Reducing environmental risk of nitrogen by popularizing mechanically dense transplanting for rice production in China
2020-08-10HUANGMinZOUYingbin
HUANG Min, ZOU Ying-bin
Crop and Environment Research Center, College of Agronomy, Hunan Agricultural University, Changsha 410128, P.R.China
Abstract The high nitrogen (N) application rates typically used in Chinese cropping systems have led to diminishing returns for yields and have also imposed substantial environmental costs. Here, we estimate that the annual N loss from rice production in China reached approximately 2.6×109 kg from 2011 to 2015, and we demonstrate that adoption of the mechanically dense transplanting technique by producers is an effective method to reduce N loss from rice cropping systems without suffering a yield penalty.
Keywords: dense planting, environmental risk, mechanical transplanting, nitrogen loss, rice
Nitrogen (N) is the primary limiting nutrient for plant growth in many terrestrial ecosystems (Vitousek and Howarth 1991).To ensure food security, synthetic fertilizer N has been widely applied as an external nutrient source to increase crop yields worldwide. Global N consumption has risen about 10-fold over the last 50 years (Fig. 1-A). The increased global N consumption is attributable to increases in both arable land area and N application rate before the 1990s and is mainly due to increased N application rates after that(Fig. 1-B and C).
China is currently the largest N consumer in the world(FAO 2019). The annual N consumption in China has exceeded 30×109kg since 2011 (Fig. 1-A), accounting for nearly 30% of the global N consumption (Fig. 1-D). High N application rate rather than large arable land area is responsible for the high N consumption in China (Fig. 1-B,C, E, and F). Increased N application has clearly contributed significantly to the improved crop yields in China (Fan et al.2012). However, the high rate of N application has not only caused diminishing returns with sharply decreased N use efficiency (Fan et al. 2012), but also imposed substantial environmental costs such as enhanced N deposition (Liu et al. 2013), soil acidification (Guo et al. 2010) and surface water eutrophication (Le et al. 2010).
Rice is the staple food crop for more than 65% of the population in China (Hsiaoping 2005). The annual rice planting area has been about 30×106ha in China since 2011, accounting for approximately 28% of the total arable land area nationally (FAO 2019; IRRI 2019). The average N application rate for rice production in China is 180 kg ha-1,which is about 75% higher than the world average (Ma et al.2008; Peng et al. 2009; Chen et al. 2014). Based on the logarithmic relationship between N loss proportion and N application rate plotted by Ju et al. (2009), it is estimated that the annual N loss amount in rice production was as high as about 2.6×109kg during 2011-2015 (Fig. 2). This highlights that reducing the N application rate is one of the most urgent requirements for sustainable rice production in China.

Fig. 1 Nitogen (N) consumption amount (A), arable land area (B) and N application rate (C) in the world and China and their ratios in China compared to the world (D-F) from 1961 to 2015. Data were collected from the FAOSTAT database (FAO 2019).
There have been many studies on improving N management to reduce N application rate in rice production,and several improved N management practices (e.g.,integrated soil-crop system management, real-time N management and site-specific N management) have been developed in recent years (Penget al.2006; Huet al.2007;Juet al.2009; Chenet al. 2014). Although these improved N practices have been shown to reduce the N application rate and environmental impact compared to traditional farmers' practices, they are not commonly adopted by rice farmers in China.
This mismatched situation is related to the changes in socioeconomic conditions. The number of laborers,especially younger ones, for rice production has markedly decreased in China due to urban expansion, and the daily labor wage has more than doubled in less than 10 years(Penget al. 2009). In addition, the prices of agricultural means of production (e.g., seeds) have increased rapidly with economic development (Penget al.2014) while the price of unhusked rice has decreased continuously due to both high inventory and import in China in recent years. As a consequence, the economic benefit of rice production is very low, which negatively affects the initiative to improve the N management for rice farmers. Under such conditions,the rice farmers have greatly simplified crop management practices, e.g., transplanting rice at extremely wide spacing to reduce labor inputs (Penget al. 2009). Meanwhile, to overcome the potential negative effect of reducing planting density on tiller number and grain yield, high N application rates are usually applied by farmers under the wide-spacing transplanting condition (Huanget al. 2013). This suggests that increasing planting density through a labor-saving method may be a feasible way to reduce the N application rate in rice production in China.
In 2012 and 2013, we determined the effect of planting density and N rate on grain yield in rice (Xieet al. 2015).The results showed that grain yield was increased with increasing either planting density or N application rate,and a yield reduction due to reducing N application rate can be compensated for by increasing planting density(Fig. 3). Similar results are also reported in other studies across different genotypes, establishment methods and regions (Huanget al. 2013, 2018; Zhuet al. 2016; Liuet al. 2019). These studies show that increasing planting density is a feasible way to reduce the N application rate in rice production. The possible mechanisms for this are:(1) increasing planting density increases uptake of soil N,which plays a more important role than fertilizer N in yield formation in rice (Zouet al.2015; Huanget al. 2017); (2) N use efficiency is increased in rice grown under a combination of increased planting density with reduced N application rate (Xieet al.2015); and (3) changes in planting density and N application rate result in compensation among yield attributes in rice (Xieet al. 2015; Huanget al.2019).
High planting density can be easily achieved in rice production by adopting the establishment method of direct seeding, which has been very popular in China since the 1990s due to its advantage of labor saving (Nie and Peng 2017). However, N losses from the basal N fertilizer are generally high at the early growth period in direct-seeded rice because the surge of available N from the basal fertilizer is a mismatch for the low N requirement of young rice plants and consequently a large amount of N is lost.This N loss may be higher in China since many rice famers apply fertilizers only once at basal fertilization for the entire growing season to avoid in-season fertilizer application to minimize labor inputs (Penget al. 2009). Moreover, direct seeding has the potential to: (1) increase environmental and health risks due to herbicide application at a frequency 2-3 times higher than other establishment methods per growing season; and (2) reduce yield due to using very short-duration cultivars in intensive rice-based cropping systems, which are important for ensuring national food security in China with limited arable land area per capita (Huang and Zou 2019). Therefore, direct seeding is not a good choice for sustainable rice production in China.

Fig. 2 Nitogen (N) loss amount in rice production in China from 2011 to 2015. Data were calculated by multiplying rice planting area by average N loss rate. Data of the rice planting areas were collected from the World Rice Statistics database (IRRI 2019).The average N loss rate was calculated by multiplying average N application rate (180 kg ha-1) by N loss proportion (48%). The average N application rate was determined according to Ma et al. (2009), Peng et al. (2009) and Chen et al. (2014). The N loss proportion was estimated by the logarithmic relationship between N loss proportion and N application rate plotted by Ju et al. (2009). The horizontal line shows the mean across years.

Fig. 3 Grain yield in manually transplanted rice grown under factorial combinations of four planting densities and three nitogen (N) application rates. Data of grain yield (ordinate) are separated by LSD (0.05) values, the least significant difference at the 0.05 probability level, shown in different colors. Data were collected from Xie et al. (2015).
Mechanical transplanting is another rice establishment method that allows for effective use of labor, and dense planting is easy to do using a mechanical rice transplanter.For example, a high planting density of 36×104hills ha-1(25 cm×11 cm) can be achieved with a PZ80-25 high speed rice transplanter (Dongfeng Iseki Agricultural Machinery Co.,Ltd., Xiangyang, China). In 2014 and 2015, we evaluated the yield performance and N requirement in mechanically transplanted rice grown under high and low planting densities (Huanget al.2018). The results showed that equal grain yields can be obtained with significant reductions in N application rates in mechanically transplanted rice grown under high planting density compared to low planting density(Fig. 4-A). This finding is consistent with those reported in rice grown under manual transplanting and seedling throwing conditions (Huanget al. 2013; Zhuet al. 2016; Liuet al.2019). Here, we further estimated the combined effect of increasing planting density and reducing N application rate on N loss in mechanically transplanted rice and found that an average N loss reduction of 40% was achieved(Fig. 4-B). These results indicate that mechanically dense transplanting is a practical approach to reduce N application rate and N loss for rice production in China.
Although some problems (e.g., increased seeding rate) have been encountered in developing mechanical transplanting for rice, especially for hybrid rice with expensive seeds (Huang and Zou 2019), they are gradually being resolved with the emergence of new technologies such as mechanically dense transplanting of single seedlings(Huang and Zou 2019). Moreover, it has been documented that hybrid rice transplanted as single seedlings does not necessarily require more N fertilizer to produce high grain yield because compensation among yield attributes and increased N use efficiency always occurs with reducing N application rate (Huanget al. 2019). We believe that popularizing mechanically dense transplanting in major rice-producing areas (excluding terraced rice areas where mechanization is not appropriate) will help reduce the environmental risk of N in China.

Fig. 4 Grain yield (A) and nitrogen (N) loss rate (B) vs. N application rate in mechanically transplanted rice grown under high(closed circle, 36×104 hills ha-1 with a hill spacing of 25 cm×11 cm) and low (open circle, 19×104 hills ha-1 with a hill spacing of 25 cm×21 cm) planting densities. Data of grain yield and N application rate were collected from Huang et al. (2018). Data of N loss rate were calculated by multiplying N application rate by N loss proportion, and the latter was estimated by the logarithmic relationship between N loss proportion and N application rate plotted by Ju et al. (2009). Data are mean±SE (n=4). LSD(0.05)bars denote the least significant difference between the means at the 0.05 probability level.
Acknowledgements
This work was supported by the National R&D Program of China (2017YFD0301503) and the earmarked fund for China Agriculture Research System (CARS-01).
杂志排行
Journal of Integrative Agriculture的其它文章
- Evaluation of sugar and organic acid composition and their levels in highbush blueberries from two regions of China
- An optimized industry processing technology of peanut tofu and the novel prediction model for suitable peanut varieties
- Effects of water application uniformity using a center pivot on winter wheat yield, water and nitrogen use efficiency in the North China Plain
- Spatial variability of soil properties in red soil and its implications for site-specific fertilizer management
- Phosphorus fertilization alters complexity of paddy soil dissolved organic matter
- Two farnesyl pyrophosphate synthases, GhFPS1-2, in Gossypium hirsutum are involved in the biosynthesis of farnesol to attract parasitoid wasps
