Root cell walls and phytochelatins in low-cadmium cultivar of Brassica parachinensis
2020-06-24YanSUNHuiYEZebinWEIXuhuiKONGandQitangWU
Yan SUN,Hui YE,Zebin WEI,Xuhui KONG and Qitang WU,∗
1Key Laboratory on Soil Environment and Waste Reuse in Agriculture of Guangdong Higher Education Institutes, College of Natural Resources and Environment,South China Agricultural University,Guangzhou 510642(China)
2College of Life Science,South China Agricultural University,Guangzhou 510642(China)
3Key Laboratory on Agricultural Ecology and Rural Environment of Guangdong Higher Education Institutes, South China Agricultural University,Guangzhou 510642(China)
ABSTRACT‘Lvbao-701’is a cultivar of Chinese flowering cabbage(Brassica parachinensis)that exhibits low cadmium(Cd)accumulation and high Cd tolerance.In this study,this cultivar was compared with a high-Cd accumulating cultivar,‘Chixin-4’,to characterize the mechanisms influencing Cd accumulation in B.parachinensis.Root cell walls were isolated by dissolving the cytoplasm with an organic solvent,and root Cd and phytochelatin(PC)contents were analyzed.In addition,a PC synthase gene fragment was cloned and expressed under Cd stress conditions.The proportions of Cd bound to root cell walls were higher in the‘Lvbao-701’plants(68.32%—76.80%)than in the‘Chixin-4’plants(35.36%—54.18%)after exposure to Cd stress.The proportions of Cd bound to root cell walls measured using cell walls isolated with a non-destructive method were higher than those obtained using a conventional method that required grinding and centrifugation.Exposure to Cd stress induced the PC production and resulted in higher PC contents in the‘Lvbao-701’plants than in the‘Chixin-4’plants.Cloning and expression analysis of a B.parachinensis PC synthase cDNA fragment indicated that PC synthase gene expression was induced by Cd and occurred mainly in the roots of both‘Lvbao-701’and‘Chixin-4’plants.However,the PC synthase gene expression level was higher in the‘Lvbao-701’roots than in the‘Chixin-4’roots.Therefore,a higher abundance of Cd in the root cell walls of‘Lvbao-701’and up-regulated PC production in the roots are probably the main reasons why‘Lvbao-701’exhibits lower Cd translocation to the shoots and higher tolerance to Cd than‘Chixin-4’.
Key Words: cadmium accumulation,cadmium stress,cadmium tolerance,cadmium translocation,gene expression,Lvbao-701,phytochelatin synthase
INTRODUCTION
Heavy metal contamination of agricultural lands is widespread, particularly in China, and cadmium (Cd) is the major pollutant among the heavy metals based on the contaminated land area(MEPC,2014).Bioaccumulation of Cd in the food chain through soil-plant systems can be very harmful to humans.Cadmium poisoning can adversely affect the respiratory,cardiovascular,and renal systems and cause skeletal lesions.It was responsible for an outbreak of itai-itai disease in Japan during the 1970s(Adriano,1986).Therefore, studies on the accumulation of Cd in plants have attracted considerable attention(Salt et al.,1995;Hart et al.,1998).Plants in general,and even varieties within species,differ in terms of Cd accumulation and tolerance(Adriano,1986). Cadmium tolerance has been attributed to several factors, such as compartmentalization of Cd, complexation with organic acids,and binding by peptides containing sulfhydryl groups. Phytochelatins (PCs) can form Cd-PC chelates,which are stored in vacuoles,and play an important role in Cd detoxification(Vögeli-Lange and Wagner,1990;Zenk,1996;Sghayar et al.,2015).
The low accumulation of Cd by cereals has been extensively studied(Grant et al.,2008).The large amounts of PCs produced in barley roots contributed to greater retention of Cd in barley roots than in lettuce roots (Akhter et al.,2012).Six barley cultivars also differed in their capacity to load Cd ions into the xylem,which is negatively correlated to root PC content(Sghayar et al.,2015).In rice,some genes that regulate Cd accumulation have been identified(Ueno et al.,2010).In addition,a low-Cd commercial durum wheat cultivar(i.e.,‘Strongfield’)has been generated(Clarke et al.,2005),and it is widely grown in Canada(Grant et al.,2008).
The low levels of Cd accumulation in Brassica vegetables have not yet been thoroughly investigated. Chinese cabbage(Brassica rapa L.ssp.chinensis)has been studied,and some low-Cd cultivars have been selected(Chen et al.,2012).Chinese flowering cabbage(Brassica parachinensis)is one of the main leafy vegetables grown in southern China and Southeast Asia,with its flowering-stage shoot consumed as a vegetable.Some low-Cd cultivars were selected and observed to retain Cd in the root cell walls(Xu et al.,2002;Ye,2010).Compared with high-Cd cultivars,low-Cd cultivars have a lower stem:root xylem Cd ratio,fewer low-molecularweight organic acids, and a greater abundance of amino acid-bound Cd(Wu et al.,2007).A low-Cd accumulating,but highly tolerant B. parachinensis cultivar was recently identified(i.e.,‘Lvbao-701’)(Ye,2010).The shoot Cd level is relatively low in this cultivar(less than 50%of the average concentration in nine studied cultivars).However,whether PCs influence the tolerance of this cultivar is unknown.In this study, we aimed to compare the PC contents and PC synthase gene expression levels between‘Lvbao-701’and a high-Cd accumulating cultivar‘Chixin-4’(Xu et al.,2002).Furthermore,a non-destructive method(Hart et al.,1992)was used to isolate the root cell walls instead of conventional methods,which require grinding,homogenization,centrifugation (Nishizono et al., 1987), or sieving (Wang et al.,2009),to clarify the effects of root cell walls on Cd accumulation.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Plant materials and growth conditions
The Chinese flowering cabbage(B.parachinensis)cultivars‘Lvbao-701’and‘Chixin-4’used in this study were obtained from the Vegetable Institute of the Agricultural Academy of Guangdong Province,China.The seeds were surface-sterilized in 5 g L−1NaOCl for 20 min,rinsed,and germinated in the dark on moistened filter paper covering cleaned small-grain gravel in black polyethylene cups with mesh bottoms.After 48 h,each cup with germinated seeds was positioned in a hole in a plastic board(four holes per board and one plant per hole).The board was placed in a 25-L plastic case containing 1/2 Hoagland nutrient solution so that the bottom of each cup was immersed in the nutrient solution. The plants were grown in a greenhouse under natural light and temperature conditions for 10 d.The nutrient solution was then supplemented with Cd to final concentrations of 0.0,0.5,and 5.0µmol L−1.The growth solutions were replaced with fresh Cd-containing solutions after 5 d, and the plants were harvested after 10 d. Three replicates were used for each Cd concentration and cultivar.
Plant treatment and analysis
The shoots and roots were collected separately and washed once with tap water and then three times with distilled water.Root cell wall preparations that maintained the morphological characteristics of intact roots were also collected.The root systems were immersed in a methanol:chloroform(2:1,volume:volume)solution for 3 d and then rinsed several times with distilled water for 1 d(Hart et al.,1992).This treatment yields lipid-free cell wall preparations in maize,while maintaining the structure and morphological characteristics of intact roots (Hart et al., 1992). The root cell wall was also obtained using another published method(Nishizono et al.,1987).The washed roots were cut into small pieces,lyophilized,and ground in a mill.The ground root material was homogenized and sonicated for 10 min in 10 mL of 10 mmol L−12-(N-morpholino)ethanesulfonic acid-NaOH buffer(pH 6.0)per 1 g of root.The slurry was centrifuged at 750 × g for 10 min at 4◦C, and then the supernatant(i.e.,cytoplasmic fraction)was removed.The residue was mixed with 10 mL of 5 g L−1sodium lauryl sulfate and centrifuged at 30 000×g for 10 min.This procedure was repeated three times.The residue was washed three times in 10 mL of distilled water.The wet root cell wall samples obtained using the two methods were then placed on filter paper, oven-dried at 75◦C for 48 h, and ground using a stainless steel grinder.The Cd concentrations in the root cell walls,whole roots,and shoots were determined using an AA 220Z atomic absorption spectrometer (Varian, Australia)after the dried and ground plant tissues were digested with concentrated HNO3and HClO4(4:1,volume:volume).
Non-protein thiols(NPTs)were extracted by grinding 2 g of fresh roots in 4 mL of 0.16 mol L−1sulfosalicylic acid and 6.3 mmol L−1diethylene triamine pentaacetic acid(1:19,volume:volume)with quartz sand in a mortar at 0◦C for 30 min(Devi and Prasad,1998).The homogenate was centrifuged at 10 000×g for 10 min at 4◦C.The clear supernatants were collected and immediately used for thiol measurements.The abundance of total acid-soluble −SH compounds(i.e.,NPTs)was determined using Ellman’s reagent(Devi and Prasad,1998).Glutathione,including reduced(GSH)and oxidized glutathione(GSSG),levels were assayed according to the GSSG-recycling method(Anderson,1985)with a detection kit purchased from the Nanjing Jiancheng Bioengineering Institute, China. The abundance of non-glutathione NPTs was used to represent the PC content(De Vos et al.,1992).
Isolation of PC synthase cDNA
Total RNA was isolated from B. parachinensis plants by using TRIzol reagent(TaKaRa,Japan),according to the manufacturer’s instructions. The N-terminus of PC synthase genes are highly conserved in most organisms. Two degenerate primers(forward primer:5′-TGGAA(AG)GGGCCTTGGAG(GA)TGGT-3′;reverse primer:5′-TCTTTGAT(AC)CC(AT)GACCA(GT)GT-3′)were designed according to the conserved domains of Arabidopsis thaliana and Brassica juncea PC synthase cDNA sequences.Polymerase chain reaction(PCR)was used to amplify the PC synthase cDNA sequences under the following conditions:94◦C for 2 min;35 cycles of 94◦C for 30 s, 53◦C for 30 s, and 72◦C for 1 min; and 72◦C for 10 min.The PCR products were purified using agarose gel electrophoresis,cloned into the pMD18-T simple vector by using DH5α Escherichia coli cells,and sequenced(Sangon Biotech,China).The amplified B.parachinensis PC synthase gene fragment was similar to known PC synthase gene sequences.
Semi-quantitative reverse transcription PCR
Expression of the B. parachinensis PC synthase gene was analyzed using semi-quantitative reverse transcription PCR, as described by Zhang et al. (2005). Primers were designed for the PC synthase gene(5′-GGCCTTGGAGGTGGTTTGAT-3′and 5′-AGGTAAGGCCAGCAGAAGTA-3′)and β-adenosine triphosphatase(β-ATPase)gene(5′-CTGAATCAATCTCTTAAGCTG-3′and 5′-GTGCAGAAAGTTCTACAGAACTAC-3′) as a reference. Expression analyses were conducted in 20-µL tubes containing 10µL of PCR buffer,0.8µL of reverse transcriptase mix,and 0.8µL of each primer.The PCR conditions were as described above,but with only 30 cycles.
Statistical analysis
Means and standard errors were calculated using Microsoft Office Excel 2003.Analysis of variance and comparisons between means were completed by Duncan’s test with SAS 8.1(SAS Institute Inc.,USA)(Hong and Hou,2004).
RESULTS
Cd contents in shoots and roots
The shoot and root Cd concentrations for the two contrasting B.parachinensis cultivars are presented in Table I.Analysis of variance for a two-factor randomized design revealed that there were significant Cd dosage effects on the shoot and root Cd contents as well as on the different cultivars.Regarding the cultivar effect,no significant differences were observed in the shoot Cd concentrations between the two cultivars, which was in contrast with the root Cd concentrations. The‘Lvbao-701’plants retained considerably more Cd in their roots than‘Chixin-4’plants.The Cd concentration ratio of shoot:root decreased under Cd stress conditions for both cultivars. This result implied that the roots function as a barrier to prevent the translocation of Cd to the shoots,especially in‘Lvbao-701’plants,which showed a much lower shoot:root Cd ratio than‘Chixin-4’plants at 0.5µmol L−1Cd.However,the Cd concentration ratio of shoot:root in the‘Lvbao-701’plants increased at 5.0µmol L−1Cd,indicating the ability of the roots to prevent the translocation of Cd to the shoots approached the upper limit at 5.0µmol L−1Cd.Under Cd stress conditions,the‘Lvbao-701’plants retained more Cd in the roots than in the shoots,resulting in a shoot:root Cd ratio of less than 1.In contrast, the ratio for the‘Chixin-4’plants was always greater than 2.
Cd concentrations in root cell walls
The Cd concentrations in root cell walls for the two contrasting B. parachinensis cultivars, determined using cell walls extracted with a non-destructive method(Hart et al.,1992),are presented in Table II.The‘Lvbao-701’root cell walls retained considerably more Cd than the‘Chixin-4’root cell walls, especially when exposed to Cd stress conditions.Under the treatment conditions,56.08%of the Cd present in the‘Lvbao-701’roots was located in the cell wall in the absence of Cd stress,while 68.32%—76.80%of the root Cd was present in the cell wall under Cd stress conditions. In contrast, 26.78%—54.18% of the Cd in the‘Chixin-4’roots was localized to the cell wall under all treatment conditions. In addition, the proportion of root Cd concentration located in the cell walls obtained using the non-destructive method(Hart et al.,1992)was higherthan that in the cell walls collected using the procedure that required grinding and centrifugation(Nishizono et al.,1987).The difference reached 10%—20%.

TABLE I Shoot and root biomass and Cd concentrations for two contrasting Brassica parachinensis cultivars,‘Lvbao-701’and‘Chixin-4’,exposed to different Cd concentrations for 10 d in a hydroponic culture
Root PC contents
In the absence of Cd stress, the two B. parachinensis cultivars contained similar amounts of NPTs and PCs(Table III). However, the ‘Lvbao-701’plants grown in a hydroponic culture produced more NPTs and PCs than the‘Chixin-4’plants at 0.5µmol L−1Cd.Both cultivars produced considerably more NPTs and PCs at 5.0µmol L−1Cd than at 0.5µmol L−1Cd,and the‘Lvbao-701’plants produced significantly more NPTs and PCs than the‘Chixin-4’plants at the higher Cd concentration.
PC synthase gene isolation and expression analysis
The amplified B.parachinensis‘Lvbao-701’PC synthase gene fragment is shown in Fig.1.The cDNA fragment was 1 070 bp in length and encoded a putative protein composed of 356 amino acids (Figs. S1 and S2, see Supplementary Material for Figs.S1 and S2).The putative B.parachinensis PC synthase was highly homologous to PC synthases from other plants,i.e.,89%homologous to B.juncea PC synthase(386—1 461 bp;GenBank accession No.AB057416),88%homologous to A. thaliana PC synthase (226—1 301 bp;GenBank accession No.AF461180),and 87%homologous to Thlaspi caerulescens PC synthase(364—1 439 bp;GenBank accession No.AY540104).These results indicated that the cloned fragment was from a PC synthase gene.

Fig.1 Amplified Brassica parachinensis‘Lvbao-701’phytochelatin synthase gene fragment(A)and DNA markers(M)separated using agarose gel electrophoresis.

TABLE II Cd concentrations in the root cell wallsa) of two contrasting Brassica parachinensis cultivars, ‘Lvbao-701’and ‘Chixin-4’, exposed to different Cd concentrations for 10 d in a hydroponic culture

TABLE III Non-protein thiol,total glutathione,and phytochelatin contents in the roots of two contrasting Brassica parachinensis cultivars,‘Lvbao-701’and‘Chixin-4’,exposed to different Cd concentrations for 10 d in a hydroponic culture
The semi-quantitative PCR analysis of B.parachinensis PC synthase gene expression levels under Cd stress conditions(Fig.2)revealed the gene was expressed mainly in the roots of the two studied cultivars.In addition,the expression level was higher in the‘Lvbao-701’plants than in the‘Chixin-4’plants under all Cd treatments.The expression of the PC synthase gene in the‘Lvbao-701’plants increased with increasing Cd concentrations,while the increase in the‘Chixin-4’plants was less obvious.These results,along with the observed high PC content in the roots of the‘Lvbao-701’plants,suggested that PC synthase gene expression may be important for the tolerance to Cd stress exhibited by this cultivar.
DISCUSSION
While studying the detoxification and translocation of Cd in Brassica vegetables,Wu et al.(2015)investigated the physiological and genetic processes involved in Cd uptake and transport in two oilseed rape(Brassica napus)cultivars.They observed that Cd accumulates more in the ‘L351’shoots than in the‘L338’shoots,while the opposite trend occurs in the roots.In addition,the Cd transport genes are more highly expressed in the‘L351’plants.Cd translocation to shoots is a determining factor for Cd accumulation in the shoots.Sun et al.(2013)reported that the increases of PC and citric acid contents in leaf and root are more pronounced in the Cd-tolerant cabbage(Brassica oleracea L.)cultivar‘CF’than in the Cd-sensitive cultivar ‘LF’. However, the contributions of PCs and citric acid to Cd detoxification may be smaller than that of the cell walls.The above-mentioned Brassica vegetables are not low-Cd species.More than 66%of the Cd taken up by cabbage is transported to shoots(Sun et al., 2013), while oilseed rape may be considered a Cdhyperaccumulating plant(Ru et al.,2004).Although Chinese flowering cabbage is also a Brassica species,we observed that less than 50%of the Cd taken up by the‘Lvbao-701’plants was transported to the shoots(Table I)after exposure to Cd stress.The ability of the root cell wall to bind Cd may explain this result.Indeed,the root cell wall retained more than 30%of the Cd taken up by the whole plant.
The cell wall extraction methods that require grinding and centrifugation probably underestimate the proportion of Cd bound to the cell walls.A reason for this may be the redistribution and rebalancing of Cd among cell components during the grinding and centrifugation steps.Cell components and Cd are thoroughly mixed in the ground suspension,which disturbs the original subcellular compartmentalization of Cd.However,we did not wash the roots with an exchanging solution(e.g.,CaCl2)(Rauser,1987).Therefore,the total root Cd concentration (Table I) was probably overestimated in this study because it was influenced by the amount of Cd adsorbed to the cell walls surrounding the root parenchyma cells.In other words,the Cd concentrations reported in this study represent the Cd retained, but not necessarily absorbed,in the roots.
Regarding the role of PCs in Cd detoxification and translocation,Gong et al.(2003)revealed that the formation of Cd-PC chelates promotes the translocation of Cd to the aerial parts of a high-Cd A.thaliana plant.However,Gasic and Korban(2007)concluded that transgenic Indian mustard(B.juncea,a high-Cd plant)plants that express an A.thaliana PC synthase gene exhibit enhanced Cd tolerance,with upregulated production of PCs and other thiols.However,they did not observe increased Cd translocation from the roots to the shoots.In this study,it was revealed that the PC synthase gene expression level and root PC contents were higher in a low-Cd B.parachinensis cultivar than in a high-Cd cultivar.Thus, PCs may increase the detoxification of Cd, but not affect Cd translocation from the roots to the shoots. The Cd-PC complexes are assumed to transport Cd to the root vacuole(Sanita di Toppi and Gabbrielli,1999).Therefore,they decrease the amount of Cd available for translocation to aerial tissues.In B.parachinensis,the Cd concentration in soluble fractions,including the root vacuole solution,was higher in the‘Lvbao-701’plants(3.17µg g−1fresh weight)than in the ‘Chixin-4’plants (1.78 µg g−1fresh weight)after exposure to 0.5 µmol L−1Cd (Ye, 2010). However,the proportion of total root Cd content localized in the root soluble fractions was higher for‘Chixin-4’than for‘Lvbao-701’plants at all tested Cd concentrations(Ye,2010).This means that the Cd-PC chelates in the roots of the low-Cd B.parachinensis cultivar mainly affect Cd detoxification rather than Cd accumulation in the shoots.

Fig.2 Semi-quantitative polymerase chain reaction analysis of the phytochelatin synthase gene(PCS1)expression levels in the shoots and roots of two Brassica parachinensis cultivars, ‘Lvbao-701’(a) and ‘Chixin-4’(b), exposed to 0.0, 0.5, and 5.0 µmol L−1 Cd for 10 d. β-ATPase = β-adenosine triphosphatase.
CONCLUSIONS
The objective of this study was to clarify the effects of PCs and root cell walls on Cd accumulation in the low-Cd Chinese flowering cabbage cultivar ‘Lvbao-701’. The Cd concentration and proportion of Cd bound to the root cell walls were higher in the ‘Lvbao-701’plants than in the high-Cd‘Chixin-4’plants.The high proportion of Cd bound to the root cell walls in the ‘Lvbao-701’plants under Cd stress conditions is a main reason for the low rate of Cd translocation to the shoots in this cultivar. Future studies should use a non-destructive method to isolate root cell walls for Cd retention analysis. In addition, ‘Lvbao-701’plants produced more PCs than‘Chixin-4’plants.This is supported by the fact that the PC synthase gene expression level was higher in the ‘Lvbao-701’plants than in the ‘Chixin-4’plants.The higher production of PCs in roots is important for Cd detoxification in low-Cd B.parachinensis cultivars.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
This study was supported by the National Natural Science Foundation of China(No.41371308),the Science and Technology Supporting Project of China (No. 2015-BAD05B05), and the Research Project of the Education Department of Guangdong Province, China (No. 2013-CXZDA007).
SUPPLEMENTARY MATERIAL
Supplementary material for this article can be found in the online version.
杂志排行
Pedosphere的其它文章
- Notes to Authors
- Effect of nitrogen limitation on antioxidant qualities is highly associated with genotypes of lettuce(Lactuca sativa L.)
- Soil organic carbon and phosphorus availability regulate abundance of culturable phosphate-solubilizing bacteria in paddy fields
- Nature of redox concentrations in a sequence of agriculturally developed acid sulfate soils in Thailand
- Downed logs improve soil properties in old-growth temperate forests of northern Iran
- Long-time precipitation reduction and nitrogen deposition increase alter soilnitrogen dynamic by influencing soil bacterial communities and functional groups
