A comparison of three fixations for intertrochanteric femoral fractures in the elderly
2011-08-15贾燕飞JiaYanfeiDeptPeripelvis2ndAffilHospInnerMongoliaMedColHohhot010030ChinOrthopTrauma201113130134
贾燕飞(Jia Yanfei,Dept Peri-pelvis,2nd Affil Hosp,Inner Mongolia Med Col,Hohhot 010030)…∥Chin J Orthop Trauma.-2011,13(2).-130~134
A comparison of three fixations for intertrochanteric femoral fractures in the elderly
贾燕飞(Jia Yanfei,Dept Peri-pelvis,2nd Affil Hosp,Inner Mongolia Med Col,Hohhot 010030)…∥Chin J Orthop Trauma.-2011,13(2).-130~134
ObjectiveTo compare the efficacy of 3 internal fixations,locking proximal femoral plate(LPFP),ASIAN IMHS and InterTAN,for intertrochanteric femoral fractures in elderly patients.MethodsA retrospective study was done to analyse 185 elderly patients who had been treated for intertrochanteric femoral fractures from February 2008 to December 2009 in our hospital and fully followed up.They were treated with LPFP(group A,95 cases),ASIAN IMHS(group B,52 cases)and Inter-TAN(group C,38 cases).Statistical analyses were conducted to compare the 3 groups in operative time,blood loss,fluoroscopy exposure,hospital charges,intraoperative complications and functional outcome(Harris hip score).ResultsThe average follow-up was 14.5 months(from 6 to 28 months).Compared with group A,grous B and C showed significant advantages in operative time,blood loss and functional outcome but significant disadvantages in fluoroscopy exposure and hospital charges(P <0.05).Compared with group A,groups B and C had significant fewer implant failures(P <0.05).There were no significant differences in all the indexes between groups B and C(P >0.05).ConclusionThe ASIAN IMHS and InterTAN appear to be more reliable than LPFP for the treatment of intertrochanteric femoral fractures in the elderly.There appear to be no significant differences between ASIAN IMHS and InterTAN.9 refs,4 figs,2 tabs.
(Authors)
杂志排行
外科研究与新技术的其它文章
- Treatment for 63 cases of the elderly with choledocholith by duodenoscope
- Clinical features and surgical treatment of the coexistence of cervical,thoracic and lumber degen-erativ diss
- Free-hand cervical pedicle screw fixation for upper cervical fracture and instability
- Atlantoaxial pedicle screw system for treatment of unstable atlantoaxial dislocation post traction
- The application of C1-C2 pedicle screw internal fixation on the upper cervical diseases of chil-dren
- One stage anterior release and posterior fusion for the treatment of irreducible atlantoaxial dislocation secondary to os odontoideum