Effects of tungsten on the oxidation resistance and high-temperature strength of 18CrNbTi ferritic stainless steel
2016-02-17LIXinBIHongyunandCHENLiqing
LI Xin,BI Hongyun and CHEN Liqing
1)State Key Laboratory of Rolling and Automation,Northeastern University,Shenyang 110819,Liaoning,China;2)State Key Laboratory of Development and Application Technology of Automobile Steels(Baosteel),Shanghai 201900,China;3)Research Institute,Baoshan Iron & Steel Co.,Ltd.,Shanghai 201900,China
Effects of tungsten on the oxidation resistance and high-temperature strength of 18CrNbTi ferritic stainless steel
LI Xin1),2),3),BI Hongyun2),3)and CHEN Liqing1)
1)State Key Laboratory of Rolling and Automation,Northeastern University,Shenyang 110819,Liaoning,China;2)State Key Laboratory of Development and Application Technology of Automobile Steels(Baosteel),Shanghai 201900,China;3)Research Institute,Baoshan Iron & Steel Co.,Ltd.,Shanghai 201900,China
18CrNbTi ferritic stainless steel is a low-cost material mainly used for the fabrication of manifolds,which usually work at temperatures below 950 ℃.With the development of engine technology,exhaust manifolds tend to work above 1 000 ℃ and this may be even higher in the future.For developing a new kind of steel to satisfy these requirements,the effects of tungsten(W)addition on the high-temperature strength and oxidation resistance of 18CrNbTi ferritic stainless steel are discussed in this study.The test results show that W enhances high-temperature strength at 1 000 ℃ and significantly improves oxidation resistance.However,W addition tends to degrade oxide layer adhesion,causing spalling during alternate hot and cold conditions.
ferritic stainless steel; high temperature strength; oxidation resistance; exhaust manifold
1 Introduction
The sharp increase in the number of automobiles increases the negative impact on the environment.To purify automotive emissions and improve fuel effi-ciency,exhaust-gas temperature needs to increase.Ferritic stainless steels are characterized by low cost,high strength at elevated temperatures,superior thermal fatigue resistance,and better resistance to high-temperature oxidation,stress corrosion crac-king,and aqueous corrosion.They are widely used in automotive exhaust systems as an alternative to austenitic stainless steels[1-3].Exhaust manifolds,which are located close to engines,are usually exposed to temperatures higher than 800 ℃ and subjected to cyclic loads in the exhaust system.It has become critical for such components to exhibit excellent high-temperature strength,high-temperature oxidation resistance,and fatigue resistance.With the development of engine technology,exhaust mani-folds tend to work at temperatures above 1 000 ℃ and this may be even higher in the future,resulting in higher demands on the materials from which they are manufactured.
The effects of Cr,Si,Mn,Mo,and Nb have been widely discussed in many research works[4-6].Of these,Cr is the most effective for enhancing oxidation resistance,but brings a lot of problems,such as sticking defect during the hot-rolling process.Meanwhile,its contribution to the enhancement of high-temperature strength is weak.Nb is usually added to steel as a stabilizer to improve intergranular corrosion resistance and is also effective for promoting high-temperature strength,but it tends to precipitates as Fe2Nb at grain boundaries causing embrittlement at room temperature[7].It has also been reported that adding low amount of Laves phase formation elements(Nb,V,or Ti)to traditional Fe-Cr alloys is effective in controlling the elemental diffusivity at the alloy grain boundaries by forming Laves phases in air[8].In recent years,some researchers have introduced tungsten(W)to ferritic stainless steel to improve corrosion resistance,high-temperature strength,and creep resistance.Chan-Jin Park studied the effect substituting W for Mo in 29% Cr ferritic stainless steel and found a remarkable improvement in the resistance to localized corrosion because of a lower rate of formation of the sigma phase[9].Yung-Tang Chiu proposed that improvements in high-tem-perature strength and creep resistance of 22% Cr ferritic stainless steel resulted from the formation of a(Fe,Cr)2(Nb,W)Laves phase during aging at 800 ℃[10].
To satisfy the requirements of exhaust-gas temperature enhancement,the authors are trying to modify the composition of an 18CrNbTi stainless steel to improve its high-temperature strength and oxidation resistance at 1 000 ℃ by adding W.The aim of the present work is to study the effects of W on the high-temperature strength and heat resistance of 18CrNbTi stainless steel at 1 000 ℃.
2 Experiment
The materials used in the present study are presented in Table 1.C1 is a commercial 18CrNbTi stainless steel produced by Baosteel.C2,containing 1.04% W,was produced by induction heating in a vacuum furnace,then casting as 150 kg ingots.These were hot forged and heated at 1200 ℃ for 1 h,then hot-rolled to 4 mm thick.Finally,C1 and C2 were cold-rolled to 1 mm thick sheets,annealed at 1020 ℃ and 1040 ℃ separately for 1.2 min,then cooled in air.For oxidation resistance test,samples of 25 mm×20 mm×1.0 mm in dimension were cut,then polished with SiC paper up to 1200#polishing grade.

Table 1 Chemical composition of the material %
The individual samples were ultrasonically cleaned,weighed,and physically measured prior to oxidation testing.All samples were placed in a roasted crucible to avoid weight loss through spalling.Continuous isothermal oxidation tests were conducted at 1 000 ℃ for different times in labora-tory air for up to 100 h.After oxidation,the samples were removed from the furnace,air cooled,and weighted at room temperature.Weight change was determined from the difference before and after oxidation testing,normalized by the sample surface area.The weight gain of the samples is indicative of oxygen ingress and the formation of an oxide scale.
The morphology of the external interfaces and the cross-sections were observed using secondary electrons under a Quanta 400 scanning-type electron microscope(SEM)operating at 20 kV.The surface composition was measured over an area of 12.5 mm2with a DGLS-5017 glow discharge spectrum(GDS),performed at an argon flow rate of 500 mL / min and at a discharge current of 20 mA.
3 Results and discussion
3.1 Oxidation resistance
Fig.1 shows the weight gain of each specimen as a function of oxidation time.It is clear that the largest weight change occurred in sample C1.The weight gain curve for C1 is parabolic during the first 30 hours,followed by breakaway oxidation when the testing time was over 100 h.The oxidation rate of C1 W-free steel was more than 17 times higher than the C2 W-added steel at 1 000 ℃ for 100 h.For C2,a parabolic regime is observed throughout the oxidation test.The parabolic rate constant(kp)is an important index indicating the parabolic nature of oxidation,which can be calculated from the weight gain per unit area of a sample and oxidation time,according to the following equation[11]:
(1)
Where Δwis weight gain,Ais the sample surface area,tis the oxidation time andkpis parabolic rate.
The parabolic rate constantkpis about 0.02 mg2/ (cm4· h) for steel C2.Compared with thekpvalue of similar stainless steels after oxidation at 1 000 ℃ for 100 h[1],it can be concluded that C2 exhibited good oxidation resistance at 1 000 ℃.
Fig.2 shows the cross-section morphologies ofC1 and C2 after oxidation at 1 000 ℃.Table 2 shows the corresponding energy dispersive spectroscopy(EDS)analysis results of the oxides marked in Fig.2.It can be observed that the C1 oxide layer is thicker than that of C2.The C1 oxide layer exhibits a typical three-layer structure;the outer layer is composed of Fe / Mn oxides and EDS analysis shows that the Cr content of this layer is 0.63%.The interlayer,between the outer and internal layers,contains 17.72% Cr.A detailed observation of the surface of C1 is shown in Fig.3 and shows nodular oxides in the surface.The Cr content of the inner layer is about 25.30%.The presence of Fe-rich oxides in all three layers and the internal oxidation zone indicate that the oxidation process is controlled by a gas-phase reaction instead of element diffusion,i.e.,breakaway oxidation has occurred.In C2 the oxides consist of only one layer and this is much thinner than in C1,indicating a remarkable improvement in oxidation resistance.
Fig.1 Kinetic curve of isothermal oxidation of 18CrNbTi ferritic stainless steels
Table 2 EDS analysis results of the corresponding areas in Fig.2 %

No.wOwCrwFe128.430.6369.53227.9017.7252.40327.7925.3043.51439.1056.270.59
However,oxide spalling was observed in C2 and micro-cracks were found in the oxides adhering to the substrate,as shown in Fig.2(b).This indicates that although the C2 oxides are not dense,they still exhibit a lower oxidation rate and no breakaway oxidation occurred.In Fig.2(b)a large number of voids can be observed in the substrate near the scale / alloy interface of C2.In addition,many precipitates can be seen at the interface of the oxide and substrate.A similar result was observed by Azim Safikhanietal.,who deduced that if the amount of W was high enough,it could easily accumulate at the oxide / metal interface and form voids.These voids reduce the oxidation rate by reducing the diffusion paths of the metal.However,if the specimens are subjected to long-term exposure in a high-temperature oxidizing environment,the large number of voids formed decreases the oxidation resistance by dissociative transport across the voids,which become micro-channels for diffusion.Moreover,a large number of voids and second-phase particles reduce adhesion between the oxide and substrate,and eventually lead to spalling of the oxide layer.In summary,W improves the oxidation resistance of 18CrNbTi ferritic stainless steel,but the optimal W content and how to improve the spalling of the oxide layer still requires more research.
3.2 High-temperature strength
High-temperature strength is another important property of steels used for exhaust system mani-folds.Fig.4 shows the results of the comparison between the two steels.This shows that W is very effective in improving the tensile strength of 18CrNbTi steel,as the tensile strength of C2 is 10 MPa higher than C1 at 900 ℃.When the test temperature rises to 1 000 ℃,the tensile strength of C1 reduces to 13 MPa,while the tensile strength of C2 remains at 20 MPa,which is even closer to the tensile strength of C1 at 900 ℃.As mentioned,C1 steel has been widely used in various manifolds working in the 800-900 ℃ temperature range,so it is reasonable to assume that 18CrNbTi stainless steel with 1% W could be a reliable option at 1 000 ℃.Further investigation into the effect of W on thermal fatigue resistance and high-temperature fatigue resistance properties are worthy of future consideration.
Fig.4 High temperature strength of as-received C1 and C2 steels at different temperatures for 100 h
Fig.5 shows the calculated equilibrium phase diagrams for C1 and C2 steels.In the W-free steel(C1),a Fe2Nb-type Laves phase precipitated below 950 ℃.In the W-added steel(C2),there are two types of Laves phase precipitates,Fe2Nb and Fe2W.The precipitation temperature of Fe2Nb is higher than that of Fe2W.Some researchers have observed that when ferritic stainless steels with added Nb and W are worked at temperatures of 600-800 ℃,these Fe2(Nb,W)Laves phase significantly enhance the high-temperature strength and creep resistance[9].Nevertheless,in this study the assumed application temperature is 1 000 ℃ and according to the simulation results in Fig.5,there are no Laves phases precipitated because Nb and W are soluble in the matrix at 1 000 ℃ if the normalization time is long enough.Therefore,the improvement in the high-temperature strength of Nb and W-added steel could be attributed to solid-solution strengthening.Of course,for both specimens,the high-temperature strength test was conducted after holding for 15 min at 1 000 ℃,so a fraction of undissolved Laves phase,formed during the hot-rolling process,probably remained,but these precipitates do not deteriorate the high-temperature strength unless they become very coarse.
4 Conclusions
For the development of a ferritic stainless steel,which can be used at 1 000 ℃ in exhaust manifolds,the effects of W addition on the oxidation resistance and high-temperature strength of a 1.04%W 18CrNbTi ferritic stainless steel were investigated.The results are summarized as follows:
(1) The oxidation resistance of 18CrNbTi stain-less steel can be improved by W addition,but can dete-riorate with high amounts under long-term exposure.
(2) W addition tends to reduce the adhesion of oxide layers causing oxide spalling.
(3) At 1 000℃,the high-temperature strength of the 18CrNbTi stainless steel was improved signifi-cantly due to the solution-strengthening effect of W.
[1] LI X,SHU J,CHEN L Q,etal.Effect of cerium on high-temperature oxidation resistance of 00Cr17NbTi ferritic stainless steel[J].Acta Metallurgica Sinica(English letters),2014,27(3):501-507.
[2] LIU T L,CHEN L J,BI H Y,etal.Effect of Mo on high-temperature fatigue behavior of 15CrNbTi ferritic Stainless steel[J].Acta Metallurgica Sinica(English letters),2014,27(3):452-456.
[3] INOUE Y and KIKUCHI M.Present and future trends of stainless steel for automotive exhaust system[J].Nipppon Steel Technical Report,2003(378):62-69.
[4] FUJITA N,OHMURA K and YAMAMOTO A.Changes of microstructures and high temperature properties during high temperature service of niobium added ferrtic stainless steels[J].Materials Science and Engineering A,2003,351(1):272-281.
[5] ALI-LÖYTTY H,JUSSILA P and VALDEN M.Optimization of the electrical properties of Ti-Nb stabilized ferritic stainless steel SOFC interconnect alloy upon high-temperature oxidation:the role of excess Nb on the interfacial oxidation at the oxida-metal interface[J].International Journal of Hydrogen Energy,2013,38(2):1039-1051.
[6] SEO H S,YUN D W and KIM K Y.Oxidation behavior of ferritc stainless steel containing Nb,Nb-Si and Nb-Ti for SOFC interconnect[J].International Journal of Hydrogen Energy,2013,38(5):2432-2422.
[7] SELLO M P and STUMPF W E.Laves phase precipit-ation and its transformation kinetics in the ferritic stainless steel type AISI 441[J].Materials Science and Engineering A,2011,528(3):1840-1847.
[8] JUUTI T,ROVATTI L,MKELA,etal.Influence of long heat treatments on the Laves phase nucleation in type 444 ferrtic stainless steel[J].Journal of Alloy and Compounds,2014,616(2):250-256.
[9] PARK C J,AHN M K and KWON H S.Influences of Mo substitution by W on the precipitation kinetics of secondary phases and the associated localized corrosion and embrittlement in 29% Cr ferritic stainless steel[J].Materials Science and Engineer A,2006,418(1):211-217.
[10] CHIU Y T and LIN C K.Effects of Nb and W additions on high-temperature creep properties of ferritic stainless steel for solid oxide fuel cell interconnect[J].Journal of Power Sources,2012,198(1):149-157.
[11] SAFIKHANI A and AMINFARD M.Effect of W and Ti addition on oxidation behavior and area-specific resistance of Fe-22Cr-0.5Mn ferritic stainless steel for SOFCs interconnect[J].International Journal of Hydrogen Energy,2014,39(5):2286-2296.
BAOSTEEL TECHNICAL RESEARCHTotal Contents of Vol.10, 2016
Electromagnetic Metallurgy
Preface
1(1)
Physical modeling and numerical simulation of electromagnetic stirring in a slab continuous casting mold
1(3)
Numerical simulation of fluid flows in a slab continuous casting mold under electromagnetic stirring
1(10)
Effect of electromagnetic stirring on flow field in mold under submerged entry nozzle clogging
1(16)
Progress on research of induction heating in Baosteel
1(21)
Mathematical modeling of induction heating of discard substitution block for billet hot extrusion process
1(28)
Variation microstructure and properties of X80 pipeline steel in the rapid induction tempering process
1(33)
Metallurgical Product Research
Delayed fracture of tensile strength 980 MPa grade steels for automotive applications
1(38)
Self-cleaning performance of a self-cleaning pre-coated steel sheet in an industrial environment
1(44)
Development of high elongation steels by quenching and partitioning process
2(33)
Light weight analysis of a skeleton vehicle frame using BS960 super-high-strength steel
2(40)
Test study on the fatigue performance of HSS for steel wheels
2(45)
Study on the bendability and toughness of a 1 500 MPa cold-rolled martensitic sheet steel
3(28)
Research on the properties and microstructures of 27Cr-7Ni-4Mo super duplex stainless steel
3(35)
Application and comparison of different elastoplastic constitutive models for springback simulation of aluminum sheet forming
3(42)
Effects of tungsten on the oxidation resistance and high-temperature strength of 18CrNbTi ferritic stainless steel
4(41)
Metallurgical Process Research
Effect of continuous annealing temperature on the microstructure and mechanical property of an aluminum killed steel
2(1)
Analysis of causes and influence factors of small black spot defects in hot-dip galvanized pure Zn products
2(7)
Sensitization behavior of welded 304L austenitic stainless steel using scanning vibrating probe
2(14)
Simulation of temperature field in pipe during single-face quenching process
2(20)
Application of surface-defect detector in CDCM at Baosteel
2(27)
Advanced green refractory technologies for coke ovens at Baosteel
3(1)
Study on life cycle assessment of stainless steel
3(7)
Influence of graphene on the anti-corrosion performance of epoxy-based coatings
3(15)
Flow field research on bottom argon blowing in a 40 ton ladle
3(21)
Cold Rolled Steel Sheet
Preface
4(1)
Comparative study on the corrosion behavior of low alloy steels in sulfuric acid solution
4(3)
Cause of stamping cracks in pure iron magnetic shielding covers
4(12)
Effect of intercritical annealing temperature and cooling rate on the microstructure and mechanical properties of low-carbon aluminum killed steel
4(18)
Effect of Pb content on the surface topography and corrosion resistance of hot dip Zn-Al-Mg coatings
4(24)
Causes of progressive stamping die damage and retooling measures to reduce carbide punch fracture
4(30)
Secondary work embrittlement of cold-rolled 05CuPCrNi sheet at low temperature
4(36)
Contributions toBaosteelTechnicalResearchwanted
Baosteel Technical Research,aquarterlyjournal,whichisissueddomesticallyandabroad,isrunandsponsoredbyBaosteelGroupCorporation.Baosteel Technical Researchmainlyreportstheachievementsintechnologicalinnovation,academicresearch,newproductdevelopmentandindustrialequipmentimprovementbyBaosteel.Itwillcontinuetofollowuponhottopicsandservethecompany’stechnologicaldevelopmentandprogress.Itsreadersincludeexpertsinsteelmetallurgyandrelatedfields,technicians,managementstaff,professorsandstudentsinuniversitiesandcolleges.Itmainlypublishesacademicandapplicablepapersonironandsteelmetallurgyandrelatedtechnicalfieldssuchaschemicals,metalforming,materials,mechanicalandelectricaltechnology,refractory,energy,automationinstruments,comprehensiveutilizationandenvironmentalprotection.Allthecontributionsfromitsreadersarewelcome,butauthorsshouldpayattentiontothefollowingrequirements:
(1)Theincomingmanuscriptsshouldhaveaclearsubject,reliabledataanddetailedcontentsaswellasusinganeconomyword.
(2)Yourpapershouldcontain:Title,Author(s),Affiliation(s),Abstract,Keywords,MainsectionandReferences.
(3)Thetitleshouldbenomorethan10Englishnotionalwords,withoutusingunknown,notwell-acceptedabbreviations,codesandvaguevocabulary.
(4)Author(s)andtheiraffiliationsshouldbecentered.Thereisablanklineofspacebetweenthetitleandtheauthor(s).SuperscriptofArabicnumbersisusedforcorrespondingauthorsandtheiraffiliations.
(5)Theabstractshouldbeanindependentshortpassage,withnomorethan400words.Itshouldmainlycovertheaimoftheresearchwork,methodsusedinthetests,resultsofthetestandtheconclusionfromanalysis,comparisonandapplication.
(6)Threetoeightkeywordsrelatingtothesubjectareneeded,colorillustrationsarewelcomeandaconciseexplanationisrequired.
(7)Thetextshouldbewithin5 000-10 000letters,includingallthefigures,chartsandtables.Pleasepayattentiontothecorrectusageofcapitallettersanditalics.Mainsectioncontainstext,figures,tables,andequations.Therearetwoblanklinesbetweenthekeywordsandthemainsection.Theheadingsandsubheadingsofthetextareboldfaceandplacedflushleftonaseparateline.Thereisablanklinebetweenaheadinganditsabovetext.Thenumberingoftheheadingsandsubheadingsisas1,1.1,1.1.1,2,2.1,2.1.1…
(8)EachfiguremusthaveacaptiontypeddirectlybelowitsuchasFig.1.ThefiguresshouldbeconsecutivelynumberedwithArabicnumerals.
(9) Each table must have a caption typed directly above it.The tables should be consecutively numbered with Arabic numerals.
(10) Equations are set off from the text by a double space above and below the equation.All equations should be typed and separated from the text by one line of space above and below.They should be numbered consecutively in parentheses at the right-hand margin,in line with the last line of the equation as seen in the example below.
(1)
(11) All the references cited by the author should come from formal publications.Do not use those unpublished.References should be given in numerical order as they appear in the manuscript text and cited in the following manner.All text references should be consecutively numbered.Complete citations should appear at the end of the paper in the References section,using a single-spaced format.The word “References” are boldface and placed flush left on a separate line.References should provide readers with enough information to find the cited material.
Please deliver your manuscript to bstr@baosteel.com if it is an electronic one or mail your manuscript to our editorial office.We are looking forward to your great contributions to Baosteel Technical Research.
Address:Baosteel Technical Researcheditorialoffice
Room608,TechnologyBuilding,
ResearchInstitute,BaoshanIron&SteelCo.,Ltd.
655FujinRd,BaoshanDistrict,
Shanghai201900,China
Tel: 0086+21+26648493
Fax: 0086+21+26643977
Web: www.baosteel.com
LI Xin; E-mail: li_xin@baosteel.com
10.3969/j.issn.1674-3458.2016.04.007
杂志排行
Baosteel Technical Research的其它文章
- Secondary work embrittlement of cold-rolled 05CuPCrNi sheet at low temperature
- Causes of progressive stamping die damage and retooling measures to reduce carbide punch fracture
- Effect of Pb content on the surface topography and corrosion resistance of hot dip Zn-Al-Mg coatings
- Effect of intercritical annealing temperature and cooling rate on the micro-structure and mechanical properties of low-carbon aluminum killed steel
- Comparative study on the corrosion behavior of low alloy steels in sulfuric acid solution
- Cause of stamping cracks in pure iron magnetic shielding covers
