Meta analysis and medication analysis of TCM compound in the treatment of senile osteoporosis
2020-04-03FanYuFuJiGaoSunRongTianWangHengLiYeBiaoTanYanYanWeiHengChen
Fan-Yu Fu, Ji-Gao Sun, Rong-Tian Wang, Heng-Li Ye, Biao Tan, Yan Yan, Wei-Heng Chen
1. Guizhou University of Traditional Chinese Medicine, Guizhou 550002
2. Wangjing Hospital, China Academy of Chinese Medical Sciences, Beijing, 100102
3. The Third Affiliated Hospital of Beijing University of Chinese Medicine, Beijing, 100029
Keywords:
ABSTRACT
1. Introduction
Senile osteoporosis (SOP) refers to a systemic skeletal disease characterized by a decrease in bone mineral content and destruction of the microstructure of bone,which is prone to fracture[1].According to China's epidemiological statistics, the overall prevalence of osteoporosis in the elderly over 60 years of age in China reaches 36%, of which 23% are males and 49% are females[2].Western medicine is mostly used in clinical treatment, such as calcium,b isphosphonates,estrogen, etc.,but patients have low medication compliance,lack of treatment drugs and low clinical treatment rate[3][4].In recent years,Chinese medicine has achieved certain results in the treatment of osteoporosis and has a positive effect on its treatment[5].There are many clinical reports of traditional Chinese medicine compound for treating senile osteoporosis,but there is insufficient evidence-based medical evidence.Therefore,this study uses a meta-analysis method to evaluate various indicators of traditional Chinese medicine compound for treating osteoporosis and analyze its medication Law to provide an objective basis for its clinical efficacy.
2. Materials and methods
2.1 Literature inclusion criteria
(1) The clinical research subjects all meet the diagnostic criteria for "senile osteoporosis" and have been published, regardless of age, gender and ethnicity; (2)the included literature is a randomized controlled clinical trial (RCT) and is not limited to whether It adopts blind operation and the language of publication is Chinese or English; (3) The treatment course of the control group and the study group is clear, the baseline has a good balance and comparability,and there is a clear evaluation standard of efficacy; (4) Intervention measures: the experimental group uses Chinese medicine compound treatment, the control group was treated with calcium or noncalcium; (5) Outcome indicators: ① Effectiveness ② VAS ③ Bone density (lumbar spine) ④ Bone density (femoral neck) ⑤ Bone density in other parts ⑥ Bone mineral content (BMC) ⑧ Serum Calcium ⑧ Serum Phosphorus ⑩ Efficacy of TCM Syndromes ⑩ALP ⑪ Urine Calcium / Urine Creatinine ⑫ TCM Syndrome Points⑬ Calcaneus Index ⑭ Radial Bone Density.
2.2 Literature exclusion criteria
(1) Non-randomized controlled trials; (2) The main content is missing for statistical analysis; (3) There is no control group in the literature and the basic data is incomplete; (4) Duplicate data; (5)Summary, conference abstracts, etc. Animal experiment literature;(6) In addition to the traditional Chinese medicine compound, the experimental group also used other traditional Chinese medicine therapies, such as acupuncture and cupping.
2.3 Literature search strategies
Computer search of Chinese journal full-text databases CNKI,Wangfang Data, VIP, CBM, PubMed, Embase, Cochrane Library,manual retrieval of grey literature, etc. "osteoporosis", etc., searches for keywords or topics, downloads and saves the bibliography. If the full text cannot be downloaded, manual retrieval and photocopying are adopted. The retrieval time is from the establishment of the database to October 2019.
2.4 Data extraction
All documents were jointly searched by 2 searchers, cross-checked,and a unified data extraction table was used to extract the data.According to the content of the search, eligible documents werescreened according to the inclusion and exclusion criteria. If there were disagreements, an agreement was reached through internal discussion Or by consulting with a third-party reviewer.

Table1 Basic characteristics of included research trials
2.5 Quality Evaluation
The Cochrane Handbook 5.1.0 was used to evaluate the RCT's"bias risk assessment" tool[6]. The evaluation included the following aspects: ① the generation of random sequences; ② the allocation of hidden information; Implementation of blindness; ④ blindness of effect indicators; ⑤ incomplete results; ⑥ selective reporting of results; other sources of bias.
2.6 Statistical processing
Meta-analysis was performed on the data using RevMan5.3 software provided by the Cochrane collaboration network.Continuous variables were expressed by standardized mean difference (MD) and its 95% confidence interval (CI). Binary variables were expressed by relative risk (RR) and its 95%confidence interval (CI). Heterogeneity tests are conducted between studies. When P≥0.1 and I2<50%, the heterogeneity can be considered to be low. A fixed effect model is used. When P <0.1 and I2> 50%, heterogeneity is considered to exist. The random effects model performs a meta-analysis of the literature.
3. Results
3.1 Literature search results
A total of 258 relevant literatures were retrieved in this study.Duplicate documents were automatically excluded by EndNote software and screening was performed according to the inclusion and exclusion criteria of the literature. Finally, 19 articles were included for meta-analysis. A total of 1831 patients were included in this study, including 987 in the experimental group and 844 in the control group. The baseline was well balanced and comparable. See Table 1 for details.

Figure 1 Document screening process
3.2 Literature quality evaluation
The quality of the included literature was evaluated in accordance with Cochrane's evaluation criteria, as shown in Figures 2 and 3. It should be noted that this study also has the following limitations:From the overall situation, the quality of the literature is generally low, mainly concentrated in The following aspects: ① The method of random grouping is unclear. Only one of the 19 random assignments mentions the random number table, and the remaining 18 only describe the random grouping without describing the specific random method. ②No blinding method was included in the literature. ③ Only three articles were followed up, and the remaining 16 articles did not mention follow-up. ④ There were 7 articles mentioning adverse reactions, and the remaining 12 articles did not mention adverse reactions. ⑤ All literatures do not mention the concealment of random schemes.

Figure 2 Bias risk assessment chart
3.3 Meta Analysis
3.3.1 Effect
There are 16 articles[7,8,10,11,12,14,15,17,18,19,20,21,22,23,24,25]related to efficiency and found through heterogeneity test (P < 0.0001, I2= 68) indicates heterogeneity. Using random effect model analysis,the clinical effect combined effect size (RR = 1.30, 95% CI: 1.19~ 1.43, P <0.05) is statistically significant, suggesting the use of traditional Chinese medicine The effective rate of treating senile osteoporosis is higher than that of the control group, as shown in Figure 3.

Figure 3 Meta analysis of the effectiveness of the two groups
3.3.2 Lumbar spine bone density
Six literatures[7,10,13,15,16,22] used lumbar vertebra bone density as an evaluation index, and there was heterogeneity among the literatures (P = 0.01, I2= 66%) using random effect model analysis,forest plot The combined effect amount (MD = 0.02, 95% CI: 0.01~ 0.04, P = 0.009) was statistically significant. The results showed that the traditional Chinese medicine treatment of senile osteoporosis had a significant effect on improving lumbar bone density. See Figure 4.

Figure 4 Forest plot of lumbar spine bone density in two groups
3.3.3 Femoral neck bone density
Five articles[7,10,16,22,23] used lumbar vertebra bone density as an evaluation index, and there was no heterogeneity among the literatures (P = 0.12, I2= 45%). Application of fixed-effects model analysis, forest map merger The effect amount (MD = 0.01, 95%CI: 0.00 ~ 0.02, P = 0.004) was statistically significant. The results showed that the traditional Chinese medicine compound had a significant effect on femoral neck bone density in the treatment of senile osteoporosis. See Figure 5.

Figure 5 Forest plot of femoral neck bone density in two groups
3.3.4 Bone mineral density in other parts
Four literatures[9,12,14,17] used bone mineral density as an evaluation index, but did not describe the specific site. There was heterogeneity among the literatures (P <0.00001, I2= 96%). Application of fixedeffect model analysis, forest The difference in the combined effect size (MD = 0.11, 95% CI: -0.01 ~ 0.22, P = 0.06) is not statistically significant, indicating that it is not yet possible to judge whether the traditional Chinese medicine compound is effective for bone mineral density in other parts of senile osteoporosis. See Figure 6.

Figure 6 Bone density forest of other parts
3.3.5 Radial Bone Mineral Density
Two literatures[8,18] used radial bone density as an evaluation index,and there was no heterogeneity among the literatures (P = 0.85,I2= 0%). The fixed effect model was used to analyze the combined effect of forest plots (MD = 0.04 95% CI: 0.03 ~ 0.05, P <0.05)The difference is statistically significant, and the results show that the traditional Chinese medicine compound has a significant effect on radial bone density in the treatment of senile osteoporosis. See Figure 7.

Figure 7 Forest diagram of radial bone density
3.3.6 VAS score
Three articles[7,9,16] evaluated the VAS scores. Heterogeneity (P =0.04, I2= 70%) existed among the documents. Random effect model analysis was used. The combined effect of forest plots (MD = -1.04 95% CI: -1.67 to -0.40, P = 0.001) The difference is statistically significant, indicating that the traditional Chinese medicine compound treatment of senile osteoporosis has a significant improvement in VAS score. See Figure 8.

Figure 8 VAS score forest map
3.3.6 BMC
Three literatures[8,13,18] used bone mineral content BMC as an evaluation index, and there was heterogeneity among the literatures(P = 0.004, I2= 82%). The random effect model was used to analyze the effect of the forest map merger effect (MD = 0.06,95% CI:0.01 ~ 0.11, P = 0.03) The difference is statistically significant,indicating that the traditional Chinese medicine compound treatment of senile osteoporosis has a significant effect in increasing bone mineral content. See Figure 9.

Figure 9 BMC forest plot of ore content
3.3.7 Blood Calcium
Five articles[9,12,13,18,23] used blood calcium as an evaluation index,and heterogeneity between the articles (P <0.00001, I2= 98%) was analyzed using a random effects model, and the combined effect of forest plots (MD = -0.01, 95% CI: -0.11 ~ 0.09, P = 0.83) The difference was not statistically significant. See Figure 10.

Figure 10 Blood calcium forest map
3.3.8 Blood phosphorus
Three literatures[12,13,18] mentioned blood phosphorus as an evaluation index, and there was no heterogeneity among the literatures (P = 0.48, I2= 0%). Using fixed effect model analysis, the combined effect of forest map (MD = 0.03,95% CI: -0.01 ~ 0.07, P= 0.09) The difference is not statistically significant. See Figure 11.

Figure 11 Map of blood phosphorus forest
3.3.9 Alkaline phosphatase
Five papers[12,13,15,18,23,] mentioned that alkaline phosphatase was used as an evaluation index, and there was heterogeneity among the various literatures (P <0.00001, I2= 92%) using random effect model analysis, The difference in the combined effects of forest plots(MD = 4.72, 95% CI: -6.00 to 15.44, P = 0.39) was not statistically significant. See Figure 12.

Figure 12 Alkaline phosphatase forest map
3.3.10 Estradiol
Two literatures[12,23,] used estradiol as an evaluation index, and there was heterogeneity between the literatures (P <0.00001, I2=98%). The random effect model was used to analyze the combined effect of forest plot (MD = 10.45 95% CI: -1.75 to 22.64, P = 0.09)The difference was not statistically significant. See Figure 13.

Figure 13 Estradiol forest map
3.3.11 Urinary calcium / creatinine
Two literatures[13,18] used urine calcium/urine creatinine as an evaluation index, and heterogeneity between the literatures (P =0.0009, I2= 91%) was analyzed using a random effects model. -0.09,95% CI: -0.24 ~ -0.06, P = 0.24) The difference is not statistically significant. See Figure 14.

Figure 14 Urine calcium / urinary creatinine forest map
3.3.12 Root Bone Index
Two papers[20,21] used the root bone index as the evaluation index,and there was no heterogeneity between the literatures (P = 0.92,I2= 0%). The fixed effect model analysis was used. 95% CI: -0.17~ 0.18, P = 0.95) The difference is not statistically significant. See Figure 15.

Figure 15 Root bone index forest map
3.3.13 TCM Syndrome Points
Two literatures[20,21] used TCM syndrome scores as the evaluation index, and there was no heterogeneity between the literatures (P= 0.38, I2= 0%). The fixed effect model was used to analyze the combined effect of forest plots (MD = -6.76, 95% CI: -7.94 ~ -5.59,P <0.05) The difference is statistically significant, indicating that the treatment of senile osteoporosis with traditional Chinese medicine compound has a significant improvement on TCM syndrome score.See Figure 16.

Figure 16 Forest map of TCM syndromes
3.3.14 Effect of TCM Syndrome
Four literatures[12,16,17,18] used the efficacy of TCM syndromes as an evaluation index, and there was no heterogeneity among the literatures (P = 0.37, I2= 5%). Application of fixed-effects model analysis, forest plot merger The amount (RR = 1.49, 95% CI: 1.28~ 1.73, P <0.05) was statistically significant, indicating that the treatment of senile osteoporosis with traditional Chinese medicine prescriptions has significantly improved the efficacy of TCM syndromes. See Figure 17.

Figure 17 Forest chart of TCM syndrome efficacy
3.4 Adverse reactions
Seven[11,14,17,18,19,21,24] literatures mentioned adverse reactions.Among them, Liu Da et al[19].found that the adverse reaction rate of chest tightness, nausea and vomiting in the compound Chinese medicine group was 10%. Less than 43.3% of the control group with Calci D tablets. There were no obvious adverse reactions in the remaining 6 literatures.
3.5 Frequency statistics of Chinese medicines
In the included literature studies, the traditional Chinese medicine compound used 68 traditional Chinese medicines to treat senile osteoporosis, with a total frequency of 216 times, of which the traditional Chinese medicines with frequency ≥ 7 times were Astragalus (11), continuity (10), psoralea Zhi (9), Chinese wolfberry(8), Cuscuta seed (8), Bone broken tonic (8), Chuanxiong (8),Eucommia (8), Chinese yam (7), Rehmannia glutinosa (7), Dogwood(7), Epimedium (7), angelica (7), chicken blood rattan (7).
According to the Chinese Pharmacopoeia (2015 edition), 68 kinds of Chinese medicines can be divided into 13 categories, amongwhich the tonic medicines have the highest frequency, reaching 124 times, accounting for 57.4% of the total frequency, followed by blood circulation medicine, astringent medicine, and rheumatism medicine. Using Gephi software to visualize the data, the results are shown in Table 2 and Table 3.

Table2 Chinese medicine frequency table

Table3 Chinese medicine classification frequency table
4. Discussion
According to the epidemiological survey, as of the end of 2015,China's population over 60 years of age has exceeded 210 million,accounting for about 15.5% of the total population, and people over 65 years old have nearly 140 million, accounting for about 10.1% of the total population[26]. With the aging of our country, the incidence of senile osteoporosis has also increased year by year [27].
Traditional Chinese medicine believes that senile osteoporosis should belong to the category of "osteoporosis" and"osteoporosis"[28].Kidney essence metaplasia weakens with age, and the decrease of bone marrow function reduces its ability to maintain bone, which leads to bone marrow emptiness and osteoporosis[29].
A total of 19 literatures were included in this meta-analysis, and the baseline data of the included literatures were comparable. The results showed that the patients in the experimental group were superior to the control group in terms of effectiveness, lumbar bone density,femoral neck bone density, radius bone density, VAS score, bone mineral content, TCM syndrome score, and TCM syndrome efficacy,and the differences were statistically significant. . There were no significant differences in bone mineral density, blood calcium, blood phosphorus, alkaline phosphatase, estradiol, urine calcium / urinary creatinine, and root bone index between the two groups of patients.
According to the analysis of the traditional Chinese medicine compounding rules included in this study, astragalus is the most frequently used drug, astragalus is sweet and warm, and belongs to the lung, spleen, and kidney meridians. Studies have found that[30]astragalus has very important value in the treatment and prevention of osteoporosis, and its clinical efficacy has also been widely recognized.
This Meta analysis evaluation also has certain shortcomings: (1)the quality of the included literature is generally low, and they are all Chinese literature. (2) Although the included literatures are randomized, the specific random methods and their descriptions are not described. Many (3) The literature included this time has few descriptions of safety and adverse reactions. Only one reported adverse reaction rate, which is difficult to conduct safety metaanalysis.
In short, the curative effect of the compound Chinese medicine on senile osteoporosis is definite, but in the future research, the design of randomized controlled trials should be strictly, the large sample and multi-center RCT should be emphasized, and more objective clinical evidence should be provided. Safety and adverse events to ensure the reliability of the research results.
杂志排行
Journal of Hainan Medical College的其它文章
- The Effect of Clinically Used Crystalloid Solution on the Clearance Rate of Lactic Acid in Septic Shock Patients
- Efficacy of intravitreal injection of ranibizumab in the treatment of macular edema secondary to non-ischemic branch retinal vein occlusion
- Efficacy of PC-PRL implantation in the treatment of high myopia and its complications
- Clinical study of warm acupuncture combined with massage in treatment of periathritis of shoulder
- Expression and clinical significance of lncRNA SNHG3 in peripheral blood mononuclear cells of patients with chronic obstructive pulmonary disease
- Effects of Pioglitazone on Renal Mitochondrial calcium and cytochrome C levels in Early Diabetic Nephropathy Rats
