APP下载

Nature of redox concentrations in a sequence of agriculturally developed acid sulfate soils in Thailand

2020-06-24TanabhatsakornSUKITPRAPANONAnchaleeSUDDHIPRAKARNIrbKHEORUENROMNESomchaiANUSONTPORNPERMandRobertGILKES

Pedosphere 2020年3期

Tanabhatsakorn SUKITPRAPANON,Anchalee SUDDHIPRAKARN,∗,Irb KHEORUENROMNE,Somchai ANUSONTPORNPERM and Robert J.GILKES

1Department of Soil Science,Faculty of Agriculture,Kasetsart University,Bangkok 10900(Thailand)

2School of Earth and Environment,The University of Western Australia,35 Stirling Highway,Crawley WA 6009(Australia)

ABSTRACT Potential acid sulfate soils(PASS)are drained for agriculture,resulting in the formation of active acid sulfate soils(AASS),which gradually evolve into post-active acid sulfate soils(PAASS).Various redox concentrations(precipitates,costings,and mottles)occur in these soils as a result of pedogenic processes including biological activity and effects of land management.Although several studies have determined the mineralogy and geochemistry of ASS,the mineralogy and geochemistry of redox concentrations occurring in a sequence of ASS through PASS to PAASS have not been investigated.This study examined the mineralogy and geochemistry of redox concentrations and matrices within 5 PASS,8 AASS,and 5 PAASS in Thailand.The labile minerals were predominantly controlled by oxidation status and management inputs.The unoxidized layers of PASS,AASS,and PAASS contained pyrite and mackinawite.The oxidation of Fe sulfides caused acidification and accumulation of yellow redox concentrations of jarosite and Fe(hydr)oxides at shallow depths.As the soils became well developed,they were recognized as PAASS,and the jarosite and goethite transformed to hematite.As ASS were drained,Co,Mn,Ni,and Zn moved downward and were associated with Fe sulfides and Mn oxides in the unoxided layer.Concentrations of As,Cu,Cr,Fe,and V did not change with depth because these elements became associated with jarosite and Fe(hydr)oxides in yellow and red redox concentrations,as well as the root zone,in the partly oxidized layer of AASS and PAASS.Arsenic was associated with pyrite under reducing conditions.

Key Words: active acid sulfate soils,geochemistry,mineralogy,post-active acid sulfate soils,potential acid sulfate soils,trace metals

INTRODUCTION

Potential acid sulfate soils (PASS) disturbed by natural and manmade drainage experience the oxidation of Fe sulfide minerals and sulfur that are stable under reducing conditions(Kraal et al.,2013).Consequently,the soils become acidic and release dissolved Fe,Al,Mn,Ni,and other contaminants into groundwater if there is insufficient neutralization capacity(Åström,2001;Österholm and Åström,2002;Burton et al.,2008;Gröger et al.,2011).The PASS are waterlogged soils with highly reducing conditions and transformed by drainage to active acid sulfate soils(AASS)due to the oxidation of Fe sulfides and sulfur. Eventually,AASS may be transformed by land management practices to post-active acid sulfate soils(PAASS)(Fanning,2012).In Thailand,where drainage of acid sulfate soils(ASS)has been carried out for more than 140 years,many PASS have become PAASS, but little is known of the effects of this transition on soil composition.

Under the reducing conditions of PASS,the dark gray color of organic-rich sulfidic sediments is evident,and pyrite(FeS2) is the dominant sulfide, comprising about 10—40 g kg−1of the soil (Gröger et al., 2011). Oxidation of Fe sulfides in PASS with little carbonate results in the acidification and accumulation of Fe minerals in the form of variously colored redox concentrations, which represent the zone of apparent accumulation of Fe-Mn oxides(Soil Survey Staff,2014).The pale-yellow minerals jarosite(KFe3(SO4)2(OH)6)and natrojarosite(NaFe3(SO4)2(OH)6),reddish-orange schwertmannite (Fe8O8(OH)4.6(SO4)1.7),lepidocrocite (γ-FeOOH), and goethite (α-FeOOH) (Sullivan and Bush, 2004; Fitzpatrick and Shand, 2008),pale yellowish-green sideronatrite(Na2Fe(SO4)2·OH·3H2O)(Fitzpatrick et al., 2008), and red hematite (Fe2O3) (van Breemen and Harmsen, 1975)occur in these soils. In the Netherlands,sediments from the former Zuyder Sea were developed for agriculture in a similar manner to those in Thailand. The Dutch sediments contain more than 10 g kg−1of reduced sulfur,but they also contain relatively high amounts of carbonate, which prevents acidification upon land reclamation(Pons and van Breemen,1982);this is not the case in Thailand.

Although a number of studies have determined the mineralogy and geochemistry in particular ASS environments such as coastal ASS (Åström, 1998; Deng et al., 1998;Sullivan and Bush, 2004; Boman et al., 2010; Vithana et al.,2015)and inland ASS(Fitzpatrick et al.,2008;Mosley et al., 2014; Virtanen et al., 2014; Creeper et al., 2015),the mineralogical and geochemical characteristics of redox concentrations occurring in a sequence of agriculturally developed ASS ranging from PASS through AASS into PAASS have not been investigated.Thus,the objective of this study was to determine the mineralogy and chemical compositions of various redox concentrations occurring in PASS,AASS,and PAASS.This study will provide a better understanding of the changing nature of redox concentrations in ASS as the soils are developed,particularly for agriculture.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Soil sampling

The 18 ASS sites representing PASS,AASS,and PAASS investigated in this study are in the Lower Central Plain Delta and the Southeast Coast of Thailand,where estuarine sediments were deposited during the Holocene epoch(Sinsakul,2000)(Fig.1).Thailand is located in the tropical area between latitudes 5◦37′N and 20◦27′N and longitudes 97◦22′E and 100◦37′E. The climate is tropical savanna with a tropical monsoonal climate and an average annual temperature of 27—30◦C.The rainy season extends from mid-August to mid-October,with an average rainfall of 903 and 1 418 mm for the Central and Eastern regions,respectively(Meteorological Department,2015).

Soil materials are more sandy (clay-sandy clay loam)in the Southeast Coast area than in the Lower Central Plain(clay-silty clay loam)because the sediments in the Southeast Coast have been derived from granitic rocks(Charusiri et al.,1993),while those in the Lower Central Plain have originated in a complex alluvial and deltaic environment (Sinsakul,2000).Field-moist soil samples were collected from the topsoil,partly oxidized and unoxidized parent material layers from 5 PASS(PASS 1—PASS 5),8 AASS(AASS 1—AASS 8),and 5 PAASS(PAASS 1—PAASS 5)in the dry season from October 2012 to February 2013. Soil samples were collected by hand auger to a maximum depth of 2 m and packed in sealed plastic containers. They were described and classified by Soil Taxonomy(Soil Survey Staff,2014)(Table I).Soil samples were split into two subsamples for bulk soil analysis and for analysis of the soil matrix and redox concentrations.

Bulk soil sample analyses

Fig.1 Sampling locations for acid sulfate soils(ASS)on the Lower Central Plain and the Southeast Coast of Thailand.PASS=potential ASS;AASS=active ASS;PAASS=post-active ASS.

TABLE I Field data for acid sulfate soils(ASS)in Thailand sampled in the dry season(October 2012—January 2013)for the investigation of this study

Physicochemical properties were determined on fieldmoist soil samples,but they were reported on an oven-dried(105◦C)basis.The particle size distribution was determined by the pipette method (Gee and Bauder, 1986). Redox potential (Eh) of PASS was determined with a calibrated electrode. The Eh of AASS and PAASS was generally not measured and was not listed because these soils had been partly and inhomogeneously oxidized by drainage.The Eh reading was recorded when a steady state was obtained.This occurred after approximately 5—10 min,and Eh values were reported in mV relative to the standard hydrogen electrode.Soil pH and electrical conductivity(EC)of saturated soil paste were measured in the laboratory within 24 h of collection from the field.The pH(H2O)was measured in water,using a soil:water(weight:volume)ratio of 1:1(National Soil Survey Center,2004).The pH(H2O2)was measured in 30%hydrogen peroxide solution adjusted to pH 5.5, using a soil:solution (weight:volume) ratio of 1:5 (Ahern et al., 2004). Total organic carbon (OC) was determined using a CN analyzer(Vario Macro,Elementar,Germany).Peroxide-oxidizable sulfur(SPOS),which was the sulfate produced from oxidation of reduced inorganic sulfur during peroxide oxidation,was determined by the complete suspension peroxide oxidation combined with acidity and sulfur(SPOCAS)method(Ahern et al.,2004).

Metal concentrations (As, Co, Cr, Cu, Fe, Mn, Ni,V, and Zn) in the bulk soil samples were determined by X-ray fluorescence spectrometry (XRF) of fused lithium metatetraborate discs (Norrish and Hutton, 1969) for Cr and V and by inductively coupled plasma-optical emission spectrometry (ICP-OES, Optima 7300 DV, Perin Elmer,USA)of aqua regia digests(3:1 HCl:HNO3at 130◦C for 1 h)(APHA,1998)for As,Co,Cu,Fe,Mn,Ni,and Zn.

Organic matter,metal sulfides,clay minerals,and some micas(mostly trioctahedral biotite)were almost completely dissolved in aqua regia,while sand-size quartz,feldspars,muscovite,and amphiboles were dissolved to a limited extent(Chao,1984).Hereafter,aqua regia digestion was referred to as total element digestion.

Soil matrix and redox concentration analyses

Hand-picked materials were separated from subsoil samples by hand under a dissecting microscope(Fig.2).These materials consisted of 43 soil matrices,14 root zone materials,13 red redox concentrations,27 yellow redox concentrations,and 20 unoxidized layer subsamples.A few drops of chloroform were added to the separated materials to suppress microbial activity.

The color of the redox concentration was measured under field-moist conditions using a Munsell Soil Color Chart(Munsell Color,2000)(Table II).Concentrations of Al,As,Co,Cr,Cu,Fe,K,Mn,Ni,S,Si,V,and Zn in hand-picked materials of soil matrix and variously colored redox concentrations were determined using ICP-OES on a digest obtained with aqua regia(3:1 HCl:HNO3)and a solid:solution ratio of 1:16 at 130◦C for 1 h (APHA, 1998). The analytical methods were assessed for accuracy and precision using a rigorous control system with reagent blanks and certified reference materials, including stream sediment reference material STSD 3(Lynch,1999)and multi-element reference material OREAS 43P(Ore Research and Exploration Pty Ltd.,1997)for aqua regia digests and XRF,respectively.

Hand-picked materials were rapidly dried using ethanol and deposited onto a SiO2single-crystal low background holder for X-ray diffraction (XRD) using copper Kα radiation, scanning between 3◦and 70◦2θ with a 0.02◦2θ step size and a scan speed of 0.02◦2θ per second. The

morphology, chemical compositions, and elemental mapping of hand-picked materials were determined by scanning electron microscopy (SEM) with energy dispersive spectroscopy(EDS)(SEM/EDS TESCAN VEGA3,15kV,TESCAN,Czech Republic)on samples prepared on aluminum stubs with a C coating.

TABLE II Morphology of representative potential,active,and post-active acid sulfate soils(ASS)in Thailand

Fig.2 A representative post-active acid sulfate soil(PAASS)(PAASS 4)under paddy rice cultivation(a),soil profile of representative PAASS 4(b),topsoil with plant roots(c),red redox concentrations in the partly oxidized layer(d),yellow redox concentrations in the partly oxidized layer(e),and unoxidized layer(f).

Statistical analyses

Principal component analysis (PCA) of the chemical analyses(Bellehumeur et al.,1994)was used to determine elements of similar geochemical behavior and to group samples on the basis of their geochemical affinity.An analysis of variance (ANOVA) using Tukey’s honest significance difference test for unequal sample sizes was used to determine significant differences in composition among the soil matrices of the partly oxidized layer, root zone material,red redox concentration, yellow redox concentration, and unoxidized layer. All data were log-transformed to meet the requirement of normality for ANOVA analysis (P <0.05).Log-transformed data were standardized to zero mean and unit variance before performing PCA using Statistica software version 8.0 for Windows.

RESULTS AND DISCUSSION

Soil characteristics

Potential acid sulfate soils. The PASS occurring in swamps or mangrove forests were classified as Typic Sulfaquents(Soil Survey Staff,2014)(Table I).They were located up to several kilometers from the coast(Fig.1).They consisted of a layer of dark grayish brown(2.5Y 4/2)loam(0—20 cm),underlain by massive dark grayish brown to dark greenish gray(Gley1 4/10Y)silt loam(>20 cm)materials(Table II),with various amounts of OC(median 39 and 23 g kg−1for topsoil and subsoil layers,respectively)(Table III).

The pH (H2O) values were mostly near-neutral, with some low values(Table III).The pH(H2O2)was much lower than pH(H2O)because of the oxidation of Fe sulfides,sulfur,and organic matter.The PASS subsoil generally experienced reducing conditions (median Eh of −33 mV), with the topsoil layer(median Eh of 149 mV)being oxidized.The EC values were similar for the topsoil and subsoil layers,ranging between 1.1 and 74 dS m−1depending on the influence of seawater.The SPOS contents ranged between 0.64 and 57 g kg−1.The median SPOS content of topsoil(0.82 g kg−1)was much lower than that of the unoxidized subsoil layer(19 g kg−1),indicating that the unoxidized layer contained much more Fe sulfide than the topsoil.

Active acid sulfate soils. The AASS in this study were mostly used for paddy rice cultivation.The soils at the AASS sites had a 15 cm or more thick sulfuric horizon(pH <4),with its upper horizon boundary within 50 cm of the soil surface.The median pH(H2O)values of the AASS were 3.6,3.7,and 4.7 for the topsoil,partly oxidized,and unoxidized layers, respectively (Table III). The soils are classified as Hydraquentic Sulfaquepts by Soil Taxonomy(Soil Survey Staff,2014)(Table I).Soil texture ranged from sandy loam to clay,and three soil layers were recognized(Table II).The topsoil layer(0—20 cm)had a black matrix(2.5Y 2.5/1)with light olive brown redox concentrations(2.5Y 5/3)in the root channels.The underlying partly oxidized layer(20—170 cm)had an angular blocky structure and consisted of olive yellow(2.5Y 6/8)to yellow(2.5Y 7/8)redox concentrations on the surface of peds of a very dark gray(2.5Y 3/1)and light olive brown(2.5Y 5/3)matrix.Beneath the partly oxidized layer was a massive dark grayish(2.5Y 4/1)unoxidized layer.

The AASS were utilized for agricultural practices that retained crop residues, and consequently the topsoil was richer in OC(median of 27 g kg−1)than the partly oxidized layer(median of 7.5 g kg−1)or unoxidized layer(median of 9.1 g kg−1)(Table III).The median EC value increased with depth,and SPOS content was much higher in the unoxidized layer where groundwater had excluded air,thus preventing oxidation of Fe,S,and organic matter.

Post-active acid sulfate soils. The PAASS were situated in the inland marginal zone of the delta,where drainage and agriculture had been carried out for many years(Fig.1).The PAASS contained the same sulfuric horizon(pH <4)asAASS.Their sulfuric horizon occurred above 2 m depth but was too deep(>50 cm from the soil surface)to affect most plants growing on these soils. These soils were classified as Sulfic Endoaquepts(Soil Survey Staff,2014)(Table I).The PAASS ranged from silty clay loam to clay in texture(Table II).Three layers were recognized. The topsoil was dark grayish brown(10YR 3/2)with reddish brown redox concentrations(5YR 4/4)along root channels and cracks.The partly oxidized layer extended to approximately 100 cm depth with an angular blocky structure,and redox concentrations were mainly dark red(10R 3/6),reddish yellow(7.5YR 6/8),dusky red(10R 3/4),and red(10R 4/8),occurring on the surface of structural units in a gray matrix(2.5Y 6/1).Yellow redox concentrations(2.5Y 8/8)in a weak red matrix(10R 4/2)occurred below 100 cm,while a dark gray color(2.5Y 4/1)was dominant in the massive unoxidized layer).

These data were consistent with the findings of van Breemen and Harmsen(1975),Öborn(1989),Janjirawuttikul et al.(2010),Johnston et al.(2011),and Sánchez-Maraňón et al.(2015),who demonstrated that yellowish brown(e.g.,10YR 5/6) and red (e.g., 7.5R 5/6, 10R 3/4) redox concentrations occurred in the upper layer and contained both pale yellow(e.g.,5Y 8/4)and yellowish brown(e.g.,2.5Y 5/2)redox concentrations at a greater depth in ASS profiles.These materials were underlain by a dark gray(e.g.,5Y 4/1)substratum.The soil color of ASS could change over a period of oxidation from very dark gray(4.3Y 3.3/1.5)to yellowish brown(9.8YR);this alteration became progressively deeper with development of ASS(Sánchez-Maraňón et al.,2015).

The PAASS contained large amounts of OC in the topsoil (Table III) as a consequence of retention of harvest residues.The median pH(H2O)value was greater than 4.0 in the topsoil and partly oxidized layers,which partly reflects amelioration of acidity by liming and drainage.Median pH(H2O2)was lower than pH(H2O)and in the same range as for PASS and AASS.The lower pH(H2O2)value is caused not only by the oxidation of Fe sulfides(Ahern et al.,2004;Soil Survey Staff, 2014), but also by the oxidation of soil organic matter. Douglas and Fiessinger (1971) stated that H2O2caused the oxidation of organic matter and degradation of clay minerals,especially 2:1 clay minerals.The Fe sulfides could be formed when ASS were re-flooded by fresh water(Johnston et al.,2014).This study indicates that even though PAASS have been managed for a long period of time,the acidity in PAASS profiles can result from oxidation of residual sulfidic materials and/or soil organic matter.

The median EC value of PAASS was lower than that of AASS owing to leaching, and it increased with depth(Table III).The SPOS content of the unoxidized layer was much higher than that of the partly oxidized layers.The low SPOS content of 0.01 g kg−1was for partly oxidized layers in PAASS 1 and PAASS 4,indicating that oxidation of Fe sulfides is almost complete.

Mineralogy of soil matrix and redox concentrations

The soil matrix and variously colored redox concentrations in the ASS mainly consisted of quartz, feldspars,kaolinite,and illite.Typical XRD patterns(Fig.3)showed the presence of minerals that was characteristic of the variously colored redox concentrations in topsoil,partly oxidized,and unoxidized layers.The ASS located near the coast contained halite because they were affected by seawater in the recent past.Pyrite and mackinawite occurred in unoxidized layers of PASS,AASS,and PAASS and in some partly oxidized layers of AASS and PAASS.Electron microscopy showed that both single crystal and framboidal forms of pyrite occurred in the unoxidized layer(Fig.4b,c).

The AASS and PAASS,commonly limed by farmers,contained gypsum formed by the reaction of calcite and sulfuric acid. Jarosite, goethite, and hematite, secondary Fe minerals, were present in the partly oxidized layer of ASS.Jarosite appeared to be absent within 50 cm of the soil surface of PAASS.Jarosite and small amounts of goethite had been deposited in yellow redox concentrations,coating the face of structural units/peds, and in root channels within the gray matrix in the partly oxidized layer of AASS and PAASS(Figs.3 and 4a).The high redox conditions on the ped surfaces had resulted from oxygen transported in pores,channels,and plant roots from aboveground into the unoxidized subsoil.The oxygen diffuses into the rhizosphere soil,causing local oxidation(Ferreira et al.,2007).Jarosite is the product of oxidation of Fe sulfides and can precipitate directly if Eh,pH,and the composition of the soil solution are appropriate(Fanning et al.,1993; Casas et al.,2007).Jarosite usually occurs in yellow redox concentrations,while goethite usually occurs in yellow to yellowish-red redox concentrations(Fanning et al.,1993;Schwertmann,1993).Small amounts of goethite in yellow redox concentrations observed in this study are probably owing to the hydrolysis of jarosite near the surface of peds.

Lepidocrocite occurs in red redox concentrations in the surface soil of PASS owing to ferrous oxidation at near neutral pH(>5)(Fitzpatrick et al.,2008;Johnston et al.,2011).Lepidocrocite does not commonly occur in red redox concentrations,usually occurring in reddish yellow to strong brown redox concentrations(Schwertmann,1993).The occurrence of lepidocrocite in red redox concentrations in the surface soil of PASS is due to lepidrocrocite precipitates being colored by red hematite(Fig.3).

Fig.3 Random powder X-ray diffraction patterns of hand-picked redox concentrations and matrix materials on a low background holder.Materials were selected from topsoil,partly oxidized,and unoxidized layers in acid sulfate soils.Qz=quartz;Fsp=feldspar;Ill=illite;Kln=kaolinite;Gt=goethite;Hem=hematite;Lep=lepidocrocite;Py=pyrite;Mkw=mackinawite;Jrs=jarosite;Gp=gypsum;Hl=halite;Tlc=talc.

Goethite and hematite were present in yellowish orange and red redox concentrations in the topsoil and partly oxidized layers.The red redox concentrations of hematite were dominant in the upper part of partly oxidized layers of PAASS(Table II),which were located at high elevations ranging from 3 to 11 m above mean sea level (Table I).Although, there is little information about the stability of hematite under aquic moisture conditions, a study by van Breemen and Harmsen(1975)reported that red redox concentrations of hematite in the soil surface of ASS were associated with elevation and good drainage. In addition,this study indicates that the red redox concentration of hematite exists in ASS, especially in upper soil profile of well-developed PAASS.These may have formed by dehydration of Fe(hydr)oxides,alteration of jarosite,or oxidation of Fe in soil solutions during the long dry season of the tropical savanna climate in Thailand.

The SEM backscattered electron micrograph of representative root zone material from a partly oxidized layer showed Fe oxides with quartz and clay minerals(Fig.5a).The EDS spectrum showed that Fe oxide,which could be either goethite(α-FeOOH)or lepidocrocite(γ-FeOOH),was a dominant mineral coating root material under oxidizing conditions(Fig.5b).The XRD results for root zone materials (Fig. 3) indicated that it was goethite (Fig. 5b). The elemental mapping and associated ternary diagram of the chemical composition of matrix showed Fe oxides with an admixture of Si,Al,and other elements from clay minerals in the matrix (Fig. 5). Black root zone materials under a reducing condition contained framboidal and single crystal pyrite,mackinawite,elemental sulfur,and Fe oxides together with matrix materials(Fig.6a).The chemical compositions of mackinawite and pyrite occurring in black root zone materials had Fe/S ratios consistent with the ideal compositions of FeS and FeS2,respectively(Fig.6f).Elemental sulfur was also present(Fig.6b,e)owing to incomplete oxidation of pore water sulfides by O2,Fe3+,and Mn4+(Aller and Rude,1988)or the partial oxidation of Fe monosulfides such as mackinawite(Burton et al.,2006).

Geochemistry of soil matrix and redox concentrations

Median concentrations of Al, As, Co, Cr, Cu, Fe, K,Mn, Ni, S, Si, V, and Zn in five classes of separated soil matrix and redox concentrations from PASS, AASS, and PAASS from the Lower Central Plain and the Southeast Coast are given in Table IV.Concentrations of Ca and Mg were not shown as they mostly reflected the various impacts of dolomitic limestone applied to soils.Similarly,amounts of Na and Cl were not shown as they reflect the residual effect of seawater. The elemental compositions of the separated materials from soils of the Lower Central Plain were similar to those from the Southeast Coast.The amounts of Al,Cu,and Si in the Lower Central Plain and the Southeast Coast soils were not systematically different for the five materials.Arsenic,Cr,Fe,K,S,and V were more abundant in colored redox concentrations,while the concentrations of Co,Mn,Ni,S,and Zn were higher in the unoxidized layer.

Principal component analysis of standardized logtransformed total concentrations of Al, As, Co, Cr, Cu,Fe,K,Mn,Ni,S,Si,V,and Zn for the five ASS materials showed that the first two components explained 50%of the variation,indicating that these materials are highly diverse in chemical composition,which partly reflects the considerable differences in composition of the parent materials and various pedoenvironment conditions of formation(Fig.7a,b).

Fig.4 Backscattered electron micrographs with energy dispersive spectra showing euhedral micron-size crystals of jarosite(K,Na,Fe,and S)and associated clay minerals(Al and Si)in a yellow redox concentration in the partly oxidized layer of an active acid sulfate soil(a),euhedral,5—10µm crystals of pyrite(Fe,S,and As)with minor quartz and clay minerals in the unoxidized layer of a potential acid sulfate soil(b),and framboidal pyrite(Fe and S)and minor clay minerals in the unoxidized layer of a potential acid sulfate soil(c).At.=atomic.

Fig.5 Yellow root zone material from the partly oxidized layer in an active acid sulfate soil described by scanning electron microscopy(SEM)backscattered electron micrograph showing plant root,Fe oxides,quartz,and clay minerals(a)with X-ray spectra for goethite(FeOOH)(b)and ternary diagram of the chemical composition of the yellow root zone material measured by energy dispersive spectroscopy(EDS)showing that it is mostly a mixture of matrix minerals and Fe oxides with no elemental S or pyrite(c).At.=atomic.

Elements were generally allocated into two major groups.The first group consisted of Co,Mn,Ni,and Zn,which were associated with unoxidized layers and situated along the factor 2 axis(Fig.7).Under reduced conditions,Co,Mn,Ni,and Zn are likely to be associated with Fe sulfides and Mn oxides(Åström,1998;Morse and Luther III,1999;Yin et al.,2006;Claffet al.,2011;Morgan et al.,2012).However,the PCA data showed that Co,Mn,and Zn were separated from Ni in the unoxidized layer along the factor 1 axis,indicating that Co and Zn were more closely associated with Mn oxides than with Fe sulfides in the unoxidized layer.The Mn oxides have a great affinity for Co and Zn but a poor affinity for Ni in natural environments(Tani et al.,2004).Reducing and acidic conditions of soils play important roles in the solubilization of Mn oxides(Kabata-Pendias,2011).Much Mn and associated Zn,Co,and Ni can occur in sediments in very fine-grained Mn oxides.After reduction,Mn and associated elements (Co, Zn, and Ni) are released and incorporated into Fe sulfides in PASS.These elements are removed under acidic conditions(Morse and Luther III,1999).Nickel was more strongly associated with Fe sulfides than with Mn oxides in the unoxidized layer,although in this study Fe was not associated with Ni in the unoxidized layer(Fig.7a).The PCA data showed that Fe made little contribution to the factor 2 axis(close to 0.0)because Fe is a major element in both colored redox concentrations and the unoxidized layer in the form of diverse redox-sensitive Fe minerals,such as jarosite,lepidocrocite,goethite,hematite,and Fe sulfides,as well as occurring in silicate clay minerals such as illite(Fig.3).Our data showed that Fe had a close association with yellow and red redox concentrations(Table IV).As a consequence,Fe was more associated with As, Cr, K, S, and V in colored redox concentrations than with Ni in the unoxidized layer,as shown in Fig.7a.According to Kabata-Pendias(2011),Ni can be present in sulfides in sediments rich in organic matter and under reducing conditions.X-ray spectra in this study demonstrated that Ni was present in framboidal pyrite in the waterlogged unoxidized layer(Fig.6c).

The second group of elements in the PCA diagram consisted of As,Cr,Fe,K,S,and V,which were associated with yellow and red redox concentrations and some root zone materials(Fig.7a,b).The yellow redox concentrations were grouped towards higher Fe, S, K, As, Cr, and V in the diagram, but showed no separation from red redox concentrations because these elements were constituents of jarosite and Fe(hydr)oxides,mostly occurring in yellow and red redox concentrations(Burton et al.,2008;Johnston et al.,2010;Gröger et al.,2011;Ketrot et al.,2014).The soil matrix was separated from other redox sensitive materials because it mostly contained smaller amounts of As,Co,Cr,Fe,K,Mn,S,V,and Zn than present in other materials.

Fig.6 Root zone materials from the unoxidized layer of an active acid sulfate soil described by scanning electron microscopy(SEM)backscattered electron micrograph showing elemental S,mackinawite,framboidal,and single grain pyrite and Fe oxides(a)with X-ray spectra of elemental S(b)and framboidal pyrite(c),maps of Fe(d)and S(e),and a ternary diagram of the chemical composition of the various materials in the root zone material measured by energy dispersive spectroscopy(EDS)including Fe oxides,mackinawite,pyrite,and elemental S in various admixtures and mixed with matrix minerals(f).

Fig.7 Principal component analysis based on the chemical composition of hand-picked soil matrices and redox concentrations from acid sulfate soils in Thailand:distribution of elements(variables)(a)and distribution of samples(cases)(b).

TABLE IV Median with range in parentheses of the total concentrations of elements in various types of materials including redox concentrations in acid sulfate soils from the Lower Central Plain and the Southeast Coast of Thailand

Distribution of trace metals in the soil profiles

The vertical distributions of trace metals(As,Co,Cr,Cu,Fe,Mn,Ni,V,and Zn)in bulk soil samples from representative ASS profiles are shown in Fig.8.The concentrations of As, Cr, Cu, and V showed no systematic change with depth. The higher amounts of Fe in the partly oxidized layer of PAASS indicate that some Fe has been transported by diffusion to the upper partly oxidized layer or leaching from the upper layer,or has moved upward via evaporation transport during the dry season.The behavior of Fe in ASS under a tropical climate of Thailand was similar to that observed in other climatic zones,such as the boreal(e.g.,Finland) and subtropical (e.g., Australia) zones (Åström,1998;Boman et al.,2010;Claffet al.,2011;Creeper et al.,2015). Harmsen and van Breemen (1975) suggested that the enrichment of Fe in the partly oxidized layer of ASS was caused by repeated flooding and redox cycles under paddy rice cultivation. Dissolved Fe2+, controlled by the reduction of Fe3+minerals during soil flooding for paddy rice cultivation and also during natural flooding,can migrate toward the partly oxidized layer and oxidize during the dry season to form Fe(hydr)oxides such as schwertmannite and goethite(Gialanella et al.,2010;Creeper et al.,2015).These minerals can transform to hematite in red redox concentrations at higher elevations and in well-drained soils(van Breemen and Harmsen,1975)as well as during the long dry period in a seasonal tropical climate.

Arsenic and Cu can be retained in the jarosite and Fe(hydr)oxides occurring in yellow and red redox concentrations in ASS under oxidizing conditions(Acero et al.,2006;Gräfe et al.,2008;Miretzky and Cirelli,2010;Gröger et al.,2011; Freitas et al., 2015)and are present in pyrite under reducing conditions(Mango and Ryan,2015).Consequently,As and Cu showed no systematic change in concentration with depth (Fig. 8). A backscattered electron micrograph with energy dispersive spectrum confirmed that some As was present in single-crystal pyrite(Fig.4b).The constant vertical distribution of Cr and V in soil profiles indicates that these elements are mostly present in redox-resistant minerals,as suggested in other studies(Richard and Bourg,1991;Sohlenius and Öborn,2004).

Fig.8 Vertical distributions of metals(As,Co,Cr,Cu,Fe,Mn,Ni,V,and Zn)in bulk soil profiles of representative active acid sulfate soil(ASS)(AASS 8)(a)and post-active acid sulfate soil(PAASS)(PAASS 3)(b)in topsoil layer(0-20 cm for both AASS 8 and PAASS 3),partly oxidized layer(20—100 cm for AASS 8 and 20—160 cm for PAASS 3),and unoxidized layer(100—200 cm for AASS 8 and 160—200 cm for PAASS 3).

Concentrations of Co, Mn, Ni, and Zn were lower in the topsoil and partly oxidized layers of the representative PAASS4,but these elements were enriched at the boundary between the partly oxidized and unoxidized layers(Figs.8 and 9),as has been observed elsewhere,such as in the boreal zone (Åström and Deng, 2003). The boreal and tropical PASS developed in Holocene marine sediments containing Fe sulfides,so these soils had a high potential to generate acidity when oxidized.

Fig.9 Principal component analysis based on Fe and trace elements in bulk samples of acid sulfate soils(ASS)in Thailand:distribution of elements(variables)(a)and distribution of samples(cases)(b).PASS=potential ASS;AASS=active ASS;PAASS=post-active ASS.

The PCA diagram based on standardized log total concentrations of As, Co, Cr, Cu, Fe, Mn, Ni, V, and Zn for the bulk soil samples showed that the unoxidized layers of PASS,AASS,and PAASS were separated from the partly oxidized layers along the factor 1 axis owing to the greater concentrations of Co,Mn,Ni,and Zn.This indicates that Co,Mn,Ni,and Zn may mobilize downward through the soil profiles of AASS and PAASS to be present in redox-sensitive minerals such as sulfides and Mn-oxides in the unoxidized layer.These metals may leach from the topsoil and partly oxidized layers to the unoxidized layers and groundwater and into adjacent drains(Morse and Luther III,1999;Åström and Deng,2003;Burton et al.,2008;Boman et al.,2010;Claffet al.,2011).During the oxidation of ASS,the Southeast Coast ASS,which have a sandy texture,might be at a higher risk of acidification and mobilization of trace elements,especially Co, Mn, Ni, and Zn, than the Lower Central Plain ASS,which have a more clayey texture and higher pH buffering capacity.Creeper et al.(2015)suggested that management strategies should consider soil texture in the rehabilitation of sandy and clayey ASS.

CONCLUSIONS

Various types of materials occurring in potential,active,and post-active ASS in Thailand indicate that these materials have diverse mineralogical and chemical compositions due to the different compositions of parent materials and changes in the pedoenvironment during the development of the soils for agriculture.We observed that the soils consisted mostly of a matrix of quartz,feldspar,kaolinite,and illite.Labile minerals occurred in various materials depending on oxidation and drainage status.Pyrite and mackinawite were dominant sulfide minerals in unoxidized soil layers of PASS,AASS, and PAASS. Under oxidizing conditions, jarosite,lepidocrocite,goethite,and hematite were the secondary Fe minerals in the partly oxidized layers of AASS and PAASS and in the topsoil of PASS, occurring in yellow and red redox concentrations.In PAASS,red redox concentrations of hematite dominated in the upper part of the soil profile(>50 cm from the soil surface),whereas yellow redox concentrations of jarosite were present in the sulfuric horizon(pH <4),occurring deeper than in AASS.Reclamation of ASS for agricultural purposes had caused the oxidation of Fe sulfides with acidification and mobilization of Co,Mn,Ni, and Zn. Cobalt, Mn, and Zn co-precipitated with Fe sulfides and Mn oxides,whereas Ni substituted in Fe sulfides in the unoxidized layer.Concentrations of As,Cr,Cu,Fe,and V did not change with depth during ASS development,because these elements were adsorbed or co-precipitated during the dry season within redox concentrations of jarosite and Fe(hydr)oxides in the partly oxidized layer.Our results indicate that variations in the abundance and types of redox concentrations within ASS profiles can be used as indicators of soil development and reclamation status.Further research is required to understand the stability of jarosite,goethite,and hematite in ASS under the wetting and drying cycles of paddy rice cultivation,as these minerals can control plant uptake of some elements(e.g.,Fe,Cu,and As)and affect the quality of water and sediments in ASS environments.

ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS

The authors gratefully acknowledge the Royal Golden Jubilee Ph.D. Program under the Thailand Research Fund and Kasetsart University for financial support (No.PHD/0150/2552). We gratefully acknowledge assistance from Dr.Nattaporn Prakongkep from the Land Development Department,Kasetsart University,Thailand,Drs.Rathanon Jaroenchasri and Rachan Leotphayakkarat from the Department of Soil Science, Kasetsart University, Thailand,Drs.Michael Smirk and Kim Duffecy from the School of Earth and Environment, the University of Western Australia (UWA), and stafffrom the Centre for Microscopy,Characterisation and Analysis,UWA.


登录APP查看全文