Quantifying key model parameters for wheat leaf gas exchange under different environmental conditions
2020-08-10ZHAOFunianZHOUShuangxiWANGRunyuanZHANGKaiWANGHelingYUQiang
ZHAO Fu-nian , ZHOU Shuang-xi, WANG Run-yuan, ZHANG Kai, WANG He-ling, YU Qiang
1 Key Laboratory of Water Cycle & Related Land Surface Processes/Institute of Geographic Sciences and Natural Resources Research, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100101, P.R.China
2 College of Resources and Environment, University of Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100049, P.R.China
3 Key Laboratory of Arid Climatic Change and Disaster Reduction of Gansu Province/Key Laboratory of Arid Climate Change and Disaster Reduction of China Meteorological Administration (CMA)/Lanzhou Institute of Arid Meteorology, CMA, Lanzhou 730020,P.R.China
4 The New Zealand Institute for Plant and Food Research Limited, Hawke’s Bay 4130, New Zealand
5 State Key Laboratory of Soil Erosion and Dryland Farming on the Loess Plateau/Institute of Soil and Water Conservation,Northwest A&F University, Yangling 712100, P.R.China
6 School of Life Sciences, University of Technology Sydney, Sydney 2000, Australia
Abstract The maximum carboxylation rate of Rubisco (Vcmax) and maximum rate of electron transport (Jmax) for the biochemical photosynthetic model, and the slope (m) of the Ball-Berry stomatal conductance model influence gas exchange estimates between plants and the atmosphere. However, there is limited data on the variation of these three parameters for annual crops under different environmental conditions. Gas exchange measurements of light and CO2 response curves on leaves of winter wheat and spring wheat were conducted during the wheat growing season under different environmental conditions.There were no significant differences for Vcmax, Jmax or m between the two wheat types. The seasonal variation of Vcmax, Jmax and m for spring wheat was not pronounced, except a rapid decrease for Vcmax and Jmax at the end of growing season. Vcmax and Jmax show no significant changes during soil drying until light saturated stomatal conductance (gssat) was smaller than 0.15 mol m-2 s-1. Meanwhile, there was a significant difference in m during two different water supply conditions separated by gssat at 0.15 mol m-2 s-1. Furthermore, the misestimation of Vcmax and Jmax had great impacts on the net photosynthesis rate simulation, whereas, the underestimation of m resulted in underestimated stomatal conductance and transpiration rate and an overestimation of water use efficiency. Our work demonstrates that the impact of severe environmental conditions and specific growing stages on the variation of key model parameters should be taken into account for simulating gas exchange between plants and the atmosphere. Meanwhile, modification of m and Vcmax (and Jmax) successively based on water stress severity might be adopted to simulate gas exchange between plants and the atmosphere under drought.
Received 8 April, 2019 Accepted 29 July, 2019
ZHAO Fu-nian, E-mail: zhaofn@iamcma.cn; Correspondence YU Qiang, E-mail: yuq@igsnrr.ac.cn
© 2020 CAAS. Published by Elsevier Ltd. This is an open access article under the CC BY-NC-ND license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/).
Keywords: biochemical photosynthetic model, stomatal conductance model, maximum carboxylation rate of Rubisco,maximum rate of electron transport, drought
1. Introduction
Gas exchange between leaf and the atmosphere plays a critical role for plant growth and survival in various environmental conditions (Kosugi and Matsuo 2006). It includes two main processes, the uptake of carbon dioxide from the atmosphere for photosynthesis and the release of water vapor from the plant for transpiration. These two processes are regulated by the aperture, or the conductance of stomas, on the leaf surface. However, multiple signal transduction mechanisms contribute to opening and closing of the aperture of stomas, involving both biochemical and biophysical aspects, and they are still not fully understood(Buckley and Mott 2013).
A large number of models have been commonly used in simulating stomatal conductance (Damour et al. 2010).Among others, the Ball-Berry (BB) Model (Ball et al. 1987)is the most commonly utilised empirical model. It estimates stomatal conductance (gs) based on net photosynthesis(Pn), carbon dioxide (Cs) and relative humidity (RHs) at the leaf surface. In the BB Model, Csand RHscan be easily obtained by meteorological factors and plant leaf characters, whereas the Pncan not be observed easily or calculated directly from meteorological data. Therefore,the Biochemical Photosynthetic Model for computing Pn(Farquhar et al. 1980) was adopted to couple with the BB Model for estimating gas exchange between plants and the atmosphere. The linking of these two models has proven to be hugely popular and has accurately simulated gas exchange for a large number of plant species at the leaf and canopy scales (Yu et al. 2002; Wang et al. 2006), as well as on regional and global scales (De Kauwe et al. 2015).
The maximum carboxylation rate of Rubisco (Vcmax) and maximum rate of electron transport (Jmax) in the Biochemical Photosynthetic Model represent the intrinsic photosynthetic capacity of leaf (Egea et al. 2011). The slope (m) of the BB Model reflects a compromised relation between the benefits and costs of gsrelative to leaf photosynthetic activity (Ball et al. 1987). These three parameters are the most important model parameters for leaf gas exchange simulation. Misestimation of their values influences gas exchange simulation results greatly (Bauerle et al. 2014;Rogers 2014; Ali et al. 2015). Because it is time-consuming to obtain robust values by observation, these parameters have been mainly specified from literature and short-term measurements in field, pot or greenhouse. Meanwhile,identical and fixed values of these parameters have been used to simulate gas exchange in a large number of models for different species under various environmental conditions.However, their values vary not only with different species and functional types (Zhou et al. 2013), but also with diverse environmental conditions (Bunce 1998; Medlyn et al. 2002). At present, the great variation of biochemical photosynthetic model parameters and m for the BB Model between different species and plant functional types have been commonly accepted (Medlyn et al. 2002; Zhou et al.2013; Miner et al. 2016). The impacts of environmental factors, such as temperature, carbon dioxide, water, and radiation, on these parameters also have been widely discussed (Bunce 1998; Muraoka et al. 2010; Ali et al. 2015;Miner and Bauerle 2017). However, the results of variation of these model parameters under different environmental conditions often disagree with each other. For example,several land surface models take m as a constant for plants under both well-watered and water deficit conditions, and they change Vcmaxand Jmaxas drought develops (Sellers et al. 1996; Colello et al. 1998). On the contrary, a larger number of researchers suggest reducing m to simulate gas exchange between plant and the atmosphere as drought occurs (Beeck et al. 2010; Raab et al. 2015). Nevertheless,Xu and Baldocchi (2003) observed that m remained constant for blue oak during the whole growing season while severe water stress and extremely high air temperature affected the other two parameters, Vcmaxand Jmax.
Furthermore, a large number of previous researchers evaluated the effect of various environmental conditions on key model parameters, mainly focusing on trees(Baldocchi 1997; Xu and Baldocchi 2003; Osuna et al.2015). Nevertheless, annual crops play critical roles in determining water and energy exchange between vegetation and the atmosphere in some areas of the world, especially in arid and semi-arid areas (Vote et al. 2015). Meanwhile,the life cycle of annual crops has unique characteristics.The whole growing season of annual crops is commonly limited to 1 year, and its morphological indexes might change greatly during a short period with different phenological stages (Ahuja et al. 2008). Recently, some crop models have used leaf gas exchange to simulate crop growth and yield formation, and to evaluate the effect of environmental factors on these processes taking global changes impact on crops into account (Fleisher et al. 2015; Masutomi et al.2016; Seidel et al. 2016). This highlights the need for determining the variation of key model parameters of annual crops for accurate gas exchange simulation under different environmental conditions (Miner and Bauerle 2017, 2019).
Wheat (Triticum aestivum L.) is a typical annual crop,comprising the third largest crop in the world, and mainly grown in semi-humid, semi-arid and even some arid areas,under irrigation or totally rainfed condition (Wang et al.2009). The prediction and quantification of carbon dioxide and water exchange for wheat cropland is very critical for agricultural water use and management in these areas.Hence, in this study, the leaf gas exchange of two wheat types during different growth stages under well-watered and drought conditions were measured. Meanwhile, a coupled model of the biochemical photosynthetic model and the BB Model was established. Our objectives were to: (1) quantify the variation of key parameters for the wheat leaf gas exchange model, Vcmax, Jmaxand m, under different wheat growth stages, different water supply conditions and diurnal changes of meteorological factors; and (2) evaluate the sensitivity of the coupled model to key parameters in simulating gas exchange under different meteorological conditions.
2. Materials and methods
2.1. Site description and experiments
The experiments for spring wheat were conducted in 2014,2015 and 2017 at the Dingxi Arid Meteorology and Ecological Environment Field Experimental Station, Dingxi County of Gansu Province, Northwest China (35°33´N, 104°35´E,1 896.7 m elevation). The site has a typical semi-arid climate with average annual precipitation of 386 mm (Zhao and Wang 2014; Zhao et al. 2018) for a full description of spring wheat growing conditions in the study region.
Spring wheat seeds were planted both in pots filled with 14 kg of air-dried soil and in the field in 2014 and 2017. In 2015, only the pot experiment was carried out. The spring wheat variety was Dingxixin 24 in all 3 years and it was sown in late March each year. For the pot experiments, 20 pots were sown with spring wheat, and 10 of these were randomly assigned to a well-watered treatment, the other 10 to a drought treatment. In 2014 and 2015, the different treatments were conducted during jointing stage and the drought treatment consisted of withholding water during the flowering period in 2017. Field experiments in 2014 had two water treatments, well-watered and drought, which were carried out during the jointing stage. In 2017, the field spring wheat was treated with two water supply conditions,one with enough water through the whole growth season and another under rainfed condition only. Air temperature,relative humidity (RH) and solar radiation were measured hourly at the experimental station.
The experiment for winter wheat was carried out at Yucheng Comprehensive Experiment Station (36°57´N,116°36´E, 28 m elevation), Chinese Academy of Sciences,located in the North China Plain. Only one treatment was conducted at this station, winter wheat growing in the field with well-watered conditions. The experimental management and environmental conditions had been described by Yu et al. (2004) in detail.
2.2. Gas exchange measurements
Gas exchange for spring wheat was measured by two portable steady-state photosynthetic systems (Li-6400, Li-Cor Inc., Lincoln, NE, USA). Two types of response curve of Pnto photosynthetically active radiation (Pn/Qp) and CO2concentration (Pn/Ci) were conducted in different years using a red-blue LED artificial light source (Table 1). Two first fully expanded leaves, with four replications, were selected to produce the response curves. For spring wheat, the Pn/Qpcurve was mainly monitored during the jointing stage(s2) in the pots and from the tillering stage (s1) to the milk stage (s6) in the field during 2014 and 2015. The Pn/Cicurve was produced in 2017 at the anthesis stage (s4) in the pots and from s1 to s6 in the field. For Pn/Qpcurves,wheat leaves were acclimated in the chamber with leaf temperature at 25°C and Qpat 1 500 μmol m-2s-1for more than 40 min before making measurements. The Qpused to generate the Pn/Qpcurves were 1 800, 1 500, 1 200, 900,600, 300, 200, 120, 60, 30, 15, and 0 μmol m-2s-1while the CO2concentration was at a constant value, 400 μmol m-2s-1. Meanwhile, the measurement of Pn/Qpcurves under four different air temperatures (20, 25, 30, and 35°C) was conducted for spring wheat growing in the field during s2,to validate the coupling model. For production of Pn/Cicurves, before making measurements, wheat leaves were also acclimated in the chamber with a Qpof 1 500 μmol m-2s-1, but two constant leaf temperatures at 25 and 30°C,were adopted, respectively. Then the CO2concentration was changed sequentially at 400, 200, 100, 50, 400, 600,800, 1 000, and 1 200 μmol mol-1. During measurement of the two types of curves, RH in the chamber was varied at(40±15)%. The minimum of 120 s and the maximum of 240 s were adopted respectively for individual measurements of each curve response to reach a steady state. Diurnal changes of gas exchange parameters for spring wheat under well-watered and rainfed conditions were monitored by Li-6400 with sunlight and free air conditions on 19 May in 2017 (day 57 after sowing, at s2). Three typical periods were chosen to be analysed in this study, morning (08:00-11:00),noon (11:00-14:00) and afternoon (14:00-17:00).

Table 1 Experimental information for leaf gas exchange observation of winter wheat and spring wheat growing in pots and the field for different years
At Yucheng Comprehensive Experiment Station, thePn/Cicurve for winter wheat growing in the field under wellwatered conditions was measured in approximately 1 week intervals, during late s2, whole booting and heading stages(s3) and early s4. ThePn/Cicurve was produced by the same approach for spring wheat under two controlled leaf temperatures, 25 and 30°C.
2.3. Calculation of model parameters and model validation
The coupling models and parameters for leaf gas exchange simulation are described and summarized in Appendices A and B. The input variables of the coupling models are radiation, temperature, RH, and CO2concentration and there are nine unknowns (Pn,gs, leaf temperature (TL), vapor pressure at the leaf surface (es),Cs,Ci, total water vapor conductance (gv), heat conductance for boundary layer(gh), and radiative conductance (gr), refer to Appendix B).A nested iterative procedure was adopted to obtain these unknown variables numerically (Kimet al. 2003). TheTLwas assumed to be equal to air temperature andCiwas at 0.7Cafirstly, and then used to estimate thePnandgs. The coupled mathematical model in this study was written and run by the computer programming language, Fortran90.
ThePn/Cicurve was used to estimate parametersVcmaxandJmax. AsPnwas limited by Rubisco whenCiwas less than 150 μmol mol-1,Vcmaxwas estimated based on eq. (A2)in Appendix A. However, asPnwas limited by the regeneration of RuBP at higherCiexposures, greater than 250 μmol mol-1,Jmaxwas determined by eqs. (A3) and (A4)in Appendix A. Furthermore, the data of thePn/Cicurve collected during s2 to s4 were used for comparison ofVcmaxandJmaxunder different temperatures between the two different wheat types.
To estimate the parameter m by eq. (A10) in Appendix A,we mainly used the data whenQpwas higher than 150 μmol m-2s-1and the CO2concentration greater than 100 μmol mol-1, as recommended by previous researchers (Mineret al. 2016). For calculating m for winter wheat, the data of thePn/Cicurve during s2 to early s4 were used. To compare the m values between winter wheat and spring wheat, the data of thePn/Cicurve for spring wheat growing in the field in 2017 during s2 to s4 were used. The seasonal variation of m was calculated based on data of thePn/Qpcurve for spring wheat growing in the field under well-watered conditions at s1, s2, s3, s4, grain-filling stage (s5), and s6. Photosynthetic parameters withQpat 1 500 μmol m-2s-1(defined as light saturated condition), temperature at 25°C and CO2at 400 μmol mol-1from thePn/Qpcurve in 2014 and 2015 and thePn/Cicurve in 2017 for spring wheat both growing in pots and the field under different water conditions were used to calculate m. Hence, other environmental factors have relatively small impacts on m estimation under different water conditions.
The coupled model was tested by validation data sets. The data sets included the response of the main photosynthetic parameters,Pn, transpiration (Tr),gs, and water use efficiency (WUE,Pn/Tr), to variedQpunder four different ambient temperatures, 20, 25, 30, and 35°C.
2.4. Sensitivity analyses
Sensitivity analyses were conducted to determine the impact for variation of key model parameters (Vcmax,Jmax, and m) on gas exchange simulation under diurnally meteorological conditions. Each parameter's effect was evaluated individually, and one parameter changed while other parameters were kept constantly. We chose a typical day in the Dingxi region during the spring wheat growing season and set each parameter to vary from a given value to -30% of it, and then compare the simulated results. Each parameter's effect (PE) was calculated as follows:

whereSsis the simulated gas exchange parameters under 30% reduced key parameters andSgis the simulated gas exchange parameters for a given key model parameter.
2.5. Redefinition of water supply condition
Due to the impact of different environmental conditions on drought occurrence, and adaptation strategies of plant to drought, plants would not suffer water stress immediately after withholding water supply. Therefore, we need to redefine water supply condition accurately for wheat in the current study. Medranoet al. (2002) suggested thatgsunder light saturated condition (gssat) can be used as a reference of water stress indicator. Various water stress levels, mild,moderate, and severe, can be classified bygssatat 0.15 and 0.05 mol m-2s-1for C3crops (Cifreet al. 2005). In the current study, we adopted this approach instead of soil water content to divide spring wheat growing in pots and the field into two main water supply conditions. Spring wheat grown in pots and the field withgssatgreater than 0.15 mol m-2s-1were defined as well-watered conditions (potww and fieldww). Spring wheat growing in pots and the field withgssatless than 0.15 mol m-2s-1were defined as water-stressed conditions (potdr and fielddr).
2.6. Statistical analyses
Non-linear regressions were used to calculateVcmaxandJmaxand linear regressions were used to estimate m. The differences ofVcmaxandJmaxfor spring wheat and winter wheat under different environmental conditions were tested by variance analysis. Linear, non-linear regressions and variance analysis were accomplished in R Software with functions of ‘lm', ‘nls', and ‘TukeyHSD' (R Development Core Team 2014). Results were considered ‘significant'asP-value less than 0.05. Before conducting statistical tests, data used in the study were examined to ensure homogeneity and normality of variances.
3. Results
3.1. Values of Vcmax and Jmax for wheat
Comparison of Vcmaxand Jmaxfor winter wheat and spring wheatThe averageVcmaxfor spring wheat at 25°C was about 95.9 μmol m-2s-1,vs. 107.5 μmol m-2s-1for winter wheat (Fig. 1-A), but there was no significant difference (P>0.05). As temperature increased, theVcmaxfor both wheat types decreased significantly, andVcmaxwas 76.1 μmol m-2s-1for spring wheat and 90.6 μmol m-2s-1for winter wheat at 30°C.
The averageJmaxvalues at 25°C were about 214.1 and 186.8 μmol m-2s-1for spring wheat and winter wheat,respectively (Fig. 1-B), and there was no significant difference. Meanwhile,Jmaxdecreased for spring wheat and winter wheat as temperature increased to 30°C. However,there were no significant differences forJmaxbetween the two temperatures for either wheat type.
Seasonal variation of Vcmax and JmaxTheVcmaxfor spring wheat varied slightly from s1 to s5 and declined sharply at s6 (Fig. 2-A). The averageVcmaxvalues for spring wheat were 93.1, 101.5, 95.1, 88.3, and 84.9 μmol m-2s-1at s1,s2, s3, s4, and s5, respectively. There were no significant differences ofVcmaxamong these stages. However, theVcmaxat s6, 78.2 μmol m-2s-1, was significantly lower than the value at s2.

Fig. 1 Comparison of maximum carboxylation rate (Vcmax, A)and maximum electron transport capacity (Jmax, B) under two different temperatures for well-watered spring wheat and winter wheat (n=3 to 10). sw25, spring wheat under 25°C. ww30,winter wheat under 30°C. Different lowercase letters indicate differences at 0.05 significance level with each treatment. The cross and horizontal lines inside each box are the average and median, respectively, the upper and lower end points of each box are the upper and lower quartile, respectively, and whiskers are the 1.5 times the interquartile ranges.
TheJmaxfor spring wheat at s1, s2, s3, s4, and s5 had no significant differences between them, whereas,Jmaxat these five stages were significantly larger than at s6(Fig. 2-B). Additionally, unlike the maximum Vcmaxobtained at s2, the Jmaxat s4, 242.1 μmol m-2s-1, was larger than other five stages.
Variation of Vcmax and Jmax under different water conditionsThe response of Vcmaxto gssatboth in the field and pot experiments, showed two totally different stages(Fig. 3-A). When gssatwas greater than 0.15 mol m-2s-1,the Vcmaxof spring wheat in the field showed no significant variation with the change of gssat, and it had a slightly decreasing trend for spring wheat in the pots (Table 2).Meanwhile, the statistical test of Vcmaxfor spring wheat grown in both pots compared with the field under well-watered conditions showed no significant difference (Fig. 3-B).However, when gssatwas less than 0.15 mol m-2s-1, the Vcmaxof spring wheat decreased sharply, especially for spring wheat growing in pots. Meanwhile, the average Vcmaxfor spring wheat at water-stressed conditions was significantly smaller than it was under well-watered conditions.Furthermore, the Vcmaxfor spring wheat growing in pots and the field were significantly different. The difference might be due to the spring wheat grown in the field suffering less severe water deficit compared with the pots.

Fig. 2 Variation of maximum carboxylation rate (Vcmax, A) and maximum electron transport capacity (Jmax, B) under different stages for well-watered spring wheat (n=3 to 5). s1-s6, tillering,jointing, booting, anthesis, grain-filling, and milk-ripe stages,respectively. Different lowercase letters indicate differences at 0.05 significance level with each treatment. The cross and horizontal lines inside each box are the average and median,respectively, the upper and lower end points of each box are the upper and lower quartiles, respectively, and whiskers are the 1.5 times the interquartile ranges.
Similarly, the variation of Jmaxfor spring wheat growing in pots and the field against gssatfell into two apparently different stages, divided by gssatat 0.15 mol m-2s-1(Fig. 3-C).These Jmaxvalues changed slightly as gssatdecreased from 0.6 to 0.15 mol m-2s-1(P>0.05) (Table 2), and there were no significant difference in Jmaxbetween spring wheat grown in pots and the field (Fig. 3-D). However, as gssatdecreased from 0.15 to 0 mol m-2s-1, Jmaxof spring wheat both in the field and pots decreased significantly, and the average Jmaxvalues were significantly different from their values under well-watered condition.
Relationships between Vcmax and JmaxAs spring wheat developed, the Jmax/Vcmaxincreased from 2.05 at s1 to 2.75 at s5, and declined sharply at s6, down to 1.88 (Fig. 4-A).However, there were no significant difference of Jmax/Vcmaxamong these six stages.
There was no significant difference between Jmax/Vcmaxfor winter wheat (1.77) and spring wheat (2.06) grown in the field under well-watered conditions (Fig. 4-B). However,the Jmax/Vcmaxfor spring wheat grown in pots under wellwatered conditions was 2.23, which was significantly larger than spring wheat grown in the field under well-watered condition. Meanwhile, when spring wheat suffered water deficit in both pots and the field, the Jmax/Vcmaxdecreased.However, there was no significant difference of Jmax/Vcmaxfor spring wheat under different water conditions, whether grown in pots or the field.
3.2. Values of m for the stomatal conductance model
Comparison of m for winter wheat and spring wheatThe BB index (PnRH/Cs) had a significant relationship with gsfor both wheat types, winter wheat and spring wheat grown in the field under well-watered conditions (Fig. 5). There was no significant difference between the m for winter wheat(12.172) and spring wheat (11.991) (Table 3). However, for a given BB index, the stomatal conductance of winter wheat was always slightly higher than that of the spring wheat.Combining the data of spring wheat and winter wheat, the m was 11.166 and gowas 0.021 mol m-2s-1.
Seasonal variation of m for spring wheatAt different growth stages for spring wheat under well-watered conditions, there was no apparent trend for the change of m(Fig. 6; Table 3). The m at s2 was 10.4, which was slightly higher than the values at s1, s3, s4, and s6, but with no significant differences. However, the m at s5 was 11.04,which had a significant difference with the slope in s6, 9.038.The overall m for spring wheat from s1 to s6 was 10.097,and theg0was 0.038 mol m-2s-1.

Fig. 3 Variation of maximum carboxylation rate (Vcmax, A and B) and maximum electron transport capacity (Jmax, C and D) under different water conditions for spring wheat growing in pots and the field (n=10 to 19). Potww, spring wheat growing in pots with gssat greater than 0.15 mol m-2 s-1; Potdr, spring wheat growing in pots with gssat less than 0.15 mol m-2 s-1; Fieldww, spring wheat growing in the field with gssat greater than 0.15 mol m-2 s-1; Fielddr, spring wheat growing in the field with gssat less than 0.15 mol m-2 s-1. Different capital letters above or below the boxes indicate differences at 0.01 significance level with each treatment. The cross and horizontal line inside each box are the average and median, respectively, the upper and lower end points of each box are the upper and lower quartiles, respectively, and whiskers are 1.5 times the interquartile ranges.

Table 2 Response of maximum carboxylation rate of Rubisco (Vcmax) and maximum rate of electron transport (Jmax) to light saturated stomatal conductance (gssat) under different water supply conditions

Fig. 4 Variation of ratios between maximum carboxylation rate(Vcmax) and maximum electron transport capacity (Jmax) during different growth stages for spring wheat (A) and under different water condition for winter wheat and spring wheat (B). s1-s6,tillering, jointing, booting and heading, anthesis stage, grain-flling,and milk stages, respectively. Fwww, winter wheat growing in the field under well-watered condition; Fswww, spring wheat growing in the field under well-watered condition; Fswdr, spring wheat growing in the field under drought condition; Pswww, spring wheat growing in pots under well-watered condition; Pswdr, spring wheat growing in pots under drought condition. The same lowercase letters above or below boxes indicate no differences between each treatment.The cross and horizontal lines inside each box are the average and median of 3-19 individual measurements per treatment,respectively, the upper and lower end points of each box are the upper and lower quartile, respectively, and whiskers are 1.5 times the interquartile ranges.
Diurnal change of m for spring wheatThe BB index had significant relationships with stomatal conductance at different times of the day for spring wheat growing in the field (Fig. 7-A). However, the m in the morning was 17.03,which was significantly higher than the values at noon and in the afternoon (Table 3). There was no significant difference between m at noon and in the afternoon. Meanwhile, the relationship betweenPnandgswas also significantly different at various time of the day (Fig. 7-B). The slope ofPn-gsin the morning was significantly lower than the slope at noon and in the afternoon (Table 4). There was no significant difference of thePn-gsslope between noon and in the afternoon. We found leaf temperature in the morning was apparently lower than the temperature at noon and in the afternoon, and RH was higher than the value at noon and in the afternoon.
Variation of m for spring wheat under different water supply conditionsThere existed significant relationships between the BB index andgssatfor spring wheat, when both grown in pots and the field under either well-watered or water-stressed conditions (Fig. 8-A). However, we found the m under well-watered condition was significantly greater than the value under water-stressed conditions (Table 3).The m was 10.6 and 10.8 in the field and pots under wellwatered condition, respectively, whereas it was 7.5 and 6.9 under water-stressed condition in the field and pots,representing decreases of 29.7 and 36.3%, respectively.Combining the data of pots and the field, the m was 10.5 for well-watered spring wheat,vs. 7.3 under water-stressed conditions, a decrease of up to 31%.
As shown in Fig. 8-B and Table 4, the relationship betweenPnandgssatfor spring wheat under different water conditions was significantly different, both grown in pots and the field. ThePn-gssatslope under well-watered conditions was apparently lower than the slope under waterstressed conditions. There was no significant difference of thePn-gssatslope between spring wheat growing in pots and the field both under well-watered and water-stressed conditions.
3.3. Parameter perturbation and sensitivity of gas exchange simulation
The comparison between observed gas exchange and simulated gas exchange showed the coupling model could simulate leaf gas exchange successfully (Appendix C). By using the model, key model parameters were perturbed individually, which consisted of altering the value of each parameter from given set of values (120 and 200 μmol m-2s-1and 12 forVcmax,Jmax, and m, respectively) to decreased them one-at-a-time by 30% while the others were kept constant.During a typical sunny day (Appendix C), the diurnal trends ofPn,Tr,gs, and WUE with different key model parameters perturbation were nearly identical with the values calculated based on the given set of parameters (Fig. 9). However,it was shown that the values ofPn,Tr,gs, and WUE were totally different from each other by parameter perturbation during the various time of the day.

Fig. 5 Relationship between observed stomatal conductance(gs) and the Ball-Berry Model index (PnRH/Cs) for winter wheat and spring wheat under well-watered conditions from jointing to anthesis stages. sw, spring wheat; ww, winter wheat. Pn, net photosynthesis rate; RH, relative humidity; Cs, carbon dioxide.

Table 3 Variation of slope (m) and intercept (go) of Ball-Berry stomatal conductance model for winter wheat and spring wheat growing under different environmental conditions
For the 30% decreased value ofVcmax, thePnwas apparently lower than the normal treatment nearly all day(Fig. 9-A). The greatest difference, up to 30%, occurred at 11:00 as thePnwas at its maximum for the normal treatment during the day (Fig. 9-B). ForTrandgs,Vcmaxperturbation showed a slight decrease compared with the normal value (Fig. 9-C). The greatest difference occurred later in the day, whileTrandgswere at their maxima for the normal treatment, and the differences were not up to 30%(Fig. 9-C-F). Meanwhile, the perturbation ofVcmaxshowed nearly no effect on the diurnal variation of WUE (Fig. 9-G and H). The perturbation ofJmaxhad nearly same effect on the variation of diurnal gas exchange at the perturbation ofVcmax. However, the differences between perturbed and normal values forPn,Trandgswere slightly smaller than the difference of perturbation ofVcmaxand the normal values,especially during the time from 10:00 to 18:00 (Fig. 9-A-F).
Compared with the perturbation ofVcmaxandJmax, the decreased m value showed a very different effect on the diurnal variation of gas exchange. It decreased thePnslightly as the normal treatment obtained the maximumPn,but it had greater influence asPndecreased in the afternoon(Fig. 9-A and B). The greatest difference forPnbetween the normal and changed values of m occurred around noon. Meanwhile, perturbation of m had a great impact on the diurnal variation ofTrandgs, and they decreased up to 30% nearly all day, sometimes even greater than 30%(Fig. 9-C-F). Furthermore, the decreasing of m apparently increased the WUE (Fig. 9-G and H), especially during the time from 07:00 to 12:00 when thegswas relatively high.
4. Discussion
4.1. Variation of Vcmax and Jmax for wheat under different conditions

Fig. 6 Relationship between observed stomatal conductance(gs) and the Ball-Berry Model index (PnRH/Cs) for spring wheat during different growth stages. Pn, net photosynthesis rate; RH,relative humidity; Cs, carbon dioxide.
TheVcmaxof spring wheat and winter wheat under wellwatered conditions at 25°C were nearly identical to those in previous reports, (88.14±6.3) to (108.44±8.2) μmol m-2s-1for four varieties wheat of Katarinaet al. (2016),for instance. TheJmaxof spring wheat and winter wheat under well-watered conditions at 25°C were in the range of seasonal variation for winter wheat reported in Sunet al. (2015), although they took mesophyll conductance into account when calculatingVcmaxandJmax. Meanwhile,we found the photosynthesis rate for wheat under wellwatered conditions in the current study was higher than in most trees (Sala and Tenhunen 1996), and so was theVcmaxandJmax(Kosugi and Matsuo 2006). However, as theVcmaxandJmaxfor wheat were comparable with the maximum values of blue oak (Xu and Baldocchi 2003); thePnmax(net photosynthesis rate obtained under saturatingQp) of blue oak at the time with the highestVcmaxandJmaxwas nearly identical to the values in this study, i.e.,gssatapproached 0.5 mol m-2s-1in Fig. 8. This finding clearly confirmed the close relationship between biochemical parameters andPnmax, and higher photosynthetic capability of the plants indicates a higher photosynthesis rate. Furthermore, it also verifies the fact that thePnmaxcould be used to determine key model parameters,VcmaxandJmax(Xu and Baldocchi 2003; De Kauweet al. 2016), if one lacks of the equipment or enough time to measure thePn/Cicurve.

Fig. 7 Diurnal variation of the relationship between observational stomatal conductance (gs) and the Ball-Berry Model index (PnRH/Cs) (A) and relationship between Pn and gs (B) for spring wheat. The slopes of the BB Model were significantly different between morning and noon. Pn, net photosynthesis rate; RH, relative humidity; Cs, carbon dioxide.

Table 4 Relationships between light saturated stomatal conductance (gssat) and net photosynthesis rate (Pn) under different times and different water conditions for spring wheat growing in pots and the field

Fig. 8 Variation of relationship between observed light saturated stomatal conductance (gssat) and the Ball-Berry Model index(PnRH/Cs) (A) and relationship between net photosynthesis rate (Pn) and gssat (B) for spring wheat grown in pots and the field under different water conditions. Pn, net photosynthesis rate; RH, relative humidity; Cs, carbon dioxide. Potww, wheat growing in pots under well-watered condition; Potdr, wheat growing in pots under drought condition; Fieldww, wheat growing in field under wellwatered condition; Fielddr, wheat growing in field under drought condition.
Temperature greatly affects the variation ofVcmaxandJmax,which has been found by previous studies (Medlynet al.2002; Hikosakaet al. 2006). The optimal temperature for wheat growth ranges from 19 to 23°C (Slafer and Rawson 1995). As the temperature increased to 30°C, it significantly decreasedVcmaxfor wheat compared with its value at 25°C. Meanwhile, we found theVcmaxandJmaxin our study were slightly lower than the values obtained by Drieveret al. (2014) for 64 field-grown wheat genotypes under a leaf temperature of 20°C. Taking the range of optimal temperatures for wheat into account, we speculated that the differences in the two parameters between our study and Drieveret al. (2014) is not only due to the diversity of photosynthetic capacity among wheat varieties, but also the temperature effect.
Although the trend in the data is similar to the results from other studies (Medlynet al. 2002; Xu and Baldocchi 2003; Bauerleet al. 2012), the seasonal variation ofVcmaxandJmaxfor spring wheat did not significantly fluctuated.The exception was a sharp reduction at the end of the growth season, which was identical with the results reported by Grossmanet al. (1999). Several researchers have speculated that the seasonal variation inVcmaxmight be related to leaf ontogeny, water stress, temperature and Rubisco specific activity (Grassiet al. 2005; Iioet al. 2008;Urbanet al. 2012). Meanwhile, others have suggested that the biochemical model parameters are tightly correlated with leaf nitrogen content or nitrogen use efficiency (Aliet al. 2015; Tatsumiet al. 2019). The duration of the whole growth season for spring wheat in the current research was only 110 days. With enough nitrogen supply at planting time, there would be no nitrogen deficit for spring wheat compared with winter wheat, which has a longer growth season, generally more than 200 days. The nitrogen could be transferred from old leaves to new leaves as the wheat grows. Therefore, there might have been great variation inVcmaxandJmaxfor winter wheat leaves during different growth stages in other studies (Fenget al. 2015; Sunet al. 2015). Meanwhile, Rubisco content has an inverse relationship with its specific activity (Urban et al. 2012).The increase of Rubisco specific activity that accompanies its content decrease might offset the reduction of Vcmaxand Jmaxduring the middle-late growing season for spring wheat.Furthermore, a group of studies have found that photoperiod could result in seasonal variation of Vcmaxand Jmax(Bauerle et al. 2012; Way et al. 2017). The main growing season for spring wheat is from April to June. The longer day length in June might prevent the down-regulation of Vcmaxand Jmaxat the middle-late growing season for spring wheat. It should be noted also that the observation of seasonal Vcmaxand Jmaxfor spring wheat in the current study was conducted under well-watered conditions with strict environmental control,and, thus, without water and temperature stress. Therefore,the fluctuation of seasonal Vcmaxand Jmaxfor spring wheat was not pronounced, except at the end of the growing season with leaf senescence and a sharp reduction of leaf nitrogen content (Grossman et al. 1999).

Fig. 9 Effects of variable key model parameters on diurnal leaf gas exchange for spring wheat. Vcmax, the maximum carboxylation rate of Rubisco; Jmax, the maximum rate of electron transport. Pn, net photosynthesis; PE, parameters effect; Tr, transpiration rate;gs, stomatal conductance; WUE, water use efficiency.
Water deficit has significant impacts on the biochemical parameters of the photosynthetic model. However, it did not affect the model parameters until the water stress progressed to a specific threshold, gssatat 0.15 mol m-2s-1in the current study. Previous studies have found that biochemical limitation for photosynthesis only occurs under moderate to severe water deficit condition (Brodribb 1996;Medranoet al. 2002). We speculated that spring wheat only suffered mild water stress beforegssatapproached 0.15 mol m-2s-1in the current study and the stomatal conductance decreased withoutVcmaxandJmaxbeing reduced in proportion.Meanwhile, in the field experiment, thegssatwas relatively higher, therefore, theVcmaxwas significantly higher than the wheat growing in pots, which suffered an extremely severe water stress at the end of the observation period, asgssatapproached zero.
Previous studies have reported meanJmax/Vcmaxranging from 1.6 to 1.7 for a large number of plant species, and it was shown to be sensitive to changes in environmental factors(Medlynet al. 2002). We noted that theJmax/Vcmaxfor spring wheat under well-watered condition was slightly higher than those reported by Osunaet al. (2015) and Medlynet al.(2002) for tree species. This indicates that spring wheat may allocate more nitrogen to electron transport than to Rubisco,which could be an optimal strategy for spring wheat in the study area, which has high radiation for spring wheat growth.However, more research is certainly warranted on this topic.

Fig. 10 The variation of the ratio of intercellular CO2 to atmospheric CO2 (Ci/Ca) for spring wheat grown in pots under different water conditions (A) and response of the slope (m) to variation Ci/Ca under different relative humidities (RH) (B).
4.2. Variation of m under different conditions
The m values for the two wheat types during s2 to s4 in the current study were nearly identical with each other, and comparable with the results obtained in Leiet al. (2011) for winter wheat in the middle of the growing season. However,the m was higher than the commonly used value for C3plant in several land surface models, e.g., nine in Simple Biosphere Model 2 (SiB2) (Sellerset al. 1997). The land surface models always adopts an average value for C3plants, despite the fact that great variation exists in the m values for different C3plants, 13.3±10 (Mineret al. 2016).This variation suggests that species differences of m should be taken into account as we simulate the gas exchange of various plants.
Some previous researchers have stated that the relationship betweengsand the BB index remained constant both under water-stressed and well-watered conditions(Wonget al. 1979, 1985). In contrast, a large number of studies have modified the m by multiplying it by a water stress coefficient, to make the simulated gas exchange more comparable with observations (Baldocchi 1997; Liuet al. 2009). In the current research, we found that the m for spring wheat had two significantly different values under different water conditions, which could be divided bygssatat 0.15 mol m-2s-1. Due to the strict environment at controls used in the current study (Table 4), the only factor affecting the variation of m was water. Meanwhile, we found that thePnandgssatrelationship was also affected by different water conditions (Fig. 8-B), which was identical to the previous statement that water deficit could modify the relationship betweenPnandgs, and consequently thegs-Pnratio (Bunce 1998; Damouret al. 2010). In the studies of Wonget al. (1979, 1985), they found thePnandgsvaried in proportion even under mild water-stressed conditions, and the ratio ofCiandCaremained constant. Nevertheless,in our study, we found that the slope ofPn-gsapparently increased under drought conditions, to nearly three times that of well-watered wheat. Meanwhile, theCi/Cawas not a constant, but decreased withgsand then increased sharply as gsbecame smaller than 0.05 mol m-2s-1(Fig. 10-A). Pncan be calculated as follows:

If Ci/Cais constant and Cais at a fixed value, then the relation between Pnand gswould not change and m could remain constant even when water stress occurs. However,as the relationship between Pnand gschanges, the m might vary. We took the derivative of eq. (A10) in Appendix A and eq. (2), and obtained the following eq.:

This reflects that the m is determined both by the RH and Ci/Ca(Fig. 10-B). Given a fixed RH, 50% for instance, we calculated the m for C3and C4plants to be 10.7 and 5.3,respectively, as the mean Ci/Cafor C3and C4plant were 0.7 and 0.4, respectively (Wong et al. 1979). The calculated m for C3and C4plants are nearly identical to the values most often used in several land surface models, nine for C3and four for C4plants (Sellers et al. 1997). In the current research, the RH for the well-watered condition was 50%,and 40% for the water-stressed condition (Table 4). The average Ci/Cafor well-watered spring wheat was 0.7 and it was 0.45 for water-stressed wheat, if we neglect the sharply increased Ci/Ca, where we speculated the impairment of the photosynthesis apparatus occurred (Brodribb 1996).Therefore, we obtained the m for spring wheat under wellwatered and drought conditions from Fig. 10-B, 10.2 and 7.1, respectively. We found the values from the figures were nearly identical to the values obtained from the linear relationships in Table 3, 10.6 and 7.3, respectively. In the study of Xu and Baldocchi (2003), they showed there was no difference in m under different water supply conditions.However, they obtained the m without controlling the ambient temperature, and the RH would be very low with temperatures up to 33°C as seasonal drought occurred in their study. Fig. 10-B shows that the m would be higher if RH is low, even with small Ci/Ca. We speculate this might be the reason that some researchers found m had not decreased under water-stressed condition.
The environmental conditions during different growth stages or different times of the day have an effect on m.Ono et al. (2013) found m was higher during early and late growing seasons for rice. Lei et al. (2011) showed the m remained nearly constant at first, but rapidly increased at the end of the winter wheat growing season. In the study of Lei et al. (2011), the m was calculated based on data from daily observations with skylights for radiation and without temperature control. However, under identical meteorological conditions for observations in the current study, the m varied slightly and nearly remained constant with the development of spring wheat, except in s5 when m was higher than the other stages. Meanwhile, we found the m calculated during different time of the day with skylights for radiation and without temperature control were not identical, especially a higher value was obtained in the morning. Shimono et al. (2010) also found that m for irrigated rice varied diurnally, with an especially lower value in the afternoon. The relationships between Pnand gsin the current study were totally different in the morning,at noon and in the afternoon (Fig. 7-B), which contrast with Ball (1987), who found a constant relationship of gsand Pnwith no influence of meteorological factors. In our study,we found the environmental factors, leaf temperature and RH at noon and in the afternoon, were apparently higher and lower than in the morning, respectively. A previous study had verified that increasing vapor pressure deficit,which is calculated from temperature and RH, results in Ci/Cadecreasing (Kemanian et al. 2005). Based on eq.(3), with variation of RH and Ci/Ca, m might vary diurnally.Furthermore, these two meteorological factors might induce greater variation of Pnat noon and in the afternoon compared with in the morning with the same change of gs(Fig. 7-B),which also represents an adjustment of the relationship between Pnand gs, hence, a change of m.
Decreased m indicates that plants adopt a more conservative water use strategy. Therefore, it could increase intrinsic water use efficiency (IWUE, Pn/gs) (Egea et al.2011), to maximize carbon gain while minimizing water loss (De Miguel et al. 2012). This might be a very efficient approach for a crop to escape environmental stress, such as high temperature, low relative humidity and water deficit.As the plant grows under optimal conditions, the m would increase to a maximum value, in the morning and under well-watered conditions in the current study, for instance.Under such conditions, the plant could accumulate more dry matter without taking water loss into account.
4.3. Implications for coupling models to simulate gas exchange
Because of no significant differences among key model parameters between spring wheat and winter wheat, it has been suggest that we could use these parameters obtained from references to simulate gas exchange for wheat during main growth season under favorable environmental conditions, if we do not have experimental data to calculated these parameters directly. However, it should be noted that a limited understanding of model parameterization could result in much uncertainty of the carbon and water cycle estimates at different scales. At the leaf scale, we found the variation of key model parameters, Vcmax, Jmaxand m,had totally different impacts on gas exchange with variable meteorological conditions, which were consistent with the finding of Bauerle et al. (2014) at the canopy scale. Due to the significant decrease of model parameters under water-stressed, high temperature, large vapor pressure deficit conditions and late growing season, the variation of key model parameters under both severe environmental conditions and specific growing stages should be taken into account, to simulate gas exchange between plants and the atmosphere accurately.
What processes limit Pnunder drought is still under debate. Generally, the variation of m and Vcmax(and Jmax)are related to stomatal and non-stomatal factors influencing photosynthetic process (Keenan et al. 2010). Hence,modification of m or Vcmax(and Jmax) are commonly adopted for simulating gas exchange under drought (Egea et al.2011). However, accounting for water stress in a coupling model by modification of m or Vcmax(and Jmax) separately has failed to represent the variation of several observed key leaf gas exchange attributes during drought, especially IWUE(Egea et al. 2011). In field experiments, plant leaf IWUE always increases as water stress develops (Limousin et al.2010), and we speculate that decreased m could capture this phenomenon in the gas exchange estimate (eq. (4),derived from eq. (A10) in Appendix A with neglect of go).

However, IWUE decreased with water stress up to a threshold in field experiments (Medrano et al. 2009). This might indicate that m stops increasing at a specific water stress degree and never approaches to zero, resulting in IWUE approaching infinity, which is verified in our research in Fig. 10-B. The non-stomatal factors would limit photosynthetic process greatly as severe drought occurs(Vcmaxand Jmaxdecreased while gssatwas less than 0.15 mol m-2s-1in the current study), which might result in Pnand IWUE decreasing sharply (Medrano et al. 2002; Egea et al.2011). These results suggest that we could modify m and Vcmax(and Jmax) successively based on water stress severity to simulate gas exchange under drought.
5. Conclusion
Meteorological factors and water supply conditions greatly affect the variation of key model parameters for wheat leaf exchange, including Vcmax, Jmaxand m. However, there were no significant differences for Vcmax, Jmaxand m between spring wheat and winter wheat. Meanwhile, the seasonal variation of Vcmax, Jmaxand m for spring wheat was not obvious, except a rapid decrease for Vcmaxand Jmaxat maturity. The study demonstrates that environmental factors alter key parameter values of ecological models over specific growing stages,which should be taken into account for simulating gas exchange between plants and the atmosphere.
Acknowledgements
This research was jointly supported by the National Natural Science Foundation of China (41375019,41730645, and 41275118) and the China Special Fund for Meteorological Research in the Public Interest (Major projects) (GYHY201506001-2).
Appendicesassociated with this paper can be available on http://www.ChinaAgriSci.com/V2/En/appendix.htm
杂志排行
Journal of Integrative Agriculture的其它文章
- Reducing environmental risk of nitrogen by popularizing mechanically dense transplanting for rice production in China
- Evaluation of sugar and organic acid composition and their levels in highbush blueberries from two regions of China
- An optimized industry processing technology of peanut tofu and the novel prediction model for suitable peanut varieties
- Effects of water application uniformity using a center pivot on winter wheat yield, water and nitrogen use efficiency in the North China Plain
- Spatial variability of soil properties in red soil and its implications for site-specific fertilizer management
- Phosphorus fertilization alters complexity of paddy soil dissolved organic matter
