APP下载

我国图书情报领域个人学术评价指标的应用情况研究

2020-12-17刘中兴杨建林

现代情报 2020年12期

刘中兴 杨建林

收稿日期:2020-06-01

基金项目:国家社会科学基金重点项目 “面向国家发展与安全决策的情报服务创新研究”(项目编号:NO.18ATQ003)。

作者简介:刘中兴(1996-),男,硕士研究生,研究方向:数据挖掘。

通讯作者:杨建林(1970-),男,教授,博士,博士生导师,研究方向:数据挖掘,信息检索,学术评价。

摘  要:[目的/意义]考察我国图书情报领域内个人学术评价指标的应用情况,为后续的个人学术评价指标研究提供参考,推动构建更加科学、合理的个人学术评价指标体系。[方法/过程]收集9种CSSCI图书情报学代表期刊2014—2018年有关个人学术评价指标的文献数据,运用内容分析法,从使用范围、使用环境、使用动机、使用情感4个方面考察指标应用情况。[结果/结论]分析显示,我国图书情报领域个人学术评价指标使用处于主要研究h类指数的指标发展阶段,较多使用传统简便的文献计量指标,如h指数、发文量与被引频次;个人学术综合评价的多元指标融合途径研究较少,仍有必要继续加强包括多指标融合比较、进一步完善个人学术评价指标体系在内的学术评价研究。

关键词:个人学术评价指标;使用评估;学术评价;内容分析法

DOI:10.3969/j.issn.1008-0821.2020.12.014

〔中图分类号〕G250.252  〔文献标识码〕A  〔文章编号〕1008-0821(2020)12-0140-10

Research on The Use of Individual Academic Evaluation

Index in Library and Information Field in China

Liu Zhongxing1,2  Yang Jianli1,2*

(1.School of Information management,Nanjing University,Nanjing 210023,China;

2.Jiangsu Key Laboratory of Data Engineering and Knowledge Service,Nanjing 210023,China)

Abstract:[Purpose/Significance]To investigate the use of individual academic evaluation indicators in the field of picture situation in China,to provide reference for academic evaluation researchers,and to promote the improvement of individual academic evaluation system.[Methods/Process]Literature data on individual academic evaluation indexes of 9 CSSCI representative journals from 2014 to 2018 were collected,and content analysis method was used to investigate the application of indexes from four aspects:use scope,use environment,use motivation and use emotion.[Results/Conclusions]The analysis showed that the personal academic evaluation indicators in the field of picture and situation in China were in the development stage of the indicators mainly studied in category h index,while the traditional and simple bibliometric indicators,such as h index,publication volume and citation frequency,were mostly used.There are few studies on the integration of multiple indicators in individual academic comprehensive evaluation,so it is still necessary to continue to strengthen the research on academic evaluation,including the integration of multiple individual academic evaluation indicators and the further improvement of individual academic evaluation index system.

Key words:individual academic evaluation index;usage assessment;academic evaluation;content analysis

学术评价是指针对学术成果的学术贡献、学术创新、学术价值、学术影响以及社会影响、应用价值、经济效益等方面的评估[1]。学术评价指标是对学术评价对象某个或某些属性的概括,可以从质和量两方面為学术成就评价提供数据,如发文量、引文量等。……

登录APP查看全文