 14848-2017).Some harmful elements(such as Cr)in SS exceed the limit of Identification Standards for Hazardous Wastes-Identification for Extraction Toxicity(GB 5085.3-2007).Secondly,the BFS contains high levels of Se(up to 32 mg kg−1),far exceeding the refereed critical value(3 mg kg−1)by up to 100% of the total samples,thus having the risks of Se pollution to farmland and groundwater.Thirdly,the BFS and SS contain high levels of F(up to 7 900 and 69 500 mg kg−1,respectively),far exceeding the refereed critical value(800 mg kg−1)in soils of endemic fluorosis areas in China,by up to 100% of the total samples,thus having the risks of F pollution to farmland and groundwater.Fourthly,the BFS and SS are strongly alkaline(pH up to 11-14)and contain high concentrations of chloride(Cl up to 560-760 mg kg−1),exceeding the refereed critical value(200 mg kg−1),by up to 67%-100% of the total samples,easily leading to soil salinization and groundwater pollution,which would affect crop growth.Fifthly,the iron and steel slags contain radioactive elements.The concentrations of232Th and226Ra in BFS are about 34 and 2 times greater than the soil background values,respectively,and232Th in SS is about 6 times higher than the natural radionuclide background value in China.Sixthly,the iron and steel slags have hydraulicity,thus easily resulting in soil compaction and degradation of soil physical structure.
The range of the application rate of iron and steel slags in China is about 2-50 t ha−1.The impacts of applying iron and steel slags at large doses over the long term to farmland may lead to excessive accumulation of pollutants in soil within a few years,endangering the safety of soil,water environment,and human health.There are many kinds of pollutants in iron and steel slags,and the degree of pollution is mainly related to the quality of the iron ores imported from different countries.In the process of iron and steel smelting,some toxic and harmful elements in iron ores eventually can be transferred into the iron and steel slags,easily causing environmental pollution when directly used as soil amelioration agents in farmland.In order to ensure soil health,food safety,and environmental quality,it is suggested that those ISWs,such as iron and steel slags without any pretreatment for reducing harmful pollutants,should not be used for soil remediation or conditioning directly into farmland by solid waste disposal methods,to prevent hazardous pollutants from entering the food chain and harming human health.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
The study was supported by the Special Program for Fertilizer Registration of Ministry of Agriculture and Rural Affairs of China(No.2130109).
杂志排行
Pedosphere的其它文章
- Notes to Authors
- Agricultural and environmental challenges in agroecosystems
- In Commemoration of Professor Tianren YU’s 100th Anniversary
- Microbial diversity assembled from series-diluted suspensions of diseasesuppressive soil determines pathogen invasion resistance
- Global patterns of phosphorus transformation in relation to latitude,temperature and precipitation
- Chemical and spectroscopic characteristics of humic acid from a clay loam soil in Ontario after 52 years of consistent fertilization and crop rotation
