Possible Tendencies of World Pattern and Options for China
2016-12-17HUANGPING
HUANG PING
Research Professor and Director of Institute of European Studies, Chinese Academy of Social Sciences
Possible Tendencies of World Pattern and Options for China
HUANG PING
Research Professor and Director of Institute of European Studies, Chinese Academy of Social Sciences

POSSIBlE TENDENCIES OF WORlD PATTERN
1. “Eastward Power Shift”
This is a matter of great concern for some of the people in American strategic circle. A decade and more after the“9/11” happens to witness the process of rapid development of China in becoming one of the emerging economies of the world. Since 2012, the country has overtaken Japan in terms of GDP. According to current trend of development, given the China’s economy will grow at the rate of 6 to 6.5% per year under the new normal, it will be on the fore front of the world economy in a decade, to say nothing about the conditions by the counting of PPP. The“US decline” is, for the moment, a state of affairs worrying the US strategic circle (including diplomatic, defense, intelligence and academic circles) a great deal, even though in terms of“comprehensive national strength”such as economy, military, science and technology and resources there is still quite a distance between China and the US, and China does not entertain the strategic aspirations to replace the US. However, it is the scope, the pace and the trend of China’s development that worries the US. In this context, it is not difficult to understand the occurrence of “pivot to Asia” and “rebalancing the Asia-Pacific”. The main content of “pivot to Asia” is to take Asia for center of US energy instead of either remaining in the Middle East for “war on terror”or continuing to deploy sizable troops in Europe. Of course, this time around, the US does not use the method of the Korean War, the Vietnam War or the Cold War, not even the method used by George W. Bush against Iraq but“smart power”, “advanced deployment”and “advanced diplomacy” instead.
Behind such a method, there is a basic assumption that it is the intent of the US to prevent an “eastward power shift”. A “power shift” like that has happened for several times in the modern history of capitalism, shifting from Italy to the Netherland, from the Netherland to the UK, and from the UK to the US, during the whole period there being several crises and challenges including the two world wars. Even after the power shift to the US, there was the Cold War lasting for more than forty years. As such, since the US harbors the aspiration to keep its “global leadership”, it is only natural for it to have strategic misgivings or concerns about the rise of China.
However, if one knows about China’s modern history for over a century and its course of development for the past decades, and if he understands China’s national strategy and the institutions and culture behind it, it will be difficult for him to find on the part of China motivation for “power shift”. If one correctly estimates the historical position and the comprehensive national strength of the US, he will see that it is less than possible for “power to move the other away” from the US in decades to come. Especially, if he gains insight to the trend of contemporary world development, and if he has a more comprehensive understanding of the international environment, he will see that it is very difficult for a “power shift” in the original sense of the word to reoccur. As for China, it does not desire or want such a “power”. China does not need it and will not have it. To say China does not desire it is because of China entertaining no such ambition or goal. And to say China does not need it is because of the nature of the Chinese state and its social system deciding against it.
2. US-China Contest
US-China contest is a nomenclature put forward by relatively more pragmatic Americans. It includes the proposition for G2 and a so-called“Chimerica”. Some of the people calling for “rebalancing” also see the fact that China is rising, and it is their belief that that it should not and cannot simply do to repeat the method of USSoviet confrontation as in the Cold War with China for arms race and “balance of nuclear terror”. Therefore, they return to strategic hedging, to conduct“engagement and containment” and to choose to give emphasis between the two. If China is strong (to be strong or to look strong), then the US will enlarge the side of containment. If China is weak (to be weak or to look weak), then it will stress more on the side of engagement. Or, given that China does not change much, if the US feels to be strong, it will stress more on the side of engagement, and if it feels to be weak, it will enhance the side of containment.
As for China, in achieving the two centennial development goals and the progress toward realizing the Chinese Dream, its biggest opponent in contest is indeed the US, and it cannot choose otherwise. China does not entertain the subjective intention to challenge the US, making it clear time and again that the Pacific is large enough to hold China and the US and even formally proposing the construction of a new model of major-country relationship with the US. It is China’s intent to seek not only non-conflict and non-confrontation with the US but also mutual respect and mutually beneficial cooperation in order to get out of the dilemma of zero-sum game. After all, the US is the sole superpower and hegemony of the world today, which should not be overlooked. When the US stresses the side of containment, China cannot but take reactive responses.
It is worth noting that “contest” is not necessarily antagonistic, even less moving towards war. In economic, trade, cultural, social and local government relations, China and the US have got in each a bit of the other and become inseparable. There is contest even in cooperation, which, as far as mutually beneficial, will mean winwin situation, even though the benefit is not always necessarily half and half to both parties. In this regard, the strategic option of “China-US contest” is, at least, more pragmatic than “power shift”, except that the world does not only belong to China and the US and that the “players” are more than the largest developed country and the largest developing one.
3. “A Tripod Standing on Three Pillars”
The Europeans do not take China-US contest for all the fundamentals of the world pattern. Europe and the EU in particular, remain to be one of the most important economic, political and cultural forces of the world. In spite of the recent Brexit referendum, in regard of the practical balance of power of the world forces and development potential, whoever belittles Europe and the EU will makes strategic misjudgment at his own peril. Europe is the birthplace of enlightenment of modern civilization and the opener of modernity as well as the forerunner of regional reorganization (integration) in an attempt to transcend the tendency of existing power pattern. It is also the most powerful pole in today’s world in terms of comprehensive economic, political, social and cultural strength.
A survey of the world reveals that North America, Europe and Asia are the three most dynamic regions of the world. In North America, the US is the sole dominant, Canada and Mexico being no match to the US at all. Europe, with or without the UK, far surpasses Asia in regional integration, although Asia is the most peopled region, the fastest one in development with the greatest potentials. In short, to speak about the world pattern, a tripod standing on three pillars of North America, Europe and Asia would be, for the time being, a most realistic description of the fundamentals. Each of the three regions has its strong points and weakness. In terms of geo-plates, the three regions are the strongest and the most influential. It will be an important variable of the world pattern for a period to come in the future how the three plates coordinate, cooperate, compete and make compromise with each other.
To persevere in peaceful development is both decided by China’s moral height and the essence of its institutions and objectively required by the contemporary times and the trend of the world.
4. A Multi-Polar World
An even more realistic description would be that since the end of the Cold War, with a short period of “the sole hegemony of a lone superpower”, the world has moved toward multipolarity. Besides the three plates of North America, Europe and Asia, Africa and Latin America endeavor to catch up. India has joined the ranks of the emerging economies. Russia’s development strategy and foreign policy have its own special features. It will make a difference in the posture of the world pattern no matter if Russia in strategic terms leans to the East or the West. As China’s partner of strategic coordination for the past twenty years, Russia has been for years a major country in terms of science and technology, defense and resources. Like Russia, India is both a major country in geopolitics and a neighbor of China. Japan has all along been an advanced economy in the world and also the most important military ally of the US in Asia. It has continued to try to revise its constitution to assume the status of a “normal country”. In this perspective, if one says that the world has moved and will continue to move toward multipolarity, it will not be too far-fetched from the reality of the world pattern. In general, the world today is one moving towards multipolarity, in multilateral contest and of multi-possibilities. The biggest and strongest of the day will not necessarily keep all its advantages, to say the less about the fact that the strong have their weakness and the weak have their strong points. In a world moving towards multipolarity, it depends on how countries interact with one another if they will be good or bad, strong or weak.
5. Order or Disorder?
What is at issue is that in such multipolar interactions, there is a lack of a set of rules recognized and abided in common by the international community for the world order. After all, the Westphalian system has been around for centuries and it is more than seventy years since the end of the World War II. Since the end of the Cold War, the world has been ushered in a new round of globalization not only in commodities, capital and technological knowhow but also in instant horizontal distribution of information and more and more migrant population across countries (either in the form of doing business, studying abroad, making holidays or in the form of boat people, immigrants and refugees). In face of all the new conditions, the countermeasures of the framework of the United Nations or any other frameworks are insufficient to harness or control the situation. From Davos to Boao and from the G7 to the G20, the international community has not produced, to date, an effective world order recognized by all. A more vivid description would be a “G0 World”. Where is the new order? How long will it take to get one? At what cost? These questions need to be answered, wherefore the goal for the endeavors of the international community is clear,towards a world pattern for peace, security, justice, mutual benefit and winwin situation. But what is the route to get there? It should be consultation, negotiation, dialogue and cooperation. However, some of the countries and international organizations, though being in the 21st century in body, remain in the 20th century and even the 19th century in thinking. Besides the zerosum game and the law of jungle, they do not seem to know or would not like to know that there are other possibilities.
As such, one cannot rule out that the world will experience a period of lacking order or losing order. It depends on objective situation and subjective efforts how long that period will be. On the one hand, the situation is stronger than people. And on the other, history is created by people.
CHINA’S STRATEGIC OPTIONS
1.Peaceful Development
To persevere in peaceful development is both decided by China’s moral height and the essence of its institutions and objectively required by the contemporary times and the trend of the world. Neither the zero-sum game nor the law of the jungle will work for China or is in line with its fundamental and long-term development. Since the founding of New China, from the proposition of the Five Principles of Peaceful Coexistence to the establishment of peace and development as the theme of the times, China has kept to this road, which has brought China development and security. Therefore, this will not change and there is no reason for a change.
2.Mutual Benefit and Win-Win Situation
Peaceful development does not mean that China is soft and weak and invites bullies but that under the international environment for peace and development, the country seeks a winwin situation through mutual benefit from economic trade to investment and from relations to cooperation. China does not want to develop itself by pillaging others. Nor is it possible for China to do so. No matter where China conduct economic and trade relations, it does not follow the zero-sum logics of I-win-you-lose, but goes by a new outlook of righteousness and benefit, sharing benefit of development with local societies. Only such a development is the one welcome by local population and therefore is sustainable.
3.Innovation and openness
Beyond doubt, such a development strategy calls for a strong sense of innovation and openness. In the past centuries, the zero-sum game and the law of the jungle have been prevalent in the world. In the jungle of anarchy in the international community, it seems to have become a divine code of conduct that the winner takes all and the victor becomes the king. However, China has probed for decades for innovation on the international relations and the world affairs for“peaceful development and mutual benefit in win-win cooperation”. In the past few years, China has been more clear-cut, more self-conscious and more proactive, deriving from its confidence in its own institutions and from its sober judgment of the trend of the world. The more a country takes an innovative road, the more it will persevere in openness, keeping an open posture not only in policy perseverance but also in cultural learning and absorption, being open not only to the West but also to the rest of the world. Such an openness is no longer to fight between one another or you-win-I-lose but inclusion and sharing with all.
4.Inclusiveness and Learning from One Another
Inclusiveness is not just to be tolerant but to learn from one another, comparing notes and learning from others’ strong points and close the gap. The long lasting history has taught China that everyone has his advantages and disadvantages. Each country, each society and each culture has its raison d’être. To have self-confidence is to appreciate one’s own form of beauty. But only to do so is not adequate. In a more and more interdependent world, it is necessary to learn to appreciate the form of beauty of others. No matter how long standing China’s own culture is, or how superior others consider their own cultures, only by going beyond cultural arrogance and prejudice of each other, can all learn widely from others’ strong points and contribute to a new world and a new future. As such, beauty can be spotted anywhere anytime will no longer be empty talk.
5.Holding Fast Its Position
A long march starts with the first step. As long as a nation exists, its national interest will exist. When the nation and the national interest remain the basic necessities for China, its openness and inclusiveness cannot but be principled. The position of the country is the position of its people, which is to stand for the fundamental interest of the people, a position that integrate happiness of the people, development of the society and security of the country. Development and security are two sides of the same coin. Without development, security has no guarantee. Without security, development is either impossible to happen or only to find its results be destroyed overnight.
6. Keeping the bottom-line
In fact, both the Westphalian system and the system of the United Nations are based on the respect for sovereignty and territorial integrity of countries. On this basis, common defense for world peace, security and stability should be a principle to be followed in common by all. If some of the countries go by it whereas others do not, then there will be no peace. Nor will there be international security or stability in the world situation. Whatever the tendency of the world pattern will be, peace and security remain the premise, and development and prosperity, the overall objectives, and stability and justice, the very bottom-line. If all countries work to maintain stability and justice, there will be security. Otherwise, it will be inevitable to fall into security dilemma, the prisoner’s dilemma and the Thucydides’s trap.
杂志排行
Contemporary World的其它文章
- Balance, Rationality and Developmental Perspective Are the Key to Assess Sino-African Ties
- British Political Economy in Post-EU Era and China-UK Relations
- US-Japan Containment against China Can Only Make China Rise Faster
- China’s Neighborhood Environment and Options for Neighborhood Strategy
- Assessing Current Asia-Pacific Political Situation
- Theory of Community of Shared Future for Mankind in Xi Jinping Diplomatic Thought
