Postural control deficits identify lingering post-concussion neurological deficits
2016-04-25ThomsBuckleyJessieOldhmJclynCcceseDeprtmentofKinesiologyndAppliedPhysiologyInterdisciplinryProgrminBiomechnicsndMovementScience150HumnPerformnceLortoryUniversityofDelwreNewrkDE19716USAInterdisciplinryprogrminBiomechnicsnd
Thoms A.Buckley*,Jessie R.Oldhm,Jclyn B.Cccese,Deprtment of Kinesiology nd Applied Physiology,Interdisciplinry Progrm in Biomechnics nd Movement Science,150 Humn Performnce Lortory,University of Delwre,Newrk,DE 19716,USAInterdisciplinry progrm in Biomechnics nd Movement Science,University of Delwre,Newrk,DE 19716,USA Received 1 Mrch 2015; revised 26 My 2015; ccepted 20 Novemer 2015 Aville online 11 Jnury 2016
Postural control deficits identify lingering post-concussion neurological deficits
Thomas A.Buckleya,b,*,Jessie R.Oldhama,Jaclyn B.Caccesea,baDepartment of Kinesiology and Applied Physiology,Interdisciplinary Program in Biomechanics and Movement Science,150 Human Performance Laboratory,University of Delaware,Newark,DE 19716,USAbInterdisciplinary program in Biomechanics and Movement Science,University of Delaware,Newark,DE 19716,USA Received 1 March 2015; revised 26 May 2015; accepted 20 November 2015 Available online 11 January 2016
Peer review under responsibility of Shanghai University of Sport.
* Corresponding author.
E-mail address: TBuckley@UDel.edu (T.A.Buckley)
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.jshs.2016.01.007
2095-2546/©2016 Production and hosting by Elsevier B.V.on behalf of Shanghai University of Sport.
Abstract
Concussion,or mild traumatic brain injury,incidence rates have reached epidemic levels and impaired postural control is a cardinal symptom.The purpose of this review is to provide an overview of the linear and non-linear assessments of post-concussion postural control.The current acute evaluation for concussion utilizes the subjective balance error scoring system (BESS) to assess postural control.While the sensitivity of the overall test battery is high,the sensitivity of the BESS is unacceptably low and,with repeat administration,is unable to accurately identify recovery.Sophisticated measures of postural control,utilizing traditional linear assessments,have identified impairments in postural control well beyond BESS recovery.Both assessments of quiet stance and gait have identified lingering impairments for at least 1 month post-concussion.Recently,the application of non-linear metrics to concussion recovery have begun to receive limited attention with the most commonly utilized metric being approximate entropy (ApEn).ApEn,most commonly in the medial-lateral plane,has successfully identified impaired postural control in the acute post-concussion timeframe even when linear assessments of instrumented measures are equivalent to healthy pre-injury values; unfortunately these studies have not gone beyond the acute phase of recovery.One study has identified lingering deficits in postural control,utilizing Shannon and Renyi entropy metrics,which persist at least through clinical recovery and return to participation.Finally,limited evidence from two studies suggest that individuals with a previous history of a single concussion,even months or years prior,may display altered ApEn metrics.Overall,non-linear metrics provide a fertile area for future study to further the understanding of postural control impairments acutely post-concussion and address the current challenge of sensitive identification of recovery.
©2016 Production and hosting by Elsevier B.V.on behalf of Shanghai University of Sport.
Keywords:Balance; Concussion; Mild traumatic brain injury; Postural control; Variability
1.Concussion overview
The National Institute of Health has deemed concussion,a mild traumatic brain injury (mTBI),a major public health disorder.1Concussions have reached epidemic levels both epidemiologically and in the popular media.2,3Indeed,the discussion of concussion permeates major sporting events from the Super Bowl to the World Cup to the Olympic Games.4,5There are estimated 1.6-3.8 million concussions which occur annually in the US; however,between 50% and 80% of concussions may go underreported either through intentional non-disclosure or lack of injury recognition.6-8However,sports and recreation related concussions comprise only a small minority (4%-11%) of all head injuries in children in the United States.9Beyond sports and recreation,TBI has been referred to as the signature injury of the current military engagements in Iraq and Afghanistan with up to 23% of active deployment military personal suffering an mTBI.10The costs associated with all TBI exceed US$60 billion annually in direct and indirect costs with mTBI comprising 75%-90% of all TBIs with an annual economic burden of~US$22 billion alone.11,12
While many neurological pathologies are associated with specific supraspinal structures or pathways,the pathophysiology of concussion is less well understood.13Frequently described as a functional injury,recent advances in imaging have identified microstructural anatomical damage postconcussion.13The acute pathophysiology,often termed the neurometabolic cascade,is associated with elevated glutamate,potassium,and calcium levels resulting in an energy crisis due to impaired mitochondrial dysfunction.13This process does notaffect a specific structure or pathway,rather it is termed a “spreading depression”in which diffuse areas of the brain are affected.13Although some recent human studies have suggested prolonged recovery,animal studies indicate that reduced cerebral blood flow and glucose metabolism persist for up to 7-10 days post-concussion which correlates well with symptom resolution.13-16Thus,it is not surprising that the 4th International Consensus Statement on Concussion in Sports suggests that 80%-90% of concussions recover,based on standard clinical markers,within this same 7- to 10-day window.2Herein,clinical recovery refers to achieving baseline (pre-morbid) values on the assessment battery utilized by the clinicians which typically includes assessment of concussion related symptoms,cognition,balance,and computerized neuropsychological tests.2
The consequences of concussion include elevated risks acutely,the potential for recurrent concussions,and later life neuropathological consequences.Specifically,in the acute post-concussion period there is a risk of the rare,but potentially fatal and debated,second impact syndrome which is believed to occur when a subsequent head impact occurs prior to resolution of the neurometabolic cascade.17,18Furthermore,there is an elevated risk of recurrent concussion which will likely present worse and have prolonged recovery as well as the recent suggestion of increased risk of non-concussion sports injuries.19-21The well-publicized long-term complications of repeated concussions include elevated risk of clinically diagnosed depression,mild cognitive impairment,earlier onset of Alzheimer’s disease and the much discussed,albeit debated,chronic traumatic encephalopathy.22-24Finally,there is even emerging evidence for elevated rate of future traumatic death amongst individuals in the general population who suffered mTBI.25
There are currently no well accepted methods to predict or prevent concussions,thus the key to reduce the associated risks are proper acute evaluation and identification of recovery for safe return to participation.Encouragingly,a multifaceted concussion assessment battery is highly sensitive,0.89-0.96,in the acute concussion evaluation and most athletic trainers are utilizing this type of battery.26-28However,the sensitivity of this battery drops to unacceptably low levels (0.14-0.30) within a week likely due to a practice effect from repeat administration of the assessments.29Currently,computerized neuropsychological testing is the standard of care to identify post-concussion cognitive recovery; whereas,assessment of postural control remains substantially limited with the balance error scoring system (BESS) is the current clinical recommendation despite extremely low sensitivity (0.07) at 1 week post-injury.2,27-29However,recovery of cognitive processing capabilities occurs independent of postural control and therefore neurocognitive testing alone is insufficient to identify recovery.30-34Thus,a multifaceted approach,including postural control assessment,is critical in both the acute recognition of concussion as well as the determination of recovery and the safe return to participation.35The purpose of this review is to provide an overview of the linear and non-linear assessments of postconcussion postural control.
2.Linear assessment of post-concussion postural control
Postural control requires controlling the body’s orientation in space and encompasses both postural stability and postural steadiness.36Traditionally,linear dynamic postural control modeling stems from a stimulus-response paradigm,during which output is predicted using linear equations (e.g.,position,displacement,velocity,acceleration).36Within this model,postural steadiness is measured by variations in the center of pressure (CoP) as a function of time whereas an increase in the area of CoP measures is associated with greater impairment in postural stability.36Following a concussive injury,the impairments to the postural control system are thought to result from an impaired interaction between the somatosensory,visual,and vestibular systems.37,38However,this approach may be limited by emphasis on the sensory system (e.g.,primarily static and single tasks challenges) and resulting limited consideration of the motor and cognitive systems (e.g.,dynamic and dual task challenges).38,39The Romberg test was one of the first static balance tests to be used in the clinical setting for concussion management which challenges the sensory system by evaluating sway during quiet stance with both the eyes open and closed.40However,the Romberg has been criticized as being insensitive due to its subjective nature of the interpretation and it has never been validated for clinical management of sports concussion.40,41These limitations,in an effort to objectify balance impairments,lead to the development of the BESS.40,42While an improvement over the Romberg test,the BESS also suffers from multiple limitations leading to the implementation of instrumented measures of postural control,primarily using force plates and the sensory organization test (SOT).
The most commonly utilized postural control assessment for sports-related concussion is the BESS.27,28The BESS was created as a cost effective and clinically feasible test which assessing balance on multiple surfaces (firm and foam) in multiple stances(doublelimb,singlelimb,andtandem).42The BESS has demonstrated strong correlations with force plate sway measures in five static balance positions(single-leg firm surface,tandem firm surface,double leg foam surface,single leg foam surface,and tandem foam surface),has with an intertester reliability coefficient correlations (ICC) ranging from 0.78 to 0.96,and produced results similar to those on the SOT.40,42,43However,the total BESS score,the score utilized clinically,has low to moderate ICC values (0.57-0.74) that have been identified raising reliability concerns.Following a concussion,BESS scores typically increases by 3-6 errors which is less than the minimal detectable change scores (7.3-9.4 errors) which could explain the test’s low initial sensitivity (0.34).29,44Further,environmental distractions,fatigue,functional ankle instability,and dehydration may all impair performance whereas improved performance may occur secondary to a learning effect associated with repeat administration.45-51These limitations may be underlying the low initial sensitivity which decreases substantially within the first week post-injury (0.07).29
To address these considerations,instrumented measures of postural control,primarily the SOT,has been incorporated into research testing paradigms.The SOT disrupts informationavailable to the somatosensory and visual systems while it measures an individual’s ability to maintain a steady equilibrium.52The SOT consists of three 20-s trials with three different visual conditions (eyes open,eyes closed,and sway referenced) as well as two stance conditions (fixed and sway referenced).38Within the SOT,the term sway-referencing refers to tilting of the forceplate or the test apparatus (Fig.1).38An overall equilibrium score is derived from performance on all six stances while composite scores are calculated for somatosensory,visual,andvestibular.38While the SOT has the advantage of providing objective,reliable,and valid postural control data,the implementation of the SOT within the sports medicine community is limited by cost,expertise,and lack of portability.27,53
In the immediate aftermath of a concussion,impaired postural control is a cardinal symptom.2On the BESS assessment,performance typically worsens by 3-6 errors,compared to baseline,when first assessed within 24 h.14,29,38,54However,the BESS typically returns to baseline values within 2-5 days post-injury and,with repeat administration,will continue to improve with nearly20%less errors committed after a week of testing.14,29This apparent clinical recovery,operationally defined as achieving baseline/premorbid values,on the BESS exists despite persistent cognitive deficits and concussion related symptoms reported by patients.14Even when utilizing the instrumented SOT,collegiate student-athletes recovery patterns were similar to BESS with recovery occurring within 3-5 days post-injury,with both tests displaying a similar recovery curve suggesting test-retest limitations may also exist (Fig.2).38,42,54,55Overall,these results suggest that the BESS is a moderately valid clinical tool for the post-concussion assessment of postural control.However,the aforementioned limitations must be considered when evaluating the conclusion that postural control recovers within several days post-concussion.14,29

Fig.1.Six testing conditions for the sensory organization test.Vision is removed in Conditions 2 and 5.The sway-referenced AP angular motion of the surrounding wall reduces optic flow stimulation in Conditions 3 and 6,which is useful for the perception of self-motion relative to the visual field.In Conditions 4 and 6,the sway-referenced AP angular motion of the force plates reduces somatosensory stimulation,which is useful for the perception of AP self-motion relative to the surface of support78(adapted with permission).AP = anterior-posterior.
These studies,primarily from the early to mid-2000s,were largely viewed as conclusive findings on linear measures of post-concussion postural control with general agreement that balance recovers within a few days.However,in recent years several other approaches have identified conflicting findings suggesting that post-concussion impairments in postural control may persist far beyond a few days.Both traditional (e.g.,95% area,velocity,stability index) and novel biomechanical measures of quiet stance and associated CoP metrics have been utilized to challenge the BESS and SOT findings.Slobounov et al.,30utilizing virtual time to contact (VTC) (an assessment of instantaneous CoP values including position,velocity,and acceleration),identified residual postural abnormalities at least 30 days post-concussion in collegiate student-athletes despite no apparent differences in traditional CoP metrics.Further,when used in conjunction with electroencephalogram,VTC was a predictor of future postural control impairments.56Similarly,Powers et al.57identified increased anterior-posterior (A/P) CoP displacement in collegiate student-athletes,compared to a healthy control group,on the day the individual returned to athletic participation (26 + 14 days post-injury) and suggested this was secondary to poor sensorimotor integration of the lateral vestibulospinal tract.Slobounov et al.31concurred with deficits noted in CoP area for at least 30 days post-concussion when compared within subject to baseline values,but encouragingly noted apparent recovery at 6 months post-injury.Taken together,these studies suggest that instrumented measures of postural control identify impairments persisting at least 30 days postconcussion and through clinical recovery.However,the feasibility of these tests remains low and thus is unlikely to be incorporated into clinical settings due to cost,time demand,and expertise.

Fig.2.Means±SD on the NeuroCom Smart Balance Master.(A) Composite score,(B) visual ratio,(C) vestibular ratio,and (D) Balance Error Scoring System for 36 injured and 36 control subjects across test sessions (pre-season through day 5 post-injury).*Significant group difference;#significant difference from baseline (p<0.05).Higher scores represent better performance on A,B,and C,and a lower score is indicative of better performance in D54(adapted and revised with permission).
Dynamically,a conservative gait strategy (slower gait velocity,reduced separation of the CoP-center of mass (COM),increased mediolateral range of motion of the COM,and increased time in double support) has been routinely identified post-concussion in collegiate student-athletes.32,53,58-68These noted deficits tend to be exacerbated when the challenge is increased either in the motor task (e.g.,obstacle avoidance) or when a cognitive task is incorporated.53,69It is important to note that the majority of gait studies reviewed were performed at one laboratory and were largely delimited to grade II concussions,as defined by the American Academy of Neurology (no LOC and symptoms persisting longer than 15 min),70had fairly homogeneous and small (n = 10-17/group) participant populations for most studies,lacked within-subject pre-injury data,and have involved a variety of gait tasks including single task gait,dual task gait with working memory challenges,and obstacle avoidance tasks.57-67Beyond traditional gait testing,Buckley et al.33identified an impaired motor strategy during gait termination through altered propulsive and braking forces post-concussion which persisted beyond recovery on the multifaceted clinical concussion assessments and was also independent of gait velocity.Thus,sophisticated measures of postural control and gait have successfully identified lingering impairments in post-concussion postural control which persist far beyond the clinical markers of recovery.
3.Non-linear assessments of post-concussion postural control
A dynamic system,the human body,may appear to be in a static state during upright standing,but fluctuations in movement provide evidence that the body is in slight disequilibrium with the environment and thus the term“quiet”is more appropriate than“static”stance.71Dynamic systems theory is an area of applied mathematics used to describe a dynamic system or a system which evolves over time.71Non-linear measures represent alternative instruments to explore movement variability and are based on dynamic systems principles.72,73Variability,itshould be noted,is not inherently“good”or“bad”,but rather provides a range of coordinated patterns that can be utilized to complete a motor task.72,74However,the dynamic systems theory argues that increased variability in a movement pattern generally indicates a loss of stability whereas decreased variability generally indicates a more stable pattern.75
Despite the growth of dynamic systems analysis and the related subfield of non-linear entropy measures,these assessment protocols have received limited attention in the sportsconcussion literature.74The most commonly utilized metric in post-concussion postural control measures,approximate entropy (ApEn),takes into account the sequential order of successive data points and is based on how likely a given pattern is to reappear within the time series.76ApEn is a non-linear measure which characterizes orderliness in the temporal output of a complex system.36Mathematically,ApEn is a measure of the logarithmic likelihood that a series of data points of length m + 1 will be close,given that observations of length m are close.76In this calculation,the length of data points (m) is defined by the investigator,often m = 2 per convention,and closeness (r) is defined as a percentage of the standard deviation(SD)of the time series of interest.Conventionally,m = 2,r = 0.2×CoP SD.76The ApEn is a unitless quantity that ranges from 0,perfect repeatability,such as a sine wave,to 2,complete randomness,such as Gaussian noise.76As it relates to postural control,high sway regularity would have a low ApEn (approaching 0),and high sway irregularity would have a high ApEn (approaching 2).Currently,it is unknown what specific pathophysiology or compensatory strategies are represented by high or low sway regularity and suggested mechanisms are presented in subsequent paragraphs.Importantly,ApEn does not necessarily correlate well with traditional linear analysis of a data series and thus may elucidate impairments in postural control not currently identified by traditional linear metrics.36The test-retest reliability of ApEn values calculated from raw data obtained using the SOT for the anterior-posterior (AP) time series is moderate to good (ICC(2,1) = 0.79-0.90); however,the ML time series were less consistent between trials (ICC(2,1) = 0.53-0.77).77

Fig.3.Mean approximate entropy (ApEn) values for center of pressure (CoP) anterior-posterior (A,B) and medial-lateral (C,D) time series in athletes (A,C) with (n = 13) and (B,D) without (n = 16) postural instability after concussion.ApEn values are displayed for the six Sensory Organization Test conditions.Athletes were tested at pre-season,within 48 h after injury,and between 48 and 96 h after injury.Lower scores reflect greater regularity of CoP oscillations78(adapted with permission).
Only five studies have utilized non-linear analysis to identify potential changes in postural control strategies amongst acutely concussed collegiate student-athletes.78,79-81These studies described alterations in postural control that were not otherwise recognized using traditional linear CoP measures including area,displacement,and velocity.Further,in two studies this also included achieving baseline values on the SOT overall equilibrium score as well as the vestibular,visual,and somatosensory ratios.78,82Acutely post-concussion,operationally defined as within 48 h of injury,multiple studies have identified altered postural control utilizing ApEn measures in both the A/P and medial-lateral (M/L) directions.78,80,82Specifically,Cavanaugh et al.82identified increased regularity (lower ApEn values) with the largest changes occurring in SOT Condition 1 (eyes open,surface fixed) and 2 (eyes closed,surface fixed) which were almost three times as large as the standard error of the mean,exceeded all changes observed in the other conditions for the concussed and all conditions in the healthy participants.This finding suggested that despite the lack of differences noted in SOT,significant alterations in CoP regularity were identified utilizing ApEn during the acute phase of concussion.Further,these differences,the magnitude of decline,were greater in the M/Lplanewhichtheauthorssuggestedwasduetoahigherlevel ofirregularityduringthebaselinetestandthereforehadagreater potential to identify alterations.82Higher irregularity in the M/L plane may be a result of lower boundary area compared to the A/P plane or maybe a result of greater muscle co-activation(e.g.,tibialis anterior and gastrocnemius/soleus) in the A/P plane compared to gluteus medius activation in the M/L plane.However,the authors do not speculate why there were no differences in SOT measures which have routinely identified acute postural control impairments post-concussion.26,38,42,55
Once immediate changes in CoP regularity were identified,the next logical step was to assess the duration of these alterations.The same group followed up with a study which extended the assessment to 2-4 days post-concussion,placing the testing timeframe within the normal recovery period when utilizing the BESS test (Fig.3).78During the SOT,the A/P ApEn began to return to baseline values; however,changes in M/L ApEn persisted,especially in Conditions 1 and 2 of the SOT,through Day 4 with noted reductions in randomness (lower ApEn values).Once again,the noted differences between Day 4 and baseline were substantial with the differences three to four times larger than the standard error of the mean and these changes were largely independent of patient self-reported symptoms.This finding suggests that altered postural control may persist for a longer period of time than indicated based on BESS or SOT testing.The decline in ApEn values were again suggested to be associated with increased cortical regularity,but the authors herein also speculated increased co-contraction of the lower extremity musculature to gain control over postural sway may have reduced the CoP oscillations; however,electromyography data were not presented to support or refute this hypothesis.78From these two findings,the authors suggest that postural control is achieved through unconstrained and irregular patterns of motor output.78,80Unfortunately,this study,nor subsequent published studies by this group,tracked these changes for longer periods of time,thus the time to full resolution,based on ApEn values,remains unknown.
While ApEn provides valuable insights into non-linear analysis of postural control via CoP oscillations,others have suggested alternative forms of entropy assessment including Shannon,Renyi,Kolmogorov,sample,and multiscale entropies with each approach having their own unique strengths and limitations (Table 1).80,83,84Gao et al.80suggested the short data sets utilized in the SOT were an inherent limitation to the analysis and therefore utilized a 120-s bipedal stance data capture while utilizing alternative entropy measures: Shannon and Renyi entropies.Shannon entropy can be calculated by mapping a CoP trace on to a grid and then determining the probability of the CoP occupying a given box during the CoP trace.Renyi entropy is a mathematical generalization of Shannon entropy,which does not assume the additivity of independent events.Interestingly,Gao et al.80identified a substantial influence of samples on the outcome measures.Specifically,during bipedal stance when only the first 20 s of data were analyzed,there were no differences between Day 1 and Day 12 post-concussion.Indeed Day 1 had slightly lower Shannon entropy which would lead one to conclude that either there were no differences in Shannon entropy or that the entropy actually decreased.However,when the entire 120 s trial is analyzed,a greater than linear increase is observed on Day 1 whereas on Day 12 the entropy value plateau’s around 40 s (Fig.4).These findings suggest that in order to identify altered postural control post-concussion,a 20-s assessment may be insufficient and only longer data collections may reveal the impairments.Clinically,this could be relevant as the BESS test stances are only held for 20 s and longer assessment points could better discriminate balance impairments.Further when applying this approach,apparent alterations in postural control were present for at least 1-2 weeks post-concussion and well beyond clinically defined recovery.Unfortunately,this study lacked baseline data such that within-subject comparison was not available and therefore determining an individual’s recovery was not plausible; however,this result provides a proof of concept that may provide for future approaches and investigations.80

Table 1Description of entropy measures used in concussion populations and their limitations.
The primary focus of this review has been the assessment of postural control in the acute aftermath of a concussion; however,several studies have investigated the chronic effects of concussion on postural control utilizing both linear and non-linear measures.79,81,85Despite only limited differences when evaluated with traditional linear metrics,both Sosnoff et al.79and De Beaumont et al.81identified altered non-linear measures during quiet stance and SOT testing.Specifically,Sosnoff et al.79observed that as the task difficulty increased,individuals with a previous history of concussions (>1) decreased M/L irregularity while increasing their A/P irregularity.Further,the SOT test failed to identify between group differences in three of the four functional balance scores and the only difference was noted in the visual ratio score,but the authors suggested this was not a meaningful clinical change.79Similarly,De Beaumont et al.81identified both lowerApEn and CoP displacement amplitude in theA/P,but not M/L,direction during a 30-s quiet stance task amongst athletes with a history of>1 concussion (2.65±1.45) at least 9 months prior (19.03±13.77 months).The primary focus of investigations related to the long-term consequences of concussion are cognitive,emotional,and quality of life related; however,these limited studies suggest the potential of postural impairments in individuals with even a single concussion.How these potential impairments will affect quality of life and fall risk as these participants age are currently unknown but worthy of investigation given the personal and societal implications associated with falls.86
Another potential area for future consideration is the application of a dual task (DT) methodology whereby an individual performs a motor task while also addressing a cognitive challenge.87During gait trials,DT has successfully identified lingering impairments in postural control despite apparent resolution on motor only tasks.58-60,64-66,68During quiet stance with a cognitive challenge,digit recall,healthy participants increased the A/P ApEn,but not M/L ApEn,independent of changes in the amplitude of CoP oscillations.88This approach provides an additional potential avenue for future investigations to utilize DT methodologies while applying non-linear metrics.However,as described herein,this topic remains largely unexplored within this population.
4.Conclusion
Taken together,these studies suggest that ApEn outcome measures,as well as other entropy measures,can successfully identify impairments in postural control not detected by traditional linear outcome measures arguing in favor of their inclusion in an instrumented assessment battery.The successful identification of impaired postural control during the eyes open and closed with fixed surface conditions of the SOT(Conditions 1and2)suggested these may be the only conditions required for testing,thus increasing the clinical plausibility of the approach as new instruments could incorporate fixed surfaces.75Unfortunately,access to the SOT and/or forceplates is extremely limited within most sports medicine clinics and therefore currently this approach may have limited applicability.27,28Future approaches to post-concussion postural control assessments should focus toward the development of clinician friendly protocols potentially utilizing cost-efficient commercially available products (e.g.,Wii Fit balance board) with custom written software that could provide easy to interpret outcomes measures for clinicians.Currently,of course this will require extensive further experimentation to identify the measure(s)which are bothhighly sensitive and specific to changes post-concussion.Unfortunately,no gold standard currently exists on which to compare these assessments protocols.Moving forward,improved and clinically applicable measures of postural control,utilizing both linear and non-linear approaches,are warranted to further the neuropathological and clinical challenges associated with concussion.
Acknowledgment
This project was funded,in part,by an NIH/NINDS grant (No.1R15NS070744-01A1).The funding agency had no role in the development of the manuscript,the interpretation of the results,or the decision where to submit the manuscript.
Authors’contributions
All authors were involved in the development of this review article.JRO performed the review and writing of the linear analysis section of the paper.JBC performed the review and writing of the non-linear analysis section of the paper.TAB was responsible concussion overview section and for the overall paper.All authors have read and approved the final version of the manuscript,and agree with the order of presentation of the authors.
Competing interests
None of the authors declare competing financial interests.
References
1.National Institute of Neurological Disorders and Stroke.Traumatic Brain Injury.Available at: http://www.ninds.nih.gov/disorders/tbi/detail_tbi.htm; 2012 [accessed 12.12.2012].
2.McCrory P,Meeuwisse WH,Aubry M,Cantu RC,Dvorˇák J,Echemendia RJ,et al.Consensus statement on concussion in sport.The 4th International Conference on Concussion in Sport.Zurich,Switzerland.November 2012.J Athl Train 2013;48:554-75.
3.Cusimano MD,Sharma B,Lawrence DW,Ilie G,Silverberg S,Jones R.Trends in North American newspaper reporting of brain injury in ice hockey.PLoS One 2013;8:e1865.doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0061865
4.Williams JM,Langdon JL,McMillan J,Buckley T.English professional footballers concussion knowledge and attitudes.J Sport Health Sci 2015.doi:10.1016/j.jshs.2015.01.009
5.Tuominen M,Stuart MJ,Aubry M,Kannus P,Parkkari J.Injuries in men’s international ice hockey: a 7-year study of the International Ice Hockey Federation Adult World Championship Tournaments and Olympic Winter Games.Br J Sports Med 2015;49:30-6.
6.Langlois JA,Rutland-Brown W,Wald MM.The epidemiology and impact of traumatic brain injury: a brief overview.J Head Trauma Rehabil 2006;21:375-8.
7.McCrea M,Hammeke T,Olsen G,Leo P,Guskiewicz K.Unreported concussion in high school football players: implications for prevention.Clin J Sport Med 2004;14:13-7.
8.Llewellyn T,Burdette GT,Joyner AB,Buckley TA.Concussion reporting rates at the conclusion of an intercollegiate athletic career.Clin J Sport Med 2014;24:76-9.
9.Quayle KS,Powell EC,Mahajan P,Hoyle Jr JD,Nadel FM,Badawy MK,et al.Epidemiology of blunt head trauma in children in U.S.emergency departments.N Engl J Med 2014;371:1945-7.
10.Terrio H,Brenner LA,Ivins BJ,Cho JM,Helmick K,Schwab K,et al.Traumatic brain injury screening: preliminary findings in a US Army Brigade Combat Team.J Head Trauma Rehabil 2009;24:14-23.
11.Gerberding JL,Binder S.Report to congress on mild traumatic brain injury in the United States: steps to prevent a serious public health problem.Available at: http://www.cdc.gov/traumaticbraininjury/pdf/mtbireport-a .pdf; 2003.[accessed 16.02.2015].
12.Finkelstein EA,Corso PS,Miller TR.Incidence and economic burden of injuries in the United States.J Epidemiol Community Health 2007;61:926.13.Giza CC,Hovda DA.The new neurometabolic cascade of concussion.Neurosurgery 2014;75:S24-33.
14.McCrea M,Guskiewicz KM,Marshall SW,Barr W,Randolph C,Cantu RC,et al.Acute effects and recovery time following concussion in collegiate football players: the NCAA Concussion Study.JAMA 2003; 290:2556-63.
15.Meier TB,Bellgowan PS,Singh R,Kuplicki R,Polanski DW,Mayer AR.Recovery of cerebral blood flow following sports-related concussion.JAMA Neurol 2015;72:530-8.
16.Maugans TA,Farley C,Altaye M,Leach J,Cecil KM.Pediatric sports-related concussion produces cerebral blood flow alterations.Pediatrics 2012;129:28-37.
17.Cantu RC.Second-impact syndrome.Clin Sports Med 1998;17:37-44.
18.McCrory P,Davis G,Makdissi M.Second Impact syndrome or cerebral swelling after sporting head injury.Curr Sports Med Rep 2012;11:21-3.19.Zemper ED.Two-year prospective study of relative risk of a second cerebral concussion.Am J Phys Med Rehabil 2003;82:653-9.
20.Collins MW,Lovell MR,Iverson GL,Cantu RC,Maroon JC,Field M.Cumulative effects of concussion in high school athletes.Neurosurgery 2002;51:1175-81.
21.Nordstrom A,Nordstrom P,Ekstrand J.Sports-related concussion increases the risk of subsequent injury by about 50% in elite male football players.Br J Sports Med 2014;48:1447-50.
22.Guskiewicz KM,Marshall SW,Bailes J,McCrea M,Cantu RC,Randolph C,et al.Association between recurrent concussion and late-life cognitive impairment in retired professional football players.Neurosurgery 2005; 57:719-26.
23.Guskiewicz KM,Marshall SW,Bailes J,McCrea M,Cantu RC,Mihalik JR,et al.Recurrent concussion and risk of depression in retired professional football players.Med Sci Sports Exerc 2007;39:903-9.
24.McKee AC,Stein TD,Nowinski CJ,Stein TD,Alvarez VE,Daneshvar DH,et al.The spectrum of disease in chronic traumatic encephalopathy.Brain 2013;136:43-64.
25.Vaaramo K,Puljula J,Tetri S,Juvela S,Hillbom M.Head trauma with or without mild brain injury increases the risk of future traumatic death: a controlled prospective 15-year follow-up study.J Neurotrauma 2015; 32:1579-83.
26.Broglio SP,Macciocchi SN,Ferrara MS.Sensitivity of the concussion assessment battery.Neurosurgery 2007;60:1050-7.
27.Kelly KC,Jordan EM,Burdette GT,Buckley TA.NCAA Division I athletic trainers concussion management practice patterns.J Athl Train 2014;49:665-73.
28.Buckley TA,Burdette GT,Kelly K.NCAA Division II and III athletic trainers concussion management practice patterns: how the other half lives.J Athl Train 2015;50:879-88.
29.McCrea M,Barr WB,Guskiewicz K,Randolph C,Marshall SW,Cantu R,et al.Standard regression-based methods for measuring recovery after sport-related concussion.J Int Neuropsychol Soc 2005;11:58-69.
30.Slobounov S,Cao C,Sebastianelli W,Slobounov E,Newell K.Residual deficits from concussion as revealed by virtual time-to-contact measures of postural stability.Clin Neurophysiol 2008;119:281-9.
31.Slobounov S,Sebastianelli W,Hallett M.Residual brain dysfunction observed one year post-mild traumatic brain injury: combined EEG and balance study.Clin Neurophysiol 2012;123:1755-61.
32.Buckley TA.Acute and lingering impairments in post-concussion postural control.In: Slobounov SM,Sebastianelli W,editors.Concussions in athletics: from brain to behavior.1st ed.NewYork,NY: Springer Scientific Publishing; 2014.p.139-65.
33.Buckley TA,Munkasy BA,Tapia-Lovler TG,Wikstrom EA.Altered gait termination strategies following a concussion.Gait Posture 2013; 38:549-51.
34.Guskiewicz KM,Register-Mihalik JK.Postconcussive impairment differences across a multifaceted concussion assessment protocol.PM R 2011;3:S445-51.
35.Littleton A,Guskiewicz K.Current concepts in sport concussion management: a multifaceted approach.J Sport Health Sci 2013;2:227-35.
36.Cavanaugh JT,Guskiewicz KM,Stergiou N.A nonlinear dynamic approach for evaluating postural control: new directions for the management of sport-related cerebral concussion.Sports Med 2005; 35:935-50.
37.Guskiewicz KM,Perrin DH,Gansneder BM.Effect of mild head injury on postural stability in athletes.J Athl Train 1996;31:300-6.
38.Guskiewicz KM.Balance assessment in the management of sport-related concussion.Clin Sports Med 2011;30:89-102.
39.Shumway-Cook A,Woollacott MH.Motor control: translating research into clinical practice.4th ed.Philadelphia,PA: Lippincott Williams & Wilkins; 2012.
40.Riemann BL,Guskiewicz KM,Shields EW.Relationship between clinical and forceplate measures of postural stability.J Sport Rehabil 1999; 8:71-82.
41.Broglio SP,Guskiewicz KM.Concussion in sports: the sideline assessment.Sports Health 2009;1:361-9.
42.Riemann BL,Guskiewicz KM.Effects of mild head injury on postural stability as measured through clinical balance testing.J Athl Train 2000;35:19-25.
43.Guskiewicz KM.Postural stability assessment following concussion: one piece of the puzzle.Clin J Sport Med 2001;11:182-9.
44.Finnoff JT,Peterson VJ,Hollman JH,Smith J.Intrarater and interrater reliability of the Balance Error Scoring System (BESS).PM R 2009; 1:50-4.
45.Rahn C,Munkasy BA,Barry Joyner A,Buckley TA.Sideline performance of the balance error scoring system during a live sporting event.Clin J Sport Med 2015;25:248-53.
46.Onate JA,Beck BC,Van Lunen B.On-field testing environment and balance error scoring system performance during preseason screening of healthy collegiate baseball players.J Athl Train 2007;42:446-51.
47.Fox ZG,Mihalik JP,Blackburn JT,Battaglini CL,Guskiewicz KM.Return of postural control to baseline after anaerobic and aerobic exercise protocols.J Athl Train 2008;43:456-63.
48.Docherty CL,McLeod TCV,Shultz SJ.Postural control deficits in participants with functional ankle instability as measured by the balance error scoring system.Clin J Sport Med 2006;16:203-8.
49.Weber AF,Mihalik JP,Register-Mihalik J,Mays S,Prentice WE,Guskiewicz KM.Dehydration and performance on clinical concussion measures in collegiate wrestlers.J Athl Train 2013;48:153-60.
50.Burk JM,Munkasy BA,Joyner AB,Buckley TA.Balance error scoring system performance changes after a competitive athletic season.Clin J Sport Med 2013;23:312-7.
51.McLeod TV,Perrin DH,Guskiewicz KM,Shultz SJ,Diamond R,Gansneder BM.Serial administration of clinical concussion assessments and learning effects in healthy young athletes.Clin J Sport Med 2004;14:287-95.
52.Guskiewicz KM.Assessment of postural stability following sport-related concussion.Curr Sports Med Rep 2003;2:24-30.
53.Buckley TA.Concussion and gait.In: Li L,Holmes M,editors.Gait biometrics: basic patterns,role of neurological disorders and effects of physical activity.1st ed.Hauppauge,NY: Nova Science Publishers; 2014.p.141-64.
54.Guskiewicz KM,Ross SE,Marshall SW.Postural stability and neuropsychological deficits after concussion in collegiate athletes.J Athl Train 2001;36:263-73.
55.Peterson CL,Ferrara MS,Mrazik M,Piland T,Elliott T.Evaluation of neuropsychological stability following cerebral domain scores and postural concussion in sports.Clin J Sport Med 2003;13:230-7.
56.Slobounov S,Cao C,Sebastianelli W.Differential effect of first versus second concussive episodes on wavelet information quality of EEG.Clin Neurophysiol 2009;120:862-7.
57.Powers KC,Kalmar JM,Cinelli ME.Recovery of static stability following a concussion.Gait Posture 2014;39:611-4.
58.Howell DR,Osternig LR,Chou LS.Return to activity after concussion affects dual-task gait balance control recovery.Med Sci Sports Exerc 2015;47:673-80.
59.Howell DR,Osternig LR,Koester MC,Chou LS.The effect of cognitive task complexity on gait stability in adolescents following concussion.Exp Brain Res 2014;232:1773-82.
60.Catena RD,van Donkelaar P,Chou LS.The effects of attention capacity on dynamic balance control following concussion.J Neuroeng Rehabil 2011;8:8.
61.Catena RD,van Donkelaar P,Chou LS.Different gait tasks distinguish immediate vs.long-term effects of concussion on balance control.J Neuroeng Rehabil 2009;6:25.
62.Catena RD,van Donkelaar P,Halterman CI,Chou LS.Spatial orientation of attention and obstacle avoidance following concussion.Exp Brain Res 2009;194:67-77.
63.Parker TM,Osternig LR,van Donkelaar P,Chou LS.Balance control during gait in athletes and non-athletes following concussion.Med Eng Phys 2008;30:959-67.
64.Catena RD,van Donkelaar P,Chou LS.Altered balance control following concussion is better detected with an attention test during gait.Gait Posture 2007;25:406-11.
65.Catena RD,van Donkelaar P,Chou LS.Cognitive task effects on gait stability following concussion.Exp Brain Res 2007;176:23-31.
66.Parker TM,Osternig LR,van Donkelaar P,Chou LS.Recovery of cognitive and dynamic motor function following concussion.Br J Sports Med 2007;41:868-73.
67.Parker TM,Osternig LR,Van Donkelaar P,Chou LS.Gait stability following concussion.Med Sci Sports Exerc 2006;38:1032-40.
68.Parker TM,Osternig LR,Lee HJ,van Donkelaar PV,Chou LS.The effect of divided attention on gait stability following concussion.Clin Biomech (Bristol,Avon) 2005;20:389-95.
69.Lee H,Sullivan SJ,Schneiders AG.The use of the dual-task paradigm in detecting gait performance deficits following a sports-related concussion: a systematic review and meta-analysis.J Sci Med Sport 2013;16:2-7.
70.Kelly JP,Rosenberg JH.Diagnosis and management of concussion in sports.Neurology 1997;48:575-80.
71.Harbourne RT,Stergiou N.Movement variability and the use of nonlinear tools: principles to guide physical therapist practice.Phys Ther 2009; 89:267-82.
72.Preatoni E,Hamill J,Harrison AJ,Hayes K,Van Emmerik RE,Wilson C,et al.Movement variability and skills monitoring in sports.Sports Biomech 2013;12:69-92.
73.Vaillancourt DE,Sosnoff JJ,Newell KM.Age-related changes in complexity depend on task dynamics.J Appl Physiol 2004;97:454-5.
74.Latash ML.The bliss (not the problem) of motor abundance (not redundancy).Exp Brain Res 2012;217:1-5.
75.Stergiou N,Decker LM.Human movement variability,nonlinear dynamics,and pathology: is there a connection? Hum Mov Sci 2011;30: 869-88.
76.Pincus SM,Gladstone IM,Ehrenkranz RA.A regularity statistic for medical data-analysis.J Clin Monit 1991;7:335-45.
77.Cavanaugh JT,Mercer VS,Guskiewicz K.Response stability estimates for the sensory organization test: approximate entropy values and equilibrium scores in healthy young adults.Gait Posture 2004;20:S55-6.
78.Cavanaugh JT,Guskiewicz KM,Giuliani C,Marshall S,Mercer VS,Stergiou N.Recovery of postural control after cerebral concussion: new insights using approximate entropy.J Athl Train 2006;41:305-13.
79.Sosnoff JJ,Broglio SP,Shin S,Ferrara MS.Previous mild traumatic brain injury and postural-control dynamics.J Athl Train 2011;46:85-91.
80.Gao J,Hu J,Buckley T,White K,Hass C.Shannon and Renyi entropies to classify effects of mild traumatic brain injury on postural sway.PLoS One 2011;6:e24446.doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0024446
81.De Beaumont L,Mongeon D,Tremblay S,Messier J,Prince F,Leclerc S,et al.Persistent motor system abnormalities in formerly concussed athletes.J Athl Train 2011;46:234-40.
82.Cavanaugh J,Guskiewicz K,Giuliani C,Marshall S,Mercer V,Stergiou N.Detecting altered postural control after cerebral concussion in athletes with normal postural stability.Br J Sports Med 2005;39:805-11.
83.Yentes JM,Hunt N,Schmid KK,Kaipust JP,McGrath D,Stergiou N.The appropriate use of approximate entropy and sample entropy with short data sets.Ann Biomed Eng 2013;41:349-65.
84.Gao J,Hu J,Tung W.Entropy measures for biological signal analyses.Nonlinear Dynam 2012;68:431-44.
85.Martini DN,Sabin MJ,DePesa SA,Leal EW,Negrete TN,Sosnoff JJ,et al.The chronic effects of concussion on gait.Arch Phys Med Rehabil 2011;92:585-9.
86.Gillespie LD,Robertson MC,Gillespie WJ,Lamb SE,Gates S,Cumming RG,et al.Interventions for preventing falls in older people living in the community.Cochrane Database Syst Rev 2012;9:CD007146.doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD007146.pub3
87.Woollacott M,Shumway-Cook A.Attention and the control of posture and gait: a review of an emerging area of research.Gait Posture 2002;16:1-14.
88.Cavanaugh JT,Mercer VS,Stergiou N.Approximate entropy detects the effect of a secondary cognitive task on postural control in healthy young adults: a methodological report.J Neuroeng Rehabil 2007;4:42.
杂志排行
Journal of Sport and Health Science的其它文章
- Assessing proprioception: What do you really want to know? —Response to Krewer et al.
- Commentary on:“Assessing proprioception: A critical review of methods”by Han et al.
- Author biographies
- Performance on the Functional Movement Screen in older active adults
- Intermittent blood flow restriction does not reduce atrophy following anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction
- Single dose of intra-muscular platelet rich plasma reverses the increase in plasma iron levels in exercise-induced muscle damage: A pilot study
