APP下载

苏格兰教育体系正走向衰败

2018-04-16ByMadeleineKearns

英语学习 2018年3期
关键词:课程课堂教育

By Madeleine Kearns

Once one of the best in the world, Scotlands education system has been steadily marching backwards for the past 10 years. From the outside, it seems baffling: why, given that Scottish spending per pupil is among the highest in the world, are things going so wrong? From the inside, its far easier to understand. You can explain it in three words: Curriculum for Excellence.

Id heard stories about it before I started training as a teacher. By the time I qualified—in April last year—how I wished Id listened to them. The story starts in 2010, when the new system was introduced with four aims: to create“confident individuals”, “successful learners”, “responsible citizens” and “effective contributors”. Perhaps the meaning of these phrases was clear to those who came up with them. But as I found out, many teachers cant recall—let alone explain—them.

Picture a grey Glasgow sky and underneath, a cosy school staffroom. “What are they called again? Successful contributors? Effective learners?” one teacher with 30 years experience asks. “No, no. It is the learners who are successful; the contributors are effective!” a student teacher replies helpfully.

The idea of teaching had been turned on its head. Rather than stick to a topic—like English or chemistry—we had to mix them up according to a bizarre formula created in the devolved1 parliament. In 1999, the new MSPs2 had been given power over the school system—so decided to use it. When the SNP3 came to power, the shake-up began. Devolution made a nations children into guinea pigs.

So instead of straightforward maths lessons, wed have “interdisciplinary learning”. Bar charts would be shoehorned4 into lessons about Shakespeare. For a teacher to perform “active learning”, the “learners” had to be constantly entertained. Then came the demand for“collaborative learning”, which means group work, where nothing gets done.

Exams were to be judged by classwork, which of course created plenty of scope for foul play5. And not only by pupils. One experienced teacher told me of “the pass factory” in her school, a place where pupils go for unlimited attempts on core assessments. Gaming the system6 is particularly noticeable in middle-class areas, where children pay for private tutors in order to be coached through exams. In some cases, tutors actually write the coursework for them.

In English, graphic novels crept7 their way into classrooms. Literature and media studies were fused. Presumably to cater for this, Penguin8 even published an emoji series of Shakespeares plays. This is new, certainly, but is it progress? Glaring ignorance of world geography or history is not just permissible, but expected. In history, for example, its normal for pupils to study the Second World War year after year, and merely be assessed at different levels, constant assessment being the SNPs only guarantee. The number of pupils studying French or German has halved.

All of this was supposed to empower teachers and give them more say. But the SNP failed to do its homework, and it didnt quite turn out like that. And so, despite teacherssceptical willingness, the whole project has become seen as a sick joke. In the staffroom, the Curriculum for Excellence is known as the “curriculum for excrement9”.

I know quite a few of the dropouts now. Theres the Frenchman with a degree in philosophy from the Sorbonne, who stormed out of our school placement10 after a disagreement about the quality of his teaching. A fellow secondary school teacher who, due to unmanageable stress, now tutors young offenders rather than return to the classroom. A once enthusiastic primary teacher who said to me, “Id rather do anything—anything—than go back.” At the last count, there were almost 700 vacant teaching posts in Scotland. Thats around 21,000 pupils who are missing teachers.

In the staffroom of one school where I taught, there was a poster. It read, “Being a teacher is easy. Its like riding a bike. Except the bike is on fire. Youre on fire. Everything is on fire. And youre in hell.”Sometimes, on breaks between classes, I would sit and stare at it. I did not see the funny side; for the teachers, or for the pupils, who are the principal victims of a system that is so visibly failing.

蘇格兰的教育体系曾经是世界上最好的教育体系之一,过去十年来却一直在稳步倒退。从外部来看,这似乎令人费解:苏格兰学生的人均教育开支是世界上最高的,为什么还会出现如此严重的问题呢?从内部来看,要理解起来就容易得多了。你可以用四个字来解释:卓越课程。

我在开始接受教师培训之前,就已经听说过关于卓越课程的故事了。到去年四月,我获得教师资格的时候,我多希望我当时认真听了这些故事。故事始于2010年,当时推出了新的教育体系,有四大目标:培养“自信的个人”、“成功的学习者”、“负责任的公民”和“有效的贡献者”。也许这些短语只有那些想出这套说法的人才清楚是什么意思。但是,我发现许多教师根本记不清这些目标,更不用说去解释它们了。

想象一下这幅画面,在格拉斯哥灰色的天空之下,有一间舒适的教师办公室。“怎么说来着?成功的贡献者?有效的学习者?”一位有着30年教龄的老师问道。“不,不。是成功的学习者,有效的贡献者!”一位实习老师帮忙回答道。

教学理念发生了巨大转变。我们不再只是固定学习单个学科——比如英语或化学——相反,我们必须根据权力下放后的苏格兰议会制定的某种奇怪的方案来将这些学科混合起来。1999年,新苏格兰议会议员被授予了管理教育系统的权力——因此决定使用这一权力。苏格兰民族党上台之后,变革就开始了。权力下放让整个国家的孩子变成了实验室的小白鼠。

因此,我们不再只是简简单单地上数学课,而要进行“跨学科学习”。……

登录APP查看全文

猜你喜欢

课程课堂教育
国外教育奇趣
甜蜜的烘焙课堂
题解教育『三问』
美在课堂花开
数字图像处理课程混合式教学改革与探索
软件设计与开发实践课程探索与实践
翻转课堂的作用及实践应用
为什么要学习HAA课程?
教育有道——关于闽派教育的一点思考
最好的课堂在路上