个体行为抑制-激活对其风险决策加工策略的影响研究
2016-03-10刘增强郭宗君徐圣芬赤海娇刘世恩
刘增强,郭宗君,魏 巍,徐圣芬,陈 娟,赤海娇,刘世恩
个体行为抑制-激活对其风险决策加工策略的影响研究
刘增强,郭宗君,魏 巍,徐圣芬,陈 娟,赤海娇,刘世恩
【摘要】目的探讨个体行为抑制-激活(BIS/BAS)对其风险决策加工策略的影响。方法选取2013年1月—2014年10月在青岛大学附属医院进行健康体检的人员347例,根据BIS/BAS量表测评,选取BIS和BAS得分同高、同低各15%的受试者,分别作为BIS/BAS高分组(n=27)和低分组(n=25)。两组均进行高、低风险决策实验,同时记录决策损益、选择偏好和策略模式。结果两组低风险决策条件下保持策略、放弃策略、转换策略得分间差异均无统计学意义(P>0.05);两组高风险决策条件下保持策略、放弃策略、转换策略得分间差异均有统计学意义(P<0.05);两组高风险决策条件下保持策略、放弃策略、转换策略得分与低风险决策条件下比较,差异均有统计学意义(P<0.05)。两组低风险决策条件下损益、选择偏好得分间差异均无统计学意义(P>0.05);两组高风险决策条件下损益、选择偏好得分间差异均有统计学意义(P<0.05);两组高风险决策条件下损益、选择偏好得分与低风险决策条件下比较,差异均有统计学意义(P<0.05)。在低风险决策条件下,BIS得分与选择偏好、保持策略得分均呈正相关(P<0.05),而与转换策略得分呈负相关(P<0.05);BAS得分与保持策略得分呈负相关(P<0.05),而与转换策略得分呈正相关(P<0.05)。在高风险决策条件下,BIS得分与放弃策略得分呈正相关(P<0.05),而与转换策略得分呈负相关(P<0.05);BAS得分与放弃策略得分呈负相关(P<0.05),而与转换策略得分呈正相关(P<0.05)。结论风险规避和获得收益是个体决策的重要机制,随着风险的增加,决策倾向于更加保守和不确定。低风险情况下BIS对个体决策具有更加明显的调控作用,策略稳定性较高;高风险情况下BAS对个体决策具有更加明显的调控作用,表现为更高的策略不稳定性。
【关键词】行为抑制/激活系统;决策;风险;偏好;策略
刘增强,郭宗君,魏巍,等.个体行为抑制-激活对其风险决策加工策略的影响研究[J].中国全科医学,2016,19(4):458-461.[www.chinagp.net]
Liu ZQ,Guo ZJ,Wei W,et al.Behavioral inhibition and activation effect on the risk decision-making process strategy[J].Chinese General Practice,2016,19(4):458-461.
Behavioral Inhibition and Activation Effect on the Risk Decision-making Process StrategyLIUZeng-qiang,GUOZong-jun,WEIWei,etal.DepartmentofGerontology,theAffiliatedHospitalofQingdaoUniversity,Qingdao266003,China
【Abstract】ObjectiveTo investigate the effect of behavioral inhibition/activation system(BIS/BAS) and risk decision-making process strategy.MethodsWe enrolled 347 healthy people who received physical examination in the Affiliated Hospital of Qingdao University from January 2013 to October 2014.According to the evaluation by BIS/BAS scale,we selected the subjects that were among both 15% highest BIS scorers and 15% highest BAS scorers and assigned them into high score group (n=27);we selected subjects that were among both 15% lowest BIS scorers and 15% lowest BAS scorers and assigned them into low score group (n=25).High-risk decision test and low-risk decision test were conducted on both groups,and gain-loss of decision making,choice preference and strategy pattern were also recorded.ResultsThe two groups were not significantly different in the scores of keeping strategy,abandoning strategy and changing strategy under low-risk decision-making condition(P>0.05);the two groups were significantly different in the scores of keeping strategy,abandoning strategy and changing strategy (P<0.05) under high-risk decision-making condition;the scores of keeping strategy,abandoning strategy and changing strategy of the two groups under high-risk decision-making condition were significantly different from those under low-risk decision-making condition (P<0.05).The two groups were not significantly different in the scores of gain-loss and choice preference under low-risk decision-making condition (P>0.05);the two groups were significantly different in the scores of gain-loss and choice preference under high-risk decision-making condition (P<0.05);the scores of gain-loss and choice preference of the two groups under high-risk decision-making condition were significantly different from those under low-risk decision-making condition (P<0.05).Under low-risk decision-making condition,BIS score was positively correlated with the scores of choice preference and keeping strategy (P<0.05),and was negatively correlative with the score of changing strategy(P<0.05);BAS score was negatively correlated with keeping strategy(P<0.05),but was negatively correlated with the score of changing strategy.Under high-risk decision-making condition,BIS score was positively correlated with the score of abandoning strategy(P<0.05),but was negatively correlated with the score of changing strategy (P<0.05);BAS score was negatively correlated with the score of abandoning strategy(P<0.05),but was positively correlated with the score of changing strategy (P<0.05).ConclusionRisk aversion and getting gains are important mechanisms of individual decision,and with the increase of risk,decision-making tends to be more conservative and uncertain.Under low-risk condition,BIS has more significant control effect on individual decision making,with higher strategy stability;under high-risk decision,BAS has more significant control effect on individual decision making,showing higher strategy instability.
【Key words】Behavioral inhibition/activation system;Decision making;Risk;Preference;Strategy
行为抑制(BIS)是对惩罚性刺激、非奖赏刺激敏感。当BIS被激活时,个体常减慢或停止行为[1]。行为激活(BAS)是对奖赏、非惩罚性刺激敏感。当BAS被激活时,常促进个体行为[2]。Suhr等[3]发现BIS得分高且BAS得分低的个体较BIS得分低且BAS得分高的个体在爱荷华赌博任务(IGT)中得分更高。由此可见,由于BIS/BAS的不同,其决策绩效存在差异,推测其决策加工的策略模式亦应存在差异,从而导致行为绩效的差异。因此,探讨不同BIS/BAS类型个体在不同风险决策过程中的策略模式和特点具有重要的意义。本研……
