外科医师胜任力评价量表的编制和信效度检验
2018-12-12吴浩王菁佩
吴浩 王菁佩
【摘要】 目的:自编外科医师胜任力评价量表。方法:采用文献阅读、问卷调查、专家咨询法等构建量表,用360度反馈评价进行实证和信度效度检验。结果:编制7个维度5个层级10个等级的《外科医师胜任力评价量表》(The Competency Assessment Scale of Surgeon,CASS)。维度:理论知识、操作技术、逻辑思维、沟通技术、工作态度、适应能力、危机处理。总α系数0.934,基于标准化α系数0.936,各项已删除的α值在0.922~0.928间,组内相关系数均大于0.5,分半信度为0.886和0.891。与被评价对象实际工作量、质量等效标资料比较,两者非参数一致性检验肯德尔和谐系数为0.879。对不同年龄、职称、职务、绩效水平单因素分析,差异均有统计学意义(P<0.05)。结论:本量表具有较好的信度效度,可以用于评价外科医师胜任力。
【关键词】 外科医师; 胜任力; 量表; 信度; 效度
【Abstract】 Objective:To establish a surgeon competency assessment scale.Method:Using the literature reading,the questionnaire survey,the expert consultation method and so on construction scale.The 360 degree feedback evaluation was used to test the reliability and validity.Result:7 dimensions,5 levels and 10 levels of Competency Assessment Scale of Surgeon(CASS).Dimensions:theoretical knowledge,operation technology,logical thinking,communication technology,working attitude,adaptability,crisis handling.The total α coefficient was 0.934,based on the standardized alpha coefficient 0.936,the deleted α values ere between 0.922 to 0.928,the intra group correlation coefficients were all greater than 0.5,and the split half reliability were 0.886 and 0.891.Compared with the actual work load and the quality equivalent data of the evaluated object,the non parametric consistency test of Kendalls harmony coefficient was 0.879.The single factor analysis of different age,job title,job and performance level showed that the difference was statistically significant.Conclusion:This scale has good reliability and validity,and can be used to evaluate the competency of surgeons.
【Key words】 Surgeons; Competency; Scale; Reliability; Validity
First-authors address:Hunan Aerospace Hospital,Changsha 410205,China
doi:10.3969/j.issn.1674-4985.2018.24.037
自1959年Robert White提出胜任力概念并建立应用基础[1],McClelland[2]教授进一步奠定理论基础。胜任力多認为是与工作或工作绩效或生活中其他重要成果存在直接联系的知识、技能、能力、特质或动机。外科医师工作与其他医师有着显著区别,如疑难病症的诊断与治疗、急危重症的抢救的认识和经验[3]。特别是手术,与其能力关系密切,也是病人预后十分重要的影响因素。“21世纪医学教育展望报告”提出第三代医学教育改革将是基于岗位胜任力的变革[4]。标志现代医学教育发展的重大转折。美国已开发各专科医师胜任力评价表[5]。国内现有《卫生机构管理者胜任特征词典库》[6],外科医师胜任特征[7-8],汇总我国医疗领域胜任力研究等[9]。相关量表少,主要集中在护理和少数专科医师[10-11],也有将国外量表本土化改进、编译与评价[12-13]。……
