APP下载

Solubility measurement and thermodynamic modeling ofcarbamazepine (form III) in five pure solvents at various temperatures

2021-08-26WenjuLiuZehuaBaoYanminShenTiantianYaoHongjuanBaiXinyuJin

Wenju Liu*,Zehua Bao,Yanmin Shen,Tiantian Yao,Hongjuan Bai,Xinyu Jin

School of Chemistry and Chemical Engineering,Henan University of Technology,Zhengzhou 450001,China

Keywords:Solubility Carbamazepine (form III)Modified Apelblat model λh model

ABSTRACT In this work,the solubilities of carbamazepine (CBZ) (form III) in ethyl acetate,methyl acetate,ethylene glycol,chloroform and cyclohexylamine were determined by laser monitoring techniques at pressure above sea level,and the solubility data of CBZ (form III) in different pure solvents were fitted by the Modified Apelblat model and λh model.The result shows that the solubility of CBZ (form III) in five solvents increases as temperature rises,and the solubility in chloroform was the largest.The experimental solubility values of CBZ(form III)in ethyl acetate,methyl acetate,chloroform and cyclohexylamine were in better agreement with the simulated fitting values of the λh model.For ethylene glycol,the σ value was much larger than the other four solvents,and it can be seen from the λh model that ethylene glycol was closer to the ideal solution system than the other four solvents.

1.Introduction

Carbamazepine (CBZ) is a white or crystal powder and is pharmaceutically important due to its properties as an antiepileptic and analgesic drug[1].The chemical structure of CBZ is shown in Fig.1.CBZ is also known to form at least four different polymorphs(form I,form II,form III and form IV) as well as a growing number of hydrates,solvates,and cocrystals [2–4].Among them,form III is the most stable at room temperature and is often used in commercial products.

Solubility data are very important in production and purification processes.So far,the solubility data of CBZ in ethanol,ethanol solutions in the presence of additives,ethanol–water mixtures,methanol,1-propanol,2-propanol,tetrahydrofuran has been publicly reported [5–8].Also,the degree of solubility marks the limit of the crystallization yield,and the solubility will be affected by many factors.Therefore,measuring the solubility of crystalline substances in different systems is necessary to grasp whether the product can be obtained by the crystallization method,the ideal yield of the product,the crystallization temperature of the product and the supersaturation of the product.

In this paper,the solubilities of CBZ (form III) in ethyl acetate,methyl acetate,ethylene glycol,chloroform,and cyclohexylamine were measured by a synthetic method between 278 and 367 K at pressure above sea level.The solution was monitored by laser method.

2.Experimental

2.1.Materials

Carbamazepine (form III) was obtained from Suzhou Hengyi Pharmaceutical Co.Ltd.,China,(≧0.99,in mass fraction);ethyl acetate,methyl acetate,ethylene glycol,chloroform and cyclohexylamine were all purchased from Tianjin Kewei Chemical Reagent Co.,Ltd.,(≧0.99,in mass fraction).

2.2.Apparatus and procedure

The measuring device for the solubility of CBZ (form III) is shown in Fig.2,which mainly includes crystallizer,temperature control system,laser measurement system and stirring system,among them,the laser generator in the laser measurement system emits a helium–neon laser with a wavelength of 633 nm,which has the advantages of good monochromaticity and directivity,and high brightness compared with the beam emitted by other ordinary light sources.To ensure the accuracy of temperature measurement,a mercury precision thermometer with a minimum scale of 0.1 °C was used in the experiment,and its zero point was calibrated with ice water mixture before use.The instruments details used in the experiment were listed in Table 1 below.

Table 1Type and name of instruments

Fig.1.Structure of cabamazepine.

Fig.2.Sketch of the apparatus for measurement of the solubility.

First,measure 100 ml of solvent into the crystallizer,and the maximum light intensity of the display instrument was recorded after the laser system was stabilized.Then,a certain amount of CBZ (form III) was accurately weighed by an electronic analytical balance with an accuracy of 0.0001 g,and the solution showed turbidity after it was added to the crystallizer.Then,when the temperature fluctuation range of the water bath was within ±0.05 K,the temperature rise rate was set to 0.05 K∙min-1,during which the temperature and light intensity were recorded every 5 minutes until the solute was completely dissolved (that is,the light intensity display reaches the maximum value or there is no major change in the next 30 minutes).Finally,replace the solvent and repeat the above steps.The saturated mole fraction solubility of solute xAcan be obtained as follows

where mAand mBrepresent the mass of solute and solvent,and MA,MBrepresent the molecular mass of solute and solvent,respectively.

3.Results and Discussion

3.1.Solubility of CBZ (form III) in solvent

Fig.3 shows the solubility curves of CBZ (form III) in different solvents,and Table 2 shows the specific data.It can be seen from Fig.3 that the solubility is a function of temperature and increased with the temperature rising.Experiment results indicated that solubility data in five pure solvents followed this order:chloroform >cyclohexylamine >methyl acetate >ethyl acetate >ethylene glycol (temperature range:280–305 K),when the temperature is greater than 305 K,the solubility of ethylene glycol is greater than that of ethyl acetate.The solubility of CBZ(form III) in methyl acetate is greater than that in ethyl acetate,it may be that the polarity of methyl acetate is greater than ethyl acetate(Table 3),which affects the interaction between the solute and the solvent,but this may be just one of the reasons.Solvent properties and the measured solubility data shows that a single influencing factor cannot be used to explain the changing trend of solubility.The dissolution process is complicated,and the influencing factors may include van der Waals force,the degree of molecular association caused by the polarity of the molecule,the formation of molecular complexes,solvation,the relative molecular mass of the solvent and solute,the type and number of dissolving active groups,etc.The current research on the change trend of solubility cannot give a reasonable explanation,and the specific reasons need to be further studied.

The values of RD (relative error) in Table 2 were calculated by:

Table 2Mole Fraction Solubilities of CBZ (form III),xA,in ethyl acetate,methyl acetate,ethylene glycol,chloroform and cyclohexylamine

Table 3Physicochemical properties of the solvents studied [9]

3.2.Solubility data correlate

According to the different calculation methods of the fugacity of mixture components,the theoretical research methods of solid–liquid equilibrium can be divided into equation of state and activity coefficient method.At present,the basic data of the solid–liquid equilibrium are insufficient,meanwhile,the calculation process of using the equation of state and the activity coefficient equation to correlate the solid–liquid equilibrium data is quite complicated and requires a lot of basic physical parameters.As a result,the application of the equation of state and the activity coefficient equation in production practice is limited.In order to improve the practical value of the solid–liquid equilibrium model,many scholars have studied a large number of solid–liquid equilibrium data,so some simplified empirical equations for correlating the solid–liquid equilibrium data have been created,including the Modified Apelblat model [10–14],λh model [15–18] and (CNIBS)/Redlich-Kister model [19–21],etc.

Fig.3.Measured solubilities of CBZ (form III) in pure solvents.

For the solubility data of CBZ in different solvents,the widely used and reliable Apelblat equation and λh equation which requires fewer parameters were used to correlate in this paper.

3.2.1.Modified Apelblat model

where T is the absolute temperature,and A,B,and C are all empirical constants.The values of A,B,C can be obtained by importing solubility data into Origin software for simulation.The values of A,B,C and the relative root-mean-square deviations(σ)of different solvents are listed in Table 4,where σ is defined as follows:

where N represents the number of experimental points,the solubility calculated by Eq.(3),is the solubility measured by the experiment,both of which are mole fraction values.

Fig.4 shows the solubility values and fitting curves of different solvents.As we can see from the values of fitting coefficient and relative root-mean-square deviation in Table 4 and the solubility fitting curve in Fig.4 that the experimental values in ethyl acetate,methyl acetate,chloroform and cyclohexylamine are in good agreement with the simulated fitting values.For ethylene glycol,the σ value is larger than the other four solvents.

3.2.2.λh model

where T is the absolute temperature,Tmis the absolute temperature of the melting point of the solute,λ and h are obtained by regression of experimental data in this study,while λ is a measure of nonideality of the saturated solution and can be interpreted as the mean association number of the solute if nonideality is mainly due to association [22].

Tmis replaced by the melting temperature of CBZ (form III)(438 K,measured by differential scanning calorimeter).It can be seen from the data (Table 5) and the fitting curve (Fig.5) that the experimental values are in good agreement with the simulated fitting values.λ is a measure of non-ideality of the saturated solution,the more the value of λ deviates from 1,the stronger the nonideality of the solution.Table 5 shows that the λ value of ethylene glycol is 0.4578,while other nonalcoholic solvents are less than 0.1,which indicates that alcohols are closer to the ideal solution system,and the nonalcoholic solvent is far from the ideal solution system,this provides help for the prediction of the solubility in mixed solvents [22].

Table 4Parameters of Apelblat equation for CBZ (form III) in pure solvents

Table 5Parameters of λh equation for CBZ (form III) in pure solvents

In the process of determining the solubility of polymorphic drugs,the possible source of experimental error is the transformation of crystal or the formation of solvates during the experiment.It can be seen from the solubility curve of this experiment that the curve is well-fitted and has no inflection point.The crystals obtained from ethyl acetate,methyl acetate,ethylene glycol,chloroform,cyclohexylamine were CBZ (form III) (Tested by X-ray diffraction),which indicates that there is no transformation of crystal in the experiment and the experimental data is reliable.The result shows that the experimental values in ethyl acetate,methyl acetate,chloroform and cyclohexylamine are in good agreement with the simulated fitting values.By comparing the simulated values of the modified Apelblat model and the λh model,it is found that the simulated values of the λh model are more consistent with the experimental values,because the RD values of λhmode are smaller than that of modified Apelblat mode,which means that the semi-empirical correlation is suitable for this solubility data,and can provide the necessary reliable data for the production and purification process design of CBZ.

Fig.4.Solubilities curves of CBZ (form III) in pure solvents by modified Apelblat model.

Fig.5.Solubilities curves of CBZ (form III) in pure solvents by λh model.

4.Conclusions

The solubilities of CBZ(form III)in ethyl acetate,methyl acetate,ethylene glycol,chloroform and cyclohexylamine were determined,and the modified Apelblat model and λh model were used to analyze the correlation of the solubility data.The result shows that the solubility of CBZ (form III) in five solvents increases as temperature rises and the solubility in chloroform is the largest,and the experimental values are in good agreement with the simulated fitting values and the correlation of the λh model is better.For ethylene glycol,the σ value is much larger than the other four solvents,which means that ethylene glycol may be closer to the ideal solution system than the other four solvents.

Declaration of Competing Interest

The authors declare that they have no known competing financial interests or personal relationships that could have appeared to influence the work reported in this paper.

Acknowledgements

The authors would like to thank the Science Foundation of Henan University of Technology (2017RCJH09,2017QNJH29),Science Foundation of Henan Province (202102310208,182102210399) for their financial assistance in this project.


登录APP查看全文