APP下载

The influence of mining factors on seismic activity during longwall mining of a coal seam

2021-07-10ukszWojteckiJonnKurzejgorztKnopik

矿业科学技术学报 2021年3期

Łuksz Wojtecki *,Jonn Kurzej ,Młgorzt Knopik

a Department of Geology and Geophysics,Central Mining Institute,40-166 Katowice,Poland

b Polish Mining Group,40-039 Katowice,Poland

Keywords:Underground coal mining Induced seismicity Seismic statistics Benioff strain release

ABSTRACT In this article an attempt to determine the influence of mining factors on the seismic activity during the longwall mining of the upper layer of coal seam no.405/2 in one of the Polish hard coal mines in the Upper Silesian Coal Basin was conducted.Two longwall panels were mined in analogous geological conditions and based on the same mining system and technology.However,there was significant difference with regards to the mining factors,which was reflected in the observed seismic activity.Some tools used in mining seismology were applied to illustrate the aforementioned influence of mining factors,e.g.the frequency-energy distribution,the frequency-magnitude distribution,the 2D distribution of released seismic energy,the relationship between released seismic energy and the volume of mined coal,the Benioff strain release,and the Gutenberg-Richter (GR) b coefficient distribution (b is the proportion between high and low energy tremors).Concerning the Benioff strain release,a new solution,based on the slope of a fitted line in a moving time window,is proposed.

1.Introduction

The underground mining of coal seams in the Upper Silesian Coal Basin (USCB) is responsible for inducing and triggering seismic events,e.g.[1-6].Seismic hazard,accompanying the excavation of hard coal in the USCB,is continuously and precisely monitored in mines.Seismic and rockburst hazards are correlated with each other.The rockburst hazard is one of the main natural hazards in the hard coal mines in the USCB,e.g.[7-9].Seismological observations enable the influence of geological and mining conditions on the level of seismicity to be found,e.g.[1-6].A correlation between seismic activity and geological and mining conditions in a monitored area depends on the determination of their mutual space-time relations [9].The mining seismology method,being a part of the comprehensive method for rockburst hazard assessment [10],is commonly applied in hard coal mines in the USCB [11].The seismicity is evaluated with the usage of a wide range of parameters,e.g.the number of tremors,the seismic energy,the focal mechanism,the seismic source parameters,the energy index,the seismic energy release in the unit of time or excavation advance,the frequency-energy and frequencymagnitude distributions,or the b coefficient of the Gutenberg-Richter (GR) relation in the moving time window.The analysis of seismicity in hard coal mines based on the parameters presented has been the subject of many studies,e.g.[12-16].The causes of induced seismicity during underground mining works,especially during longwall mining,are numerous.Generally,they can be divided into three main groups,i.e.geological,mining,and technological factors.The group of mining factors consists of remnants and edges of other and earlier extracted coal seams,established protecting or retaining pillars,the changing of longwall mining direction,increase of unsupported roof surface,excessive bed cutting,being in the vicinity of gobs or other filled or unfilled excavations,etc.These factors have a negative influence from the perspective of seismic and rockburst hazards.The most positive mining factors consist of earlier and total mining of overlying or underlying coal seams deposited a short vertical distance from the current works.Unfortunately,however,the destress effects from this fade over time.While this time is short,the total excavation of a coal seam can effectively destress the floor and roof rock masses,and minimize the seismic and rockburst hazard during mining works in the surrounding coal seams.Over many years of mining in underground hard coal mines in the USCB the influence of different factors on seismic and rockburst hazard was investigated,however much still remains to be explored on this subject.

A unique opportunity to test the impact of mining factors on seismic activity appeared when longwall mining of the upper layer of coal seam no.405/2 in one of the Polish hard coal mines in the USCB was planned.It was decided to excavate two separate longwall panels in analogous geological and technological conditions,with only mining conditions differing.The seismic activity was monitored by a mine seismic network during the excavation of both longwall panels,which made the comparison of induced seismicity possible.The influence of mining factors on seismic activity was clearly visible.Some tools used in mining seismology were applied to illustrate the influence of mining factors on seismic activity.Additionally,a new way to analyse the Benioff strain release (BSR) was proposed.The presented research results may turn out to be useful for the assessment of seismic and rockburst hazards in underground hard coal mines.

2.Conditions of mining

2.1.Geology and mining factors

The selected hard coal mine is located in the Polish part of the USCB,at the structural unit called the Main Saddle (or the Main Anticline).In the southern part of this mine an excavation of two longwall panels in the upper layer of coal seam no.405/2 was planned and realized.Both longwall panels were mined with caving in the eastern direction(Fig.1).They were mined one at a time,i.e.the first one from October 2017 to June 2018,and the second one from January 2019 to September 2019,with an approximately 20-day break in mining from around June 20th due to combustion hazard.The first longwall panel was at a depth of approximately 700-730 m below the surface,while the second one was at a depth of approximately 720-760 m.The ground level within the minefield is approximately 250 m above the sea level.Stress level resulting only from the depth of coal seam no.405/2 deposition equalled theoretically,for the first longwall panel approximately 17.50-18.25 MPa,and for the second longwall panel approximately 18.00-19.00 MPa.The first longwall panel was 235.6-237.3 m wide and approximately 415 m long,while the second one was 157.3-160.6 m wide and approximately 588 m long.The face height of the first longwall equalled 2.40-2.89 m,while of the second one it was 2.41-2.81 m.The coal seam no.405/2 had not been mined in this part of the deposit before.The mining of coal seam no.405/2 north of the first longwall panel was not carried out.The second longwall panel was planned to be a greater length along the gob of the first longwall.The gob of the second longwall merged with the gob of the first longwall,therefore an increase unsupported roof surface took place.The second longwall panel was separated from gob of the first longwall only by a rib of coal,approximately 5 m wide.At the beginning of the second longwall panel,an edge of coal seam no.401 was present (Fig.1).This coal seam is deposited approximately 167-187 m above coal seam no.405/2 and was partly mined around 46 years earlier.The edge of coal seam no.401 had an irregular shape,but generally coal seam no.401 was mined over the western part of the second longwall panel in coal seam no.405/2,while it was left unmined over the eastern part.Above the beginning of both longwall panels in coal seam no.405/2,a rib of coal from seam no.358/1 was present.This remnant is about 20-m wide,and it was abandoned several dozen years earlier before the excavation of coal seam no.405/2.The thickness of coal seam no.358/1 varies from 1.8 to 2.4 m.The distance between coal seams nos.358/1 and 405/2 equals approximately 305-315 m.Coal seam no.358/1 was extracted over the majority of the area of both longwall panels in coal seam no.405/2.Taking into account the distance between coal seams nos.358/1 and 405/2 and the time elapsed from the extraction of coal seam no.358/1,the destress effect during the longwall mining of coal seam no.405/2 was negligible.Moreover,in the middle of the second longwall panel an unfilled inclined drift was present,and it was situated diagonally to the approaching longwall face.Additionally,in the neighbourhood of the crossing of the aforementioned inclined drift and tailgate of the second longwall,a remaining part of the unfilled maingate of the first longwall was still present.In this area excessive coal bed cutting occurred,so the yielding arch support in these excavations was reinforced by props.The excessive coal bed cutting is assumed as at least three galleries and the distance between each of them does not exceed 20 m [10].The end of the second longwall panel was again unaffected by mining factors.Longwall mining of coal seam no.405/2 ended near the border of the established protecting pillar for drifts at the level of 642 m,located to the east.Within selected longwall panels splitting of coal seam no.405/2 was present.Generally,in the western part of both longwall panels,the upper and lower layers of coal seam no.405/2 were split into two individual coal seams,separated by shale which was locally interbedded by thin coal layers.Residual stresses usually exist close to such geological disturbances.Any other disturbances,e.g.faults,did not occur within the selected longwall panels.

Fig.1.Map of the upper layer of coal seam no.405/2 with the selected longwall panels.

The thickness of the upper layer of coal seam 405/2 varied from 2.1 to 3.0 m.The total thickness of coal seam no.405/2(upper and lower layers together) equals,according to the closest borehole,7.9 m.The seam dip ranged from 4° to 14° and the dip direction was S or SW.According to Polish law,this coal seam is classified as having the highest (2nd) degree of rockburst hazard.The depth of the deposition and thickness of coal seam no.405/2,and its splitting into separate layers were the main geological factors affecting the rockburst hazard.It should be noticed that these factors were present both within the first and second longwall panel,and they were comparable.In the direct roof of coal seam no.405/2 the following rocks are deposited:shale (3.7 m),sandy shale(2.9 m),shale (4.4 m),sandy shale (6.0 m),and sandstone(1.2 m).In the area of the selected longwall panels,thick layers of sandstone are not deposited in the direct roof of coal seam no.405/2.Layers of competent and rigid sandstones,with a total thickness of 22.5 m,and which are potentially capable of generating strong tremors,are deposited approximately 320 m over coal seam no.405/2.The direct floor of coal seam no.405/2 is composed of sandy shale (4.6 m),sandstone (1.5 m),sandy shale (1.8 m),coal shale (0.4 m),coal (0.6 m),and shale (3.4 m).In the area of the selected longwall panels,the floor of coal seam no.405/2 is composed of competent and weak rocks,which are deposited alternately.

Several methods were applied to determine the current state of rockburst hazard during longwall mining of coal seam no.405/2,i.e.the seismoacoustic method,the small-diameter drilling method,the seismic method (e.g.seismic tomography),and the mining seismology method.In the last of the methods the hypocentres and energy of mine tremors are determined.High seismic activity and occurrence of strong tremors during underground works testify about the state of the rockburst hazard in excavations.The high seismic activity zones correlate with the presence of unfavourable factors.The mining seismology method was realized via seismic monitoring.

2.2.Seismic monitoring and observed seismic activity

The selected longwall panels in coal seam no.405/2 were monitored by the mine seismic network.Both vertical-component seismometers and geophone probes,installed on bolts were located in underground openings at a depth of between 640 and 1050 m below ground level.The mine seismic network consisted of 13 seismic stations and enabled the monitoring of the seismic activity during the longwall mining of coal seam no.405/2 (Fig.2).The locations of some sensors were changed in such a long period of excavation time but they were moved only to a minor extent.Most of the seismic sensors were located to the south from the longwall panels in coal seam no.405/2(Fig.2).Hypocentres of mine tremors were located using the P-wave first arrivals method.Because of seismic sensor distribution the hypocentres location error decreased towards the south.The error of the hypocentres location in the area of the selected longwalls ranged between approximately 30 and 65 m (average of 55.6 m).The seismic energy E of the tremors induced during the mining of coal seam no.405/2 was determined using the method of the numerical integration of seismograms.The sampling rate equalled 500 Hz.On each of the seismograms the start and end markers were picked,and between them the square of amplitude in each sample was calculated.The squares of amplitude were next summed up.For further calculations of the seismic energy,the density of the rock mass(2600 kg/m3),the quality factor (30) representing the attenuation of the rock mass,and the calibration factor of the seismometer/-geophone probe,the hypocentre-sensor distance,and also the seismic wave velocity (3800-4100 m/s) were taken into account.The seismic energy was calculated separately for each seismic sensor,which registered a mine tremor.These energies were next arithmetically averaged providing the seismic energy E of each tremor[17].These energies were also converted to local magnitude MLwhich was calculated according to the formula logE=1.8+1.9MLgiven by [18].The energy of strong tremors was additionally verified with the calculations of the Upper Silesian Regional Seismological Network of the Central Mining Institute in Katowice,Poland,established in 1974 [19].This is an overarching network,relative to the local seismic networks operating separately in hard coal mines.

During the mining of the first longwall panel in coal seam no.405/2 the seismicity was rather low (Fig.2).Total 164 mine tremors were recorded:105 with energy of 102J (0.11 ≤ML<0.63),54 with energy of 103J(0.63 ≤ML<1.16),and 5 of medium energy,i.e.with energy of 104J(1.16 ≤ML<1.68).Total 4 tremors(3 with energy of 104J,i.e.2 × 104,3 × 104,and 4 × 104J,and 1 with energy of 103J,i.e.7×103J)were provoked by the long-hole destress blasting of roof rocks,performed from the longwall gates.Most of the mine tremors occurred in the part of the coal bed where the upper and lower layers of coal seam no.405/2 joined together.In Fig.2,the epicentres of mine tremors were marked as circles,whose size corresponds to the order of seismic energy.Green circles indicate mine tremors which occurred during the mining of the first longwall panel,and the red circles indicate mine tremors which occurred during mining of the second longwall panel.

Seismic activity was definitely higher during the mining of the second longwall panel in coal seam no.405/2 (Fig.2),and almost ten times more mine tremors were recorded.Total 1630 mine tremors occurred:1180 with energy of 102J (0.11 ≤ML<0.63),372 with energy of 103J (0.63 ≤ML<1.16),76 with energy of 104J(1.16 ≤ML<1.68),and 2 strong tremors,i.e.one with energy of 4 × 105J (ML=2.00) and one with energy of 2 × 106J(ML=2.37).One tremor with energy of 2 × 104J (ML=1.32) was provoked by the long-hole destress blasting of roof rocks.Ten blasts were performed to force a roof falling behind longwall face.Most of the provoked tremors had energy of 102J.One blasting performed to force the roof falling was especially effective,and provoked a tremor with energy of 4 × 104J (ML=1.48).As mentioned previously,mining of the second longwall panel began in January 2019,but only from around February 20th did the seismic activity started to increase.In this month,the start-up period of the second longwall ended,and additionally the gob of this longwall started to merge with the gob of the first longwall.In March and April 2019 a series of mine tremors with energy 104J occurred,e.g.March 26 (5 × 104and 4 × 104J),March 28 (2 × 104J),April 1 (2 × 104J),April 4 (2 × 104J),April 5 (4 × 104and 2 × 104J),and April 6(2×104and 2×104J).In April 2019,a total of 31 tremors with energy of 104J occurred,and the strongest of them had energy of 8×104J.The total released energy by these tremors with energy of 104J alone equalled 1×106J.In April 2019 the longwall face was under the edge of coal seam no.401,and they were quasiparallel to each other in some area.At the end of April 2019,the longwall face was already in the part of the rock mass where coal seam no.401 was not excavated,and out of the influence of the edge of this coal seam.At this time the longwall face started to cross the unfilled inclined drift,situated diagonally to it.However,a triangle-shaped part of the mined coal seam no.405/2 between the longwall face,tailgate,and inclined drift was systematically excavated.In the parts of the coal seam,which could be considered as pillars,high stress level is very common.The situation was additionally complicated due to the previously mentioned excessive coal bed cutting to the north of the tailgate.In May 2019,there was initially no significant increase of seismic activity.A total of 20 tremors with seismic energy 104J occurred in May,of which 5 in the first half and 15 in the second.On the 3rd of June the strongest tremor during the mining of the second longwall panel occurred,i.e.2 × 106J (ML=2.37).As a result of the dynamic impact of the tremor a dozen or so props in underground excavations close to its hypocentre were broken.After that,only 2 mine tremors with energy of 104J occurred in June.In July 2019 the longwall face finally crossed the unfilled inclined drift.No significant increase of seismic activity was observed.The monthly longwall face advances in June and July were,respectively,approximately 3 and 2 times lower than those in March,April,and May.In August 2019 high longwall face advance resumed.An increase in unsupported roof surface resulted in the increase of seismic activity.Around mid-August a series of medium energy tremors took place,i.e.August 12(2×104J),August 13(7×104J),August 16 (2 × 104J),and August 20 (1 × 104J).On the 17th August a second strong tremor with energy of 4 × 105J(ML=2.00)occurred.At this time the surface of the combined gobs in both longwall panels was large and longwall face advance was at its highest.In September 2019,the last month of the second longwall panel excavation,only 6 tremors with energy of 104J occurred,maximally with energy of 5×104J(ML=1.53).The longwall face advance was approximately two times lower at this time.

Fig.2.Configuration of seismic sensors (left) and total seismic activity during the mining of coal seam no.405/2’s longwall panels (right).

The described seismicity was analysed using mining seismology methods in order to correlate it with the mining factors present during the excavation of selected longwall panels in the upper layer of coal seam no.405/2.

3.Methods and results

A wide range of tools were applied to describe the seismicity during the mining of the selected two longwall panels in coal seam no.405/2.The seismic activities of both longwalls were compared with each other.It was decided to use the frequency-energy and frequency-magnitude distributions,the 2D distribution of released seismic energy,the relation between released seismic energy and volume of mined coal,the BSR,and the distribution of the b coefficient of the GR relation,to visualize the development of seismic activity during mining of coal seam no.405/2.Because of the usage of different methods and parameters,it was decided to describe them separately and show corresponding results immediately after their description.

3.1.Frequency-energy and frequency-magnitude distributions and 2D distribution of released seismic energy

The disproportion of the seismic activity occurring during the mining of the studied longwall panels can be clearly seen on the frequency-energy distribution (Fig.3a).During the mining of the second longwall almost 10 times more tremors occurred than during the mining of the first panel.Apart from the increase in the number of the weak (i.e.with energy of 102and 103J) and medium-energy mine tremors (i.e.with energy of 104J),it should be noted that during the mining of the second longwall panel 2 strong tremors occurred,i.e.2 × 106(ML=2.37) and 4 × 105J(ML=2.00).However,there were no large geological disturbances(e.g.large faults) or thick layers of sandstones at a short vertical distance,so the occurrence of these strong tremors should rather be correlated with the destruction of the coal seam and/or its surroundings.On the frequency-magnitude distribution (Fig.3b) it can be clearly seen that in the case of both longwall panels,the maximum number of mine tremors is in the magnitude range of 0.4-0.6.

The 2D distributions of the released seismic energy within the studied longwall panels were also plotted and are shown in Fig.4.In both cases,the starting coordinates were the same and the areas were divided into cells of equal dimension,i.e.50 m×50 m.The seismic energy of all tremors located inside each cell was added up.The isolines’ connecting points with identical seismic energy values were generated using the kriging method and the logarithmic scale was adopted.

During the mining of the first longwall panel the seismic energy was released mainly in the area of the maingate(the southern part of the first longwall panel),where the upper and lower layers of coal seam no.405/2 joined together (Fig.4a).When analyzing the 2D distribution,it can be concluded that the total released seismic energy within the first longwall panel did not exceed 7×104J.In the majority of the area of the first longwall panel the total released energy was in the order of 103J.On the contrary,in majority of the area of the second longwall panel it was one order higher,i.e.104J(Fig.4b).Most of the seismic energy was released in three areas.The first of them was the largest,and it was located in the vicinity of the edge of coal seam no.401 (mostly from the side of unmined coal seam no.401).The second area was located in the triangle-shaped part of mined coal seam no.405/2 between the longwall face,tailgate and inclined drift,and where excessive coal bed cutting was performed.In this area,in the northern part of the longwall panel,the majority of the seismic energy was released,i.e.in the order of 106J.The third area was located in the vicinity of the maingate,to the south-west of the studied second longwall panel.The surface of the merged gob was large.The total released seismic energy in the first and the third areas was in the order of 105J.

Fig.3.Frequency-energy distribution and frequency-magnitude distribution of mine tremors which occurred during the mining of the upper layer of coal seam no.405/2.

Fig.4.2D distributions of released seismic energy during mining of the first and second longwall panel in the upper layer of coal seam no.405/2.

3.2.Seismic energy vs.volume of excavated coal

Tremors occurring in underground mines are an example of induced seismic activity,which is a result of rock deformations caused by excavation of some volume of rocks.According to theoretical results proposed by [20],a model,where the total released seismic moment results from ground deformation associated with a change in volume,was introduced by [21].By making certain assumptions,this relationship can be modified to a form representing the statistical relationship between the sum of seismic energy E and the excavated volume of rocks ΔV.Presented by [22] the energy-volume relation is expressed as a simple power law.

where B is a parameter characterizing the state of the rock mass.

For each of the studied longwall panels in coal seam no.405/2,a function representing the relationship between the cumulated energy and cumulated volume of excavated coal has been determined.In the case of the first longwall panel,the function obtained shows proper correlation with empirical data (Fig.5a).The fitted function is characteristically concave.Without any other factors,except the split of coal seam no.405/2,where residual stresses were expected,the released seismic energy typically depends on the volume of excavated coal.Fitted and real data differ from each other on average by approximately 6%,and maximally by approximately 18%.A power function was also fitted to the data from the second longwall panel (the solid line in Fig.5b),but the obtained function is convex.During the majority of the second longwall panel mining,tremors were induced not only by the deformation of intact rocks but they were also a result of stress release,accumulated in the rock mass due to the presence of mining factors (the edge of coal seam no.401,the increasing of unsupported roof surface,excessive bed cutting,etc.).Fitted and real data differ from each other on average by approximately 40%.A clear difference between empirical data and model-based estimates is particularly seen for the two points representing the highest volume of excavated coal,i.e.at the end of the second longwall panel where the influence of mining factors was negligible.The percentage difference between fitted and real data equals,in these cases,approximately 60% and 90%.Therefore,a third-order polynomial function was fitted to the empirical data from the second longwall panel(the dashed line in Fig.5b).It has a comparable coefficient of determination to the fitted power function,and it is reflected in a better way the two different states,i.e.the influence of mining factors through most of the longwall panel and the lack of influence at the end of the longwall panel.The difference between the polynomial model estimates and observations equals,for the two points representing the highest volume of excavated coal,approximately 3% and 1%.

Fig.5.Relationship between the released seismic energy and the volume of excavated coal seam no.405/2 in the first and second longwall panel.

3.3.Benioff strain release (BSR)

The strain released by natural earthquakes was studied by[23].It was concluded that this release was remarkably constant over the analyzed time period,and earthquakes are related to a world-wide stress system [23].The results of many investigations e.g.[23-25],showed that strain release characteristics vary for different regions.The theory of earthquake mechanism,including the phenomenon of subcritical crack growth,was subsequently developed by [26].The modified time-to-failure method for intermediate-term earthquake prediction was proposed by [27].The cumulative BSR,estimated from the square root of energy released by each smaller intermediate event,was taken into consideration.An increase of the cumulative Benioff strain as an inverse power-law,i.e.accelerated release,can be treated as a precursory phenomenon before large earthquakes [28].It can be considered to be a signal that the Earth’s crust is approaching its critical state.The application of the seismic energy release to the induced seismicity was proposed by [29].An attempt to apply the cumulative BSR models in hard coal mines was also made,e.g.[15].These models enable the estimation of the behavior of the stress regime in the rock mass during the mining of the longwall panels[15].A mined longwall panel can be treated as a closed system,and the occurring rate and size of seismic event release is governed by the same physical process [15].It can be compared with the behavior of materials in the terminal stages of failure,investigated by[30].In order to analyze the characteristics of seismic energy release during the mining of the first and second longwall panel in coal seam no.405/2,the Benioff strain was calculated,and presented as separate cumulative plots (Fig.6).In the case of the second longwall panel,the occurrence of a series of medium energy mine tremors and two strong tremors was also marked(Fig.6b).Additionally,to illustrate the energy release rate,in the 14-day moving time window,with a 1-day step,a line was fitted to the calculated BSR with the use of the least square method.The narrow width of the time window was deliberately set to be sufficiently sensitive to local variable conditions and changing in the seismic activity correlated with them.The distributions of coefficient aBSR,representing the slope of fitted lines,are also shown in Fig.6,below the plots of cumulative Benioff strain corresponding to them.The greater the value of the coefficient aBSR,the greater the slope,i.e.the greater the energy release rate.On the plot of the cumulative Benioff strain,during mining of the first longwall panel,changes occur smoothly,without any sudden or drastic steps (Fig.6).The seismic energy was released systematically.In the case of the first longwall panel,the cumulative Benioff strain(Fig.6a) showed a similar shape to the relationship between the released seismic energy and the volume of excavated coal seam no.405/2 (Fig.5a).The seismic activity was correlated with the destruction process of the coal seam and the area in its direct vicinity because of mining operations.Some increases in the BSR slope inclination,interpreted as an increase of the ability of rock mass to release seismic energy,were observed from the second half of November 2017.In this time the longwall face was approaching the split of coal seam no.405/2,and residual stress was released independently or through destress blasting.From January 2018,on the plot of the cumulative Benioff strain,systematic flattening is observed.A similar situation can also be clearly seen on the distribution of coefficient aBSR.The highest values of coefficient aBSR(i.e.approximately 90) occur at the end of November 2017 and in mid-December 2017,when the longwall face was in the area of the split of coal seam no.405/2,situated quasi-parallel to the face.In the rest of time the value of this coefficient systematically decreased.In the last five months of the mining of the first longwall panel this coefficient did not exceed 30 (Fig.6a).

In case of the second longwall panel the maximal Benioff strain is almost 10 times higher in comparison with the first longwall panel (Fig.6b).On the plot of the cumulative Benioff strain three areas of slope decreases are clearly visible,i.e.before the series of medium energy mine tremors and before each of strong tremors.The decreases of the BSR slopes were assumed to be a decrease in the ability of rock mass to release seismic energy.A decrease in energy release,assuming that the process is stationary,resulted in the accumulation of strain energy.Within each period of low slope values,an acceleration release is clearly observed,i.e.in mid-March 2019,in mid-May 2019,and in late July and early August 2019.The cumulative Benioff strain in these periods is convex.The first period is correlated with the time when the longwall mining of coal seam no.405/2 was conducted increasingly under unmined coal seam no.401,and while approaching the longwall face to the edge of coal seam no.401,situated quasi-parallel to the face.The second period is associated with the time when the triangle-shaped part of mined coal seam no.405/2 between the longwall face,tailgate,and inclined drift was systematically excavated and it was getting smaller,therefore the stress level inside was increasing.The third period is correlated with the time when the surface of the combined gob in both longwall panels was large and longwall face advance was at its highest.Both before a series of medium energy tremors and against strong tremors,on the plot of the cumulative Benioff strain there are inflection points.They occur about 2 weeks before the above-mentioned tremors.To the right of the inflection points,the plot of the cumulative Benioff strain became convex(see Fig.6b).In the period immediately preceding the tremors,the release of seismic energy from the rock mass was accelerated.Stress changes affect the space-time pattern of seismicity following strong tremors.It has been found that a simple power-law time-to-failure equation derived from damage mechanics could be used to develop the seismicity model [31].In our case,the power increase in the released seismic energy was associated with changes in the stress level in the rock mass caused by exploitation and mining factors.Finally,when critical stress level in the rock mass was exceeded,it led to energy release through a series of medium energy or strong mine tremors.Analyzing the distribution of coefficient aBSR(the BSR slope),calculated for the second longwall panel,three maxima can be clearly distinguished (Fig.6b,bottom),i.e.at the beginning of April 2019 (approximately 735),at the beginning of June 2019 (approximately 600),and at the end around the first week of August 2019(approximately 416).The first maximum occurred approximately 6 days after the occurrence of the first medium energy mine tremor,belonging to the distinguished series.During this series there were not any strong tremors,but the energy was released in a gentler way.The coefficient aBSRsystematically decreases in the whole of April 2019 and at the beginning of May 2019,to the value of approximately 200.Around mid-May 2019 the coefficient aBSRstarted to increase.About 3 days before it reached the second maximum,the strongest tremor,i.e.2×106J(ML=2.37)occurred.The coefficient aBSRequalled approximately 539 that day.Next,the coefficient aBSRdecreased until the beginning of July 2019,to the value of approximately 13.At the beginning of August 2019,the coefficient aBSRstarted to rapidly increase,and reached a third maximum on the 10th August.One week later a second strong tremor occurred,i.e.4×105J(ML=2.00).The coefficient aBSRequalled approximately 331 on that day.

Fig.6.Benioff strain release and distribution of factor aBSR,representing the slope of the fitted lines in the moving 14-day time window during the excavation of the first and second longwall panel in coal seam no.405/2.

3.4.GR b coefficient distribution

Gutenberg-Richter (GR) relation is the most common model used to describe a dependence between the magnitude of seismic events and their number N [32].This relation has been implemented for everything from global earthquake seismology to mining seismology.Because of the fact that mine tremors are commonly described by the seismic energy E (not magnitude),the GR relation,therefore,takes the following form.

where b is the proportion between high and low energy tremors,which differs for different regions;and a the level of seismic activity in the selected area.The coefficient b is usually called the b-value and may also vary over time[12].It reflects the change of the stress level around the average value [13].Low b-value indicates that strong mine tremors dominate the seismic catalogue.This means that high stress level is present in the rock mass.High values of the b-value indicate the domination of weak tremors,and a lower stress level in the rock mass.For the catalogue of tremors containing the seismic energies the b-value can be calculated as follows[33].

where NTis the number of the consecutive tremors in a determined time interval T;i=1,2,...,NT;Eithe seismic energy of the i-th tremor;and E0the certain minimum energy.It is assumed that from this energy the mine tremors are distributed according to the GR relation.It is usually assumed that the certain minimum energy E0corresponds to the energy with the largest frequency of seismic events in the low-energy range.In the frequency-magnitude distribution,presented in Fig.3b,it has been shown that the maximum number of mine tremors for both longwall panels is in the magnitude range of 0.4-0.6.It was assumed that from the magnitude equalled 0.6,i.e.from the seismic energy approximately 8 × 102J,the GR relation is valid.During the mining of the first longwall panel the seismic activity was low,i.e.only 164 mine tremors occurred.For this reason,over short time intervals,an extremely low frequency of events was present.It was decided to spread the time window to 28 days,to ensure it contained the proper number of mine tremors.Even after such arrangements,there were cases where the number of tremors in the window was insignificant.The b-value was calculated only when the number of mine tremors was equal or higher than 3 in the moving time window,with a 1-day step.In order to provide a comparison,the calculations for the second longwall panel were made with exactly the same assumptions,although in this case the time window was able to be narrower.The b-value uncertainty was calculated with some approximation according to Eq.(4),given by [14].

where σ(b)is the uncertainty of b-value.Distributions of GR b coefficient,its uncertainty σ(b),and the number of tremors NTin the moving 28-day window during the mining of both longwall panels in coal seam no.405/2 are shown in Fig.7.

Fig.7.Distributions of GR b coefficient,its uncertainty σ(b),and the number of tremors NT in the moving 28-day window during the mining of the first and second longwall panel in coal seam no.405/2.

At the beginning of the mining of the first longwall panel,the bvalue was low,and equalled approximately 0.4-0.5 (Fig.7a).In mid-November 2017 it started to increase,and over the next three months it remained above 1.In late February and early March 2018 the b-value decreased to approximately 0.75,and in mid-March 2018 it started to increase once more.The maximal value of the GR b coefficient was reached at the end of March 2018 and it equalled approximately 2.8.After that it started to decrease once more,to a value below 1.Whereas during most of the mining of the second longwall panel the b-value was below 1 (Fig.7b).During the series of medium energy mine tremors,it systematically decreased reaching its minimal value of approximately 0.5.After this point the b-value increased and it stayed at the level of 0.7-0.8.On 3rd June 2019,when the strongest tremor occurred,i.e.2 × 106J,the b-value equalled approximately 0.75.At the end of June 2019 and in July 2019 the b-value fluctuated around 1 or higher.It reached its maximum value of approximately 1.8,which was correlated with the stoppage of mining due to combustion hazard and,therefore,seismicity decreases.In August 2019 the b-value was mostly below 1 and when the second strong tremor occurred(4×105J)on 17th August,it equalled 0.98.In the last two months of the mining of the second longwall panel the b-value equalled,on average,approximately 0.9.The statistical parameters of distributions shown in Fig.7 have been collected in Table 1.

The average value of GR b coefficient for the second longwall panel is lower than for the first longwall panel by approximately 0.2.With a high level of certainty this difference would be greater if the mining of the second longwall panel had not been stopped.The uncertainty σ(b) in the case of the second longwall is much lower in comparison with the first longwall panel which is caused by the use of a much larger sized data set (Table 1).On average approximately 80 mine tremors took place in the time window in the case of the second longwall panel in comparison to 13 tremors in the case of the first longwall panel (Table 1).Moreover,the numerous relatively-strong seismic events in the latter resulted in the decrease of the b-value.

Table 1 Statistical parameters of GR b coefficient,its uncertainty σ(b),and the number of tremors NT in the 28-day window calculated for the first and second longwall panel.

4.Discussion and conclusions

Extraction of two longwall panels placed side by side in coal seam no.405/2,but with different mining conditions,gave a unique opportunity to test how these conditions may influence seismic activity.The first longwall panel was planned in conditions of intact rock mass.During the mining of the second longwall panel the following mining factors were present:the edge of coal seam no.401,the excavation of the pillar-like part of coal seam no.405/2 (separated from the coal body by the longwall face and two other excavations),excessive bed cutting,and the merging of the gob of the first and second longwall.Almost ten times more mine tremors were recorded during the mining of the second longwall panel,with the same certain minimum energy,which caused a decrease in the b-value.Moreover,strong tremors occurred,which did not happen during the mining of the first longwall panel.A wide range of methods and parameters were applied to characterize the seismicity during the analysed longwall mining.

(1) The difference between the seismic activities of both longwall panels is clearly seen in the frequency-energy,frequency-magnitude,and 2D seismic energy distributions performed.The total released seismic energy during the mining of the first longwall panel equalled 4.09 × 105J,while during the mining of the second longwall panel it equalled 6.89 × 106J,and therefore it was almost 17 times higher.

(2) During mining of the first longwall panel the energy was released adequately to the volume of the excavated coal,typically to the power law model.The energy-volume relation using a power law model was also fitted to the data from the second longwall.For the points under the influence of mining factors this model is well fitted,but it fits considerably worse to the points with no impact.Therefore,it was decided to apply the third-order polynomial function to embrace the two-state conditions.Under variable stress conditions and with different seismicity,not only simple power law model but also other models can be applied to determine the energy-volume relation.

(3) In the case of the first longwall panel,the relationship between released seismic energy and the volume of excavated coal seam no.405/2 and cumulative BSR are similar.This similarity is not visible in the case of the second longwall panel.Before the series of medium energy mine tremors and each of the strong tremors,a deflation of the BSR is observed,thus the energy was accumulated in the rock mass.Within each deflation period an acceleration of BSR can be noticed,which indicates the fact that the rock mass is approaching its critical state.

(4) To determine the energy release rate,a solution consisting of line fitting to the BSR with the use of the least square method and in the moving time window was put forward.In the case of the first longwall panel the coefficient aBSR,representing the slope of the fitted lines,equalled a maximum of 90.During the mining of the second longwall panel,where the seismicity was much higher,the coefficient aBSRwas significantly higher than 100.It equalled a few hundreds when the energy was released from the rock mass by the series of medium energy mine tremors and strong tremors (maximally 735).This parameter seems to be promising for rockburst hazard assessment in underground excavations.

(5) A standard using the GR b coefficient was also calculated for both longwalls,and in the case of the second longwall panel the average value of this coefficient was lower by approximately 0.2,which indicates the higher stress level.Only mining factors could have influenced the increase in the stress level in the rock mass.

(6) All mentioned factors influenced the occurrence of seismic activity.However,the occurrence of strong tremors close to excavations is particularly dangerous.For this reason,the excavation of the pillar-like part of thick coal seam,in addition,in the vicinity of excessive bed cutting,appears the most unfavourable.

The analysis presented in the article confirmed the influence of mining factors on seismic activity during the excavation of coal seam no.405/2.They may prove to be a useful approach in designing subsequent mining works under unfavourable mining conditions.

Acknowledgement

The authors would like to thank the Polish Mining Group that allowed us to publish the mining data and discuss the results.


登录APP查看全文