APP下载

从萧齐宗室之争考察刘勰之丕植优劣论

2020-12-18周兴陆

安徽师范大学学报 2020年6期

周兴陆

摘 要:刘勰在《文心雕龙》中花费较多笔墨辨析曹丕曹植的优劣,是有深心用意的。历史上的“扬植抑丕”论是被建构起来的“旧谈”,刘勰严正地对之加以批驳,对曹氏兄弟的文学成就作出新的评判。曹植不仅是文人,更是宗王。联系萧齐皇室的宗王斗争来看,刘勰对曹植任性使气的裁抑,是着眼于对萧齐政局的关注和担忧,这对于保护宗王全身远害和稳定朝政,都有意义。这是刘勰论曹丕曹植的现实考量。

中图分类号:I06文献标志码:A文章编号:1001-2435(2020)06-0001-06

关键词:刘勰;曹植;宗王;萧齐;宗室之争

Abstract: In the work of The Literary Mind and the Carving of Dragons, Liu Xie compared Cao Pi and Cao Zhi on purpose. Liu Xie disproved the long-term view of praising Cao Zhi and depreciating Cao Pi which was constructed in the history and then put forward a new perspective. Cao Zhi was not only a scholar, but also a king. Based on the royal conflict in the Qi Dynasty,  Liu Xie concerned the political scene of Qi Dynasty, so he depreciated Cao Zhi literary talents. His purpose was to protect the kings of Qi Dynasty and to stabilize the political situation. His practical consideration was implied in his comments on Cao Pi and Cao Zhi.

曹丕與曹植的兄弟恩怨、才性高下,为世人所津津乐道,是政治史和文学史上一个备受争议的话题。总体上看,扬植抑丕者多,褒丕贬植者少。刘勰《文心雕龙》对曹氏兄弟多有评论,特别是《才略》篇尤为详细。刘勰说:“魏文之才,洋洋清绮,旧谈抑之,谓去植千里。然子建思捷而才俊,诗丽而表逸;子桓虑详而力缓,故不竞于先鸣;而乐府清越,《典论》辩要,迭用短长,亦无懵焉。但俗情抑扬,雷同一响,遂令文帝以位尊减才,思王以势窘益价,未为笃论也。”[1]700《才略》篇以1423字简要品评98位文人的文才识略,竟花费90个字来辨析曹氏兄弟,而且采用的是辩驳口气,可谓是具深心,有用意的。

刘勰论文学,“同之与异,不屑古今”[1]727,富有独立不倚的精神,因此不满于“雷同一响”;他所持的是大文学观,把《典论》之类子书也纳入范围,不同于他人仅仅就诗赋衡量曹丕、曹植的高下。但这还不足以彻底解释为什么刘勰如此严正地批驳“旧谈”“俗情”而对曹氏兄弟作出新的评判。……

登录APP查看全文