APP下载

学术评价中指标无量纲法对VIKOR评价的影响研究

2020-07-09俞立平

现代情报 2020年7期

摘 要:[目的/意义]VIKOR评价法是一种重要的非线性多属性评价方法,在学术评价中得到了广泛的应用,但是对于无量纲方法对VIKOR评价结果的影响研究却比较缺乏,实际应用中比较随意。[方法/过程]本文首先建立无量纲方法对VIKOR评价方法影响的分析框架,分析了无量纲方法对VIKOR评价的影响机制,然后基于JCR2017经济学期刊的数据进行了实证。[结果/结论]无量纲方法对VIKOR评价的影响机制包括评价值排序、统计特征与模拟权重3个方面;指标无量纲方法同样会影响VIKOR评价方法的模拟权重;极大值无量纲VIKOR评价结果总体优于极差无量纲;VIKOR评价方法是一种对无量纲方法比较敏感的评价方法;当VIKOR用于学术评价时建议首选极大值无量纲方法。

关键词:学术评价;VIKOR;无量纲方法;极大值无量纲;极差无量纲

DOI:10.3969/j.issn.1008-0821.2020.07.013

〔中图分类号〕G302 〔文献标识码〕A 〔文章编号〕1008-0821(2020)07-0126-08

Study on the Influence of Index Dimensionless Method on

VIKOR Evaluation in Academic Evaluation

Yu Liping

(School of Statistics and Mathematics,Zhejiang Gongshang University,Hangzhou 310018,China)

Abstract:[Purpose/Significance]VIKOR evaluation method is an important non-linear multi-attribute evaluation method,which has been widely used in academic evaluation.However,there is a lack of research on the influence of dimensionless method on VIKOR evaluation results,which is relatively random in practical application.[Method/Process]Firstly,This paper established an analytical framework for the impact of dimensionless method on VIKOR evaluation method,and analysed the impact mechanism of dimensionless method on VIKOR evaluation.Then,an empirical study was carried out based on the data of JCR2017 Economics Journal.[Result/Conclusion]The results showed that the influence mechanism of the dimensionless method on VIKOR evaluation included three aspects:ranking of evaluation values,statistical characteristics and simulation weight;The dimensionless method also affected the simulation weight of the VIKOR evaluation method;The result of maximum dimensionless VIKOR evaluation was generally superior to range dimensionless;VIKOR evaluation method was sensitive to the dimensionless method;Maximum dimensionless methods were recommended when VIKOR is used for academic evaluation.

Key words:academic evaluation;VIKOR;dimensionless method;maximum dimensionless;range dimensionless

在学术评价中,多属性评价方法是一种非常重要的评价手段。所谓多属性评价方法,就是选取若干评价指标,将其进行无量纲化处理,然后采用某种评价方法进行评价,得到评价结果。多属性评价通过建立指标体系,从多方位进行学术评价,能够提供相对全面的信息,再加上评价方法众多,每种方法均有其一定的适用范围,可以根据评价需要灵活选取。目前多属性评价已经在大学评价、学科评价、科研人员评价、科技机构评价、学术期刊评价、图书馆评价等得到了广泛的应用。

多准则妥协解排序法(VIKOR)是一个针对复杂系统的多属性评价方法。……

登录APP查看全文