APP下载

Effects of nitrogen application rates and irrigation regimes on grain yield and water use efficiency of maize under alternate partial rootzone irrigation

2020-09-30QlDongliangHUTiantianSONGXue

Journal of Integrative Agriculture 2020年11期

Ql Dong-liang,HU Tian-tian,SONG Xue

1 Engineering Research Center of Ecology and Agricultural Use of Wetland,Ministry of Education,Yangtze University,Jingzhou 434025,P.R.China

2 Key Laboratory of Agricultural Soil and Water Engineering in Arid and Semiarid Areas of Ministry of Education,Northwest A&F University,Yangling 712100,P.R.China

Abstract Faced with the scarcity of water resources and irrational fertilizer use,it is critical to supply plants with water and fertilizer in a coordinated pattern to improve yield with high water use efficiency (WUE).One such method,alternate partial root-zone irrigation (APRI),has been practiced worldwide,but there is limited information on the performance of different irrigation regimes and nitrogen (N) rates under APRI.The objectives of this study were to investigate the effects of varying irrigation regimes and N rates on shoot growth,grain yield and WUE of maize (Zea mays L.) grown under APRI in the Hexi Corridor area of Northwest China in 2014 and 2015.The three N rates were 100,200 and 300 kg N ha-1,designated N1,N2 and N3,respectively.The three irrigation regimes of 45-50%,60-65% and 75-80% field capacity (FC) throughout the maize growing season,designated W1,W2 and W3,respectively,were applied in combination with each N rate.The results showed that W2 and W3 significantly increased the plant height,stem diameter,crop growth rate,chlorophyll SPAD value,net photosynthetic rate (Pn),biomass,grain yield,ears per ha,kernels per cob,1 000-kernel weight,harvest index,evapotranspiration and leaf area index (LAI) compared to W1 at each N rate.The N2 and N3 treatments increased those parameters compared to N1 in each irrigation treatment.Increasing the N rate from the N2 to N3 resulted in increased biomass and grain yield under W3 while it had no impact on those under the W1 and W2 treatments.The W3N3 and W2N2 and W2N3 treatments achieved the greatest and the second-greatest biomass and grain yield,respectively.Increasing the N rate significantly enhanced the maximum LAI (LAI at the silking stage) and Pn under W3,suggesting that the interaction of irrigation and fertilizer N management can effectively improve leaf growth and development,and consequently provide high biomass and grain yield of maize.The W2N2,W2N3 and W3N3 treatments attained the greatest WUE among all the treatments.Thus,either 60-65% FC coupled with 200-300 kg N ha-1 or 75-80% FC coupled with 300 kg N ha-1 is proposed as a better pattern of irrigation and nitrogen application with positive regulative effects on grain yield and WUE of maize under APRI in the Hexi Corridor area of Northwest China and other regions with similar environments.These results can provide a basis for indepth understanding of the mechanisms of grain yield and WUE to supply levels of water and nitrogen.

Keywords:deficit irrigation,nitrogen fertilization,leaf area index,net photosynthetic rate,harvest index,Zea mays

1.lntroduction

Nitrogen (N) and water are the two most essential resources for determining crop production.Drought and/or N deficit reduced plant height,leaf area index (LAI),shoot growth,root growth,grain yield and biomass of maize (Payeroet al.2006;Di Paolo and Rinaldi 2008;Liet al.2009,2020;Ranet al.2016,2017;Wang and Xing 2017;Qiet al.2020).Maize production was positively related to increasing N and water supplied,until the optimal rates were reached (Liu and Zhang 2007).However,the focus of farmers is always on increasing food production regardless of concerns over the excessive use of N and water.This not only produces a reduction in economic yield (Suiet al.2015) but also leads to a decline in total factor productivity and raises serious environmental issues (Juet al.2009;Shenet al.2018).Therefore,realizing high use efficiency of water and N fertilizer usage is becoming a research hotspot.

The responses of maize to rates of N fertilizer have been found to vary with water supply levels.Different rates of N fertilizer influenced biomass and grain yield of maize under well-water conditions while they had no impact on those under serve drought (Gheysariet al.2009;Liet al.2020).Moreover,the effect of irrigation regimes on growth of maize was closely related to supply levels of N fertilizer (Liet al.2009;Ranet al.2017).When soil N availability is low,N supply levels play a vital role in limiting grain yield and water stress has a minimal effect;otherwise,water supply levels determine the grain yield (Liu and Zhang 2007).Moreover,N fertilization influences the amount of water extracted by crops and subsequently,the water use efficiency (WUE).In one study,fertilization treatments extracted more water from the deeper layers of soil compared to the un-fertilized treatments (Lenkaet al.2009).N fertilization treatments resulted in a greater WUE of maize compared to farm manure or zero-N treatment (Hatiet al.2001;Liet al.2015).These findings indicate that coordinating supply levels of water and N is a useful approach to improve crop production and crop water productivity.

In alternate partial root-zone drying irrigation (APRI),the irrigation water is applied to different parts of the root system in an alternating fashion (Davieset al.2000).APRI could increase WUE compared to conventional irrigation(Liet al.2010) due to a significant reduction in the amount of irrigation water applied without compromising the maize grain yield (Kanget al.2000).Extensive research and practice have suggested that APRI plays a vital role in agricultural practice,especially in arid and semi-arid areas(Kanget al.2000;Duet al.2010,2015;Sepaskhah and Ahaadi 2010;Tanget al.2010).However,Kirdaet al.(2005)and Wakrimet al.(2005) found that with a same amount of irrigation water,APRI does not increase WUE compared to conventional deficit irrigation.The depressive water-saving effect might be partially due to the unscientific management of irrigation water under APRI (Sadras 2009).Moreover,APRI increased WUE of maize in a fertilized treatment while it had no impact on the WUE in an un-fertilized treatment(Huanget al.2004).In addition,management decisions concerning N application should help improve grain yield and the resource use efficiencies.Thus,an understanding of the interactive effects of N and water on grain yield and crop water productivity under APRI is vital for achieving consistent and economically attractive yields.

Grain yield is a function of ear number per unit area,kernel number per ear and kernel weight,which are influenced by soil moisture,temperature,nutrition,and light status (Berthelootet al.2008).LAI is an important agronomic parameter,which is used to reflect crop growth and predict crop yield (Giuntaet al.2008).Moreover,both yield formation and LAI are influenced by the management of irrigation water and N fertilizer.Reducing the amounts of irrigation water and N fertilizer significantly decreased kernel number and kernel weight of maize (Moseret al.2006;Ranet al.2016).Thus,coordinating supply levels of N fertilizer and irrigation water can be an effective approach for improving crop yield by regulating yield formation and LAI.

Considerable data have been obtained on crop growth and yield formation under APRI;but previous investigations mainly focused on the effect of water supply levels (Kanget al.2000) or N rates (Liet al.2010).Moreover,Liet al.(2007) and Wanget al.(2017) investigated the interactive effects of supply levels of water and N on maize growth under APRI in a pot culture;and found that high irrigation water level coupled with a moderate rate of N fertilizer can enhance crop growth.However,the yield formation and its relation with shoot growth,and the mechanism behind this,remain largely unknown.

The Hexi Corridor is one of the most important food production areas in China,and the crop production in this region depends heavily on irrigation due to infrequent precipitation (Kanget al.2004).Also,the average rate of N application has now increased to 360-400 kg N ha-1owing to the fertilization practices of farmers in intensive maize cropping systems in the Hexi Corridor area,which typically apply 180-200% more than the recommended N fertilizer rate based on the soil-test technology (Yang and Su 2009).Therefore,an optimized irrigation regime and N fertilization under APRI that balances crop water productivity,N use efficiency and maize production is crucial to optimize the economic benefits (Monteroet al.2012;Zouet al.2020).

The objectives of this study were to investigate the interactive effects of irrigation regimes (no,moderate or serve water stress) and N rates (high,moderate or low N supply levels) on crop growth rate (CGR),plant height,stem diameter,LAI,chlorophyll SPAD value,net photosynthetic rate,biomass accumulation,harvest index (HI),grain yield and yield components and WUE of maize under APRI.We hypothesized that coordinating supply levels of N and water could help improve crop growth and water utilization,and consequently provide high grain yield and WUE of maize under APRI.

2.Materials and methods

2.1.Experimental site

A field study was conducted at Wuwei Experimental Station for Efficient Use of Crop Water,Ministry of Agriculture and Rural Affairs,China (37°52´20´´N,102°50´50´´E,1 581 m a.s.l.) in 2014 and 2015.The site is in a typical continental temperate climate zone with mean annual precipitation of 164.4 mm and mean annual evapotranspiration (ET) of 2 000 mm.The groundwater level is consistently 40 m below the soil surface.The soil texture was a light sandy loam,with mean soil bulk density of 1.40 g cm-3and mean field capacity (FC) of 0.30 cm3cm-3for the 0-100 cm soil depths (Ranet al.2016).The average air temperature,precipitation,and sunshine hours during the maize growth seasons in 2014 and 2015 were measured at a weather station within the experimental site as shown in Table 1.In the top soil layer (0-40 cm),organic matter was 15.90 g kg-1,total N was 0.85 g kg-1,available N was 40.43 mg kg-1,total phosphorus was 0.93 g kg-1,available phosphorus was 6.22 mg kg-1,and available potassium was 236.24 mg kg-1.

2.2.Crop management

The standard technologies of ridge planting and furrow irrigation were used in the experiment.The establishment of furrows and ridges is described in detail by Qiet al.(2019).Briefly,furrows were 30 cm in depth and 20 cm in width at the bottom.Ridges were 20 and 35 cm in width at the top and bottom,respectively,and were built in a west-east direction.Triple superphosphate (46% P2O5) was used as the phosphorus source,and was applied at a rate of 60 kg P ha-1one day before the furrows were established.Grain maize of cultivar ‘Funong 588’ (ZeamaysL.),was sown at a density of 73 000 plants ha-1on 20 April 2014 and 16 April 2015,and the crops were harvested on 19 September 2014 and 20 September 2015.

2.3.Experimental design

The experimental factors consisted of the controlled irrigation limit and N rate.The controlled irrigation limits were 45-50%,60-65% and 75-80% FC,designated W1,W2and W3,respectively.The N rates were 100,200 and 300 kg N ha-1,designated N1,N2and N3,respectively.This yielded nine treatments,e.g.,W1N1,W1N2,W1N3,W2N1,W2N2,W2N3,W3N1,W3N2,and W3N3,which were arranged in a randomized block design with three replications.Each plot was 32 m2(4 m×8 m) in 2014 and 24 m2(4 m×6 m) in 2015.There were three blocks (one for each replication),and nine treatments (plots) were randomly arranged in each block.Each plot was comprised of seven ridges and eight furrows in the two years.The source of N was urea(46% N),which was applied to the center of the furrow at 5 cm depth.N fertilizer was applied in three splits as a basal application (40%),and top-dressing at the 12 collars (V12)(30%) and tasseling (VT) stages (30%),respectively.The corresponding dates were 9 April,12 July and 1 August in2014 and 15 April,11 July and 2 August in 2015.The maize growth stages were determined according to Ritchie and Hanway (1982).

Table 1 Precipitation,sunshine hours,and mean temperature during the growing season of maize in 2014 and 2015 at the experimental site

The lower limit of FC was used for the controlled irrigation.The eight furrows of each plot were divided into two groups:group A (furrows 1,3,5 and 7) and group B (furrows 2,4,6 and 8).The measuring tubes of 1.25 m used for soil moisture determination were placed in the bottom of the two adjacent furrows (furrows 4 and 5) in the center of each plot (Fig.1).The initial (sowing date) soil mass water contents in the 0-40 cm soil depths were 17.4 and 16.8%in 2014 and 2015,respectively,which could meet the water requirement of the germinating maize seeds.The first irrigation was applied to furrows 1,3,5 and 7 when the soil water content of furrow 4 reached the controlled lower limit,which corresponded to 13 and 12 days after the sowing of seeds in 2014 and 2015,respectively.Then,furrows 2,4,6 and 8 were irrigated to the FC when the soil water content of furrow 5 reached the controlled lower limit.In turn,the furrows 1,3,5,and 7 were irrigated again as mentioned before.As a result,all furrows were alternatively irrigated throughout the maize grown season.The irrigation amount in each irrigation event (mm) was calculated by the following equation (Duanet al.1999):

I=K×S×h(FC-q) (1)

whereSis area of a plot;Kis 0.5,which is a correction factor of theS,since only one half of furrows in each plot were irrigated in each event;his the thickness of the wetted soil layer,which was 0.60 m in depth from the emergence (VE)to 6 collars (V6) stage and 1.00 m in depth from V6to the physiological maturity (R6) stage;FCis the field capacity(0.30 cm cm-3),andqis the controlled irrigation limit (cm cm-3).

Fig.1 Schematic for the locations of the measuring tube and irrigated furrows in the experimental plots.

A flexible irrigation system was installed to irrigate each plot separately,and the amount of irrigation water was measured by a water meter.The amounts of total irrigation water for the different treatments in the two years are presented in Table 2.

2.4.Data collection

Soil water content and its depletionSoil volume moisture content of the two adjacent furrows (Fig.1)was tested at intervals of 2-3 days using a portable soil moisture monitoring system (Diviner 2000,Sentek Pty.Ltd.,Australia) for calibrating the irrigation.The vertical profile of soil water content was determined from measurements of mean volumetric soil water content in 10 cm intervals down to 100 cm depth as described by Zhouet al.(2007).Soil mass water content was measured initially (at sowing)and at the end (harvest) of the maize grown season using the gravimetric method (Qiuet al.2001) for calculating the water consumption of the maize.Soil samples were taken from five depths of 0-20,21-40,41-60,61-80 and 81-100 cm in three central points of each plot.Soil water storage at the initial and the end of the maize growing season was estimated according to Bandyopadhyayet al.(2010).Briefly,the soil water storage (mm) was the product of M,soil bulk density (g cm-3),soil depth (cm) and mass water content of soil (%).The M is a constant with a value of 10.

ETET was calculated from the applied irrigation water,precipitation and soil water depletion with the assumptions of negligible drainage,surface runoff and contribution from the water table beyond the measured depth according to Liet al.(2008),whose research was conducted in the same study area.

Plant samplingFollowing the method of Pandeyet al.(2000a),five plants of each plot were sampled to determine biomass at VT and R6;and kernels per cob,1 000-kernel weight and ears per ha at R6.The CGR was calculated from biomass at VT and R6.

Leaf areas were measured at the V6,V12,VT,silking (R1)and filling (R2) stages at 45,61,77,91 and 104 days after the planting (DAP) in 2014 and 42,58,74,89 and 102 DAP in 2015,respectively.Leaf length (L) and leaf width (W)from ten plants were measured using a ruler.The total leaf area (A) for maize leaves was calculated by the following equation (Kanget al.2003):

Table 2 Total irrigation amount (mm) during the maize growing season for different nitrogen and water treatments in 2014 and 20151)

wheremis the total number of maize leaves in a certain ground area,andiis a single maize leaf.LAI was obtained by the ratio of total leaf area per unit ground area.Among the measured stages,the LAI of maize in all the treatments reached the maximum at the R1stage (91 DAP in 2014 and 89 DAP in 2015).

Chlorophyll SPAD value and net photosynthetic rate (Pn)were measured at the VT,R1,R2and denting (R5) stages of maize from 10 randomly selected plants.The chlorophyll SPAD value was measured using a portable SPAD-502 Chlorophyll Meter (Minolta Camera Co.,Japan).ThePnwas measured using a portable infrared gas analyzer (LI-6400,Li-Cor Inc.Lincoln,NE,USA) from 10:00 a.m to 1:00 p.m.

Three representative plants in each plot were cut at the R6stage (harvest) for the determination of N accumulation.The plants were divided into grain and stover.All the plant samples were oven-dried at 70°C to a constant biomass and weighed.The samples were passed through a 1-mm sieve,and then the subsamples were collected for the determination of total N as described by Bao (2000).The concentration of N in the tissues was analyzed using the semi-micro Kjeldahl method (AOAC 1984).The total N uptake was calculated from the sum of the products of dry matter and N concentrations of the different plant parts.

Plant height and stem diameter were measured at the R6stage from 10 randomly selected plants.The middle 6 m length of two rows was harvested to estimate grain yield and HI.The measurement of grain weight was obtained after cobs were shelled;and a subsample was set aside for moisture measurement.Grain yield was then corrected to 15.5% moisture content.

2.5.Statistical analysis

Analysis of variance (ANOVA) was performed on all data using the GLM procedure of the Statistical Analysis System.Means were compared among treatments using Duncan’s multiple range tests at a significance level ofP≤0.05.Pearson correlations were used to analyze the relationships between the biomass,grain yield,CGR,chlorophyll SPAD value,Pn,the maximum LAI and WUE.

3.Results

3.1.Shoot growth

As shown in Table 3,the controlled irrigation limit and N rate had significant effects on the CGR,plant height and stem diameter,whereas their interaction effect was significant only on the CGR.Treatment W1significantly decreased the CGR,plant height and stem diameter compared to W2and W3at each N rate.Treatment N1significantly decreased the CGR,plant height and stem diameter compared to N2and N3in each irrigation treatment.The greatest CGR,plant height and stem diameter values among the different treatments were found in either W3N3or W3N2treatment,and the smallest values were observed in the W1N1treatment (Table 3).Similar results were obtainedin 2014 and 2015,with only minor differences between the years (Table 3).

Table 3 Crop growth rate (CGR),plant height and stem diameter of maize as affected by nitrogen application rates and irrigation regimes in 2014 and 2015

As shown in Fig.2,LAI reached a maximum at the R1stage in all treatments.The differences in LAI at the V6and V12stages among the different treatments were not statistically significant.However,treatments W2and W3significantly increased LAI at the VT,R1and R2stages compared to W1at each N rate (P<0.05).The LAI was also significantly greater in W3than that in W2at the N2and N3levels (P<0.05).Compared to the N1treatment,N2and N3significantly increased the LAI at the VT,R1and R2stages in each irrigation treatment (P<0.05).The LAI at the R1stage was also significantly greater in the N3treatment than in N2under the W2and W3treatments (P<0.05).The greatest LAI among the different treatments was found in the W2N3treatment and the smallest LAI was found in the W1N1treatment.The results in 2014 and 2015 were consistent,with only minor variations between the years (Fig.2).

3.2.Grain yield and its components

Fig.2 Leaf area index of maize as affected by different controlled irrigation limits and nitrogen rates in 2014 (A-C) and 2015(D-F).W1,W2 and W3 represent 45-50%,60-65% and 75-80% field capacity (FC),respectively;N1,N2 and N3 represent 100,200 and 300 kg N ha-1,respectively.Time points of 45,61,77,91 and 104 days after planting represent the 6 collars (V6),12 collars(V12),tasseling (VT),silking (R1) and filling (R2) stages of maize in 2014,respectively;and those at 42,58,74,89 and 102 days after the planting represent the V6,V12,VT,R1 and R2 stages of maize in 2015,respectively.Vertical bars represent the standard deviations (n=10).

The controlled irrigation limit,N rate and their interaction had significant effects on grain yield,ears per ha,kernels per cob and 1 000-kernel weight (Table 4).The W1treatment significantly decreased all four measures compared to W2and W3at each N rate.The N1treatment significantly decreased grain yield and kernels per cob compared to N2and N3in each irrigation treatment.Ears per ha and 1 000-kernel weight increased with an increase in N rate,although the difference in 1 000-kernel weight between the N1and N2was not statistically significant in the W3treatment (Table 4).The greatest grain yield,ears per ha,kernels per cob and 1 000-kernel weight among the different treatments were found in the W3N3treatment and the smallest values were observed in the W1N1treatment (Table 4).Moreover,the grain yield increased with the increase in N rate under 75-80% FC (Table 4),suggesting that a high N rate(300 kg N ha-1) coupled with 75-80% FC could improve grain yield of maize under APRI.Similar results were obtained in 2014 and 2015,and only minor differences were observed between the years (Table 4).

3.3.Biomass accumulation

The controlled irrigation limit,N rate and their interaction had significant effects on biomass accumulation (Table 5).The biomass was significantly greater in the N2and N3treatments than in N1for each irrigation treatment.The biomass was significantly greater in the W2and W3treatments than in W1at each N rate.Also,the biomass increased with increasing N rate from N1to N3in conjunction with W3.The W3N3treatment attained the greatest biomass,while W1N1resulted in the least biomass (Table 5).The results in 2014 and 2015 were consistent,with only minor variations between the years (Table 5).

3.4.Hl

The controlled irrigation limit,N rate and their interaction had significant effects on the HI in 2014 and 2015 (Table 5).The W2and W3treatments significantly increased the HI compared with W1at each N rate.Also,compared to W2,W3significantly decreased the HI at the N1rate (Table 5).The HI was significantly higher in N2and N3than in N1under the W1and W3treatments;whereas,the HI had no response to the different N rates under W2.The smallest HI among the different treatments was found in the W1N1treatment,and the largest HI was observed in the W2N1,W2N2,W3N2,W2N3and W3N3treatments (Table 5).Similar results were obtained in 2014 and 2015,and only minor differences were observed between the years (Table 5).

3.5.Chlorophyll SPAD value

The controlled irrigation limit,N rate and their interaction had significant effects on chlorophyll SPAD values(Table 6),which decreased from the VT to R5stages.The W1treatment significantly decreased chlorophyll SPAD at the VT,R1,R2and R5stages compared to W1and W2at each N rate.The N1treatment significantly decreased chlorophyll SPAD values at the VT,R1,R2and R5stages compared to N2and N3in each irrigation treatment.The W3N3,W3N2and W2N3treatments resulted in the greatest chlorophyll SPAD values at the VT,R1,R2and R5stages;while the W1N1treatment resulted in the smallest chlorophyll SPAD value.The W2N2treatment also achieved the greatest chlorophyll SPAD values at the VT,R2and R5stages (Table 6).Similar results were obtained in 2014 and 2015,with only minor differences between the years (Table 6).

Table 4 Ears per ha,kernels per cob,1 000-kernel weight and grain yield of maize as affected by nitrogen application rates and irrigation regimes in 2014 and 2015

Table 5 Biomass accumulation and harvest index (HI) as affected by nitrogen application rates and irrigation regimes in 2014 and 2015

Table 6 Chlorophyll SPAD value of maize as affected by nitrogen application rates and irrigation regimes in 2014 and 2015

3.6.Pn

ThePnof maize at the VT,R1,R2and R5stages showed similar variations among the different treatments.Also,plant growth at the R1stage played a vital role in yield determination of maize (Lindquistet al.2005).Thus,only thePnvalues at the R1stage are shown in Fig.3.The controlled irrigation limit,N rate and their interaction had significant effects onPn.The N2and N3treatments significantly increased thePncompared to N1in each irrigation treatment.The W2and W3treatments significantly increased thePncompared to W1at each N rate.The greatestPnamong the different treatments was found in the W2N3and W3N3treatments,and the smallestPnwas observed in the W1N1treatment (Fig.3).The results from 2014 and 2015 were consistent,with only minor variation between the years (Fig.3).

3.7.Water uptake and use by maize

As shown in Table 7,the controlled irrigation limit,N rate and their interaction had significant effects on soil water storage in the 0-100 cm soil depths after maize harvest,the ET and WUE in both 2014 and 2015.

Fig.3 Net photosynthetic rate (Pn) at the silking (R1) stage of maize as affected by different controlled irrigation limits and nitrogen rates in 2014 (A) and 2015 (B).W1,W2 and W3 represent 45-50%,60-65% and 75-80% field capacity,respectively;N1,N2 and N3 represent 100,200 and 300 kg N ha-1,respectively.Values (mean±SE,n=10) within the same year followed by different letters are significantly different at the probability level of 0.05.

Soil water storage in the 0-100 cm soil depths after themaize harvestThe soil water storage in the 0-100 cm soil depths in the W1treatment was significantly smaller than in W2and W3at each N rate (Table 7).The soil water storage in the 0-100 cm soil depths in the N1treatment was significantly higher than in N2and N3in each irrigation treatment.The soil water storage under W3decreased significantly with the increase in N rate.The W2N1and W3N1treatments resulted in the greatest soil water storage in the 0-100 cm soil depths,while the W1N1and W3N3treatments resulted in the smallest soil water storage (Table 7).Similar results were obtained in 2014 and 2015,with only minor differences between the years (Table 7).

The W3treatment achieved the highest ET,followed by W2and W1at the N2and N3rates in 2014 and 2015.The W1treatment significantly decreased the ET compared to W2and W3at each N rate in 2014 and increasing controlled irrigation limits significantly increased ET at each N rate in 2015 (Table 7).Increasing N rates increased ET in each controlled irrigation limit,and the differences were statistically significant under W3in 2014 and 2015 (Table 7).The greatest ET among the different treatments was found in the W3N3treatment while the smallest was in the W1N1treatment in the two years (Table 7).

WUEThe W2treatment attained the highest WUE,followed by W3and W1at the N1and N2rates;and W2and W3resulted in a greater WUE compared to W1at the N3rate (Table 7).The WUE was significantly smaller in N1than that in N2and N3in each irrigation treatment.The greatest WUE among the different treatments was found in the W3N3,W3N2and W2N2treatments and the smallest WUE was found in the W1N1treatment (Table 7).Similar results were obtained in 2014 and 2015,with only minor differences between the years (Table 7).

Table 7 Soil water storage (SWS) after maize harvest (0-100 cm soil depth),evapotranspiration (ET) and water use efficiency(WUE) of maize as affected by nitrogen application rates and irrigation regimes in 2014 and 2015

3.8.Correlation analysis of biomass,grain yield,CGR,chlorophyll SPAD value,Pn,the maximum LAl and WUE

Positive relationships among the biomass,grain yield,CGR,chlorophyll SPAD value,Pn,the maximum LAI and WUE were observed (Table 8).The correlation coefficient(R) were statistically significant in relation to biomass,the maximum LAI,chlorophyll SPAD value,Pn,WUE,grain yield and CGR.Moreover,the R of biomass in relation to CGR,chlorophyll SPAD value,Pnmaximum LAI were higher than that of grain yield (Table 8),indicating that shoot growth was more directly responsible for biomass than grain yield.The greater LAI,CGR,Pnand maximum LAI could effectively improve biomass accumulation,thereby increasing both grain yield and WUE.

4.Discussion

4.1.Effect of different irrigation and N managements on shoot growth,biomass,Hl and grain yield

Serve water stress (W1) significantly reduced the CGR,plant height,stem diameter and grain yield,whereas a low N rate (N1) had less effect on those parameters in maize (Tables 3 and 4).This may be explained by several factors.First,water is related to biological macromolecules and membranes,enzymatic synthesis and activity,nitrate reductase activity,metabolism and physiology,and many other processes in plant life (Hsiao 1973).Second,soil available N and its transport to roots are determined by the content of soil moisture (Huet al.2009),resulting in N absorption being largely dependent on the water supply levels.Severe water stress has been shown to impact crop N availability due to the reduced mineralization process and root activity (Shaoet al.2013).The W1N1treatment in this study resulted in the lowest N uptake by maize;and the W2N1treatment significantly increased the N uptake compared to the W1N2(Table 9),which confirmed this relationship.Third,dry/wet cycles of soils induce the ‘Birch effect’,which enhances soil N availability under APRI (Xianget al.2008).

In this study,lowering the controlled irrigation limit from W3to W1resulted in greater reduction of the CGR at the N3compared to that at the N1(Table 3),suggesting that 45-50%FC inhibited shoot growth of maize to a greater extent at a low N rate (100 kg N ha-1).This could be related to a combined effect of water stress and lower N rate inhibiting the N uptake and assimilation by the crop (Liet al.2020).Moreover,increasing the N rate from N1to N3resulted in more incremental CGR under W3rather than that under W1(Table 3),suggesting that increasing N rates help improve shoot growth of maize under full irrigation.This result is consistent with other studies (Pandeyet al.2000a,b;Di Paolo and Rinaldi 2008).However,it is inconsistent with the findings of Ranet al.(2017) that added N fertilizer improves shoot growth of maize under serve drought conditions.This contradiction could be related to the differences in initial soil mineral N conditions and crop species.

ThePnof ear leaves indicates photosynthetic capacity and it is a key factor in determining grain yield of the crop(Liuet al.2018;Liet al.2020).In the present study,significant reduction in the biomass accumulation and grain yield occurred due to serve drought,which corresponded to significant decreases in the LAI,chlorophyll SPAD value,andPnof ear leaves under W1.Soil drought has been shown to decrease the chlorophyll content,resulting in a decline in photosynthetic characteristics (Teixeiraet al.2014).Moreover,proper application of N fertilizer can alleviate the adverse effects of moderate water stress on LAI,chlorophyll content,and leaf photosynthesis in maize(Gheysariet al.2009;Hernándezet al.2015;Liet al.2020).Consistently,the difference in LAI,chlorophyll content,and leaf photosynthesis level was not statistically significant between the W2N2 and W3N3 treatments.In addition,the interactions of irrigation water and fertilizer N management exhibited significant effects on the LAI,chlorophyll SPAD value,leaf photosynthesis,biomass and grain yield.Increasing the N rate to a high level (300 kg N ha-1) significantly increased the LAI andPnunder W3.In addition,the biomass and grain yields under W1and W2were comparable between N2and N3while those under W3increased significantly with the increase in N rate (Tables 4 and 5).This compares well with the findings of Di Paolo and Rinaldi (2008),Gheysariet al.(2009) and Guet al.(2015).Because water stress depresses the ability of N fertilizer to improve growth and development of plants (Guet al.2015;Liet al.2000),which corresponded to the increase in N fertilizer rate,the increments of LAI,chlorophyll SPAD value andPnunder W1were lower than those under W3.Thus,the interaction of irrigation and fertilizer N management significantly enhanced the leaf growth and development and grain yield under W3.These findings suggest that an appropriate combination of N rate and irrigation regime can improve leaf photosynthetic ability and help produce high grain yield of maize under APRI.

Table 8 Correlation coefficients between shoot growth parameter,grain yield,and water use efficiency (WUE) of maize from data collected in 2014 and 20151)

Table 9 Total nitrogen uptake (kg ha-1) by maize at the maturity stage as affected by nitrogen application rates and irrigation regimes in 2014 and 2015

Previous research has shown that serve deficit irrigation or N deficiency significantly decreases kernel weight and kernel number per cob in maize (Jiaet al.2014).Consistent with this,the W1and N1conditions resulted in lower 1 000-kernel weight and kernels per cob at the same N and irrigation treatment levels (Table 4).The reduced kernel weight could be related to a shortage in the supply of water or N producing an imbalance of source-sink relations,resulting in the reduced transformation of carbohydrate from ‘source’to ‘sink’ (Luoet al.2011).One explanation for the decline in kernel number was that severe water stress or N deficiency inhibited pollen production in plants before anthesis,resulting in a reduced number of well-developed kernels(Xieet al.2012).Moreover,we observed here that kernels per cob and 1 000-kernel weight were comparable between the W3N2and W3N3treatments (Table 4),suggesting that 75-80% FC coupled with 200 kg N ha-1could improve kernel weight and kernel number of maize under APRI.Also,1 000-kernel weight was significantly greater in W2N2than that in W3N2(Table 4),which is consistent with the findings of Maet al.(2014) and Songet al.(2016) and may be because appropriate deficit irrigation could enhance translocation of dry matter from vegetative organs to grain in kernel crops (Maet al.2014).In addition,W1or N1significantly decreased ears per ha compared to the other irrigation and N fertilization treatments (Table 4),consistent with the findings of Abbaset al.(2005) and Penget al.(2019).Water deficit from the V6to VT has been proven to decrease productive ears per ha of maize (Penget al.2019).In this study,45-50% FCwas maintained under W1and the amount of effective rainfall from the V6to VT stages was less than 30 mm in the two years,resulting in the inhibited development of ears under W1.However,Ninget al.(2019) suggested that N rates do not affect ear number per ha of spring maize in the Loess Plateau of China.This contradiction could be related to the differences in weather conditions,soil fertility and other growing conditions.

Earlier studies have illustrated that HI is vulnerable to deficit irrigation in arid regions,and severe water stress decreases HI dramatically (Farré and Faci 2006;Ranet al.2016).Consistently,W1significantly decreased the HI of maize under APRI in this study.Moreover,Pandeyet al.(2000b) reported that supplying a low level of N fertilizer(80 kg N ha-1) decreases HI of maize.In line with this,N1significantly decreased the HI compared to N2and N3for each controlled irrigation limit (Table 5).This could be caused by a low N rate resulting in less carbohydrate transfer from vegetative organs to grain of maize (Zhanget al.2011).In addition,the HI at the N1treatment was lower under W3than that under W2(Table 5).This was attributed to the low N rate inducing redundant vegetative growth of the plant under full irrigation (Yang and Zhang 2010).

As expected,a high correlation coefficient was observed among the maximum LAI (LAI at the R1),CGR,biomass and grain yield (Table 8),suggesting that a high LAI helps improve CGR,biomass and grain yield.This could mean that more leaf expansion means more radiation absorption and a higher photosynthetic rate (Lindquistet al.2005),ultimately increasing biomass and grain yield.Moreover,the average LAI across the different growth stages increased significantly following N1up to N2and was then comparable between N2and N3for each irrigation treatment;while it increased significantly with the increase in controlled irrigation limit at each N rate.This could be explained as follows:200 kg N ha-1is the recommended N fertilizer rate for maize production under the conventional full irrigation regime in the local area (Yang and Su 2009).When soil N availability is relatively high,the added application of N fertilizer plays only a limited role in improving plant growth(Liet al.2009).Moreover,a relatively high supply level of irrigation water has been shown to help maintain the tension of cells and enhance the development of maize leaves (Earl and Davis 2003),resulting in the improved LAI under W3(Fig.2).Also,it is worth mentioning that the LAI on average in the W3N2treatment (2.5) accounted for 90% of that in the W3N3treatment (2.8),indicating that 200 kg N ha-1coupled with 75-80% FC could improve leaf area growth of maize under APRI.

4.2.Effect of different irrigation and N managements on the ET and WUE

In this study,the ET increased with increases in N rate,and the differences in ET among the three N rates were statistically significant for the W3(Table 7).This result correlates well with the findings of Liet al.(2015) that N application treatments enhanced the ET compared to a zero N treatment.It was observed that increasing N fertilizer rates increased the LAI from the VT to R2stages under W3(Fig.2).The increased LAI enhances the transpiration of plants (Xiaoet al.2012).However,the mechanism behind the respective contributions of transpiration and evaporation to the ET of plants in response to the different supply levels of water and N under APRI is not clear,and determining this mechanism merits further study.

The water-saving effect of APRI compared to conventional irrigation has been widely proven (Kang and Zhang 2004;Duet al.2015).However,Wakrimet al.(2005) reported that with half of the full amount of irrigation water,the differences in the transpiration,plant water status,leaf ABA,stomatal closure,and xylem sap pH of common bean were not statistically significant between the APRI and conventional irrigation;and therefore they concluded that APRI improves WUE due to the obvious reduction in the amount of irrigation water (Wakrimet al.2005).In this study,W1significantly decreased WUE compared to W2and W3at each N rate(Table 7).This is consistent with the findings of other studies conducted under conventional irrigation conditions (Pandeyet al.2000a;Farré and Faci 2006;Payeroet al.2006;Ranet al.2017).Because severe water stress decreases leaf photosynthesis and root activity of crops under APRI(Zhanget al.2013),we concluded that 45-50% FC of the W1was too low to meet the minimal water requirement of maize under APRI.This may partially answer the question of why APRI did not lead to a higher WUE in the Wakrimet al.(2005) study.Moreover,N1significantly decreased WUE compared to N2and N3in each controlled irrigation limit (Table 7).This is consistent with the findings of Pandeyet al.(2000a) and Zhanget al.(2018),because the low N fertilizer rate reduced the biomass,grain yield and HI (Tables 4 and 5) and depressed the water extraction from the soil(Liet al.2015).These results suggest that achieving the water-saving effect of APRI largely depends on whether supply levels of water and N are appropriate for the essential requirements of them by the plants.

It is worth mentioning that WUE at the N1and N2levels were significantly greater under W2than those under W3(Table 7),suggesting that with a low or moderate N rate,moderate water stress is useful for improving the WUE of maize under APRI.Moreover,the W2N2,W2N3and W3N3achieved the greatest WUE in the two years (Table 7).In W2N2and W2N3,the relatively higher HI (Table 5) and lower ET (Table 7) were the two factors responsible for the improved WUE.Moderate water stress has been shown to reduce plant redundant growth and restrain the unnecessary evaporation of soil moisture under APRI (Tanget al.2010).The W3N3treatment obtained the highest grain yield,HI and ET among the treatments,resulting in a high WUE.In addition,earlier studies illustrated that appropriate combinations of irrigation regime and fertilizer application improve water productivity of maize crops (Liet al.2009;Zouet al.2020).

Although the precipitation during the maize growth season in 2014 was 31 mm greater than that in 2015 (Table 1),the shoot growth parameters,biomass,grain yield and WUE of maize were comparable between 2014 and 2015 in the all treatments.This may be explained by two factors.First,the sunshine hours,monthy mean temperature and the other experimental variables were comparable in the two years.Second,the increased precipitation in 2014 resulted from unexpected rainfall in the R5stage of maize (in late August in 2014) (Table 1),so it had a limited effect on growth and yield of maize due to the shrinking water requirement of the crop at that time (Cakir 2004).Moreover,the relatively high amount of irrigation water in all treatments (Table 2) helped maintain growth and grain yield of the maize in 2015.

5.Conclusion

In general,200 kg N ha-1and 60-65% FC resulted in a greater CGR,plant height,stem diameter,LAI,chlorophyll SPAD value,Pn,biomass,grain yield,yield components and WUE compared to 100 N ha-1and 45-50% FC at a same irrigation or N treatment.However,the further increase in N rate (to 300 kg ha-1) could not increase those under 45-50% FC or 60-65% FC.Increasing N rates increased the maximum LAI andPn,contributing to the increased shoot growth,and consequently produce high biomass and grain yield under 75-80% FC.Coupling 75-80% FC with 300 N kg ha-1and 60-65% FC with either 200 or 300 kg N ha-1achieved the greatest and the second-greatest biomass and grain yield,respectively,and subsequently a greater WUE.Therefore,60-65% FC coupled with 200-300 kg N ha-1or 75-80% FC coupled with 300 kg N ha-1should be recommended for water and N management of maize under alternate partial root-zone irrigation in the Hexi Corridor area of Northwest China and in other regions with similar environments.

Acknowledgements

The study was funded by the National Natural Science Foundation of China (51809006 and 51079124).


登录APP查看全文