Reduced nitrogen application rate with dense planting improves rice grain yield and nitrogen use efficiency:A case study in east China
2021-08-25HunheWeiTinyoMengJilinGeXuinZhngTinyiShiEnhoDingYuLuXinyueLiYunToYinglongChenMinLiQigenDi
Hunhe Wei ,Tinyo Meng ,Jilin Ge ,Xuin Zhng ,Tinyi Shi ,Enho Ding ,Yu Lu ,Xinyue Li ,Yun To ,Yinglong Chen ,Min Li ,Qigen Di ,,*
a Jiangsu Key Laboratory of Crop Cultivation and Physiology/Jiangsu Key Laboratory of Crop Genetics and Physiology/Jiangsu Co-Innovation Center for Modern Production Technology of Grain Crops/Research Institute of Rice Industrial Engineering Technology,Yangzhou University,Yangzhou 225009,Jiangsu,China
b Institutes of Agricultural Science and Technology Development/Joint International Research Laboratory of Agriculture and Agri-Product Safety,The Ministry of Education of China,Yangzhou University,Yangzhou 225009,Jiangsu,China
c Rice Research Institute of Guizhou,Guiyang 550006,Guizhou,China
ABSTRACT Dense planting could be a feasible method for reducing nitrogen (N) application rates without compromising rice grain yield in northeast and central China.It is still unclear whether reduced N application with dense planting (RNDP) can achieve higher rice yield and N use efficiency (NUE) in Jiangsu,east China.Three japonica inbred rice (JI) and three indica hybrid rice (IH) cultivars were grown in a field experiment.Their grain yield,NUE,and related traits were compared under two cultivation treatments:conventional high-yielding practice(CHYP)and RNDP.JI showed similar yields under the two treatments,while IH showed lower yield under RNDP than under CHYP,and the partial factor productivity of N and N use efficiency for grain yield increased (P <0.05) in both JI and IH under RNDP.Compared with CHYP,RNDP reduced spikelets per panicle but increased panicles per m2 and filled-kernel percentage of JI and IH,and JI’s kernel weight was increased(P<0.05)under RNDP.Shoot biomass weight and nonstructural carbohydrate (NSC) content in the stem at heading and maturity of JI and IH were reduced under RNDP,while harvest index and NSC remobilization reserve were increased (P <0.05) under RNDP,especially for JI.Our results suggest that RNDP could achieve a higher rice grain yield and NUE,particularly for JI,a dominant rice cultivar type in Jiangsu.For JI,the increased panicles per m2,sink-filling efficiency,harvest index,and NSC remobilization after heading under RNDP contributed to a grain yield similar to that under CHYP.
Keywords:Japonica inbred rice Grain yield Nitrogen use efficiency Reduced nitrogen rate Dense planting
1.Introduction
The simultaneous improvement of grain yield and nitrogen use efficiency (NUE) in China’s rice cropping systems remains a huge challenge [1].Nitrogen (N) fertilization and planting density are two crucial agronomic practices for regulating rice yield [2].Recently,on-farm surveys conducted in major rice-producing provinces of China showed that many farmers transplant rice with sparse planting to reduce labor input [3,4].Under sparse planting,the overapplication of N fertilizer to ensure high rice yield is common,but reduces the stability of the rice yield and results in low NUE and environmental degradation [5,6].
Previous studies[7,8]have revealed that dense rice planting can be a practical method of reducing the N application rate without a yield penalty in northeast and central China.Within a certain range,compensation for the adverse effects of lowering the N rate on panicles per m2and spikelets per m2,leaf area index(LAI),and biomass accumulation could be achieved by increasing the planting density[4,7,9].The reduced N rate with dense planting(RNDP)strategy can achieve rice grain yields similar to those achieved under conventional high-yielding practice (CHYP) as well as improve NUE and confer environmental benefits.RNDP is also recommended to achieve a higher yield and NUE in maize[10],cotton [11,12],and oilseed rape [13,14].However,little attention has been paid to the exploration of RNDP as a potential approach for increasing rice grain yield and NUE in east China,another critical rice-producing zone.
Rice production is always characterized by a relatively high yield under a high N rate with a low NUE in Jiangsu province,east China[15,16].An on-farm survey showed[17]that an average rate of 336.7 kg N ha-1was used to achieve a high rice grain yield and that the partial factor productivity of N(PFPN)was only 24.2 kg kg-1for rice in Jiangsu.These findings indicate the potential of increasing the NUE of rice in Jiangsu,but whether RNDP could improve rice grain yield and NUE simultaneously in this region is unknown.
Japonicainbred rice(JI)andindicahybrid rice(IH)are two main types of rice cultivar,occupying approximately 90% and 10%,respectively,of the rice-growing area in Jiangsu [18].It has been reported [19–21] that JI showed a 7%–16% higher grain yield than IH,and higher panicles per m2,improved biomass accumulation and translocation,more compact plant type,and higher leaf area accounted for the superior grain yield of JI relative to IH.These studies focusing on the morphophysiological characteristics associated with the yield advantage of JI over IH were conducted mostly under CHYP.Still,whether JI also presents a higher grain yield than IH under RNDP awaits investigation.
The primary purposes of the present study were (1) to investigate the feasibility of improving the grain yield and NUE of rice via the RNDP approach in Jiangsu,and (2) to determine whether JI would present better yield performance than IH under RNDP.For these purposes,a two-year field experiment was conducted to characterize the grain yield and NUE of JI and IH under RNDP and CHYP.The agronomic and physiological traits affecting rice grain yield and NUE were measured,including shoot and root biomass,harvest index,LAI,nonstructural carbohydrate(NSC)content and NSC remobilization reserve,leaf photosynthetic rate,and root oxidative activity and root bleeding rate after heading.
2.Materials and methods
2.1.Field trial site and growing conditions
Field trials were performed on the experimental farm of Yangzhou University(119.43°E,32.39°N),Jiangsu province,east China,in 2017 and 2018.The soil was a sandy loam,and the 0–20 cm soil layer contained 17.4 g kg-1organic carbon,1.4 g kg-1total N,36.6 mg kg-1Olsen phosphorus,and 83.9 mg kg-1available potassium.
The rice cultivars were grown during the period from May to October in this study.Generally,the rice experienced similar temperatures in 2017 and 2018 and lower sunshine hours and rainfall in 2017 than in 2018 (Fig.S1).
2.2.Cultivation treatments,rice cultivars,and field management
This field trial was laid out in a split-plot design.The cultivation treatments served as the main plots and rice cultivars served as the subplots(Fig.S2).The size of each experimental plot was 6×4 m,with three replications over two years.The cultivation treatments consisted of CHYP and RNDP.In the CHYP treatment,the N rate was 300 kg ha-1in total,and the planting density was 25 hills m-2(30 × 13.3 cm).The CHYP model was designed based on previous studies [22–24] and suggestions from the local agricultural technician (Yao Y.,personal communication).The N application rate under the CHYP model was defined according to the regular N fertilizer rate used in high-yield rice cultivation in Jiangsu province,which averages approximately 300 kg N per hectare[22,25,26].The N rate under the RNDP model was determined based on site-specific N management [1,27],according to leaf N status measured with the soil–plant analysis development (SPAD)chlorophyll meter(SPAD-502,Konica Minolta,Osaka,Japan)at one week after transplanting,panicle initiation(the first appearance of a differentiated apex),and penultimate leaf appearance stages.Mean SPAD values were measured on the topmost 15 fully expanded leaves in the field in each plot.At SPAD ≥ 42,40 Three JI and three IH cultivars were grown.The three JI cultivars were Nanjing 5055,Nanjing 9108,and Wuyunjing 30 and the three IH cultivars were Yangxianyou 68,Jinliangyou 882,and Yangliangyou 1618.The six rice cultivars were selected for popularity and widespread production.For example,Nanjing 9108 is wellknown for its excellent cooking and eating qualities [30],and its cumulative planting area has reached over 1.4 Mha by the end of 2018 (http://www.ricedata.cn).The cultivars shared similar total growth periods,with their entire growth period ranging from 150 to 156 days in this study. The rice seeds were raised in the nursery field on May 23 and transplanted at three seedlings per hill on June 13 in the two study years.All plots followed the same field management regime except with respect to N rate and planting density.Before transplanting,120 kg P2O5ha-1and 180 kg K2O ha-1were applied as base fertilizers.Water regimes and weed and pest management were consistent across the experimental plots and followed local recommendations. Plants from ten hills in each plot were sampled to measure shoot biomass weight,LAI,NSC content,and N concentration at jointing,heading,and maturity stages.The plants were divided into leaves and stems at jointing,and into leaves,stems,and panicles at heading and maturity.LAI was measured with a leaf area meter (LI-3100C,Li-COR,Lincoln,NE,USA).Plant samples were weighed after oven-drying at 75 °C for 80 h.NSC content was determined following Takai et al.[31].N concentration in rice plants was measured following Thomas et al.[32]. Because the six cultivars shared similar heading dates and period from heading to maturity,their root biomass weights were measured at the same period after heading under RNDP and CHYP,and root oxidative activity,root bleeding rate,and leaf photosynthetic rate were also measured. Three hills with a 25 × 13 × 30 cm (length × width × depth)soil block were sampled,and collection was conducted at 10 cm depth intervals of 0–10 cm,10–20 cm,and 20–30 cm at 20 days after heading (DAH).The sampled root parts were rinsed thoroughly with water and then oven-dried at 75 °C for 80 h for biomass determination.The root oxidative activity and root bleeding rate at 20 and 40 DAH were measured following Ramasamy et al.[33] and Meng et al.[34]. The photosynthetic rate of the flag leaf was measured at heading,early stage of the grain-filling period(ES,12–13 DAH),middle stage of the grain-filling period(MS,25–26 DAH),and late stage of the grain-filling period (LS,37–38 DAH).Measurements were performed in the morning(from 9:30 to 11:30)in the field with three portable photosynthesis instruments (LI-6800),and the relevant parameters were set following Gu et al.[35]. Rice plants from 150 hills were harvested at maturity to determine the rice grain yield adjusted to 14% moisture in each plot.Fifty hills of plants were sampled from each plot to measure yield components,including panicles per m2,spikelets per panicle,filled-kernel percentage,and kernel weight. All data analyses were conducted with SAS/STAT software(version 9.4,SAS Institute Inc.,Cary,NC,USA).Means were compared by analysis of variance (ANOVA) followed by the least significant difference (LSD) test.Because no differences in any of the measured parameters were significant among the three cultivars within the same cultivar type,the data for each type are presented as the mean of the three cultivars.Because year was not a significant factor in this experiment,the values from the two years were averaged. JI showed similar grain yields under the two treatments,while IH showed lower (P<0.05) grain yield under RNDP than under CHYP across the two years.Across the two years,the grain yields of JI were 6.0% and 10.0% higher than those of IH under CHYP and RNDP,respectively (Table 1).For JI and IH,RNDP increased panicles per m2and filled-kernel percentage but decreased spikelets per panicle.JI’s kernel weight was higher (P<0.05) under RNDP than under CHYP.JI presented consistently higher panicles per m2and spikelets per m2but lower spikelets per panicle,filled-kernel percentage,and kernel weight than IH under RNDP and CHYP (Table 1). Compared with the results under CHYP,RNDP resulted in lower(P<0.05) N accumulation at maturity in both JI and IH.JI showed higher (P<0.05) N accumulation at maturity than IH under RNDP and CHYP.In both JI and IH,the partial factor productivity of N(PFPN) and the N utilization efficiency for grain yield (NUEg) were higher (P<0.05) under RNDP than under CHYP.JI showed higher(P<0.05) PFPNand NUEg than IH under RNDP (Table 2). For both JI and IH,the shoot biomass weights at jointing,heading,and maturity were lower under RNDP than under CHYP.JI showed higher shoot biomass weights at jointing,heading,and maturity than IH under both RNDP and CHYP.Compared with the results under CHYP,the harvest index was increased(P<0.05)under RNDP,especially for JI.Although the harvest index was lower under CHYP,JI showed a higher harvest index than IH under RNDP.There was no significant difference in shoot biomass accumulation from jointing to heading between JI and IH under both treatments.For IH,RNDP resulted in a reduction (P<0.05)in shoot biomass accumulation from heading to maturity compared to that in CHYP.JI showed consistently higher (P<0.05)shoot biomass accumulation from heading to maturity than IH under both cultivation treatments (Table 3). For both JI and IH,RNDP reduced (P<0.05) the NSC content in the stem at heading and maturity and increased (P<0.05) NSC remobilization reserve compared to their values under CHYP.JI showed a higher (P<0.05) NSC content in the stem at heading and maturity than IH under the two cultivation treatments.For example,JI showed a 7.0% higher NSC content in the stem atmaturity than IH under RNDP across the two years.JI showed a lower (P<0.05) NSC remobilization reserve than IH under CHYP but a higher (P<0.05) under RNDP (Table 4). Table 1 Grain yield and its components of JI and IH under two cultivation treatments across two years. Table 2 Nitrogen (N) accumulation at maturity and N-related use efficiency of JI and IH under two cultivation treatments across two years. Table 3 Shoot biomass weight at the main stages,harvest index,and shoot biomass accumulation during the main periods of JI and IH under two cultivation treatments across two years. Table 4 Nonstructural carbohydrate (NSC) content in the stem and NSC remobilization reserve of JI and IH under two cultivation treatments across two years. Table 5 Leaf area index(LAI)at the main stages of JI and IH under two cultivation treatments across two years. RNDP reduced LAI at jointing,heading,and maturity in both JI and IH compared with the values under CHYP.No significant difference in LAI at jointing was observed between JI and IH under either cultivation treatment.Compared with CHYP,RNDP resulted in a lower(P<0.05)LAI at heading and maturity for JI and IH.JI showed a higher(P<0.05)LAI at heading and maturity than IH under both RNDP and CHYP (Table 5). Compared with the values under CHYP,the leaf photosynthetic rates of both cultivar types were decreased under RNDP.The difference in the leaf photosynthetic rate between JI and IH was not significant at heading,ES,or MS under RNDP or CHYP.JI showed a consistently higher(P<0.05)leaf photosynthetic rate at LS than IH under RNDP and CHYP (Fig.1). Fig.1.Leaf photosynthetic rate of the flag leaf at heading,ES,MS,and LS of JI and IH under two cultivation treatments across two years.RNDP,reduced N rate with dense planting;CHYP,conventional high-yielding practice.JI, japonica inbred rice;IH,indica hybrid rice.ES,early stage of the grain-filling period;MS,middle stage of the grain-filling period;LS,late stage of the grain-filling period.Values in the same growth stage followed by different letters are significantly different at the 0.05 probability level based on the LSD test.Vertical bars represent ± standard error of the mean(n=6).The raw data of leaf photosynthetic rate of the flag leaf at heading,ES,MS,and LS of each rice cultivar under two cultivation treatments in 2017 and 2018 are presented in Table S7. The total root biomass weight of JI and IH at 20 DAH were both lower(P<0.05)under RNDP than under CHYP.JI showed 12.2%and 19.7%higher(P<0.05)total root biomass weight than IH across the two years under CHYP and RNDP,respectively,and a similar trend was observed in the weight of the 10–20 and 20–30 cm root biomass (Table 6). Compared with CHYP,RNDP reduced the root oxidative activity and root bleeding rate of JI and IH at 20 and 40 DAH.The root oxidative activity and root bleeding rate of JI at 40 DAH were higher (P<0.05) than those of IH under both RNDP and CHYP(Fig.2). Panicles per m2was positively (P<0.01 orP<0.05) correlated with grain yield and NUEg of rice under both RNDP and CHYP.Most of the measured parameters,such as NSC remobilization reserve and 10–20 and 20–30 cm root biomass weight,were positively(P<0.01 orP<0.05) correlated with rice grain yield and NUEg under RNDP (Table 7). In this study,JI presented similar grain yields under the two tested treatments,and higher PFPNand NUEg under RNDP than under CHYP (Tables 1,2).These results indicated that RNDP could simultaneously increase the grain yield and NUE of JI,the dominant rice cultivar type in Jiangsu,east China[21].Thus,RNDP could be a practical strategy for obtaining higher yield and NUE of rice cropping systems in this region. For both JI and IH,panicles per m2was increased,while spikelets per panicle was decreased under RNDP,but no differences in spikelets per m2were detected under RNDP and CHYP.Filledkernel percentage and kernel weight were increased under RNDP,especially for JI (Table 1).These results suggest that the increase in panicles per m2and improved grain-filling efficiency both contributed to the similar grain yields of JI under RNDP and CHYP. RNDP reduced LAI and leaf photosynthetic rate and caused lower biomass weight at the main stages of both JI and IH (Tables 3,5;Fig.1).Nevertheless,the harvest index was increased(P<0.05)under RNDP,especially for JI(Table 3).These results suggest that the similar grain yields of JI between RNDP and CHYP wasdue mainly to the increased harvest index,in agreement with prior studies [7–9]. Table 6 Root biomass weight at 20 days after heading (DAH) of JI and IH under two cultivation treatments across two years. Table 7 Correlations between the measured parameters and grain yield and N utilization efficiency for grain yield of rice under two cultivation treatments. Fig.2.Root oxidative activity(a)and root bleeding rate(b)at 20 and 40 DAH of JI and IH under two cultivation treatments across two years.RNDP,reduced N rate with dense planting;CHYP,conventional high-yielding practice.JI, japonica inbred rice;IH, indica hybrid rice;DAH,days after heading;a-NA,alpha-naphthylamine;DW,dry matter weight.Values in the same growth period followed by different letters are significantly different at the 0.05 probability level based on the LSD test.Vertical bars represent ± standard error of the mean (n=6).The raw data of root oxidative activity and root bleeding rate at 20 and 40 DAH of each rice cultivar under two cultivation treatments in 2017 and 2018 are presented in Table S9. It has been reported [31,36,37] that an increase in pre-stored carbon remobilization from source (e.g.,stem) to sink (kernels) is helpful for improving sink-filling efficiency and harvest index.Compared with CHYP,RNDP increased NSC remobilization reserve,particularly for JI (Table 4).This result also indicates that better NSC remobilization after heading could increase the harvest index,grain yield,and NUE of JI under RNDP (Table 7). JI showed 6.0%and 10.0%higher grain yield than IH under CHYP and RNDP,respectively (Table 1).This result suggested that JI showed yield superiority over IH under RNDP.The grain yield of rice can be expressed as the product of sink size and sink-filling efficiency [38].The greater spikelets per m2resulting from increased panicles per m2was the basis for JI’s grain yield advantage over IH under both CHYP and RNDP (Table 1).The sinkfilling efficiency of rice is dependent on the sink–source balance[39,40].An increase in spikelets per m2in rice requires a greater ability of the source to fill the sink to achieve higher grain yield[41,42].JI showed higher shoot biomass weight and LAI at the main growth stages than IH under RNDP and CHYP (Tables 3,5).An advantage of JI over IH with respect to biomass accumulation was observed mainly during the period from heading to maturity(Table 3),indicating the greater capacity of biomass accumulation after heading in JI than in IH under RNDP. JI showed a lower harvest index than IH under CHYP but a higher harvest index than IH under RNDP (Table 3).Thus,the higher biomass accumulation after heading and higher harvest index contributed to JI’s grain yield advantage over IH under RNDP.The higher harvest index of JI than IH under RNDP was associated with a higher NSC content in the stem at heading and maturity and remobilized NSC reserve of JI under RNDP(Tables 3,4).JI presented a higher leaf photosynthetic rate than IH at heading and during the grain-filling period under both CHYP and RNDP (Fig.1).A higher leaf photosynthetic rate is desirable for maintaining source activity.Parameters such as LAI and SPAD value are often used to characterize source activity.In this study,JI,with a high leaf photosynthetic rate and LAI,clearly produced more assimilates and had greater NSC accumulation(Tables 3,4),in agreement with previous studies[43–45].For example,Chu et al.[43]reported thatindica/japonicahybrids with higher leaf photosynthetic rates and LAI showed higher NSC contents thanjaponicahybrids at heading and maturity.In cereals,the carbon used for sink-filling comes from current assimilates and assimilates remobilized from vegetative tissues to kernels,the latter of which are crucial for grain yield when plants suffer from limiting conditions,such as abiotic stresses and lower nutrient supply levels [31,46].Thus,the increased NSC accumulation and remobilization observed in JI under RNDP with a lower N supply could lead to JI’s increased sink-filling efficiency and harvest index [47–49] and consequently better yield performance than IH. JI showed 12.2% and 19.7% higher total root biomass weight than IH under CHYP and RNDP,respectively,across the two years,and the greater total root biomass of JI than of IH was seen mainly in 10–20 and 20–30 cm root biomass(Table 6).These results indicated that JI presented larger roots and a deeper root distribution than IH under RNDP.Root oxidative activity and root bleeding rate were regarded as important indexes of root physiological activity;higher root oxidative activity and root bleeding rate were necessary to maintain root and shoot growth,and improve the absorption and utilization of nutrients [43,50].Herein,JI showed higher root oxidative activity and root bleeding rate during the grainfilling period than IH (Fig.2),indicating increased root vigor of JI during grain filling.This better root system of JI would contribute to acquiring more N,maintaining biomass productivity,and increasing grain yield and NUEg[32,48,49].Thus,larger roots with a deeper distribution and increased root activity during grain filling were crucial traits underlying JI’s higher grain yield and NUEg than IH under RNDP (Table 7). RNDP could be a practical method for achieving a higher rice grain yield and NUE,particularly for JI,a dominant rice cultivar type in Jiangsu,east China.In comparison with CHYP,JI achieved a similar grain yield under RNDP,attributed to the increases in panicles per m2,sink-filling efficiency,harvest index,and remobilization of NSC after heading.The larger sink size through panicles per m2,greater capacity of biomass accumulation and NSC remobilization after heading,higher harvest index,and larger roots with deeper distribution and increased root activity during grain filling were the main traits underlying the higher yield of JI than IH under RNDP. CRediT authorship contribution statement Huanhe Wei:contributed to the conception of the study,performed the data analyses,and wrote and revised the manuscript.Tianyao Meng:contributed to the conception of the study,and review and editing of the earlier draft.Jialin Ge and Xubin Zhang:assisted with plant sampling and measurements of rice agronomic and physiological traits.Tianyi Shi,Enhao Ding,Yu Lu,Xinyue Li,and Yuan Tao:assisted in measurements of rice agronomic traits.Yinglong Chen:contributed to the conception of the study.Min Li:contributed to the conception and methodology of the study.Qigen Dai:supervised project planning and execution. Declaration of competing interest Authors declare that there are no conflicts of interest. Acknowledgments This work was financed by the National Natural Science Foundation of China (31901448),the Key Research and Development Program of Jiangsu (BE2019343),the Natural Science Foundation of the Jiangsu Higher Education Institutions of China(19KJB210004),China Postdoctoral Science Foundation(2020M671628,2020M671629),Jiangsu Postdoctoral Science Foundation (2020Z061),the Guizhou Science and Technology Department (20161148),and the Priority Academic Program Development of Jiangsu Higher Education Institutions. Appendix A.Supplementary data Supplementary data for this article can be found online at https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cj.2020.10.013.2.3.Sampling and measurement
2.4.Statistical analysis
3.Results
3.1.Grain yield and its components,and NUE
3.2.Shoot biomass,harvest index,and NSC





3.3.LAI and photosynthetic rate of flag leaf

3.4.Root biomass,root oxidative activity,and root bleeding rate
3.5.Correlation analysis
4.Discussion
4.1.The feasibility of increasing rice grain yield and NUE by RNDP in Jiangsu



4.2.The main traits responsible for the higher grain yield of JI than IH under RNDP
5.Conclusions
杂志排行
The Crop Journal的其它文章
- Evaluation of root traits and water use efficiency of different cotton genotypes in the presence or absence of a soil-hardpan
- Genome-wide characterization of early response genes to abscisic acid coordinating multiple pathways in Aegilops tauschii
- Ectopic expression of antifreeze protein gene from Ammopiptanthus nanus confers chilling tolerance in maize
- Hybrid rice yield response to potted-seedling machine transplanting and slow-release nitrogen fertilizer application combined with urea topdressing
- Exogenous abscisic acid coordinating leaf senescence and transport of assimilates into wheat grains under drought stress by regulating hormones homeostasis
- Modeling the effects of extreme high-temperature stress at anthesis and grain filling on grain protein in winter wheat
