罗尔斯原初状态的契约主义立场及其限度
2014-04-29张首先
张首先
[摘要]罗尔斯通过坚守契约主义的原则立场,以最精致、最理想化的设计建构了一幅由契约主体选择两个正义原则的“完美”图景——“原初状态”,这一状态虽然超越了古典社会契约论者关于“自然状态”的种种叙事,但是,原初状态中契约主体“自我”的丧失、契约环境的过分理性化、影响契约因素的过分理想化,导致原初状态的主体无法担当“公共反思和自我澄清”的能力,从而使这一重要的正义理论在彰显契约主义的理论优势时,也暴露了其自身具有的局限性。
[关键词]原初状态;契约主义;正义原则;罗尔斯
[中图分类号]B089[文献标识码]A[文章编号]1000-3541(2014)02-0128-04On the contract doctrine stance and limits of original state of Rawls
ZHANG Shou-xian
(Chengdu Medical College, Chengdu 610500,China)
Abstract:Rawls through the principled position on contract doctrine, with the most delicate, the most ideal design constructed a picture taken by the contract subject to choose the two justice principles ——“perfect” picture “original state”, the state although beyond the classical social contract theory on the "state of nature" in all sorts of narrative, however, the contract subject “the original state of the loss of self”, contract object too much influence over ideal contract factors, leading to the main reason, the original state could not act as the “public reflection and self- clarification ability”, which is a important theory of justice in the theoretical advantage of contract doctrine, also exposed the limitations of its.
Key words:The original state; contractualism; Justice; Rawls
[收稿日期]2014-01-11
正义问题是人类社会发展过程中面临的十分迫切而重要的问题。罗尔斯的《正义论》以其论题的重要性、分析过程的缜密性著称于世,成为西方20世纪最重要的道德和政治哲学的经典著作之一。“原初状态”作为罗尔斯正义论宏大体系的逻辑起点及理论发源地,以最精致、最理想化的设计超越了古典社会契约论者关于“自然状态”的种种叙事,尤其是实现了对康德在《纯粹理性批判》中的“超验王国”的超越,不过,这种超越只是形式上的超越,最终,罗尔斯的“原初状态”因为固守契约主义立场而陷入契约主义的困境,其理论运思的过程和结果并没有摆脱康德模式的内在制约。
一、单向度特征与契约主体自主性的匮乏
罗尔斯原初状态中人为设计的契约主体因为人性的过分简约,导……
