APP下载

老年体育伤害事故案件司法诉讼现状、特征及启示

2020-12-17刘源璞褚敏明董志周常卓时维金

体育学刊 2020年6期
关键词:体育

刘源璞 褚敏明 董志周 常卓 时维金

摘      要:以中国裁判文书网为数据来源,依据《人民法院民事裁判文书制作规范》判决文书构成要素,对所收录的54份老年体育伤害事故民事判决文书的首部、事实、理由、裁判依据、裁判主文等展开分析。研究发现诉讼过程中,老年体育伤害事故案件多为侵权责任纠纷案件;老年人体育活动场地需对老年人履行维护公共安全、管理、预见告诫、通知救助等具体职责;自冒風险可成为老年体育伤害事故案件的有效抗辩;老年体育伤害事故责任划分多采用过错责任原则、无过错责任原则以及公平责任原则。这些发现对老年体育伤害事故民事判决行动者具有重要启示作用,体现为老年体育参与者应尽到相应的注意义务,促进代理律师对老年体育伤害事故案件的参与,场地管理者与活动组织者应在“人”和“物”两方面尽到安全保障义务等。

关  键  词:体育法;老年体育;伤害事故;司法诉讼;民事判决文书

中图分类号:G80-05    文献标志码:A    文章编号:1006-7116(2020)06-0039-07

The situation, characteristics and enlightenment of judicial litigation in

sports injury accidents for the elderly

——An empirical study based on 54 civil judgment documents

LIU Yuan-pu1,CHU Min-ming1,DONG Zhi-zhou2,CHANG Zhuo1,SHI Wei-jin1

(1.School of Physical Education,Shanghai Normal University,Shanghai 200234,China;

2.Department of Physical Education,Xingtai Polytechnic College,Xingta 054000,China)

Abstract: With China judgments online as the data source, based on Specification of the Making of Civil Judicial Documents endorsed by the Peoples Courts, the paper aims to conduct an empirical analysis of the 54 civil judgment documents of the injury accidents in physical activities for the elderly, studying the characteristics of the body content, including the header, facts, arguments, referee bases, and main judgement body. The results show that in the course of litigation, the elderly sports injury accidents are mostly tort liability disputes; physical activity venues need to perform specific duties such as maintaining public safety, improving management, and offering preventive warnings and notifications for assistance. In addition, their assumption of risk may be the reason for venues to shun the responsibility, and the liability division mostly follows the principle of fault liability, non-fault liability and fair liability for the elderly with injury accidents. These results have significant implications for civil adjudicators in addressing relevant cases. The implications are as follows: the elderly should work out exercises with attention; more lawyers should be encouraged to participate in relevant cases; venue managers and event organizers should fulfill their due obligations for both the elderly and sports facilities on the safety front.

Key words: sports law;elderly physical activity;injury accidents;judicial litigation;civil judgment documents

21世纪的中国将是不可逆转的老龄社会[1],老年人健康水平的降低会加重家庭与社会在经济和心理上的负担,对国家的整体发展产生不利影响。老年体育伤害事故的妥善解决不仅关系到社会和谐与稳定,更关系到全民健身目标的实现与健康中国的全面建设。鉴于此,本研究拟通过实证研究法和案例分析法,对中国裁判文书网所收录的老年体育伤害事故案件判决文书进行研究,以探究我国老年体育伤害事故案件司法诉讼现状与特征,并提出相应的启示与建议,为进一步提高老年体育伤害事故司法审判质量,维护和促进我国老年体育事业的开展提供参考。……

登录APP查看全文

猜你喜欢

体育
“体育”一词概念流变与当代“体育旧体诗词”的生成
别让体育和美育沦为一纸空文
提倡体育100分 也需未雨绸缪
我为体育狂
论清末体育热
2016体育年
我们的“体育梦”
休闲体育教学中“休闲”的诠释与演绎
——评《休闲体育》
高考需要包括体育吗?
体育教学如何更好地使用讲解示范