APP下载

Arsenic distribution and source in groundwater of Yangtze River Delta economic region, China

2017-12-16ZHOUXun

地下水科学与工程(英文版) 2017年4期

ZHOU Xun

1 School of Environment Studies, China University of Geoscience, Wuhan 430074, China.

2 Nanjing Center, China Geology Survey, Nanjing 210016, China.

Abstract: This thesis focuses Arsenic (As) distribution and occurrence in groundwater of Yangtze River Delta economic region, East China. 2019 groundwater samples were collected to analyze 26 chemical compositions, including As. The Principal Component Analysis (PCA) was used to find out As source in groundwater. The results show that average As concentration in groundwater of this study is 9.33 μg/l, and maximum As concentration is up to 510 μg/l. The variation coefficient is 314.34%. High arsenic phreatic water (>10 μg/l) distributes along the Yangtze River and its estuary. Weak hydrodynamic conditions, wide pH value variation range and deteriorating environment are dominating factors, especially in Yangtze River Delta. The PCA suggests that arsenic in phreatic water is mainly of natural origin. Part of arsenic may directly originate from sediment organics and be related to organics decomposition.

Keywords: Groundwater; Arsenic; Distribution; Source; Yangtze River Delta economic region

Introduction

The high arsenic groundwater due to natural processes is recognized to be one of the most serious environmental geological problems,challenging the international community (Krishna M et al. 2001). The international researches on natural high arsenic groundwater are mainly carried out in Brahmaputra River Delta (Aziz Z et al. 2017),the Meghna River Delta (Smedley P L and Kinniburgh D G, 2002) and Alaska region (HAN Zi-ye et al. 2007). Such researches in China are mainly conducted in Datong Basin of Shanxi Province (WANG Yan-xin et al. 2010; GUO Hua-ming et al. 2003; Su C L and Wang Y X, 2008),Hetao Plain (GAO Cun-rong et al. 2008; Zhang Y L et al. 2010; GUO Hua-ming et al. 2010), and Pearl River Delta (Huang G X et al. 2014). Some scholars also touch upon other areas (Yin N Y et al.2017; Chen X M et al. 2017).

The Yangtze River Delta economic region is one of the most economically-developed and densely-populated areas in China. Phreatic water is under dispersed exploitation to be supplementary source of drinking water without any treatment in most cases. Therefore, the arsenic in phreatic water will have negative effect on people’s health. From 2006 to 2009, China Geological Survey carried out groundwater pollution investigation in this area.The chemical test of 2019 groups of phreatic water sample were analyzed to figure out arsenic distribution qualities, occurrence environment and sources as these factors play an important role in ensuring drinking water safety.

1 Materials and methods

1.1 Study area

The study area covers 65 000 km2of land in the Yangtze River Delta and adjacent plains. This area is the world’s sixth largest urban agglomerations with highest population density in China. Alluvial,lacustrine and marine plain are the main forms in this area with a few hills developing in the western,southern and central parts. The original slope of plain area is approximately 1/10 000 and the general surface is at an altitude of 6 m. It is of north subtropical monsoon climate with average annual rainfall of 1 000-1 900 mm. The average annual temperature is between 13-18 ℃. Drainage density ranges from 6-7 km/km2to 14-20 km/km2in some specific area. The Yangtze River is the largest river of China which enters the sea.

1.2 Sample collection, processing and analysis

Being part of groundwater pollution investigation project (the Chinese national project 1999-2009), 2019 groups of phreatic water sample were collected in Yangtze River Delta in 2006, 2007,2008 and 2009.

The majority of these samples were collected from open wells with depths of 3-10 m by fixed depth samplers. All samples were stored in polyethylene plastic bottles (1.5 l/350 ml) and tested in two labs and all the physicochemical parameters, such as the pH value, were tested under same conditions. Every sample was divided into three parts and used for different uses. Water samples were tested according to standard methods(China national standard), including ion chromatography with instrument Dionex-2500 for,, Cl-, and F-; titration forand; inductively coupled plasma atomic emission spectrometry (GB/T5750.6-2006) with the instrument iCAP6000 Series for Ca2+, Mg2+, Na+,K+, Fe and H2SiO3; high resolution inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry (HR-ICP-MS)determination with the instrument ICS900-iCAPQ for Al, Mn, Cd, Pb, Zn and Cu; atomic fluorescence spectrometry for As, Sb, Hg; spectrophotometer for Cr6+and NO2-; continuous flow chemical analyzer for NH4+and inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry for I-.

2 Discussion

2.1 The arsenic distribution in phreatic water of Yangtze River Delta

Of all the 2019 phreatic water samples, the detected arsenic rate is 54.63%. The average arsenic concentration is 9.43 μg/l with the highest concentration of 510 μg/l. The variation coefficient is 314.34%。

In most area of Yangtze River Delta, the arsenic concentration in phreatic water is low (<5 μg/l).Samples with higher concentrations than 10 μg/l are mainly collected from Taizhou and Nantong area alternately along the River. Relatively high arsenic samples (10 μg/l-50 μg/l) are discovered in northern Taizhou area and the coastal region of Qidong area. The arsenic distribution in phreatic water of Yangtze River Delta suggests that the arsenic gradually increases from east to west, and decreases by the distance from the Yangtze River(Fig. 1).

2.2 Arsenic occurrence in groundwater

The occurrence environment of high arsenic groundwater usually shares same features like in arid or semi-arid areas and inland basin closure such as Datong Basin in northern China, Hetao Plain as well as in the aquifer under heavilydeteriorating conditions in alluvial formation, such as Bangladesh and Bangladesh state area in India.

Although high arsenic groundwater doesn’t distribute all over the Yangtze River Delta, part of it has been found in typical alluvial formation under heavily-deteriorating conditions. Qualities of such kind of water are as follows:

2.2.1 The hydrodynamic conditions

Pore water aquifer Group in Yangtze River Delta consists of the Holocene lacustrine facies,alluvial lake facies and estuaries facies with clay,loam, sandy loam and silt composition (Fig. 2). The groundwater hydrodynamic conditions featured by γCl-/γCa-in the Yangtze River Delta decrease from west to east. The area with weak hydrodynamic conditions is almost of high arsenic (Fig. 3), which is consistent with that relatively weak hydrodynamic conditions lead to arsenic enrichment(WANG Yan-xin et al. 2010). Compared with arsenic enrichment by evaporation of groundwater in North China, such as Datong Basin, this rule As does not apply well in the Yangtze River Delta area with larger spatial scales.

2.2.2 Oxidation-reduction environment

The correlation between arsenic concentration and the concentration of SO42-and NO3-is that arsenic increases gradually as SO42and NO3-decrease (Fig. 4 and Fig. 5). This phenomenon shows that As in phreatic water related to the redox conditions of aquifer system and deteriorating environment lead to the increasing of arsenic content in groundwater (Smedley P L and Kinniburgh D G, 2002).

The analysis of samples with concentrations higher than 10 µg/l shows that there is negative correlation between arsenic content and SO42-while the correlation between arsenic content and NO3-is not clearly (Fig. 6; Fig. 7). It suggests the high arsenic concentration in phreatic water cannot be completely attributed to the deteriorating environment.

2.2.3 The variation range of pH value

The pH value of phreatic water in the Yangtze River Delta area ranges from 3.45 to 9.42. pH value range of more than 97% samples is 6-8. More than half of the phreatic water in the Yangtze River Delta is under neutral to slightly alkaline environment conditions. The wide range of pH value enables various arsenic content in phreatic water. The correlation between arsenic content and pH value of phreatic water is shown in Fig. 8.

Fig. 1 Distribution of arsenic concentration in the phreatic water of Yangtze River Delta

Table 1 The arsenic content of the main rivers in Yangtze River Delta

Fig. 2 The aquifer lithology of Yangtze River Delta

Fig. 3 The hydrodynamic conditions of phreatic water in Yangtze River Delta (γCl-/γCa-)

Fig. 4 The correlation between arsenic content and sulfate content in phreatic water

Fig. 5 The correlation between arsenic content and nitrate content in phreatic water

Fig. 6 The correlation between arsenic content and sulfate content of high arsenic phreatic water (>50 µg/l)

Fig. 7 The correlation between arsenic content and sulfate content of high arsenic phreatic water (>50 µg/L)

Fig. 8 The correlation between arsenic content and pH value of phreatic water

2.3 The arsenic sources in phreatic water

2.3.1 Local sources of arsenic in phreatic water

The background research shows that groundwater arsenic comes from iron and manganese in aquifer and overlying soil. The arsenic content of Quaternary loose layer in Yangtze River Delta reaches 11.50 mg/kg (ZENG Zhao-hua, 1996), which explains the general sources of arsenic in phreatic water.

On the other hand, the sediment arsenic of main rivers in this region shows that high arsenic in groundwater along the Yangtze River, especially in western Huangpu River may have something to do with the sediments in Huangpu River.

2.3.2 Arsenic sources in high arsenic groundwater

The sources of arsenic whose concentration is higher than 50 μg/l in groundwater were discussed by PCA (Huang G Xet al. 2013). This research was based on SPSS with the correlation coefficient matrix of maximum varimax orthogonal rotation method. The analysis objects are 25 water chemistry indicators of those high arsenic samples.The factor feature values and cumulative contribution rate after rotating the matrix are shown in Table 2.

The cumulative contribution rate of the first 6 variables was 89.20%, higher than 85%. Among them, the first factor accounts for 42.93%, 22.32%,6.69%, 6.50%, 5.86% and 4.91% for the second to sixth factors respectively. The characteristic values of the 6 variables after rotation are more than 1,which means no information loss. The extracted six factors actually represent comprehensive information on 25 water chemistry indicators. Convergence appeared after 8 iterations.

The first principal component is related to the total hardness, TDS, pH, Mg2+, K+, Na+, Cl-, SO42-,Fe, Mn, Zn, Pb and I-. Among these indicators,TDS, pH, Na+, and Cl-are the normal indexes in the natural groundwater. K+, Na+and Mg+are the main elements of rocks coming from the ion exchange adsorption, the formation of the seawater intrusion and the mixing of the water in the aquifer and the leaching process. The migration and transformation process of those elements derived from the aquifer and overlying rock such as Fe,Mn, Pb and Zn, is closely related to the redox conditions together with the acidity and alkalinity of groundwater. The phreatic water of this area is basically in a deteriorating environment. The Fe and Mg of high valence state in groundwater are easy to convert into Mn2+and Fe2+of low valence state. The wide pH range of phreatic water makes Pb easy to convert into the sulfide precipitation. It also enables Zn to be easily adsorbed in neutral and weak alkaline environment and form a stable complex in weak acid environment. Fluoride,chloride, iodide and other halogen elements come from the lixiviation of aquifer, overlying rock and soil. They are also considered to be related to sedimentary environment and fresh-salt water mixing effect. Some research shows that the iodide migration is linked to the organic adsorption effect(ZENG Zhao-hua, 1996). In summary, the first principal component basically reflects the natural background of groundwater and shows material source as well as migration and transformation process of groundwater are natural process with large spatial scale and long time span.

The second principal component is more relevant to Ca2+, NH4+, F-, Hg, Al and COD. These elements are related to both natural background and human activities. For example, Ca2+belongs to rock forming elements which indicates natural background and NH4+indicates the effect of domestic sewage and agricultural activities (LI Ye et al. 2011).

The third principal component, which shows that HCO3-and As are related to biological decomposition (organic matter oxidation),indicates that arsenic source is related to the decomposition process. High arsenic groundwater sample often has high HCO3-content (WANG Yan-xin et al. 2010). This phenomenon may connect to microbial activity process because the microorganism decomposition generates much HCO3-. At the same time, there is adsorption competition between the HCO3-and As anion to some extent (WANG Yan-xin et al. 2010).Therefore, part of high arsenic phreatic water is considered to come directly from organic sediments and microorganism decomposition process.

The Fourth, fifth or sixth principal components are related to Cd, NO3-, NO2-respectively, which shows that the three substances have independent sources. There is very weak correlation between these indicators and other groups. Due to mutual transformation relations among NH4+, NO3-, NO2-,the method is not ideal for the above three indicators.

2.4 Comparative study of the formation mechanism of high arsenic phreatic water

As mentioned above, the arsenic of phreatic water in the Yangtze River Delta mainly comes from the aquifer, overlying rock and soil. The migration and transformation process of arsenic in groundwater are mainly controlled by the pH value and the redox conditions. Compared to the typical high arsenic groundwater in North China, the high arsenic groundwater in this area has a more wide pH variation range and more complex chemical type.

The researches on Datong basin and Hetao Plan in North China show that As (III) is the main form of arsenic in typical high arsenic groundwater and there is a positive correlation between arsenic and Fe/Mn. But all the 2019 samples of this area show weak negative correlations between arsenic and ion in groundwater (Fig. 9). Only among those samples with higher arsenic content, arsenic content and the 3 valence iron content have a weak positive correlation (Fig. 10). It suggests that the relatively high arsenic phreatic water may not result from iron hydroxides desorption.

Table 3 The statistic qualities of As content in phreatic water from different land use type (µg/l)

The analysis of the correlation between As content and pH value of all samples, especially high arsenic water samples show (Fig. 8) that arsenic has hardly been detected in groundwater when pH=5, which suggests arsenic content is related to adsorption of clay minerals because the optimal adsorption of the clay minerals to As (V)is maxim when pH=5. On the other hand, by analyzing samples with arsenic higher than 50 μg/l,we can see that main chemical type of high arsenic content phreatic water is Na-HCO3. The pH variation range is 5.9-8.2 and the average value is 7.05. The correlation between pH value and arsenic content in phreatic water can be seen in Fig. 11. The samples with relatively high arsenic content focus around pH=7, which suggests As (V)is one of the As sources in groundwater and related to the desorption of the aluminum hydroxide(Thornburg K and Sahai N, 2004).

3 Conclusion

1) The characteristic of arsenic distribution of phreatic water in The Yangtze River Delta economic region shows that the general arsenic content in all the samples is relatively low and arsenic spatial distribution is uneven. The high arsenic content samples are mainly distributed along the river and located in estuary area.

2) The relatively weak hydrodynamic conditions, wide pH value range and deteriorating environment are the dominating factors of Arsenic content, especially the high arsenic groundwater.

3) Arsenic source in regional phreatic water is mainly of natural origin. The formation of some high arsenic groundwater is affected by human activities and closely related to the domestic pollution. Part of the direct As source in local phreatic water is considered to be related to the organic sediments and microorganism decomposition process.

Fig. 9 The correlation between arsenic content and iron content in phreatic water

Fig. 10 The correlation between arsenic content and three valent iron content in phreatic water

Fig. 11 The correlation between arsenic content and pH value of high arsenic phreatic water (>50 µg/l)

Acknowledgements

This thesis is supported by the National Natural Science Foundation of China (Grant No. 41302209)and the National groundwater investigation project(Grant No.1212011121169). The data and other statistic materials are supported by China Geology Survey.


登录APP查看全文