APP下载

Exploring the methods on improving CH4 delivery performance to surpass the Advanced Research Project Ageney-Energy target

2021-08-26WeichenZhuYuxuanHeMinmanTongXiaoyongLaiShijiaLiangXuWangYanjuanLiXiaoYan

Weichen Zhu,Yuxuan He,Minman Tong*,Xiaoyong Lai,Shijia LiangXu WangYanjuan LiXiao Yan*

1 School of Chemistry and Materials Science,Jiangsu Normal University,Xuzhou 221116,China

2 State Key Laboratory of High-efficiency Utilization of Coal and Green Chemical Engineering,College of Chemistry and Chemical Engineering,Ningxia University,Yinchuan 750021,China

Keywords:Covalent organic frameworks CH4 delivery Adsorbed natural gas Molecular simulation Structure–property relationship Material design

ABSTRACT CH4 storage associated with adsorbed natural gas (ANG) technology is an issue attracting great concern.Following the Advanced Research Project Agency-Energy (ARPA-E) targeted deliverable capacity of 315 cm3∙cm-3(STP),hundreds of thousands of materials have been experimentally or theoretically evaluated,while the best results still show a 35%gap from the target.Moreover,recent theoretical research reveals that the target is beyond the possibility that real materials can be designed.To get rid of the awkward situation,we make attempts on investigating the CH4 delivery performance under other operation conditions.Methods of raising the discharge temperature(to infinite high)or elevating the storage pressure(to 25 MPa)have been proved to show limited effectiveness.In this work,it is found that the ARPA-E target can be achieved by using a decreasing storage temperature strategy.By taking 280 CoRE(computation-ready,experimental) COFs (covalent organic frameworks) as ANG materials,when reduce the storage temperature to 190.6 K,the highest deliverable capacity can reach 392 cm3∙cm-3 (STP),and 16.1% CoRE COFs can surpass the target.The target is also achievable when storage at 220 K.Structure performance relationships study shows strong correlation between deliverable capacity and void fraction.Hence,120 hypothetical COFs are generated to ascertain the optimum void fraction.In addition,the performance of 2D-COFs can be greatly enhanced by increasing the interlayer spacings,e.g.CH4 deliverable capacity(storage at 190.6 K)of ATFG-COF can be improved from 239 to 411 cm3∙cm-3(STP)when interlayer spacing is enlarged to 1.65 nm.

1.Introduction

Natural gas(NG),mainly comprised of CH4,is an appealing substitute to petroleum as a transportation fuel due to its environmental friendliness,economic advantages and abundant natural reserves [1,2].For on-board vehicular applications,natural gas must be condensed due to the low CH4volumetric energy density under ambient conditions.Present densification strategies such as liquefied natural gas (LNG) (111 K) or compressed natural gas(CNG)(25 MPa)have been industrialized but yet still cannot motivate the widespread use of natural gas as transportation fuels due to the series problem of cost,safety and practicality [3,4].

Adsorbed natural gas (ANG),in which natural gas is stored in nanoporous material adsorbents,provides another promising solution by affording higher energy density at much moderate operating conditions such as lower pressure of 6.5 MPa.The operation condition is much safer than that of CNG and can relieve the compression and infrastructure costs [5].The difference between the amount of CH4adsorbed at the storage pressure and at the discharge pressure,denoted as the deliverable capacity of CH4,is a critical index that determines the driving range of ANG tanks.To match the performance of a CNG tank,the Advanced Research Projects Agency-Energy(ARPA-E)set a target that ANG system should arrive at a volumetric energy density of 12.5 MJ∙L-1(or equivalently deliver 315 cm3∙cm-3(STP)) to the engine between 6.5 MPa (storage)and 0.58 MPa(discharge)at ambient temperature considering 25% packing losses [6].

To realize the target,significant experimental and computational efforts have been paid on evaluating or designing various kinds of porous materials [7–21].However,present experimental results of the best porous materials still have~ 35% gap from the ARPA-E target.High-throughput computational evaluations of thousands of advanced hypothetical porous materials,including MOFs(metal–organic frameworks)[12],zeolites[13],porous polymer networks (PPNs) [14],COFs (covalent organic frameworks)[15] and,carbon-based materials [16] also strongly suggest that the ARPA-E target is unattainable by means of material design and structural refinement.For example,Wang et al.[16] computationally screened 580 activated carbon models and found that the porosity of adsorbents shall be higher than 0.58 with the ideal assumption that the adsorbed CH4has a density similar to the liquid CH4phase.Nonetheless,only 20 models that show porosities larger than 0.58 and none meets the ARPA-E target.In this case,currently proposed operation conditions were asked to be adjusted considering that the ARPA-E target is based solely on economic considerations for competitiveness with CNG [13,22].

In this work,we put our attention on experimentallysynthesized COFs,an emerging class of crystalline networks that are covalently constructed from organic components.COFs are featured by merits of light weight,high porosity and large surface area,and therefore can be promising candidates for ANG technologies [15,23–26].Assisted by the diverse COFs [27–31] as the ANG porous materials,we expect to discuss how to refine the operation conditions to meet the ARPA-E target which was demonstrated impossible at current operation conditions.Once the appropriate operation conditions are determined,relationships between performance and geometric properties and structure features are discussed,from which the obtained knowledge provides quite useful guidance for designing new COFs with excellent CH4delivery performance.

2.Methods

2.1.COF structures

The structures of 280 experimental COFs can be found in the CoRE COF database[31].Pore characterizations of LCD(largest cavity diameter),accessible surface area (Sacc) and free volume (Vfree)were performed using the open source software Zeo++[32].For each material,Saccwas calculated using a probe molecule with size equal to the kinetic diameter of N2(0.368 nm).Vfreewas computed with a probe size of 0.0 nm,which represents the geometric pore volume of a calculated framework.It is defined as the total volume of the unit cell which is not overlapping with the atoms of the crystal.Geometric pore volume generally reproduce the experimental pore volume better than the probe center pore volume(probe size is not 0.0 nm) and helium (He) pore volume do [33].Hence,the geometric pore volume is used in this work.

2.2.Simulation details

CH4adsorption at different operation conditions was determined through grand canonical Monte Carlo (GCMC) simulations.CH4molecules were modelled as LJ spheres with parameters taken from the TraPPE force field [34].The framework atoms were treated with LJ potentials using parameters from the DREIDING Force Field [35],while the missing parameters were taken from the Universal force field (UFF) [36].The above set of force fields has been validated reliable to reproduce the experimental data of methane adsorption on COFs[37].Lorentz-Berthelot mixing rules were used to describe all of the LJ cross potential parameters.Peng-Robinson equation of state was used to convert the pressure to the corresponding fugacity used in GCMC simulations.In the simulations,molecules involve five types of trials:attempts (i) to createa new molecule,(ii) to regrow a molecule at a random position,(iii) to translate a molecule,(iv) to delete an existing molecule,and (v) to exchange molecular identity.The cut-off distance for calculating intermolecular interaction energies was set to 1.4 nm without tail correction.Periodic boundary conditions were considered in all three dimensions.All GCMC simulations consisted of 2 × 107steps to ensure the equilibration,followed by 2 × 107steps to sample the desired thermodynamic properties.The operation conditions used in this work are listed in Table 1.The CH4deliverable capacity is calculated by follow equation

Table 1Operation conditions used in this work for CH4 delivery.

where CCH4is the adsorption capacity of CH4in the unit of(cm3 ∙cm-3 ((STP)),NCH4calculated by GCMC simulations,NAis the Avogadro constant,V is the total volume of the studied material,is the molar density of CH4at 273 K,101.325 kPa,DC (deliverable capacity) is the difference in adsorption capacity between adsorption and desorption condition.

The isosteric heats of adsorption(Qst)under the adsorption conditions were calculated using the ensemble fluctuation method[38],in which the contributions from the adsorbate–adsorbate interaction energy and the adsorbate-adsorbent interaction energy are respectively denoted as Qst,ffand Qst,fmin the following.More details of the simulation methods can be found elsewhere [39].COFs were held as rigid frameworks in the simulations.

3.Results and Discussion

3.1.Performance

The volumetric deliverable capacity at 298 K between 6.5 and 0.58 MPa of the 280 CoRE COFs was firstly calculated,as shown in Fig.1(a) (purple line).The maximum deliverable capacity observed from the screening is 190 cm3∙cm-3(STP),which is similar to the maximum deliverable capacity of~ 200 cm3∙cm-3(STP)found by computational screening of thousands of porous materials and extensive experimental measurements [14].To evaluate if the ARPA-E target is achievable by delicate material design,Gómez-Gualdrón et al.made a try and found that the distance between each adjacent methane pockets should be close to 0.53 nm to reach the 315 cm3∙cm-3(STP) target [20].However,it is apparent that such low distance is impossible to obtain when actual atoms are involved in the creation of the pockets.

Apart from material design,attempts have also been put on regulating the operation conditions to decrease the CH4capacity at desorption pressure [14,40].As done by Simon et al.[14].through screening 650,000 porous materials,suppose that CH4is discharged under an infinite high temperature,i.e.,all the residual gas is driven out,the deliverable capacity will be equal to the CH4uptake at 6.5 MPa and then the value can be remarkably increased to~ 260 cm3∙cm-3(STP) but still cannot meet theARPA-E demand,which is also the same situation for COFs,as shown in Fig.1(a)(red line).With the similar starting point,experimentalists have tried utilizing the flexibility of MOFs to decrease the CH4capacity at desorption pressure [41].These MOFs are approximately collapsed,non-porous frameworks at low pressure and can transit into expanded frameworks at high pressure.This is a workable strategy to improve the CH4delivery performance.However,if we note that the limit of CH4uptake at 6.5 MPa is~ 260 cm3∙cm-3(STP),we would figure out that methods of retrieving the hardly desorbed CH4cannot fundamentally transform the situation.Therefore,to substantially increase the CH4delivery performance,efforts should be paid on improving the CH4uptake at storage pressure.

Fig.1.Effects of operation conditions on the distribution of CH4 deliverable capacity of the 280 CoRE COFs.(a)red line:increasing the discharge temperature TD to ultimate high(TS=298 K,PS=6.5 MPa,TD=∞,PD=0.58 MPa),green line:increasing the storage pressure PS to 25 MPa(TS=298 K,PS=25 MPa,TD=298 K,PD=0.58 MPa);(b)orange line:decreasing the storage and discharge temperature TS and TD to 190.6 K (TS=190.6 K,PS=6.5 MPa,TD=190.6 K,PD=0.58 MPa),cyan line:decreasing the storage temperature TS to 190.6 K(TS=190.6 K,PS=6.5 MPa,TD=298 K,PD=0.58 MPa).The Y-axis of proportion means the ratio of the 280 CoRE COFs with varying CH4 deliverable capacity under different operation conditions.The total proportion with varying CH4 deliverable capacity equals to 1 for each operation condition.All the changes are on the basis of ARPA-E condition.

One possible way is increasing the storage pressure.As depicted in Fig.1(a) (green line),when the pressure is increased to 25 MPa which is the compression pressure of CNG,the highest deliverable capacity increases from 190 to 284 cm3∙cm-3(STP),noting that the deliverable capacity of empty tank also increases from 62 to 233 cm3∙cm-3(STP).Recently,Liang et al.synthesized a mesoporous Zn4O(—COO)6-based MOF showing the highest deliverable capacity of 289 cm3∙cm-3(STP)at 298 K and 0.5–20 MPa,surpassing all the previously reported records held by porous materials [42].Therefore,both the simulation and experimental works express the difficulty of arriving the 315 cm3∙cm-3(STP)target using this method,especially when we consider the higher energy cost and less safety under high pressure condition.

Another feasible way is decreasing the storage temperature,which is the method we interest in.As the critical temperature of CH4is 190.5 K,primarily,we directly decreased the temperature to the limit value of 190.6 K while ensuring the gas phase of CH4,noting that this temperature is still much higher than the operation temperature of 111 K adopted in CNG technology.Storage and discharge pressure are respectively 6.5 and 0.58 MPa.Under this condition,the highest deliverable capacity can achieve 336 cm3∙cm-3(STP),and totally 9 COFs can reach the 315 cm3∙cm-3(STP) target,accounting for 3.2% of the 280 COFs,as depicted in Fig.1(b) (orange line).When discharge is at room temperature(298 K),the highest deliverable capacity can hike to 392 cm3∙cm-3(STP),and there are 45 COFs surpassing the 315 cm3∙cm-3(STP)target,accounting for 16.1%of the 280 COFs (Fig.1(b)(cyan line)).A certain number of COFs meeting the ARPA-E demand suggest the effectiveness of temperature-regulating strategy,since it is extremely hard for other strategies to get one structure(no matter COFs,MOFs,PPNs or zeolites) reaching the goal.Along with the increasing of temperature,CH4deliverable performance will be weakened,as shown in Table 2.When the storage temperature increased from 190.6 K to 220 K,there are still 5 COFs that show deliverable capacity higher than 315 cm3∙cm-3(STP) when discharging at 298 K.Therefore,it has a certain range of choices for storage temperature if the 190.6 K is overcritical.In fact,many previous experimental studies focused on CH4delivery at ARPA-E conditions also tested the CH4uptake at low temperatures.Their experimental data showed that decreasing the adsorption temperature can increase the CH4uptake distinctly [43–44].Hence,the low temperature storage strategy is feasible to make the ARPA-E target achieved theoretically.

Table 2Temperature effects on qualified structures for ARPA-E demand.

3.2.Structure and performance relationships

For a better understanding of the adsorption behavior at different operation conditions,research on structure and performance relationships are essential,from which the obtained information on the structural features of remarkable structures are also meaningful for material design.

Under the ARPA-E condition(298 K,0.58–6.5 MPa),CH4deliverable capacity shows strong increasing relationship with increasing volumetric surface area,as shown in Fig.2.For the other three geometric properties,all the relationship diagrams show a trend of rise first then fall with a loose distribution of scatters,and these figures are placed in the Supplementary Material to save space.As shown in Fig.S1,good performed COFs are those with LCD of~ 0.9 nm,φ of~ 0.8 and gravimetric surface area of 40,007,000 m2∙g-1.Compared with other geometric properties,the monotonically increasing trend appeared in the case of volumetric surface area suggest the interaction between COF framework atoms and CH4molecules plays a leading role in CH4storage under this operation condition.Further calculation of isosteric heats of adsorption at storage condition (298 K,6.5 MPa) confirmed the speculation as the Qst,fmare higher than Qst,fffor all the COFs,as shown in Fig.3.

When storage temperature is decreased to 190.6 K (no matter discharge at 190.6 K or 298 K),CH4delivery performance is significantly improved,showing strong increasing relationship with increasing void fraction,as shown in Fig.4.For correlations with other geometric properties,when discharge at 190.6 K,LCD of1.3–3.2 nm and volumetric surface area of 850–1500 m2∙cm-3are the regions of good performed COFs center on;when discharge at 298 K,the optimum LCD is 0.8–3.2 nm,and the optimum volumetric surface area is 750–2250 m2∙cm-3,as depicted in Fig.S2 and S3.Generally,their structure performance relationships are similar although the discharge temperatures are different.Isosteric heats analysis at storage condition (190.6 K,6.5 MPa) shows that the Qst,ffare higher than Qst,fmfor the top 184 COFs (Fig.3),which is opposite to the laws found under ARPA-E condition,suggesting the CH4—CH4interaction plays a key role in CH4storage under low temperature.Since the CH4—CH4interaction is strong enough,the good performed COFs are therefore those with large void fraction that can provide abundant space for mutual attracted CH4molecules.For COFs with large void fraction,the number of 3DCOFs is quite bigger than that of 2D-COFs,resulting in their overwhelming occupation in the top-performing structures regardless of the topology type.However,it is worth noting that CCOF-2,a distinctive 2D-COF with large interlayer spacing,shows the highest CH4deliverable capacity of 336 cm3∙cm-3(STP),as shown in Fig.4(a),which inspires our further structure design for other 2D-COFs in the next section to improve their CH4delivery performance.

Fig.2.Relationship between CH4 deliverable capacity and volumetric surface area under ARPA-E condition.

Fig.3.Comparison of Qst,ff and Qst,fm under condition of 298 K,6.5 MPa(blue dots)and 190.6 K,6.5 MPa (red dots) for CH4 storage.The black line represents the zero baseline.

3.3.Structure design for better performance

According to the established structure performance relationships,CH4deliverable capacity increases with the increasing void fraction under low storage temperature.Spontaneously,we would ask whether the present void fraction touches the optimum value or even better performance can be achieved in COFs with larger void fraction.To uncover this puzzle,we construct 120 COFs with void fraction varied from 0.93 to 0.99 by using open source porous materials design suite of Zeo++[45].The building units of COFs(Fig.S4) are commercially available chemical fragments selfassembled based on established reactions for COFs synthesis[46].Common functional groups are also used in decorating the fragments to obtain structures with desired void fractions.The 120 designed COFs (accessible online https://github.com/corecof/Generated-COFs/) are consisted of 117 3D-COFs with all the four possible topologies(bor,ctn,dia and pts)and 3 functionalized 2D-COFs.As can be seen from Fig.5(a),when storage and discharge temperatures are 190.6 K,the optimum void fraction is~0.94 with the highest CH4deliverable capacity of 338 cm3∙cm-3(STP) in the designed COFs.When storage and discharge temperatures are 190.6 K and 298 K respectively,all the designed COFs are in the downward trend,pointing the optimum void fraction of~ 0.91,as shown in Fig.5(b).Therefore,under both operation conditions,the void fractions of CoRE COFs have touched the optimum value.From the estimation of CoRE-COF,it is speculated that the CH4deliverable capacity increases with the void fraction because large void fraction provides increasing adsorption space for the CH4molecules.However,if the void fraction is over large,the confinement effect exerted by the framework is negligible,as can be reflected from the relationship between Qstand φ (Fig.S5),and the corresponding CH4delivery performance is getting close to that of empty box(Fig.5).Hence,constructed COFs with over large void fraction do not have high delivery capacity.

Fig.4.Relationship between CH4 deliverable capacity and void fraction under condition (a) TS=190.6 K,PS=6.5 MPa,TD=190.6 K,PD=0.58 MPa,(b) TS=190.6 K,PS=6.5 MPa,TD=298 K,PD=0.58 MPa.

Fig.5.Exploring the optimum void fraction for CH4 delivery by constructing COFs with void fraction varied from 0.93 to 0.99 under condition(a)TS=190.6 K,PS=6.5 MPa,TD=190.6 K,PD=0.58 MPa,(b) TS=190.6 K,PS=6.5 MPa,TD=298 K,PD=0.58 MPa.

Fig.6.Comparison of the interlayer spacings of common 2D-COFs (left) and CCOF-2 (right,gray:C,blue:N,red:O;white:H).

Previously,we have mentioned that most 2D-COFs are less well-behaved because of their typically lower void fractions.Among the 2D-COFs,CCOF-2 is an exception with high void fraction of 0.938.In the sight of structural characteristics,a conspicuous feature of CCOF-2 that differs from other 2D-COFs is the wide interlayer spacing of~1.5 nm,if noting the value for most 2D-COFs is 0.3–0.5 nm,as shown in Fig.6.With the wide interlayer spacing,the void space in the direction of layer stacking is significantly enlarged,and this finally contributes to the top performance of CCOF-2 in CH4delivery.Following this train of thought,it is inquisitive to explore if the method of enlarging interlayer spacing can be effective for other less well-behaved 2D-COFs.Consequently,we choose four 2D-COFs (ATFG-COF [47],IISERP-COF3 [48],AEMCOF-1 [49],Star-COF-1 [50]) with unimpressive CH4delivery performance and pore size of~ 1.0 nm,2.0 nm,3.0 nm and 4.0 nm respectively for the test,in which only the distance of interlayer spacing(in the c-axis of a unit cell)is regulated,while the x-y plane coordinates of all the framework atoms are fixed.

Fig.7 illustrates the CH4delivery performance of the regulated 2D-COFs.The result is striking as the CH4deliverable capacities of the four tested COFs are all boosted to a high level along with the increasing interlayer spacings.Among the regulated structures,AEM-COF-1 with interlayer spacing of 1.44 nm can deliver 349 cm3∙cm-3(STP) CH4when storage and discharge temperatures are at 190.6 K (pointed out in Fig.7),ATFG-COF with interlayer spacing of 1.65 nm can deliver 411 cm3∙cm-3(STP)CH4when storage and discharge temperatures are respectively at 190.6 K and 298 K (pointed out in Fig.7).Coincidentally,the void fractions of the two identified structures are 0.943 and 0.905 respectively,conforming to the previously summarized optimum void fraction of~0.94 and~0.91 for CH4delivery.Hence,the method of enlarging interlayer spacing is demonstrated effective theoretically.

Fig.7.Function of CH4 deliverable capacity and the distance of interlayer spacings of four COFs with pore size of~1.0 nm,2.0 nm,3.0 nm and 4.0 nm,respectively.Pentagon represents the condition of TS=190.6 K,PS=6.5 MPa,TD=298 K,PD=0.58 MPa.Circle represents the condition of TS=190.6 K,PS=6.5 MPa,TD=190.6 K,PD=0.58 MPa.

4.Conclusions

In this work,we conduct a discussion on refining the operation conditions to see if and how the CH4delivery performance can be substantially improved.As the methods of raising the discharge temperature or elevating the storage pressure have been proved to show limited effectiveness,which is also demonstrated true in this work by using the 280 CoRE COFs as the ANG materials,a low temperature storage strategy is proposed to make the ARPAE target achieved.The effects are remarkable as a certain number of experimental COFs can meet the ARPA-E demand.For example,when decrease the storage and discharge temperatures from 298 K to 190.6 K,the highest deliverable capacity can achieve 336 cm3∙cm-3(STP),and 3.2% COFs among the 280 experimentallysynthesized COFs can reach the ARPA-E target;when only reduce the storage temperature to 190.6 K and keep the discharge temperature at 298 K,the highest deliverable capacity can reach 392 cm3∙cm-3(STP),and 16.1% COFs among the 280 COFs can surpass the ARPA-E target.The operation temperature can be higher (such as 220 K) if 190.6 K is overcritical.

Study on structure and performance relationships based on the 280 CoRE COFs shows that the CH4deliverable capacity increases with the increasing void fraction at 190.6 K.To definite the limit of optimum void fraction,120 hypothetical COFs are constructed with void fractions larger than or equal to the present COFs.Finally,the simulation results of totally 400 COFs show that void fractions of CoRE COFs have touched the optimum value,which are~ 0.94 when both storage and discharge temperatures are 190.6 K and~ 0.91 when storage and discharge temperatures are 190.6 K and 298 K respectively.

The findings and the methodology developed in this work will provide new ideas for ANG technology with high volumetric energy density,which is not limited to COFs but also transferrable for other nanoporous materials.

Declaration of Competing Interest

The authors declare that they have no known competing financial interests or personal relationships that could have appeared to influence the work reported in this paper.

Acknowledgements

This work was supported by the Natural Science Foundation of China(21706106,51702137),the Foundation of State Key Laboratory of High-Efficiency Utilization of Coal and Green Chemical Engineering (2020-KF-20),the Postgraduate Research &Practice Innovation Program of Jiangsu Province (KYCX20_2236).

Supplementary Material

Supplementary data to this article can be found online at https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cjche.2020.10.035.


登录APP查看全文