钨合金弹丸侵彻钢靶的数值模拟方法
2025-08-19位国旭崔浩周昊杨贵涛郭锐
中图分类号:O383;TJ012.4 国标学科代码:13035 文献标志码:A
Numerical simulation method for tungsten alloy projectile penetration into steel target
WEI Guoxu, CUI Hao, ZHOU Hao, YANG Guitao,GUO Rui (SchoolofMechanicalEnineering,Nanjing UnvesityofienceandTechnologyNnjingo4,Jangsu,Cina)
Abstract: Inorder to improve thequantitative characterization of the penetration process of tungsten aloy projectileinto the target,thenumerical methodssuchasFEM (finite element method),SPG (smoothedparticleGalerkin),SPH (smoothed particle hydrodynamics),andFE-SPH (finite element-smothed particlehydrodynamics)adaptivesimulation methods were employed to simulate the penetration of tungsten alloy projectiles into Q235A steel trgets.Based on numericalsimulations,a comparisonwas made of the advantages and disadvantages of the four numerical simulation methods for calculating the residualvelocityoftheprojectileafterpenetratingthtarget,theperforationdiameterofthetarget,andtedistributionof secondary fragments by theprojectile penetration.Theresults showthat,forcalculating theresidualvelocityof theprojectile, FEMandFE-SPHadaptive methods strictlyrelyon the selectionoffailurecriteriaand corrsponding parameters,as FEM employs anelement erosionalgorithmtomodelmaterialfailure,while SPGmethod,as itdoesnotrequireadjusting thefailure parameters in bond failure mode,canotainrelativelyaccurate calculations; forpredicting perforation diameter,FEMandFESPHadaptive methodsaccuratelyrepresent material boundariesand perforationmorphology,although theperforationdiameter variessignificantlyunderdifferentfailurecriteria,whiletheSPGmethodcanaccuratelypredicttheperforationdiameterof target plates due toitsinsensitivetofailure parameters; foranalzing secondaryfragments generationand distribution,bothFE
SPHadaptiveand SPH methods effectivelycharacterize these phenomena,while the FE-SPH adaptive method provides detailed information on large fragments,it is less computationally efficient than the SPH method.
Keywords: finite element method (FEM); smoothed particle Galerkin (SPG); smoothed particle hydrodynamics (SPH); secondary fragments; penetration
钨合金球形弹丸作为杀爆类战斗部的主要毁伤元,对装甲目标的毁伤能力主要体现在弹丸穿靶后的剩余速度、穿孔直径以及弹丸穿靶后产生的二次破片等方面。为实现弹丸对靶板毁伤能力的精确表征,学者们开展了大量的弹丸侵彻靶板的试验以及数值模拟研究[1-8]。
张钰龙等5通过量纲分析法对钨球侵彻Q235钢靶的入口孔径随着靶速度变化的试验结果进行了分析,得到了相应的数学表达式。何杨等[]采用LS-DYNA数值模拟软件中的有限元法(finite element method,FEM),对大质量破片侵彻陶瓷/钢复合装甲过程进行数值模拟,得到了破片初速、装甲倾角对破片极限穿透速度和后效威力的影响规律。徐豫新等采用AUTODYN数值模拟软件中的FEM方法,对钨球侵彻有限厚Q235A钢开展了数值模拟计算,数值模拟得到的弹道极限速度与试验结果误差较小。邸德宁等[10]、Wen 等[1-1]采用AUTODYN软件中的光滑粒子流体动力学(smoothed particle hydrodynamics,SPH)方法模拟了球形弹丸撞击薄靶形成的破片云,数值模拟结果与Piekutowski[4的试验结果吻合较好,证明了 SPH方法在模拟弹丸穿靶后形成二次破片方面的有效性。近些年来,He等[15]采用有限元-光滑粒子流体动力学(finite element-smoothed particle hydrodynamics,FE-SPH)自适应耦合方法开展了球形弹丸超高速侵彻的数值模拟研究,该方法不仅适用于均质靶板,结合细观建模技术,同样可以适用于纤维增强复合材料的数值模拟建模[16],完美再现了二次破片云的形成过程。Yin等[17]分别采用FEM、光滑粒子伽辽金(smoothed particle Galerkin,SPG)方法计……
