APP下载

法律谈判:现代民事纠纷解决机制的基础

2019-08-30陈文曲常学敏

湖南大学学报(社会科学版) 2019年4期

陈文曲 常学敏

[摘 要] 学界关于法律谈判的界定众说纷纭,未能阐释其真正内涵。法律谈判需要强调“主体间沟通”,力求克服普通谈判易被目的理性异化的弊端,通过法律因素介入,引导谈判参与者进行自我约束,遵循有效对话的基本条件,在主体之间经由对话积聚共识,化解分歧。在整个纠纷解决体系中,基于交往理性的法律谈判占有基础性地位,一方面作为独立的解纷方式活跃在纠纷解决机制的“舞台”,另一方面作为其他纠纷解决机制的基础穿插在其中,推动纠纷的及时有效化解。因此,现代社会法律谈判旨在民事纠纷解决机制中起到保障真正合意,防止合意贫困化的基础性作用。

[关键词] 法律因素;法律谈判;谈判;交往理性;基础作用

[中图分类号] D912.182    [文献标识码] A   [文章编号] 1008—1763(2019)04—0126—06

Abstract:There are many opinions on the definitions of legal negotiation in academic circles, which fail to explain its true connotation.Legal negotiation emphasizes "communication between subjects",and tries to overcome the shortcoming that ordinary negotiation is easily alienated by instrumental rationality. Through the intervention of legal factors,the participants are guided to selfrestraint and follow the basic conditions of effective dialogues. It allows the subject to accumulate consensus through dialogues to resolve differences.In the whole civil dispute resolution system, legal negotiation based on communicative rationality occupies an important position. On the one hand,as an independent way of resolving disputes,it is active in the "stage" of dispute resolution mechanism. As the basis of other dispute resolution mechanism,on the other hand, it interspersed among them to promote the timely and effective resolution of disputes.Therefore, the legal negotiation in modern society aims to play a fundamental role in protecting the true agreement and preventing the poverty of concurrence in the mechanism of civil dispute settlement.

Key words: legal factors;legal negotiation;negotiation;communicative rationality;basic function

一 法律谈判的概念辨析

(一)法律谈判的界定与评析

当代社会纠纷解决理念已然由“对抗转为协商”“追求单一价值转向实现多元价值”“输赢决斗转为争取双赢”,[1](p111)民众不再迷信诉讼万能,而是欲求搭建一个协商对话、共赢和谐的纠纷解决平台,以定纷止争,案结事了。除了调解、仲裁等较为传统和成熟的替代性纠纷解决机制外,法律谈判愈发受到推崇和重视。当前学界对法律谈判的界定不一,尚未形成共识。有学者认为法律谈判指为实现委托人利益,律师运用法律知识、谈判技能与对方磋商,达成合意的过程。[2](p5)该解释将谈判主体仅限定为律师,把其他法律人士介入排除在外,主体范围过于狭隘。……

登录APP查看全文