Comprehensive evaluation of energy efficiency in airline enterprise based on grey weight correlation
2018-07-24HongGENGShenglinYANGJingjieCHEN
Hong GENG, Sheng-lin YANG*, Jing-jie CHEN,3
(1College of Electronic Information & Automation, Civil Aviation University of China, Tianjin 300300, China) (2Research Centre for Environment and Sustainable Development of Civil Aviation Administration of China, Tianjin 300300, China) (3National Engineering Laboratory for Integrated Traffic Data Application Technology, Tianjin 300300, China)
Abstract: The energy efficiency analysis and evaluation for airline enterprises is the key content to ensure the effectiveness of energy efficiency optimization. With the principle of combining qualitative with quantitative, the comprehensive evaluation indicators system for energy efficiency of airline enterprises was established based on the analysis of the measured indicators and the influenced factors of energy efficiency. The combination weights of evaluation indicators were confirmed by analytic hierarchy process and information entropy. The comprehensive evaluation method was put forward based on grey weight correlation, and the energy efficiency development trend of airline enterprises was analyzed and evaluated by quantitative method. The case analysis show that the comprehensive evaluation for energy efficiency of airline enterprises is more objective to reflect the real situation of enterprise energy efficiency development, and the comprehensive evaluation method based on grey weight correlation is simple, scientific and practical for multi-objective decision making questions.
Key words: Indicators system, Combination weight, Grey weight correlation, Comprehensive evaluation
1 Introduction
Energy saving has received national attention with the situation of energy shortages. In order to promote the realization of energy saving and emission reduction, it is the most effective and realistic way to take the strategy of energy saving optimization at present. With the rapid development of airline enterprises, the pressure of energy saving and emission reduction will inevitably be increased. At the same time, as the focus industry of carbon emissions trading, it is very important for airline enterprises to carry out energy-saving optimization[1- 2]. It could find out the weak links of enterprise energy efficiency, and ensure the effectiveness of energy saving optimization work by constructing a comprehensive evaluation index system of energy efficiency of airline enterprises.
2 The definition of energy efficiencymeasuring indicators
The ratio of the product quantity or service output and the amount of energy input is the form of energy efficiency, which was given at 1995 by World Energy Council (WEC). But the input and output calculation methods of energy are different in different fields. Therefore, different measures of energy efficiency will be generated.
The measured indicators of energy efficiency includes economic energy efficiency indicators and physical energy efficiency indicators[3]. The energy consumption for unit output value indicator is used to reflect the economic energy efficiency. The economic revenue of airline enterprises is divided into aviation revenue and non-aviation revenue, the aviation revenue is directly related with energy consumption, such as transportation revenue and the aviation revenue are also affected by transport services pricing. The non-aviation revenue is not directly related with energy consumption, such as advertising revenue, travel or hotel accommodation commission. At the same time, the economic revenue of airline enterprises is not only to consider operating revenue, but also to the energy costs, the improvement of energy efficiency can not compensate for the negative impact of the growth of input prices and the decline of output prices on business revenue. Therefore, the economic energy efficiency indicators cannot reasonably reflect the energy efficiency of airline enterprises.
The physical energy efficiency includes three parts: mining efficiency, intermediate link efficiency and terminal utilization efficiency[4].For airline enterprises, there is no fact of energy efficiency and storage efficiency, because most of the energy is consumed immediately after the purchase, it does not include the processing of energy conversion, transportation and distribution links. The physical energy efficiency reflects the effective output of energy input, but it may ignore the invalid output, such as the carbon emission. The physical energy efficiency indicators is one-sided which will exaggerate the physical energy efficiency and ignore the impact on the environment, the evaluation of energy efficiency is unreasonable.
Therefore, the energy efficiency indicators of airline enterprises must include the energy system elements and the impact of energy consumption on the environment.
3 The construction of energy efficiency indicators system of airline enterprises
3.1 Analysis of subsystem of the indicators system
Airline enterprise is a high energy consuming enterprise, the development of enterprises are supported by the energy. At the same time, the consumption of energy will produce a negative impact on environment. While environment system provides a living environment for the development of airline enterprises, and airline enterprises need to invest a lot of capital to protect the environment system. In accordance with the international aviation emission reduction market mechanism resolution, by 2035, the domestic civil aviation enterprises will cost more than tens of billions dollars in carbon emission, the impact of energy consumption on environment of airline enterprise cannot be ignored.
The energy efficiency of airline enterprises is also affected by the internal energy-saving management factors in addition to the energy system and environmental system. With the increasing pressure of energy conservation and emission reduction, the airline enterprises will gradually increase the management of energy conservation and emission reduction. Airline enterprises generally believe that with the improvement of energy-saving management, the energy efficiency of airline enterprises will get increased by 1%~2% per year[5]. Therefore, the evaluation of energy-saving management is essential in the energy efficiency evaluation of airline enterprises.
3.2 Analysis of each subsystem
(1) Energy-saving management
The efficiency of energy-saving management is affected by many factors. The key indicators of energy conservation management evaluation of airline enterprises are analyzed, according to the Energy management systems-Requirements[6].
Top-down analysis of energy-saving management: on the one hand, energy-saving management originates from the energy-saving management planning. The energy-saving management planning determines the energy management programs and duties. The energy management planning is the core content of energy-saving management. Through the energy consumption analysis in each region of enterprise, it can identify the general area and the key area of the energy consumption, and formulate the reasonable energy-saving goal. On the other hand, the targets of energy-saving should be carried out in the vertical decomposition of the enterprise, and controlled with quota management.
Bottom-up analysis of energy-saving management: on the one hand, the energy measurement management is the basis for achieving the energy efficiency goals. It can grasp the context of energy consumption and mining potential of energy-saving through the accurate measurement of all kinds of energy consumption data. The airline enterprises should construct a three-level energy measurement network, which should meet the requirements of General principle for equipping and managing of the measuring instrument of energy in organization of energy using[7]. In the management of measurement instruments, the enterprises need to maintenance, testing, calibration and scrap the measuring instruments to ensure the accuracy of energy measurement. On the other hand, airline enterprises as a high-tech and modern service industry, it also needs a high requirement of the employees’ ability, the energy-saving ability of employees is the base to realize the goal of energy-saving management.
Therefore, the energy-saving management evaluation of airline enterprises should include four key indicators: energy saving planning, energy consumption quota management, energy measurement management and energy saving ability management.
(2) Energy system
Efficient energy utilization is one of the bases to improve enterprise energy efficiency in energy system. The fuel utilization efficiency of civil aircraft is the focus of airline enterprise, and also the focus of government management. In the ground energy system, there are mainly two kinds of calculation methods. One is the index of energy consumption per unit area of standard coal, the other is index of energy consumption per capita of standard coal. The energy consumption area of airline enterprises is relatively stable, but the number of personnel in the region is not stable, it is more reasonable to adopt the index of energy consumption per unit area of standard coal.
On the other hand, there are many kinds of ground energy consumption of airline enterprises, including heat, electricity, natural gas, diesel, gasoline and so on. If the ground energy structure is reasonable and high quality is closely related to energy efficiency. The efficiency of high quality energy such as electricity and natural gas are higher than those of coal, diesel and gasoline[8].
Therefore, in the energy system of airline enterprises, the evaluation of energy efficiency is from two aspects of energy structure and energy utilization.
(3) Environment system
In the environmental system, it mainly evaluates the degree of environmental impact caused by the use of energy, which reflects the negative impact of energy on the demand of airline enterprises. There are many kinds of energy consumption in airline enterprises, and the problem of pollution emission caused by energy consumption is the focus of airline enterprises in recent years. At the same time, all kinds of waste, such as domestic waste, office waste, etc., generated by the enterprises operation is also one of the key elements of environmental system evaluation.
3.3 The construction of energy efficiency indicators system
A comprehensive evaluation index system for energy efficiency of air transport enterprises could be established with 4 evaluation contents and 15 evaluation indexes, which are systematic, comprehensive, practical and representative.
4 Comprehensive evaluation of energy efficiency
4.1 The processing of index data
(1) Calculation of qualitative indicators
The qualitative assessment is launched by means of questionnaire. It will invite several experts in the field and quantify the qualitative index through the method of scoring, finally obtain the evaluation results by averaging the index score.
(2) Calculation of quantitative indicators
According to the contribution of energy efficiency, the quantitative indicators is divided into positive indicators (the greater the better) and negative indicators (the smaller the better). The data will be normalized by the threshold method so that the resulting values will be mapped between[0, 1].
The normalization of positive indicators:
(1)
The normalization of negative indicators:
(2)
Where,Riis the normalized indicator,Xiis the actual value of indicator during the assessment period,XmaxandXminare the maximum and minimum values of the indicators during the assessment period, respectively.
Table 1 Comprehensive evaluation indicators system for energy efficiency of airline enterprises

Comprehensive evaluation indicators systemfor energy efficiency ofairline enterprisesEnergy-saving managementEnergy structureEnergy utilizationEnvironment systemThe status of energy conservation management planThe status of energy consumption quota manage-mentThe status of energy metering managementThe status of energy-saving training managementExternal heat consumption proportionElectricity consumption proportionNatural gas consumption proportiondiesel and gasoline consumption proportionFuel consumption per unit turnoverHeating energy consumption per unit areaElectric energy consumption per unit areaNatural gas energy consumption per unit areaPer capita carbon emissionsPer capita polluted gas emissionsPer capita waste emissions
Note: all kinds of energy consumption were converted into standard coal.
Table 2 The scoring criteria of qualitative indicators

EvaluationABCDEScore9070503010
4.2 The calculation of the weight of indicators
The way to determine the weight of indicators includes subjective weighting and objective weighting. The subjective weighting relies on the relevant experience of domain experts, but it may ignore the inherent information of the indicators. The objective weighting avoids the influence of human factors, but it may ignore the actual importance of each indicator itself, and will not reflect the importance degree of the decision maker to different indicators. In the airline enterprise efficiency evaluation index system, which includes not only the basis of expert experience subjective qualitative evaluation index but also quantitative analysis index. In view of this situation, it uses the method combining AHP and entropy to determine the combined weight of each evaluation index, and makes the airline enterprises energy efficiency evaluation more objective and reasonable.
(1) Entropy method
① Normalize the indicators data, get the matrixR=(rij)m×n, wherem=4,n=15, the entropy of thejthindexej:
Where,i=1,2,…,m,j=1,2,…,n,k=1/lnm, which can certifyej∈[0,1],kis accommodation coefficient.
② Calculate the difference coefficientdjof theejindex, where the calculation formula isdj=1-ej, the importance of indexrjin the comprehensive evaluation is stronger whendjvalue is bigger.

(4)
(2) Determine the weightwjof indicators,the specific methods could be found in reference[9].
(3) The definition of combination weights

(5)
4.3 Comprehensive evaluation based on grey weight correlation
Grey relational analysis (GRA) is one of the methods of system engineering, and it is an effective method to excavate the internal rules of data. The essence of gray relational analysis method is that it can be used to analyze and evaluate the dynamic change process by calculating the degree of closeness between the evaluation object and the ideal object. It adopts the method of linear weighted calculation, and weights linear matrix and correlation coefficient matrix according to the importance of different indicators. The method of calculating grey relational analysis degree is as follows:
(6)
Where,i=1,2,…,m,j=1,2,…,n,ξoi(j) is the correlation coefficient at thejthindicator for the reference sequencex0with the comparison sequence:
(7)
Where,i=1,2,…,m,j=1,2,…,n,ρis the resolution coefficient, which is generally in the interval(0,1), the smaller the value, the more significant the difference between the correlation coefficient, setρ=0.5.
4.4 The case analysis
Converse the energy consumption data of a representative airline enterprise during 2011 to 2014, the value and weights of the indicators are as Table 3.
Determine the optimal index matrix:

The combined weight and gray correlation coefficient are calculated by Matlab.
Determine the optimal index matrix:

The combined weight and gray correlation coefficient are calculated by Matlab.
Gray weighted correlation ranking:γ2014>γ2013>γ2012>γ2011, which indicates that the comprehensive energy efficiency of airline enterprises in recent years gets increased year by year. The evaluation results objectively reflect the achievements of enterprises in recent years, such as energy saving optimization, energy conservation management and technical transformation.
Table 3 The data value, subjective weights and objective weights of evaluation indicators

Index2011201220132014Subjective weightObjective weightR1707575810.1250.010R2637075760.0940.007R3607576790.0840.076R4556065700.0340.054R555.6555.7254.8750.880.1110.056R616.9017.0218.3720.590.0740.074R79.759.789.8510.620.0470.049R817.0917.2516.8717.900.0410.096R90.3010.2950.2920.2890.1300.068R1024.9124.5723.4621.090.0570.101R1110.1010.6411.6312.100.0270.098R127.186.666.956.600.0230.075R1311.1010.6010.409.700.0630.106R140.560.620.580.520.0530.077R150.450.400.430.470.0370.055
Table 4 The combination weight and gray correlation coefficient of evaluation indicators

Indexcombination weight2011201220132014R10.0210.333 30.478 50.478 51R20.0110.333 30.519 80.866 61R30.1060.333 30.404 20.42191R40.0310.333 30.428 40.599 51R50.1040.336 50.333 30.377 61R616.900.333 30.340 80.453 71R70.0390.3330.341 30.361 01R80.0660.700 30.575 410.333 3R90.1470.333 30.500 00.666 71R100.0960.333 30.354 60.446 01R110.04410.649 40.395 30.333 3R120.0290.333 30.829 20.453 31R130.1120.333 30.437 40.500 01R140.06 80.555 60.333 30.454 51R150.0340.411 910.538 20.333 3Grey weight correlation γi0.405 00.455 00.520 60.904 0
5 Conclusions
The comprehensive evaluation method of energy efficiency is established on the basis of grey weighted correlation degree, through the construction of energy efficiency evaluation index system for airline enterprises and the development trend of airline enterprises energy efficiency is studied in this paper. The evaluation system and method has been verified with the energy consumption data of a typical domestic airline enterprise in 2011—2014. The main conclusions could be drawn as follows:
1) It is very important for energy saving and energy efficiency optimization of airline enterprises to construct a scientific and reasonable index system of airline enterprises energy efficiency. The system is the basis to ensure the validity of the evaluation results.
2) This evaluation system combines subjective wei-ght and objective weight so that it can avoid subjective color in the process of determining the weight coefficient. At the same time, it pays attention to the importance of the evaluation index, and makes full use of the information of the evaluation index.
3) The grey weighted correlation degree evaluation method has a lower requirement on the number of samples, and the optimal value of the sample can be used as the reference standard. It solves the problem that the evaluation standard is difficult to be solved.
Acknowledgements
Supported by National Key Technology Research and Development Program of the Ministry of Science and Technology of China(No.2012BAC20B03) and Energy Saving and Emission Reduction Program of Civil Aviation Administration of China(No.DPDSR0010)
杂志排行
机床与液压的其它文章
- Optimization method of prefabricated building project procedure based on QPSO algorithm
- Occupant protection evaluation for rear-end crash based on integrated simulation
- Background modeling based on improved parameter estimation for moving target detection
- Control method of engine switch based on power tracing constraint
- Security architecture of Internet of things using recursive encryption algorithm and CoAP
- Mixed image noise removal based on non-local self-similar dictionary learning
